Democracy Spraffa

CLD Partnership Annual Report 21-22 (003)

Argyll and Bute Council · 9 March 2023
Back to Community Services Committee — 9 March 2023 and its agenda

Text extracted from the council's PDF. Layout and reading order may differ from the original.

Original council PDF · Download plain text

Page 1

Appendix A
Argyll and Bute
Community Learning & Development
(CLD) Partnership
Annual Report
September 2021
- August 2022

Page 2

Welcome from Chair ............................................................................................................3
Vision, Values and Role of the Partnership ..........................................................4
Education Scotland His Majesty’s Inspector’s Visit  ......................................5
A Year in Numbers .................................................................................................................6
Case study 1 - The Power of Partnership Working ...................................7-8
Case study 2 - Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal le ...............................................9-10
Case study 3 - Making Mindful Music ...................................................................11
Case study 4 - No Wrong Path ............................................................................12-13
Case study 5 - SAWA “New Scots” Project .................................................14-15
Priorities for 2022-2023.....................................................................................................16
Thanks to our Partners ......................................................................................................17
Contents
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
2

Page 3

Welcome to our annual report
2021-2022. As the chair of the
newly formed Argyll and Bute
Community Learning and
Development Partnership, it is my
pleasure to present our first annual
report. Community Learning and
Development (CLD) is a method of
working with groups and individuals
of all ages to engage in learning,
personal development and active
citizenship. Support is focused
on disadvantaged or vulnerable
individuals or groups with the aim of
bringing about change in their lives
and communities.
I’m delighted to be able to outline
some of our many successes during
the year to realise our vision of
“Working together to improve lives
across Argyll and Bute by empowering
individuals and communities to lead
sustainable, fulfilling and happy
lives through continuous learning,
cooperative problem solving and
removing barriers to engagement,
health and wellbeing.”
The Community Learning &
Development (Scotland) Regulations
2013 place a statutory requirement
on local authorities to publish a plan
every 3 years’ outlining how it will
co-ordinate and secure “adequate
and efficient” Community Learning
& Development (CLD) provision with
other sector partners. Whilst Argyll
and Bute Council are required by
legislation to lead on meeting the
requirements of the CLD Regulations,
it is important to note that partners
must also be meaningfully involved,
taking collective ownership and
responsibility to produce, implement
and review the CLD Plan.
During the last 12 months, the focus
has very much been on partners
working more closely together to
plan and deliver services within
our schools and communities to
improve the learner offer. During
our self- evaluation process to
review year 1 of the plan aligned
to How Good Is Our CLD, partners
very much acknowledged the
improvements in joint working. There
are also clearer governance and
reporting arrangements in place via
the LiveArgyll board, Community
Planning Partnership (CPP) and
Community Services Committee.
Our Strategic Plan covers the period
September 2021- August 2024 and
sets out our priorities under six key
themes for the lifespan of the plan,
namely “Digital Skills”, “Core Skills for
Learning, Life and Work”, “Health and
Wellbeing”, “Your Voice”, “The Learner
Offer” and “Improving How We Work
as a Partnership”. This report brings
to life some great examples of the
implementation of our key themes
and then highlights our priorities the
coming year.
The ongoing
impact of the
COVID-19
pandemic has
affected our
children, young
people and
communities
significantly,
and we have
focussed
strongly on
meeting the needs of our most
vulnerable.
Two new workstream groups have
also been established to drive
forward key areas of work. Firstly
supporting learners to maximise
the use of digital technology for
essential digital skills for life and work
and secondly to focus on workforce
development across the sector
within Argyll and Bute, building on
the framework set out by the CLD
Standards Council and supporting
staff with their own development.
During 2021, Argyll and Bute won
the Scottish Government Children
and Young People Improvement
Collaborative Quality Improvement
2021 award for their Youth Advisory
Panel. The Youth Advisory Panel is
group of young people recruited to
ensure young people’s voices are
heard when creating the Children’s
Service plan. This was a 3 year
project lead by the Community
Learning Service, Third Sector, Health
and Education and supported by
the Children and Young Persons
Improvement Collaborative.
Education Scotland visited Argyll
and Bute in November 2021 as
part of the His Majesty’s Inspectors
(HMIe) programme for CLD focusing
on Covid-19 recovery. The overall
outcome was very positive having
been signed off with no further visit
planned in the short term.
Finally I’d like to express my sincere
thanks to all partners and staff
teams within the CLD sector across
Argyll and Bute for their resilience
during the last 12 months and their
commitment to working smarter
together.
Nicola Hackett
Chair CLD Partnership
Welcome
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
3

