Democracy Spraffa

Agenda reports pack

Argyll and Bute Council · 7 September 2023
Back to Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust — 7 September 2023 and its agenda

Text extracted from the council's PDF. Layout and reading order may differ from the original.

Original council PDF · Download plain text

Page 1

Argyll and Bute Council 
Comhairle Earra-Ghàidheal Agus Bhòid 
Executive Director:  Douglas Hendry 
Kilmory, Lochgilphead, PA31 8RT
Tel:  01546 602127  Fax:  01546 604435
DX 599700 LOCHGILPHEAD
30 August 2023 
NOTICE OF MEETING 
The Annual General Meeting of the ARGYLL AND BUTE WINDFARM AND RENEWABLES
TRUST will be held BY MICROSOFT TEAMS on THURSDAY, 7 SEPTEMBER 2023 at 7:00 PM,
which you are requested to attend. 
Douglas Hendry
Executive Director 
BUSINESS 
1. APOLOGIES 
2. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST 
3. MINUTE OF PREVIOUS ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING, HELD ON 22
SEPTEMBER 2022 (Pages 3 - 6) 
4. EAST KINTYRE WINDFARM TRUSTEES (Pages 7 - 14) 
5. WEST KINTYRE WINDFARM TRUSTEES (Pages 15 - 24) 
6. INVERARAY WINDFARM TRUSTEES (Pages 25 - 28) 
7. ALIENERGY (Pages 29 - 30) 
8. SSE RENEWABLES UPDATE 2022/23 - TO FOLLOW 
9. ANY OTHER COMPETENT BUSINESS 
Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust 
Councillor Jan Brown Councillor Dougie McFadzean 
Shona Barton, Governance Manager 
Contact: Lynsey Innis, Senior Committee Assistant, Tel:  01546 604338
Public Document Pack

Page 2

This page is intentionally left blank

Page 3

MINUTES of MEETING of ARGYLL AND BUTE WINDFARM AND RENEWABLES TRUST held BY
MICROSOFT TEAMS 
on THURSDAY, 22 SEPTEMBER 2022 
Present: Councillor Jan Brown (Chair) 
Councillor Dougie McFadzean
Alastair Bennett, East Kintyre
Windfarm Trust 
Margaret Pratt, West Kintyre Windfarm
Trust 
Attending: Shona Barton, Committee Manager
Audrey Martin, Projects and Regeneration Manager
Dr Lynda Mitchell, ALIenergy
Siobhan Jarvie, ScottishPower Renewables 
1. APOLOGIES 
The Committee Manager welcomed everyone to the meeting and general introductions
were made.   
Apologies for absence were intimated on behalf of:- 
Craig Mullen, Community Investment Manager, SSE Renewables 
2. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST 
There were no declarations of interest intimated.   
3. MINUTE OF PREVIOUS ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING, HELD ON 9
SEPTEMBER 2021 
The Minute of the previous Annual General Meeting of the Argyll and Bute Windfarm and
Renewables Trust held on 9 September 2022, was approved as a correct record. 
4. APPOINTMENT OF CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR OF THE ARGYLL AND BUTE
WINDFARM AND RENEWABLES TRUST 
Having recognised that the previous Chair, Councillor Anne Horn had stepped down as a
Councillor in May 2022, the Trust gave consideration to a report which outlined the recent
appointments made by the Council to the Windfarm Trust and invited Members to appoint
both a Chair and a Vice Chair.   
Councillor Brown confirmed that she was happy to assume the role of Chair.   
Margaret Pratt confirmed that she was happy to assume the role of Vice Chair.   
With no one being otherwise minded this became the decision of the Trust.   
Decision 
Page 3 Agenda Item 3

