Democracy Spraffa

Council 6-Month Performance Report - October to March 2022

Argyll and Bute Council · 23 June 2022
Back to Audit and Scrutiny Committee — 23 June 2022 and its agenda

Text extracted from the council's PDF. Layout and reading order may differ from the original.

Original council PDF · Download plain text

Page 1

1 
ARGYLL AND BUTE COUNCIL AUDIT AND SCRUTINY
COMMITTEE 
CHIEF EXECUTIVE     23 JUNE 2022 
COUNCIL 6-MONTH PERFORMANCE REPORT – OCTOBER TO MARCH 2022
__________________________________________________________________ 
1. SUMMARY 
1.1 The Performance and Improvement Framework (PIF) sets out the process for
presenting the Council’s performance reports. 
This paper presents the Council’s 6-month Performance Report and Scorecard for
October to March 2022 focussing on key performance indicators. 
It is recommended that the Audit and Scrutiny Committee: 
1.2 Note that this report presents Council performance on strategic activities across all
services; 
1.3 Review and scrutinise the Councils 6-month Performance Report and Scorecard; 
1.4 Note that the Strategic and Area Committees have responsibility to scrutinise
operational performance; 
1.5 Note the planned activity for Performance Management and Reporting during
2022/23 onwards. 
Pippa Milne
Chief Executive

Page 2

2 
ARGYLL AND BUTE COUNCIL AUDIT AND SCRUTINY
COMMITTEE
CHIEF EXECUTIVE     23 JUNE 2022
___________________________________________________________________ 
COUNCIL 6-MONTH PERFORMANCE REPORT – OCTOBER TO MARCH 2022 
2. SUMMARY 
2.1 The Performance and Improvement Framework (PIF) sets out the process for
presenting the Council’s performance reports. 
2.2 The paper identifies the strategic activities across council services that have
occurred during the reporting period along, reports on key performance indicators
and outlines the planned activity for Performance Management and Reporting
commencing 2022/23 
3. RECOMMENDATIONS
It is recommended that the Audit and Scrutiny Committee: 
3.1 Note that this report presents Council performance on strategic activities across all
services; 
3.2 Review and scrutinise the Councils 6-month Performance Report and Scorecard; 
3.3 Note that the Strategic and Area Committees have responsibility to scrutinise
operational performance; 
3.4 Note the planned activity for Performance Management and Reporting during
2022/23 onwards. 
4. DETAIL
4.1 The Performance and Improvement Framework (PIF) was approved by the
Council in September 2017. The PIF sets out the agreed framework for planning,
monitoring and reporting the Councils performance. 
4.2 Whilst Covid-19 placed an unprecedented level of demand on staff and
resources, the Council has continued to ensure that performance management,
reporting and scrutiny has continued throughout, in line with Audit Scotland
recommendations. This performance report covers a period when Covid-19 was
still impacting on services. 
To support scrutiny of performance by Elected Members and Senior Officers
during the Covid recovery period the Executive Leadership Team (ELT)

Page 3

3 
identified a Council-wide suite of 85 Success Measures for the reporting period
2021/22 (Appendix 1). 
From within the Service Plans 28 measures were identified as Council-wide Key
Performance Indicators (KPIs) for 2021/22. The Council 6-Month Performance
Report for the Audit and Scrutiny Committee contains all 28 KPIs. 
The full list of the 28 Council-wide KPIs for 2021/22 is attached (Appendix 2) and
presented in the following order – 
 Chief Executive’s Unit 
 Education 
 Legal and Regulatory Support 
 Commercial Services 
 Customer Support Services
 Road and Infrastructure Services 
 Development and Economic Growth 
Of the 28 KPIs, 21 are on-target with 7 off-target. Six KPIs are both off-target and
performance has decreased since the last reporting period (FQ3 2021/22).
Appendix 3 lists these seven KPIs and detailed commentary.   
It should be noted that all Public Sector Bodies have a statutory duty to comply
with Accessibility Legislation. The report format presented enables the Council to
comply with the above legislation changes. 
The KPIs were also reported to the appropriate Strategic Committees during
2021/22. These Strategic Committees are responsible for the scrutiny of
operational performance within their remits. 
4.3 Appendix 4 illustrates the Council’s Scorecard and Management Information.
The Council Scorecard shows our progress towards delivering our Outcomes.
These are illustrated through our 17 Business Outcomes. Of our 17 Business
Outcomes 7 are Green, 10 are Amber, 0 are Red. 
Our Business Outcomes deliver our Corporate Outcomes as illustrated in
Appendix 5. This is the final period in which we will use Business Outcomes,
which are being removed as part of our Performance Improvement Project. 
4.4 The Management Information shows areas of high-level cross cutting
information such as absence, risks and complaints. Supporting commentary is
provided below.