Page 4

Our Vision
“Working together to improve lives across Argyll and Bute by empowering
individuals and communities to lead sustainable, fulfilling and happy lives
through continuous learning, cooperative problem solving and removing barriers
to engagement, health and wellbeing.”
Values
The CLD Partnership has adopted the principles, values, ethics and
competencies set out by the CLD Standards Council for Scotland. The principles
that underpin CLD practice are:
Empowerment - increasing the ability of individuals and groups to influence
matters affecting them and their communities;
Participation - supporting people to take part in decision making;
Inclusion, equality of opportunity and anti-discrimination - recognising
some people need additional support to overcome the barriers they face;
Self – determination - supporting the right of people to make their own choices
Partnership - ensuring resources and the range of skills and capabilities
available are used effectively
Role of the CLD Partnership
• Being responsible for the development implementation, monitoring and  
reporting of the Argyll and Bute CLD Plan. This will include the appropriate  
risk management and mitigations given manpower and resources available
• Ensuring strategic priorities are aligned to key local and national plans and  
ensure there is no duplication of work
• Sharing and analysing data and identifying gaps to inform planning and  
decision making
• Fostering collaboration and where possible sharing resources across the  
partnership
• Putting in place delivery/workstream group arrangements to ensure  
effective implementation at operational and local level, taking into account  
geographical variations/needs
• Evaluating and reviewing the CLD plan on a regular basis, taking into  
account changing learner needs and ensure a culture of self-evaluation and 
improvement
• Communicating the work of the partnership to key partners, raising   
the profile of the work of the partnership and sharing and celebrating key  
successes
• Identifying and sharing examples of good practice
• Contributing to Education Scotland CLD inspections and other appropriate  
CLD quality assurance measures
Our Vision & Values
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
4

Page 5

Key Strengths Identified
• There is increased confidence in the leadership across staff at all levels, both
within the council, where responsibility remains for community development,
and within LiveArgyll, who now has responsibility for community learning.
CLD is now more outward looking, with leaders and staff engaging with and
learning from other local authorities. They are better connected to other CLD
networks such as the Northern Alliance.
• A self-evaluation and consultation process informed the development of the
CLD plan 2021-24 priorities. Where there are gaps, there are plans to revisit
during year one. LiveArgyll and partners engage well in the stronger processes
in place for self-evaluation. As a result, they know their strengths and areas
where improvement is required. This provides confidence in the leadership of
CLD.
• The role of partners in the delivery of CLD is much improved. As a result,
the CLD plan clearly outlines roles and responsibilities of partners. During
the pandemic, partnership working increased and this helped to enable the
rapid response to supporting communities and learners. As a result, there is
increased shared knowledge of what each partner has to offer. 
Improvement Areas
• Involvement of social work in the CLD Strategic Partnership
• Representation of LiveArgyll on the Argyll and Bute Child Protection
Committee
• Milestones and a timeline for other areas of priority are clearly outlined in the
CLD plan 2021-24. However, it is important that these areas are monitored
by the CLD strategic partnership regularly to ensure they are progressed
timeously.
• The CLD partnership recognise that there is more to do to strengthen the adult
learning offer, including building on opportunities for wider accreditation for
learners.
Education Scotland HMIe
Visit – November 2021
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
5

Page 6

A Year in Numbers
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
6
community groups
supported to deliver
adult learning
programmes as part of
the Community Based
Adult Learning (CBAL)
fund
10
multi agency
community learning
and employability hubs
established
6
partners/services
engaged in the CLD
Partnership
16
community groups
received community
capacity building
support
76
individuals completed
CLD nationally
recognised awards
99
young people engaged
in CLD activities/
programmes
174
Local Youth Action
Groups
7
adults engaged in
formal CLD activities/
programmes
95
adults engaged in CLD
events and informal
engagement activities
1254