Page 4

The Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust: 
1. Appointed Councillor Jan Brown, as a member of the Argyll and Bute Windfarm and
Renewables Trust, to carry out the role of Chair of the Trust; and 
2. Appointed Margaret Pratt, as a member of the Argyll and Bute Windfarm and
Renewables Trust, to carry out the role of Vice Chair of the Trust.   
(Reference:  Report by Executive Director with responsibility for Legal and Regulatory
Support, dated 22 September 2022, submitted)   
5. EAST KINTYRE WINDFARM TRUSTEES 
The group gave consideration to the annual report and audited accounts of East Kintyre
Windfarm Trust to the year ending 31 March 2022, having heard from Alastair Bennett.   
Decision 
The Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust agreed to note the detail provided.   
(Reference:  Annual Report and Audited Accounts by East Kintyre Community Council
Windfarm Trust, submitted) 
6. WEST KINTYRE WINDFARM TRUSTEES 
The group gave consideration to the annual report and audited accounts of West Kintyre
Windfarm Trust to the year ending 31 March 2022, having heard from Margaret Pratt. 
Discussion took place around the Council’s Shop Local, Love Local campaign, with the
Projects and Regeneration Manager advising that she would provide the link to the
Committee Manager for circulation around the Windfarm Trust.     
Decision 
The Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust agreed to note the detail provided.   
(Reference:  Annual Report and Audited Accounts by West Kintyre Community Council
Windfarm Trust, submitted) 
7. INVERARAY WINDFARM TRUSTEES 
The group gave consideration to the annual report and audited accounts of Inveraray
Windfarm Trust to the year ending 31 March 2022.  Consideration was also given to the
Community Action Plan.   
Decision 
The Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust agreed to note the detail provided.   
(Reference:  Annual Report; Audited Accounts and Community Action Plan by Inveraray
Community Council Windfarm Trust, submitted) 
Page 4

Page 5

8. ALIENERGY 
Consideration was given to a report by ALIenergy outlining the background of the
sustainable energy charity, together with an overview of current projects and activities. 
Discussion was had in relation to the production of renewable energy in the Kintyre area,
with members of the Trust expressing concern that this is not offset against the rising cost
of energy.  Alastair Bennett agreed to forward links to both Councillors Brown and
McFadzean which would give detail on the work being undertaken around this, including
information on the petition to the Scottish Government to seek a solution based on the
output of renewable energy.     
Decision 
The Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust agreed to note the information
provided. 
(Reference:  Report by ALIenergy, submitted) 
9. SSE RENEWABLES UPDATE 2021/22 
In the absence of Craig Mullen, the Trust gave consideration to an update which
highlighted the SSE Renewables Community Investment Review 2021/22.  The review
highlighted that SSE Renewables had donated over £9.6 million in community projects in
Great Britain and Ireland in the last year. 
Decision 
The Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust agreed to note the information
provided. 
(Reference:  Update by SSE Renewables, submitted) 
10. UPDATED WINDFARM TRUST CRITERIA 
At the previous Annual General Meeting of the Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables
Trust, it was agreed that the Committee Manager would take forward the updating of the
Windfarm Trust Criteria, which was considered to be restrictive and outdated. 
Consideration was given to the proposed changes to the criteria. 
Decision 
The Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust agreed that the Windfarm Trust
Criteria be updated as outlined and instructed the Committee Manager to forward to the
Council’s Legal Services to ask them to update the Trust Deed.     
(Reference:  Updated Windfarm Trust Criteria, submitted)   
11. ANY OTHER COMPETENT BUSINESS 
Siobhan Jarvie of ScottishPower Renewables provided a brief update on local site activity
within the area, including the progress of the Earraghail hybrid project and Sheirdrim
development.    Siobhan confirmed that ScottishPower Renewables had been successful
Page 5

Page 6

in winning the rights to develop an off-shore windfarm off of the West Coast of Islay, and
advised that this development would be known as Machair Wind.  She further advised that
ScottishPower Renewables have paid £2.7m in community benefit across the sites they
have in Argyll to date.   
Page 6

Page 7

East Kintyre Windfarm Trust
Annual Report 2023
East Kintyre Community Council (EKCC) currently consists of 5 elected members.   These
members, along with 3 independent trustees, make up East Kintyre Windfarm Trust.

During the financial year ending 31 March 2023, EKWFT received £61,918 in grant pay-
ments from Argyll & Bute Council in relation to Beinn an Tuirc 1 and 2 and Deucheran Hill
Windfarms. 

A total of 13 applications for grant funding were received during the year with 12 being
approved and 1 refused.  Grants totalling £44,415 were agreed, although only £30,215
was paid out during this period. This remains less than half the pre-pandemic level and,
while this may partly be due to clubs and groups only slowly becoming active again, the
opening of the East Kintyre Community Fund has undoubtedly had an impact.   This fund
received 18 applications during the year and agreed grants of over £125,000.