Page 4

4 
4.5 Absence 
At the start of the pandemic (FQ1 2020/21) we saw a dramatic reduction in the
number of work days lost. It is understood that this is due to employees
shielding, working from home, service shutdowns, decreased socialisation,
which reduced exposure to infection and increased sanitation measures.  As
predicted absence levels rose in 2021/22 once safeguards and lockdowns
eased.  LGE staff absence levels are now above pre pandemic levels.  For
Teachers absence levels have increased but remains below pre pandemic
levels.   
It should also be noted that sickness levels are always lowest in FQ2 for both
LGE and Teachers due to the summer holiday period. 
FIGURE 1: WORK DAYS LOST OVER TIME – TEACHER AND LGE STAFF 
With regards to the split between long and short term absence it remains that
more days are lost to long term than short term, with a gradual decrease in long
term mirrored by a gradual increase in short term but frequent absences. 
FIGURE 2: LONG AND SHORT TERM OVER TIME
FQ3
19/20
FQ4
19/20
FQ1
20/21
FQ2
20/21
FQ3
20/21
FQ4
20/21
FQ1
21/22
FQ2
21/22
FQ3
21/22
FQ4
21/22
LGE STAFF 2.8 2.8 1.59 1.89 2.94 2.82 3.32 3.16 3.49 3.42
TEACHER 2.05 2.38 0.82 0.92 1.52 1.15 1.36 0.89 1.6 1.77
2.8 2.8
1.59
1.89
2.94 2.82
3.32 3.16
3.49 3.42
2.05
2.38
0.82 0.92
1.52
1.15 1.36
0.89
1.6 1.77
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
Work Days Lost -Teacher & LGE Staff

Page 5

5 
There has been no change to the top 3 reasons for absence.  They remain as
follows:  1. Stress/Mental Health/Depression; 2. Other Musculoskeletal problems
and 3. Stomach, Liver, Kidney and Digestion. 
As Covid restrictions have been removed we anticipated absence figures would
rise to be closer to pre pandemic levels and for LGE staff they have now
exceeded pre pandemic levels. National trend data points towards a lasting
impact, especially with mental health related absences.  We expected that the
rate of infections would rise as social distancing and isolation were removed
although it is possible that they will not rise to pre pandemic levels with
increased awareness of infection control.  As the NHS get back to business as
usual with planned operations we expect to see an ongoing rise in our absences
due to medical treatment.  Both statistically and anecdotally those services that
have offered working from home have seen a bigger decrease in the number of
work days lost and we would expect this to continue, as working from home has
remained the norm. However, employees’ habits and overall wellbeing have
changed as a result of Covid therefore there may be other impacts on wellbeing
that have not yet been seen.   
The Council introduced new Supporting Attendance Procedures in October 2021
and revised its Stress in the Workplace procedures in November 2021, both of
which are intended to have a positive impact on reducing absence.  These were
amended following consultation with staff and managers and have been
simplified and improved. The Wellbeing team’s focus has continued to be on
supporting managers to deal with long term absence, particularly within the
Health and Social Care Partnership. We anticipate a related reduction in
absence in this area, although the full impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on
health and wellbeing is still to be fully understood.  The Council also introduced a
FQ3
19/20
FQ4
19/20
FQ1
20/21
FQ2
20/21
FQ3
20/21
FQ4
20/21
FQ1
21/22
FQ2
21/22
FQ3
21/22
FQ4
21/22
LONG TERM 56% 50% 77% 59% 68% 64% 62% 61% 61% 60%
SHORT TERM 44% 50% 23% 41% 32% 36% 38% 39% 39% 40%
56%
50%
77%
59%
68% 64% 62% 61% 61% 60%
44%
50%
23%
41%
32% 36% 38% 39% 39% 40%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
% of WDL LT vs ST absence