Page 7

Strategic Theme - Improve how we work as a
Partnership
Need for the project – why?
The need for this project was identified by engagement with a range of
community groups contributing to the Caring for People and Test and Protect
responses.  The engagement explored the challenges and learning arising from
the pandemic, and looked to identify how collaborative working could strengthen
communities post-Covid or in response to future public health crises. A strong
theme of “Resilient Communities, Communication and Structures of Working
Together” emerged, with agreement that meetings with Covid-19 community
response groups facilitated by the Community Development team would provide
a platform to share information, identify local needs and offer the opportunity for
response groups to ask questions of CLD partners and other agencies.
The online meetings were initially held within each of the 4 areas of Argyll and
Bute to support local needs arising.  Following common challenges identified
and similar questions being asked in all areas, there was a move to support Argyll
and Bute wide meetings from August 2021 to increase opportunities for wider
networking and sharing of best practice.
Description – what and how?
The Community Development Team co-ordinated Argyll and Bute wide monthly
meetings of the Covid-19 community response groups from August 2021 - April
2022. These meetings brought together groups who supported the emergency
response to the Covid-19 pandemic in their communities, and who have been
active in supporting community recovery. Members swapped experiences
(whether of tough times or heartening successes), networked and shared
practice. The Community Development team provided support and updates, and
responded to requests for information from the Council, CLD Partnership and
Community Planning Partnership. 
For example:
• The team was able to offer group members’ staff and volunteers access
to the Council’s ‘My Healthy Advantage’ app, which offers access to
counselling and wellbeing services.
• During the emergence of the Omicron variant, groups reported difficulty
in finding accurate information on the dates and locations of vaccination
clinics. The team rapidly checked and circulated up to date data verified by
NHS Highland, meaning that group members could help more vulnerable
members of the community to attend clinics.
• In response to concerns about how to re-start community activities
safely, Community Development officers researched, collated and shared
information on free training opportunities and resources on a range of
relevant health and safety topics. They were also able to signpost groups to
appropriate contacts in the Council’s Argyll and Bute Safety Advisory Group
(SAG).
Information and minutes were shared with around 40 organisations, with
representatives attending meetings as and when it was helpful to them. Where
information and resources discussed at the meetings was likely to be relevant to
communities beyond the Covid-19 Community Response Group, these were also
highlighted in the Community Development team’s fortnightly Information for
Communities bulletin.
Case Study 1
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
7
The Power of Partnership Working

Page 8

Impact – the difference made
The impact of this work is best expressed by the feedback offered by
participants, who reported that the group helped them in various ways to
continue the vital work they had been delivering to support their communities
during and in recovery from the pandemic (see Evidence section, below).
The way in which we created conditions for community groups to be supported,
and to empower community groups within their communities in response to
Covid-19, was recognised as an example of Best Practice within Audit Scotland’s
Community Empowerment: Covid-19 report: Support for local networking:
Garelochhead Station Trust’s experience during Covid-19 — Communities
Channel Scotland (communityscot.org.uk)
Evidence – how do we know?
The case study above reflected feedback from our evaluation where 100% of
respondents said that the effectiveness of their group had increased as a result
of the support offered. Additional comments included:
“The meetings and information shared by the team and other responders has
helped us to guide our response to changing covid events. The meetings also
helped us not to feel like we were working in isolation which was helpful in itself” 
Bute and Cowal Elderly Befrienders
“I have appreciated opportunities to discuss my work in terms of maintaining
resilient personal morale, and also to recognise its significance in the wider context
of other Argyll communities responding to challenges of pandemic restrictions on
community life. The group sessions mitigated my sense of personal isolation, and
also resulted in helpful guidance in terms of risk assessments.” 
Ross of Mull and Iona Community Transport Scheme
Lessons Learned
Attendees of the group reported that they valued the support and signposting
from the Community Development team, and also the structure of the group.
This allowed them to share experiences and practice with peers, alleviating
feelings of isolation and making them feel less like they were working alone.
Feedback from those involved
“As a small local charity operating an additional emergency response during
lockdown and beyond, the Covid Response Group was vital for us! It connected
us to other similar organisations and even more importantly to the ‘bigger picture’,
ensuring we weren’t duplicating effort and limited resources.
It was particularly helpful to have the Community Development Team’s very
proactive help in accessing specific Covid funds.
It might sound inconsequential but one of the most important aspects of the group,
besides the practical support, was the feeling that we were appreciated further up
the chain – the mainstream media focus was on the NHS and not all the formal and
informal volunteering that was happening in charities and voluntary organisations
around the country. While we were working flat out with very vulnerable people,
many working folk relaxed to a different pace of working life during Covid, but not
us! - so that recognition was an important motivating factor that I could share with
my colleague and our community of volunteers.
However the Covid cloud did have a silver lining - one of the enduring benefits of
this group is the enhanced professional relationships I now have with the other
organisations involved and in particular our Community Development Officer.”
Jayne Burnett, Manager, Visiting Friends.
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
8
Case Study 1 The Power of Partnership Working