The decrease in grant payments compared with the previous year is also explained by a
significant grant of £25,000 being included in the 2021/22 figures.  This grant helped Car-
radale Community Trust establish the Carradale Community Shop and Post Office, which
now employs one full time manager and 2 part-time Post Office Assistants.  A group of
about 20 volunteers also help staff the checkout and stock the shelves.  The shop is now
recognised by HMRC as filling a primary CCT charitable purpose, meaning it is exempt
from tax and can apply for grants to help with running costs. It has been a huge success
and become the hub of the community, and is greatly appreciated by both residents and
visitors who can now save themselves a 30 mile return journey to the shops in Campbel-
town.

Carradale Golf Club, which is registered as a Community Amateur Sports Club, received
grants of £12,071 towards the purchase of replacement grass cutting equipment.  This
machinery is also available for the maintenance of a significant area of playing fields
owned by the community council.  Indeed, the maintenance of a network of tracks and
paths in the Carradale area is a priority for the community.  Walking and outdoor recre-
ation were identified in the East Kintyre Local Development Plan (LDP) 2020/25 ( http://
eastkintyre.org/ldp.php) as priorities by both residents and visitors.  To help with this,
EKWFT sets an annual budget for the maintenance of paths and community areas and
facilities.  in the last year £3876 was paid out to local contractors to carry out these
works.   A grant was also made to The Kintyre Way to assist with the maintenance and
promotion of the East Kintyre section of the route.

A grant of £3,000 was made to Carradale Parent Council to help them develop an out-
door learning space at Carradale Primary School.   This will consist of an outdoor pod
and polytunnel and will benefit the whole community through extra-curricular gardening
clubs that will support the school vision of encouraging healthy eating.

Village halls remain a priority for the community and grants totalling £8,412 were made to
Carradale Village Hall for the purchase and installation of a new heating boiler and to-
wards the annual insurance premium.  Use of the hall is increasing again, including by a
group for the elderly run by Shopper-Aide, which was given a grant of £800 towards their
expenses.

Page 7 Agenda Item 4

Page 8

Heritage is seen as a key element in providing a sustainable, resilient and connected fu-
ture for East Kintyre in it’s LDP.  To assist with this, grants were made to Carradale Com-
munity Trust for the purchase of a display cabinet for the Heritage Centre at the Network
Centre and to Saddell Abbey Trust for the installation of new posts and chains around the
car park at Saddell Abbey.

EKWFT will continue to support larger projects such as the Community Shop and Post
Office, which are more likely to deliver long term benefits to the community, in line with
the East Kintyre LDP.  To assist in this regard, a development fund was established in
2016 and currently has a balance of £65,360.  

Each year, 10% of all community benefit funds received are transferred into a retention
fund (2 bank term deposit accounts) for use by future generations.  At 31 March 2023 it
had a balance of £76,282.

Wherever possible, trustees look for evidence of match funding from applicants, although
a degree of flexibility is often necessary as it becomes increasingly difficult for them to
obtain such funding.

NOTE - This report should be read in conjunction with the attached audited accounts.

Alasdair Bennett

Secretary & Treasurer

East Kintyre Windfarm Trust

1 August 2023
Page 8

Page 9

Hannah Fawcett
Licensed Accountant
Mr Alasdhair Bennett
East Kintyre Wind Farm Trust
Brudhearg
Carradale
By Campbeltown
Argyll
PA28 6qX
23'd May 2023
Dear Alasdhair
Please find attached signed independent examiners review certificate and accounts for East Kintyre
Wind Farm Trust for year end 31 March ZO23.l can confirm that no matter has come to my attention
in the course of my examination.
I have also attached a copy of my fee note for the service this year
Kind Regards
f+m.^.{ilefi-_^
Hannah Fawcett FMAAT
AAT Licenced Accountant
Rockbank, Low Askomil, Campbeltown, Argyll, pA28 6Ep
Tel:07858 O22374
Email : hfawcettFMAAT@gmail.com
Page 9