Page 6

6 
number of new leave types in July 21 which is also intended to impact on
absence, by, for example, extending bereavement leave will reduce the
likelihood of employees being signed off work with bereavement related stress. 
The Wellbeing team have remained in place and this forthcoming year their
focus will be on targeted, proactive wellbeing initiatives as identified by the
Executive Leadership Team and in turn it is hoped this will also improve
attendance. The team continues to monitor good practice across other Councils
on attendance, particularly through the Society of Personnel Development
Scotland Wellbeing Group. 
4.6 Performance Review and Development (PRDs) 
PRDs traditionally tended to occur in FQ4 as managers aligned the setting of
employees’ objectives with the outcome of budgetary processes and decisions. 
As referred to in the last report, as a result of feedback from managers we used
the opportunity to review the PRD process. PRDs were replaced by Quality
Conversations in FQ4 2021/22. The Quality Conversation process covers all
employees of the Council, whereas the PRD process did not include non-
networked employees – i.e. those employed in former manual roles. 
The subject areas covered during a Quality Conversation include performance,
wellbeing and aspirations, supported by flexible online learning resources
available to every employee. 
A series of webinars for both managers and employees took place to guide
participants on this new approach. 
Not only will Quality Conversations reduce the burden on all staff but it is in line
with the aim of simplifying our processes whilst improving value, engagement,
skills, performance and agility 
We will be surveying employees annually to gain insight on the conduct and
outcomes of these conversations.  Additionally, we will be surveying managers
on their handling of Quality Conversations, this is a perspective we have not had
to date from PRDs. The first surveys will take place in FQ1 2022/23 and the
results will be available in the next report to committee. 
4.7 Complaints 
The last 2 quarters of 2021/22 saw the number of complaints rising slightly
compared with the first 2 quarters of 2021/22. During FQ3 and FQ4 there were
232 stage 1 complaints and 76 stage 2 complaints received. Roads and

Page 7

7 
Infrastructure Services continues to receive the majority of complaints.
Performance within timescale has increased over the recent 2 quarters and the
Compliance and Regulatory team will continue to support services to improve
this further.   
The table below provides a breakdown by Department. A detailed Annual 
Complaints Report will be submitted to this Committee in September 2022. 
Stage 1 Stage 2 
Total
number
Number
in time
% in
time
Total
number
Number
in time
% in
time
Financial Services 28 28 100% 3 3 100%
Education 9 8 89% 22 13 59%
Legal and
Regulatory
Support
2 2 100% 2 2 100%
Commercial
Services
0 0 - 0 0 -
Customer Support
Services
4 4 100% 1 1 100%
Roads and
Infrastructure
169 145 86% 40 29 73%
Development and
Economic Growth
19 17 89% 8 7 88%
Live Argyll 1 1 100% 0 0 -
Totals 232 205 88% 76 55 73% 
4.8 Audit Recommendations 
Internal and External Audit Reports are presented at this committee meeting. 
Audit recommendations are reported quarterly to the Strategic Management 
Team and actions to complete them are recorded and allocated to the 
responsible officers.  
4.9 Finance   
The performance against budget for financial year 2021-22, after adjusting for
automatic and proposed earmarked reserve proposals, was an overall
underspend of £1.630m, 0.59% (2020-21 underspend of £0.188m, 0.07%). 
There was a net underspend of £0.815m in relation to Council services
departmental expenditure, a net overspend of £0.432m in relation to other
central costs and a net over recovery of funding of £1.247m.   
Social Work, managed by the Health and Social Care Partnership, were
underspent by £1.738m this included repayment of outstanding debt to the