Page 9

Strategic Theme - Improve how we work as a
Partnership
Project Update
Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal le… was a
project conceived by Argyll and Bute
Council to provide an opportunity for
the Gaelic community in Argyll and
Bute to come together and celebrate
the wealth of talent that Argyll
has to offer.  This was particularly
important due to the pandemic
and the increased isolation of our
communities at the time the events
began.
The application was for six online Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal le… events including
artist’s fees and a small amount for technical support.
Brief Resume
Thanks to the Tasgadh fund six Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal le… events took place
between May and October 2021 on the Argyll Gaelic Forum Facebook page. 
They included a wide range of talented Argyll artists including: Ian Smith, Alasdair
Whyte, Sìleas Sinclair, Màiri McGillivray, Joy Dunlop, Rona Wilkie and Marit Fält. 
Through the breadth of artists the events represented Argyll Gaelic songs
and tunes from Tiree, Mull, Connel, Islay and Oban.  The material ranged from
traditional to new and original work created by the Argyll artists themselves.
Over the course of the six events 202 people attended live.  There was lots of
Gaelic engagement in the comments.  Whilst many of the attendees were from
Argyll and Bute the online nature also enabled people from across the UK to
attend as well as America and Australia. 
The recorded events continue to be live on the Facebook page and are a great
resource.  To date they have been collectively viewed 8700 times.
Outcomes/Aims
The project:
• Fostered a sense of community and brought together Gaelic speakers and
learners from across Argyll and Bute
• Promoted the wealth of music, songs and poetry of Argyll and Bute
Lasting legacies:
• The recorded events are remaining on the Facebook page and will continue
to be promoted via the Argyll Gaelic Gathering
• There is now a collection of over 50 songs unique to Argyll, both traditional
and new.  They are now accessible to all in the one place
• There is interest for the recorded events to be shared with those with
dementia
• Argyll and Bute Council have made links with some wonderful artists and
these links are helping with other projects
• There are plans for a series of Argyll song workshops at Furan
Case Study 2
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
9
Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal le… Report
Tasgadh grant awarded £955
Total project cost £1515
Tasgadh contribution as % of total 63%
Number of beneficiaries 7 Gaelic artists
202 people attended the event live
There have been 8700 views of the
recordings to date