Page 10

lndependent Examiner's Report to the Trustees of
East Kintyre Windfarm Trust
for the year ended 31 March 2023
I report on the financial statements of the charity for the year ended 31 March 2023, which are set
out on pages 1- to 3.
Respective responsibilities of Trustees and Examiner
East Kintyre Windfarm Trust are responsible for the preparation of the accounts and to state whether
particular matters have come to my attention.
Basis of statement
My examination includes a review of the accounting records kept by the Trust and a comparison of
the accounts presented with those records. lt also includes consideration of any unusual items or
disclosures in the accounts and seeks explanations from the trustees concerning any such matters.
The procedures undertaken do not provide all the evidence that would be required in an audit and
consequently I do not express an audit opinion on the view given by the accounts.
lndependent Examiner's Statement
ln the course of my examination no matter has come to my attention
Signed:
tm^*.{r-W-
Hannah Fawcett FMAAT
Rockbank
Low Askomil
Campbeltown
PA28 6EP
Date: 23 May 2023
Page 10

Page 11

Balance at 1 April
2021-2022
243391.73
2022-2023
221612.28
Grant lncome 28069.46 64987.24 1
Bank lnterest 707.17 689.1 5 2
Sundry 458.3
Total lncome 272626.66 287288.67
Grants Paid 46765.78 30215.85
General Maintenance 3221.52 3876.63 4
Miscellaneous 1027.08 712.76 5
Total Payments 51014.38 34805.24
Balance at 31 March 221612.28 252483.43
Balance Sheet
Bank of Scotland (CurrentAccount) 86533.71 110839.81 6
Development Fund (Virgin Money Dep. Acc.) 62119 65360.83
10% Retention Fund (Virgin MoneyTerm Deposits) 72959.57 76282.79 7
Total 252483.43221612.28
I certify that the above correctly identif ies the f inancial transactions for the year ended 31 March 2023 and the financial position at that date.
Auditor ConvEnor Secretary/Treasurer
Signature:
Name
ft&.Intrftrr fut".lr.err
I Brodie A Bennett
Date
231 5 | rors
15 May 2023 15 May 2023
1
East Kintyre Community Council Windfarm Trust - Receipts & Payments Accounts to 31 March 2023
ffif,ffiMlffi ',; j6ftE-i{frtfl{l'Yo,a4# "'
:
::) r.ll:- fl:l Notet ./1|XI;X
Receipts ,:..
Piy.fienls
ffi
Page 11