Page 8

8 
Council of £2.759m therefore clearing the balance of any debt owed to zero.
This is consistent with the Scheme of Delegation. 
There have been a number of underspends and overspends within departmental
budgets which have contributed to this overall net favourable position including
over recovery of vacancy savings, reduced catering in schools due to less
demand as a result of Covid-19, reduced running costs within Early Learning
and Childcare, an underspend in NPDO and Hub Schools arising from insurance
savings and the settlement of historic disputed cost reductions, additional
income within Environmental Health and one-off income in Housing and
additional planning fee income. These being partially offset by overspends
related to external residential placements within Education, under recovery of
building warrant fees and transportation project costs. 
The main reason giving rise to the overspend in central costs was due to
insurance costs being higher than budget. 
The overall favourable position for Departmental and Central Expenditure
Budgets has provided the opportunity to earmark unspent budget for specific
purposes aligned to the objectives, priorities and targets of the Council. 
4.10 Strategic Risk Register (SRR) 
The Strategic Risk Register (SRR) details significant challenges and the agreed
approaches to manage them. These specific interventions are subject to scrutiny
at Strategic Committee Level and kept under review by the Council’s Strategic 
Management Team. 
The reported SRR has twelve risks in total. Three are red, six are amber and the
remaining three are green. The three red risks relate to population and economic
decline, Waste Management, and Cyber Security. 
4.11 Operational Risks 
The Chief Executive has two red risks which relate to a failure to achieve
budgeted income from local taxes due primarily to the impact of Covid and the
risk that financial impact of Covid will impact on service delivery and the
Council’s ability to agree a balanced budget. 
Executive Director Kirsty Flanagan has six red risks which relate to the cost of
delivering environmental health services in relation to public health, extreme

Page 9

9 
weather impact on both the road network and the cost of winter maintenance,
waste disposal, the affordability of maintaining ageing bridges and retaining
walls on the road network, cyber security breach and associated attack. 
Executive Director Douglas Hendry has five red risks which relate to delivery
failure of school kitchen supplies, capital investment to keep buildings safe and
operational, the availability of resources and funding to delivery capital projects,
compliance with the conditions of externally funded projects.
Key actions have been agreed to address these red risks and all other risks in
the operational risk registers. 
Other Strategic Activities
4.12 Covid 19 
The Scottish Government announced April 2022 that there is no longer a legal 
requirement to physically distance or wear a face covering in most indoor 
settings.  This is an encouraging sign and new national guidance strongly
recommends wearing a face covering indoors in crowded spaces. 
Due to the Council still experiencing infection and absence from Covid-19, the
Council has continued to encourage employees to work from home where
possible, meetings to be held remotely and observe positive hygiene practice to
minimise the risk of spread of infection. 
In December the Council committed an additional £110,000 towards ongoing
recovery measures including the recruitment of two temporary posts. The posts
will focus on building back stronger communities and supporting economic
recovery.  The roles include:
 Assisting funding providers to distribute support to community organisations
 Helping community groups access funding including the Council’s Micro-
Grant Fund
 Working with charities and third sector partners to ensure volunteer needs
are met
 Ongoing business support with Covid-19 funds and initiatives
 Supporting tourism, hospitality and creative businesses
 Ongoing support for the increase in staycations 
Working with partners, multiple public agencies, the third sector and community
groups, the Recovery Strategy outlines key initiatives including:
 Financial help and support to community groups and businesses
 Restoring public health services
 Re-instating the full range of council services
4.13 Budget

Page 10

10 
The Council agreed a balanced budget for 2022-23 on 24th February 2022 and
an estimated forecast budget gap of £7.77m for 2023 – 2024 (increasing up to
over £25m in the following 3 years) and an estimated gap of up to £30m+ in the
3 years after that. Council tax was increased by 3% and the Council also agreed
investment in the following;
 Keeping Argyll and Bute Connected: £3.153 million to increase investment in
roads reconstruction to £8 million in 2022/23, and develop active travel
improvements
 Investing in our places: £0.537 million for street lighting, more litter bins,
keeping public toilets open all year round, free parking at Christmas, and
developing staycation benefits.
 Safeguarding our future: another £1 million in schools and the wider learning
estate strategy, and £0.5 million in climate change initiatives
 Supporting growth in partnership: £0.165 million for tourism, culture and
youth development initiatives.
The Council also agreed to represent to the Scottish Government the
challenging circumstances it faces in relation to capital infrastructure needs, and
call for commensurate capital funding to help meet significant pressures. 
4.14 Education 
Empowering our Educators 
In December the Council launched a website to communicate the proposals on
the way schools in Argyll and Bute are led.  The website invited parents, carers
and residents in Argyll and Bute to examine the proposals, understand them and
have their say.  It included a short film and provides detailed information for
download. 
Schools in Argyll and Bute face falling pupil numbers, challenges in recruiting
staff, and Scotland-wide education reform is on the way.  Argyll and Bute
Council proposes a new ‘collective’ model for school leadership in the authority,
empowering schools to work more effectively together and share resources for
the benefit of all pupils. 
These proposals have been developed with ongoing input from Argyll and Bute
Head Teachers and education professionals. The changes are proposed to
protect local schools, build a stronger team of educators and enhance the
education of pupils.
This public consultation has now finished and proposals will be brought forward
to members as per the planned programme.