Page 10

Quotes from Participants
“I thoroughly enjoyed the Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal le sessions.  For me, they were
an excellent mix of performers I was familiar with and some that were new to me
(same goes for the songs and tunes). Being able to attend online was great because
I didn’t have to sort out childcare or use of the car, so it was easier for me to attend. 
They also felt really relaxed because the performers were in their own homes too – it
felt like a kitchen cèilidh.
The fact that they were delivered in Gaelic, and the chat stream was mainly in
Gaelic was a real bonus too.  I’m a Gaelic learner and the live chat felt much less
formal than a conversation group.”
Laura
“I’d like say how much I have enjoyed your series of Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal online
events. It has been lovely to see how Argyll talent has been showcased. I have
particularly enjoyed the mix of more seasoned performers, together with young
upcoming talent. They used a delightful mix of Argyll songs, too which has inspired
me to seek out and learn some of the Bàrdachd Earra-Ghàidhealach. Thanks for
brightening up the “lockdown”!”
Audrey Paterson, Taynuilt
“I was having cancer treatment during the summer of these concerts so it was really
nice to curl up on the sofa and listen to music from my favourite place in the world
– Argyll.  Now I want to explore these songs further and unlock their stories, and find
out more about favourite places, so the resource on the facebook page is a brilliant
starting point.  I even got to practice my gaidhlig on the chat.  Math fhein a h-uile
duine!”
Participant
Quotes from Artists 
“Bha e na thlachd dhomhsa gun deach iarraidh orm òrain a ghabhail mun
sgìreachd agam fèin aig fear de na tachartasan san t-sreath seo.  Tha mise den
bheachd gu bheil e riatanach gun tèid tachartasan a tha gan cumail tro mheadhan
na Gàidhlig air fad a chur air dòigh gu cunbhalach ann an Earra-Ghàidheal:
creathal na Gàidhlig ann an Alba.  Tha feum air gach cuid tachartasan tro
mheadhan na Gàidhlig, na Beurla agus dà-chànanach gun teagamh ach feumaidh
sinn barrachd thachartasan a chur air dòigh tro mheadhan na Gàidhlig air fad gun
leisgeul.  Air uairean aig tachartasan dà-chànanach, tha mise a’ faireachdainn mar
sheinneadair Gàidhlig gum feum mi leisgeul a thoirt seachad airson a’ Ghàidhlig a
bhruidhinn ann agus cha bu chòir.  Feumaidh sinn a’ Ghàidhlig àbhaisteachadh san
dòigh seo ach am faic an òigridh gu h-àraid gun tig i beò às aonais na Beurla.  Bu
mhath leam taing mhòr a chur don luchd-eagrachaidh agus don Chomhairle.”
Alasdair Whyte
“Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal was a great initiative by Argyll and Bute Council during
a difficult time for musicians and music lovers alike. To have music and song from
different areas of Argyll was of great interest to me and that interest was definitely
shared by the audiences both here and abroad. It was a pleasure to be a part
of and a great way for me to share both well and lesser known songs of Islay. I
received some lovely feedback after the concert including from people who had not
come across my music before which was incredibly humbling. I would like to again
thank the Council for having me perform and hope this is something which can be
explored again in the future, perhaps in person as well as online.”
Gun robh math agaibh, Mairi McGillivray
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
10
Case Study 2 Oidhche Earra-Ghàidheal le… Report

Page 11

Strategic Theme - Health & Wellbeing
The liveArgyll Community Learning (CL) Team in Kintyre worked in partnership
with The Kintyre Link Club, a local mental health club run by members for
members, with its main aim being to promote the welfare of those who suffer or
have suffered from mental ill health.
The group participated in the
Community Learning and
Development (CLD) Community
Consultation Exercise, in which
Health and Wellbeing came out as
top in their main priorities within the
Core Themes. The CL team then
carried out further consultations
with the group members who
came up with the idea of writing
and producing a song about the
Link Club to promote it to the wider
community.
The Link Music Club Project introduced them to writing and producing music
with the aim of improving the participants’ general wellbeing, reducing isolation
and promoting wellness.
Learner Evaluations/Feedback
“Music and song craft is about people; before I had these classes I knew how to
write songs but the social contact has made me more skilful, especially working as
a team and using collaboration and other people’s ideas. Before I was on my own
now I can work with others.”
“Such a great opportunity to learn something I would never have had before. It was
such fun working with others and also having the support of the Link Club, Dawn &
Jamie”
“The Link Club Music Project with Jamie and Dawn has been excellent. A lot of fun
and great therapy. We would love more music activities. The whole Link Club felt
more positive! Thank you!”
Case Study 3
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
11
Making mindful music