Page 12

3068.90 Paid by SSE into Deposit AccountTangy 2
30576.1 3 Paid by A&BC into current accountBienn an Tuirc 2
Paid by A&BC into current accountBeinn an Tuirc 1
10655.19 Paid by A&BC into current accountDeucheran Hill
64987.24
Notel -Grantlncome
Note2-Banklnterest
Note3-GrantsPaid
Note 4 - General Maintenance
172.93 See enclosed Statement of Credit lnterest PaidVirgin Money Deposit Acc. No. 4001 1275
151 .34 See enclosed Statement of Credit lnterest PaidVirgin Money 2 Yr Term Deposit Acc No 201 15765
364.88 See enclosed Statement of Credit lnterest PaidVirgin Money 2 Yr Term Deposit Acc No 40599519
689.15
800.00BACS Shopper-Aide Ltd Club for older people in Carradale467
9000.00BACS Canadale Golf Club Replacement Gator and Mower471
3071.10BACS Carradale Golf Club Replacement Gator and Mower (second payment)471
1468.20BACS Carradale Community Trust Display Cabinet for Heritage Centre463
1685.00461 BACS The Kintyre Way Maintenance and marketing of Kintyre Way
s00.00470 BACS CHEL Timing system for the Carradale Canter
6412.78Replacement Central Heating Boiler468 BACS Carradale Village Hall
1 600.00New posts and rails for Abbey car park457 BACS Saddell Abbey Trust
578.77CCT (Dr J Lee) Community Open Day at Village Hall474 BACS
100.00Carradale Village Hall Hire of Carradale Village Hall for Open Day474 BACS
3000.00BACS Carradale Primary School Parents Co. School outdoor project475(a)
2000.00476 BACS Carradale Village Hall Village Hall lnsurance Premium
30215.85
135.95BACS SSE Hydro Electricity - Well Park Pavilion
732.12Repairs to Well Park fencingBACS A W Gillies (Fencing)
180.00Paths cutting/maintenance MayBACS Carradale Garden Services
59.9910667 lan Buchanan Maintenance Flemembrance Gardens
180.00BACS Carradale Garden Services Paths cutting/maintenance June
180.00Paths cutting/maintenance JulyBACS Carradale Garden Services
150.00BACS MoK Cleaning Services Cleaning Saddell Abbey glass over summer months
124.68BACS J Semple Well Park Mower Repairs
187.67BACS SSE Hydro Electricity - Well Park Pavilion
180.00BACS Paths cutting/maintenance OctoberCarradale Garden Services
400.00BACS Robert Strang Grass cutting Play Park
875.00BACS Donald McAllister Grass cutting Well Park
330.00BACS Johnny Durnan Grass cutting Network Centre
BACS 161.22SSE Hydro Electricity - Well Park Pavilion
3876.63
2
ffiry '"."*
i ::il::. rl ,.r; i :: :
O4,0 [,22,,:',::= :,,:'
ll ^r iizt,u4.zz
1sr0$i0e 20687.O2
zeioSiea
Itlul l,
3t03l2s
0{,03r23
o I -uJ-zJ
ifotel:
0ffi ffihiilffi
W*$ttl&ffii
06i05,22
::i7,05:22
:1 05rAU
30r05i22
06.06122
13.06.22
i04r07"lAa
:26'Q7.22
0509;2[
05;09'ae
24,11:,,
ab,!1,2._ 2.2
Total'
lWW,1P";!i!ffi#
7zlr., lNr$.tr SNf#.r44{$iR\\\\\ilw
gtlgtsle:tffi
ffiirQ$i it
Eoirrr#tor,' ,:lI . .., ,- , ".:-1"i"f-: !-F5-: , . , .: f"i*-\' +!!'Et " "1\t ' ,: ,,.. ".'r- EFjd . r' rt'r\t;...-,\N: ,i"i. ;' :t* ; - .. 1\'i
0.6:i0-5.22:
13105'.22
08:06-;?2
2Q.o6:21':
_04-r07i22,:rr
:2A.08:22:
25.09.22
06iril.0i22
24,:!gl??,
ut. I I -tt
vr:t t-tz
IA.11E2
ffii0lrP3
24r0tt r20
Tolal
Page 12

Page 13

Note 5 - Miscellaneous
Note 6 - Contingent Liabilities
Note 7 - 10% Retention Fund
BACS 120Hannah Fawcett Auditor's fee annual accounts
BACS Rhona Elder Community website costs 146.85
BACS Wyvex Media Placement of public notice in The Courier 120.79
1 0669 Alasdair Bennett 187.O7Annual subscription for Zoom Pro community account
BACS Wyvex Media 138.05Placement of public notice in The Courier
712.76
886,533.71
Carradale Primary School Parents Co. Transport costs for extracurricular school activities 1500.00
Kintyre Songwriter's Festival 2023 Festival in Campbeltown (pro-rata contribution) 750.00
Kilbrannan Sound Affordable entertainment for East Kintyre residents 4500.00
The Kintyre Way Maintenance, promotion and administration costs KW 1728.OO
Live Argyll New gym equipment for Aqualibrium, Campbeltown 1500.00
9978.00
Term Deposit
No. 1
1 0% of total grant income fot 2021 122 (€2807) transferred by BACS from current account to
Virgin Money 2 Year Term Deposit Account No. 4049951 I (lncludes e364.88 interest)
45862.93.
Virgin Money 2 Year Term DepositAccount No. 20115765 will be renewed in March 2024when
interest accumulated will be added. (lncludes t151 .34 interest)
30419.86
76282.79
3
09,q5ir2
,1q..fi..9.,,,4
17;14:22
1 1,03;23
Tolaf
ffiffi
475(c)
469
o 1::::.::::
ffiffi i#ilt *&.w ,
un.9.li
Term Deposit
No.2
Page 13