Page 11

11 
Attainment 
In December the Council’s Community Services Committee reviewed a
breakdown on attainment for secondary schools.  The results analysis for
attainment shows that:
 All 10 of the area’s secondary schools maintained their 100% pass rate for
National 4, outperforming the national average;
 Six schools were above the 2021 national average for National 5 (85.8%).
 Nine were above the 2021 national average for Higher (87.3%), and;
 Four secondary schools were above the 2021 national average for Advanced
Higher (90.2%).
On top of these successes, young people in Argyll and Bute gained 1,067 Wider
Achievement Awards at SCQF levels 4-7 (National 4 – Advanced Higher) in
more than 50 topics including:
 Bee keeping
 Journalism
 Horse care
 Computer game design
 Legal studies
 Hair and beauty
 Personal finance
 Construction skills
4.15 Place
There remains significant regeneration and investment activity ongoing within
our towns and below are examples of specific projects and initiatives.   
Community Renewal Fund 
In November the Council was successful in securing over £2 million from the UK
Government’s Community Renewal Fund as part of the Levelling Up agenda.
The award is one of the largest in Scotland from a total allocation of over £18m.  
The Council submitted the bid on behalf of organisations and services investing
in skills, place making, community and supporting people into employment and
supports the following; 
 A new Seaweed Academy – help to create the UK’s only dedicated seaweed
industry facility, near Oban, offering training, education and business
development - £407,715.
 MACC Hydrogen Futures – a feasibility and design project to help establish a
green hydrogen production and distribution facility - £184,793.

Page 12

12 
 Driving economic growth through a bounce back curriculum that includes
employer focused education and training in remote and rural areas. -
£275,253.
 West Coast UAV Innovation Logistics and Training Hub – after successfully
trialling unmanned aircraft vehicles (UAVs) or drones to transport medical
supplies to islands.Funding will commission a business case to support the
further use of drones - £173, 400.
 Access to ethical and responsible means of carbon sequestration will be
made available to organisations looking to offset their carbon emissions -
£265,200.
 The Dunoon Project Stage 2 – Funding will help expand the project team
looking to develop a nearby forest into a world class tourism offering -
£359,652.
 Curriculum development for Science, Technology, Engineering and Maths
(STEM) Hubs projects - £102,000 towards the production of materials to
deliver learning via a new council project.
 Tarbert recovery and regeneration - £262,395 to establish a team to
complete business plans and planning applications as a prelude to a £13
million transformation project to regenerate Tarbert. 
Separate to this fund, the Council has actively developed a competitive bid for
the UK Government’s Levelling Up Fund and this will be submitted in the
summer. 
Conservation Area Regeneration Scheme (CARS) Projects
There are four CARS projects in Argyll and Bute which receive funding from
Historic Environment Scotland (HES) and National Lottery Heritage Fund
(NLHF), with match funding from the council and private owners. The schemes
provide grants to property owners to help them repair and safeguard historic
buildings. An update to the Council’s Environment, Development and
Infrastructure Committee in March 2022 included the following update:
 Rothesay Townscape Heritage Phase 2 - this is year four of a £2.75m, five
year programme. Of the five priority building repair projects, three are
complete, one is awaiting a start date, and the final project will shortly go to
tender. Three shopfront restorations have also been completed, with another
nearing completion, and a series of window repair grants have been provided
for restoration of traditional timber sash and case windows.
 Dunoon CARS - this £1.95m project is in its final year. The restoration of
three priority buildings and 22 shopfronts has been completed with a further
two projects currently out to tender.
 Helensburgh CARS – this is the first year of a £1.8m, five-year project. Four
buildings have been identified as priorities for grant assistance and two