Page 12

Strategic Theme - Core Skills For Life, Learning
and Work
Need for the project – why?
Young Person’s Guarantee (YPG) Pre-Employment Support (delivered by
WorkingRite – member of the Argyll and Bute Employability Partnership).
Sarah, age 16, lives in Argyll. She was referred to WorkingRite programme via
Skills Development Scotland, a mentored programme of learning and work
experience for young people who want to work. It comprises of one-to-one
sessions to gain soft skills and personal development followed by mentored
work placement in an industry of the young person’s choice.
Sarah’s aim was to gain further work experience in the child care sector and
begin an apprenticeship course.
Description – what and how?
Sarah had left school at earliest opportunity due to difficulties in attendance
because of social anxiety, distress and mental health issues. She struggled
academically due to dyslexia and dyspraxia which also caused her to experience
bullying at school. Her self-esteem was very low.
Sarah’s own assessment of her barriers included shyness; feeling awkward and
not having many friends; uncertainty about what she wanted to do as career;
mental health issues (including disclosure of self-harm when experiencing
bullying at school); anxiety and a lack of life experience and emotional resilience.
Sarah had low self-esteem and confidence in her capabilities, particularly in
terms of literacy and so all induction sessions were on a one-to-one basis to
focus on this rather than any group sessions.
Impact – the difference made
Bearing in mind the disrupted school attendance Sarah had, the placement was
phased to build timekeeping and resilience and to introduce her to a structured
timetable, allowing her to show commitment and progress. This was achieved
with an initial two days per week and ending at four days per week.
The mentorship of staff at the nursery led to her becoming chattier with
colleagues and her self-confidence grew as a result. She was able to make
contributions at staff meetings and make suggestions to the day-to-day plans
and organising.
Sarah initially wanted to begin an apprenticeship course with the nursery, but
the manager felt she would not manage the SVQ level 3 (which would position
her for the SQA level 6 in house apprenticeship) as it would require more support
than she could provide. As an experienced mentor she suggested Sarah start at
a course closer to Nat4 and encouraged her to speak to other apprentices who
had started this way.
The Nursery Manager and Project Coordinator, aware that this suggestion
being different to Sarah’s initial goal may impact on her new found, but fragile,
confidence and self-esteem ensured Sarah understood the positives she had
achieved and how she could gain qualifications without causing her stress and
anxiety. As a result Sarah changed her mind about the further education course
and successfully applied for the Introduction to Child Care course. Her increased
maturity and experience was demonstrated in considering and progressing with
this option.
Sarah was continually motivated and supported by her Mum throughout the
programme, who disclosed when in contact with the Project Coordinator about
the suggested progression to college that Sarah has stopped self-harming as a
coping mechanism for her emotional distress.
The WorkingRite Project Coordinator supported Sarah to complete the online
Health & Safety Training (Atlas) as well as the range of modules and sessions
which make up the induction phase of the YPG programme.
Case Study 4
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
12
No wrong path

Page 13

Evidence – how do we know?
The phased placement and support of placement nursery enabled Sarah to
progress from two days to four days a week on placement.
Online health & safety training and preparation for work placement induction.
Sarah will remain on an extended placement with the nursery until August and
then progress to the Introduction to Child Care course at college – three days
in college and one at other childcare providers. Whilst at college she has been
invited to volunteer at the nursery to gain more experience and build on the
learning.
Lessons Learned
This case study shows that there is more than one path for individuals to realise
their ambitions to pursue a particular and successful career.
Learner Feedback
As noted above, Sarah’s Mum had disclosed that as a result of being on the YPG
Pre-Employment Support Programme, Sarah has stopped self-harming as a
coping mechanism for her emotional distress.
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
13
Case Study 4 No wrong path

Page 14

Strategic Theme - Health & Wellbeing
Need for the project – why?
Since the winter of 2015, Syrian refugees have been coming to Rothesay on the
Isle of Bute. Due to tragic worldwide developments an increasing number of
refugees have been placed on the island initially predominantly from Muslim
backgrounds but more recently a substantial number from Ukraine.
The island is part of the council area of Argyll and Bute, the island resident
population has been declining steadily over the last 20 years, according to
the population census in 2000 – 7,230; 2010 – 6,500; 2020 – 5,990 – also the
population is predominantly elderly, over sixty five per cent are over 65 years old. 
Therefore it seems an ideal place to place refugees so as well as other factors
they can help address the population decline and because they are all under 65
they can bring new vitality to the island.
Description –what and how?
The island has a history of being welcoming but obviously incomers and local
residents alike both experience cultural differences. SAWA means ‘together’ in
Arabic, so the project was set up to provide a ‘cultural bridge’ so the participants
are local volunteers and learners
and ‘new Scots’ recent arrivals to the
island.
The main activities have been
mentoring matching of volunteers
directly one to one with refugees in
order to facilitate English learning,
integration and friendship. Joint away
day activities, this year there have
been trips to Benmore Gardens near
Dunoon, Blair Safari Park as well as
trips on the island itself for example
the round Bute bus tour, a walk to
Ardencraig gardens, etc. There has
also been an excursion to see a
travelling Scottish Opera performance
at Mount Stuart in addition a modern
dance performance there.  We have
also initiated the New Horizons
women’s empowerment programme
which has been very successful,
so much so that the women of the
two main communities Muslim and
Ukrainian meet up in a different one of
their houses, every week and pair off in
different language groups in order to
exclusively speak English.
Other ongoing activities are every
Tuesday morning there is book repair
group at Mount Stuart library, it was
particularly interesting for the Syrians
to work on a 170 year old copy of
the Koran and also a very old Arabic
English dictionary –one of the oldest
of these in existence.
The video class happens on a
Tuesday afternoon and the videos are
uploaded onto the internet please see
the youtube  ‘Ameen N SAWA Bute’
channel.
Every Saturday morning at the Bank
of Ideas in the High Street there is
an art class for 11 to 15 year olds which is taken by volunteers namely Larrainne
Duquemen , a retired English artist now resident on Bute and Volodymyr
Durytskyi , from Kiev, another artist who has recently arrived from the Ukraine.
Case Study 5
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
14
SAWA “New Scots” Project