Page 14

This page is intentionally left blank

Page 15

Page 15 Agenda Item 5

Page 16

Page 16

Page 17

Page 17

Page 18

Page 18

Page 19

Page 19

Page 20

Page 20

Page 21

Page 21

Page 22

Page 22

Page 23

Page 23

Page 24

This page is intentionally left blank

Page 25

Report for
The Argyll and Bute Windfarm Trust
By 
Inveraray Community Council 
For meeting on 7th September 2023 
Following on from last year’s report, to confirm the Clachan Farms (Inveraray) Windfarm
Trust have awarded the following grant: 
2023 
Inspire Inverary 
Awarded £500 
Inspire Inveraray applied for an award for the local Parent and Toddler’s group for insurance
and running costs for the toddlers group, to prevent the club having to close down. 
Inveraray Pipe Band 
Awarded £1500 
For the costs towards travel for the band to and from events and competitions.  The Pipe
band are recovering from a loss of finances dues to the pandemic. 
Inveraray Highland Games 
Awarded £2000 
For costs towards the hire of marquees and toilets for the Highland Games. 
Inveraray Golf Club 
Awarded £2000 
For costs towards the maintenance and improvement of the golf course and its facilities
such as sand bunkers, greens and clubhouse toilets which are maintained by volunteers. 
British Region 
Awarded £750 
For costs toward the Remembrance Parade which was held in Inveraray on the 17th of June
to commemorate the service of men and woman in the British Armed Forces. 
Page 25 Agenda Item 6

Page 26

Please find attached:
Accounts 2022-23 
Alyssa Stewart
Treasurer 
Inveraray Community Council 
Page 26

Page 27

Page 27

Page 28

This page is intentionally left blank

Page 29

ALIenergy Overview 2023     
Argyll, Lomond and the Islands Energy Agency (ALIenergy) is a sustainable energy charity based in
Argyll and Bute, Scotland. ALIenergy currently has a team of 16 working on a range of projects in
Affordable Warmth/Alleviation of Fuel Poverty; Education and Skills Development; and Local Energy. 
ALIenergy’s aims are: 
- To help people with fuel poverty and energy efficiency issues 
- To encourage community renewables and local energy economy
- To reduce carbon emissions and mitigate climate change. 
Affordable Warmth Advice Service – over the past year, funders have included Energy Redress
Scheme, Robertson Trust, Argyll & Bute Council, Highland Council, Bank of Scotland, Smart Energy
GB, Big Energy Saving Network, Scottish Federation of Housing Associations, Energy Action
Scotland / William Grant Foundation, Scottish Government’s Investing in Communities Fund, Argyll &
Bute Community Led Local Development Fund, SSE Renewables (Tangy), various donations. 
In response to the energy price crisis and the increasing number of households struggling to afford to
adequately heat their homes, we have further expanded our affordable warmth activities. 
Our service offers a range of energy advice topics to raise awareness, increase resilience and reduce
the risk of fuel poverty going forwards, alongside crisis interventions, referrals for insulation and
heating replacement schemes, support with complex issues and dealing with energy companies and
the ombudsman. We offer a mix of home visits, face-to-face advice at events and telephone sessions. 
We also deliver free training events, for frontline workers that support vulnerable or disadvantaged
people, to help them to recognise and refer fuel-poor households. This is an extremely effective way
for us to engage with hard-to-reach individuals who may otherwise be reluctant to ask for help for a
variety of reasons. We also receive a large number of direct enquiries. 
Our clients are typically vulnerable to fuel poverty for reasons such as low income, poor
health/disability, and reliance on high-cost heating. Many have no access to gas, often using electric
storage heaters on expensive electric tariffs. Many are self-restricting or in debt to suppliers. 
We have continued to access crisis payments for clients from various sources. These include: 
prepayment meter vouchers and bulk fuel deliveries from the Fuel Bank Foundation; energy debt
relief and ongoing cost payments from the Scottish Government Home Heating Support Fund; free
appliances (cookers fridges, freezers, washing machines) from the Glasspool Trust; and we are a
partner in the Argyll & Bute Flexible Food Fund which provides cash interventions alongside money
advice (from Bute Advice Centre) and energy advice from ourselves. We continue to prioritise urgent
cases, and aim to provide rapid financial assistance and crisis interventions wherever needed –
alongside providing the advice and referrals to address longer term resilience to fuel poverty. 
Among all the factors which make fuel poverty so serious here, particularly crucial is the lack of
access to mains gas across much of the area. Electric heating can be 3-4 times as expensive per
kWh than gas. We also have cold wet weather, energy inefficient housing, elderly demographics, and
typically low average incomes. Detailed recent statistics are not yet available, but fuel poverty is now
thought to affect over 50% (the majority) of households across northwest Scotland. 
Our advisors were overwhelmed with clients last winter and are likely to be again as soon as the
weather cools down, after a slight easing in client numbers over the summer months. We endeavour
Page 29 Agenda Item 7