Page 13

13 
expressions of interest have been submitted by owners of properties for
smaller grants.
 Lochgilphead CARS – this is the second year of the project with the first
building project set to begin in April and development underway for a second
building.
Other significant activity led by the Council’s Transformation and Regeneration
Team includes the following:
 Hermitage Park, Parks for People – this £3.7m project is in its final year.
Current activity includes creating a new volunteer bothy in the park’s
demonstration garden with the garden itself now under development. An
agreement with the University of the Highlands and Islands is now in place to
allow the Park to be used as a venue for practical activities for students’ NC
Horticulture courses.
 Tarbert/Lochgilphead Regeneration Fund – four projects are complete and
current projects include Lochgilphead Front Green, Ardrishaig North Public
Realm and phase two of former Gleaner oil site.
 Regeneration Capital Grant Funding - three projects secured funding: Obair
Ùr Thirodh – Tiree Community Business Hub (£565k), Kerrera Old School -
Community Hub Final Phase (£285k), and Ulva Ferry Shore Facilities
Building - Doras Caolas Ulbha (£603k). Current projects include Kilmartin
Museum, Mid Argyll Community Pool, Storas Ulbha Heritage project, Ulva,
Port Ellen Community Hub on Islay, Scalasaig business units on Colonsay
and Kilmory Business Park, Lochgilphead.
 Scottish Government Town Centre Fund 2019-2022 - 28 projects using the
full £1.686m allocation have now been delivered, focusing on making key
town centres more attractive, healthier, and easier to navigate places, as well
as strengthening the area as a tourist destination. 
Scottish Government’s Place Based Investment (PBI) Programme
In March, the Council’s Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee
confirmed plans to direct the £821,000 from the Scottish Government’s Place Based
Investment (PBI) Programme into supporting eight new regeneration and restoration
projects.  These are all at various stages of development and delivery. These
include:
 A region-wide (excluding CARS or BID towns) shopfront improvement scheme
(£80,000)
 Rothesay Townscape Heritage priority building (£100,000)
 Public realm enhancements in Bowmore town centre (£80,000)

Page 14

14 
 Improvements to Castle House Gate Lodge, Dunoon (£70,000)
 Landscaping grant to Dunoon Burgh Hall Trust (£50,000)
 Enhancing the surface of Helensburgh masonry pier (£163,000)
 Public realm improvements in Gibraltar Street, Oban (£250,000)
 Helensburgh Hermitage Park, Greening The Bothy project (£28,000) 
Lismore Ferry
A new replacement ferry for Lismore was delivered after successfully completing
sea trials. Islanders and primary school pupils chose the name ‘Lady of Lismore’
following a poll organised by the Community Council. The Council awarded the
contract to Mainstay Marine Solutions at a cost of £620,000, with funding support of
£500,000 to date from Transport Scotland.  
The new all-steel vessel, designed by Keel Marine is 39ft accommodates 23
passengers all year round and will have a crew of two. 
Rothesay Pavilion 
At its meeting on 9 December 2021 the Council’s Policy and Resources
Committee took the decision to pause the development project to seek national
funding support to meet pandemic and EU exit costs of completing Rothesay
Pavilion’s transformation as a national center for arts and popular culture.  It is
anticipated that the project will require an estimated additional £11 million to be
completed. 
The total budget set aside for the project is £20.586m with £11.560m externally
funded leaving the Council's commitment at £9.026m. Rothesay Pavilion Charity
is set up to run the building as a thriving concern once complete. Construction
work was progressing until the original contractor went into administration in
2020.
The council now has another construction company in place to complete the
Pavilion’s transformation, but cost increases, resulting in large part from the
pandemic and global supply chain challenges, labour shortages in the
construction sector and EU exit, mean the council must seek further additional
funding sources.
The council established a cross-party group to lead a programme of targeted
lobbying activity, to include both the Scottish and UK Governments (who have
provided assistance and investment to similar projects elsewhere, including the
Glasgow School of Art, V&A in Dundee and the Tate Modern project in St Ives),