Page 15

CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
15
Case Study 5 SAWA “New Scots” Project
We have an ongoing relationship with Mount Stuart and the local University
of Highlands and Islands College Argyll, we initially had a tree planting day
subsequently five of the Muslim refugees have completed the level 3 SQA unit in
horticulture the aim of the course is to help the refugees gain employment.
An Arabic book section and Ukraine book section are being created in the
libraries, in consultation with, regarding what books to order etc. members of
both communities.
Leisure passes, most of the refugees, from both communities and also the
volunteers have registered and received one year free leisure passes this allows
them to go swimming and attend keep fit classes for a year for free.
We are presently setting up a bike repair class this has been done in conjunction
with the local CLD men’s group and also the police, who allowed us to collect
abandoned bikes around the island and gave us some of their unclaimed bikes.
This class will be taught by Lucian, who is himself a new Scot, having arrived on
the island from Poland and set up a bike hire shop.
Impact – difference made
The impact has been to create a
solidarity amongst the two main sets
of refugees who regularly meet as
parts a mens group and womens
group. Also we have a great volunteer
network who regularly meet up and
engage with the new Scots.  There
is a definite reduction in feelings of
isolation as this is often reported in
the groups.
Evidence – how do we know?
As evidenced by the fact we have helped people into employment at the local
cheese factory and hotels. New businesses have opened, for example Brandane
Barbers has been opened by a Syrian family, who we put in touch with Business
Gateway, young people through engagement with us and the college and have
gone on to take courses on the mainland and through of course word of mouth
feedback.
Lessons Learned
There are ongoing lessons to be learned – mainly to continue the integration
between what is effectively three communities, the refugee Muslims, the
recently arrived Ukrainians and the local community. To build on what has
already been achieved but to perhaps focus a bit more on creating self-reliance
amongst the refugee communities, especially in the fields of pursuing further
education and employment.
Learner Feedback
Olena the wife of Ukrainian artist
Volodymyr who arrived in August in
interview said “we are very grateful
to SAWA, the local council and all
the people of Bute for their help and
support during this difficult time for us
and our country”
Wafa Murad from Syria – “I’m very
happy to be on the board of SAWA and
am grateful to them and all the people
of Rothesay who have made us feel
very welcome”.

Page 16

Following the self - evaluation process and further learner consultation at the end of year one, the following
priorities have been identified for year 2. These priorities will be embedded into the six themes and form the
action plan for 2022-2023.
Health and Wellbeing
Community engagement work and community empowerment
Targeted family learning interventions
Grow adult learning offering
Identification of shared performance indicators across CLD
Partnership
All of our work will be underpinned by our commitment to equality and inclusion.
Priorities for 2022-2023
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
16

Page 17

Partners
CLD Annual Report 2021-2022
17
With thanks to our partners within the Argyll and Bute CLD Partnership
liveArgyll • HSCP - Public Health • Argyll and Bute Council Education Service • Argyll and Bute Council Economic Growth • Argyll and Bute Drugs and Alcohol
Partnership • Argyll College UHI • Third Sector Interface • 3rd sector community organisations representative • Strategic Housing Forum • Skills Development Scotland •
Department for Work and Pensions • Community Planning management team • Argyll and Bute Council Community Development team • Police Scotland • Scottish Fire
and Rescue • Argyll and Bute Social Work