Page 30

to offer advice and assistance to any individual who is struggling to pay their energy bills. In very busy
periods, there may be waiting times and we aim to prioritise the most needful clients. 
Community Energy for Energy Solidarity (CEES), funded by Horizon 2020.
Working with 10 partners from Portugal, France, Belgium, Croatia and UK, this 3-year European
project identifies, compares and analyses successful community energy initiatives to tackle fuel
poverty in different countries, and creates a toolkit for replication. Through investigating different
funding methods for tackling energy poverty, the project may also help us to diversify our own funding
methods. We continue to promote and disseminate our good practice activities and achievements
across the network and learn from others; and feed data into a formal evaluation exercise of partners’
good practices led by our academic partner, the University of Birmingham. 
Consumer Comfort Choice (funded by Scottish Government CARES, and Centrica’s Energy for
Tomorrow grant: Across much of rural Scotland, mains gas is unavailable, and many households use
electric storage heaters, which can be difficult to control and expensive to run – contributing to the
issue of fuel poverty. Charging may be controlled via smart control technology, providing greater
comfort and control, less energy waste and reduced costs. Working with technical partner Connected
Response, we seek to install smart controls in 90-100 households with storage heaters in Oban and
monitor the resulting improvements in energy bills and household comfort. This innovative project has
recently restarted after a pause due to issues with the energy price crisis which delayed the roll out of
smart meters and prevented people from switching suppliers. 
ALIenergy's Education and Skills Development Programme  
Funded by Scottish Power Renewables, Beinn an Tuirc Community Benefit Fund 'Regional Tranche'. 
This local economic development project encourages and facilitates young people to pursue local
careers in STEM subjects and the renewable energy sector, providing events, workshops and careers
advice in schools and communities, particularly in the areas of Mid Argyll and Kintyre. 
The project makes first contact with young people during their transition from P7 to S1, with activity
stands at events followed by energy and climate change-related classroom workshops, and careers
activities delivered in the three secondary schools in Campbeltown, Tarbert and Lochgilphead. In the
summer, each year, the ALIenergy education officers also run stands for the whole community at the
main Agricultural Shows in the area: Kintyre, Mid Argyll and Islay. 
In recent years, ALIenergy has created a series of three short films in 2021, 2022 and 2023
showcasing the diversity of careers opportunities in STEM related local businesses. The first, ‘STEM
Journeys in Argyll’ showcased four STEM professionals working in the Argyll & Bute area, highlighting
the range career paths open to young people as well as raising awareness of the opportunities for
STEM roles in the area. The 2022 film ‘A Day in Industry 2022’ followed a selection of pupils’ work
experience group placements organised by ALIenergy in local STEM-related workplaces. S4-6
applicants put into practice a range of employability skills in a bid to spend hands-on time in the
workplace, finding out at first-hand what the company does and how STEM skills are integrated into
the work of its staff. Building on these, ‘A Day in Industry 2023’ filmed 10 successful applicants from
school years S4-6 in individual work experience placements with 7 local STEM employers: Ardern
Yacht Centre, Argyll Pharmacy, DM Fabrications, Forestry and Land Scotland, Kintyre Gin, Midton
Acrylics, Renewable Parts). These films can be seen at https://www.alienergy.org.uk/education-
training-skills/ along with further information on all ALIenergy’s education-related activities. 
Going forward, education officers are now focussing on organising a major local careers event,
MAKSTEMFest in early 2024. This follows preparatory work and planning carried out for a previous
event which was due to take place in spring 2020, which sadly had to be cancelled at the last minute
due to the pandemic. Education Officers are delighted and excited to now be returning to this.
Page 30