Page 15

15 
and any other agencies or organisations which can assist.
Other Activities
4.16 Performance Management Project 
Following on from previous updates the Council has embarked on a highly
ambitious initiative to explore centralising some data from across various
systems into a single ‘data platform’ using self-service tools.  A ‘data platform’ is
a standard generic name for the integrated set of technologies that collectively
creates the data in an accessible format (i.e. dashboards).  This links to an
action within the Council’s Best Value Improvement Action Plan to develop data
analytics/business intelligence as a tool to inform transformation and
improvement.   
In relation to the above, the ELT also agreed to create an internal Data Advisory
Group consisting of senior officers from across the organisation (both Council
and HSCP).  Accountable to the Executive Leadership Team, the group will
facilitate a corporate approach to directing the development of data platforms.   
The objective is to harness our data to ensure an evidence led approach to
performance management, service design, policy development, strategies and
other decisions that impacts on outcomes for our communities and stakeholders.
This internal initiative has and will maintain close links with the Scottish Local
Government Digital Office data initiative. 
It will take time to develop the proposal and any subsequent system and in the
interim a decision has been made to retain Pyramid for a further year.   
4.17 PIF Activity 
The data cleanse of Pyramid is continuing, simplifying where possible and
removing old ‘archived’ data. This not only improves the user experience but
helps to ensure the move to a new method of performance reporting is as
smooth as possible. Pyramid will continue to remain ‘live’ with all Success
Measures aligned to Service Plans and updated as agreed. 
From 2022/23 financial year the Council will no longer align success measures
through the Business Outcomes. To monitor the delivery of our Corporate
Outcomes a suite of 47 Indicators has been identified. These are known as
Corporate Outcome Indicators (COIs) and will all align directly to our Corporate
Outcomes. These are attached for information, however work is in progress to
finalise the wording for some indicators (Appendix 6). 
By nature the majority of COIs are longer term in nature with the data collected

Page 16

16 
annually and will be reported on annually to the relevant Strategic Committees.
Fourteen COIs can be reported on quarterly. These will be reported to the Area
Committees each quarter. 
Service Plans are not being renewed for 2022/23. A Council-wide Business Plan
will be developed during 2022/23 which will align to our Corporate Plan, the
Argyll and Bute Outcome Improvement Plan (ABOIP). Only the Corporate
Outcome Indicators and those indicators that feature within the Area Committee
Scorecards will be reported to committee. 
The 6-monthly ASC report will continue to present performance on cross-cutting
strategic themes currently on the Council Scorecard such as Absence,
Complaints and Risks. Additional information relating to strategic activity will also
be reported. 
This agreed process feeds into the Performance Management Project which
commenced in September 2020. 
5.0 CONCLUSION 
This report updates the Audit and Scrutiny Committee on how we are delivering our
outcomes; the key challenges and how we plan to manage them; other Strategic
activity along with implemented and planned changes to the PIF.   
6.0 IMPLICATIONS
6.1 Policy: None
6.2 Financial: None
6.3  Legal: None
6.4  HR: None
6.5  Fairer Scotland Duty: None
6.5.1   Equalities - protected characteristics: None
6.5.2   Socio-economic Duty: None
6.5.3  Islands: None
6.6 Climate Change: None
6.7 Risk: This report sets out key challenges to the organisation and actions in
response to these.
6.8 Customer Service: None               
For further information contact: 
 Stuart Green, Corporate Support Manager
stuart.green@argyll-bute.gov.uk

Page 17

17 
 Sonya Thomas, Performance and Improvement Officer 
sonya.thomas@argyll-bute.gov.uk 
APPENDICES 
Appendix 1 - Full Suite of 85 Success Measures With in Service Plans
Appendix 2 - 28 Key Performance Indicators FQ2 2021/22: All Services 
Appendix 3 - Off-Track KPIs with Decreasing Performance
Appendix 4 - Council Scorecard: October to March 2022
Appendix 5 - Seventeen Business Outcomes aligned to the Corporate Plan
Appendix 6 – Suite of 47 Corporate Outcome Indicators 
Pippa Milne, Chief Executive – Argyll and Bute Council
1 June 2022