Item 3 Appendix 2 - final draft overprovision assessment

West Dunbartonshire Council · 11 October 2023
Back to Licensing Board — 11 October 2023 and its agenda

Text extracted from the council's PDF. Layout and reading order may differ from the original.

Original council PDF · Download plain text

Page 1

PART 4 
OVERPROVISION 
29. Pro-active assessment of overprovision 
29.1 Section 7 of the Act requires the Licensing Board to include in its Statement of
Licensing Policy a statement as to the extent to which the Licensing Board
considers there to be overprovision of licensed premises, or licensed premises
of a particular description, in any locality within the Licensing Board’s area.   
29.2 The Licensing Board is of the view that its assessment of overprovision is a key
tool in tackling alcohol-related health harms within West Dunbartonshire. In
particular, the information submitted by the NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde is
of particular importance. The Licensing Board hopes that a robust overprovision
assessment underpinned by probative evidence as well as whole population
measures such as minimum unit pricing can help address the foregoing health
harms. 
29.3 The Licensing Board notes that setting out a clear and transparent Assessment
of Overprovision will offer a clear indication to potential applicants within the
localities identified as areas of overprovision that, depending on the nature of
their application, they may face abortive costs should they not rebut the
presumption against the granting of the application whilst always treating each
application on its own merits. The Assessment further clearly narrates the
factors that the Licensing Board will have regard to when considering whether
to grant an application in a locality designated as being overprovided for. 
29.3 It is for the Licensing Board to determine which localities within the Licensing
Board’s area are considered for the assessment of overprovision. In identifying
the localities the Licensing Board has had regard to the material gathered as
part of its pre-consultation exercise (see paragraph 7 for further information). 
29.4 In its Assessment of Overprovision, the Licensing Board has continued its
established approach of utilising the Scottish Neighbourhood Statistics
intermediate data zone geographies as the localities for this purpose. A number
of agencies use intermediate data zone geographies to collate and publish
statistics. Using these geographies allows the analysis of statistics and the
number, capacities and hours of licensed premises. 
29.5 The West Dunbartonshire area can be broken up in to 18 distinct IDZ localities.
These intermediate data zones represent small geographical sections of the
West Dunbartonshire Council area equivalent to an average of 4,000 household
residents. 
29.6 The Licensing Board, having examined data regarding:- 
 Alcohol Related Hospital Admissions;
 Alcohol Related Death Rate ;
 Alcohol Related Mental Health;

Page 2

 the Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation;
 police incidents including assaults, domestic incidents, disorder &
alcohol specific crimes; and
 information regarding the number, capacity and licensed hours of
licensed premises; 
as well as its own local knowledge and having regard to its duty to promote the
licensing objectives the Licensing Board is of the view that there is
overprovision of certain types of the licensed premises as detailed at paragraph
29.9 within several localities in the Licensing Board area. 
29.7 When considering the material outlined at paragraph 29.6 the Licensing Board
had regard to the impact of Minimum Unit Pricing and considering all the
information before it was of the view that the information presented to it justified
an approach being taken on a local level. This allows the Licensing Board to
address the issues presented by the number, capacity, and hours of licensed
premises in several localities within West Dunbartonshire. 
29.8 A summary of the evidence considered by the Board in assessing overprovision
can be found on the Licensing Board’s webpage1. ].  
29.9 The Licensing Board considers there to be overprovision of the following types
of licensed premises namely:- 
 public houses;
 nightclubs;
 off-sales and local convenience stores; and
 supermarkets. 
29.10 The Licensing Board will determine as a matter of fact whether the subject
premises in an application fits within one of the foregoing categories of licensed
premises. The Licensing Board will come to a view on a premises category
based on the consideration of any evidence presented to it and having regard
to the information disclosed within the application (including but not limited to
the description of premises narrated), the operating plan and the layout plan. 
29.11 The Licensing Board having regard to the forementioned information at
paragraph 29.6 is satisfied that there is sufficient evidence to establish a
dependable causal link between alcohol related harm and the number, hours
and capacity of licensed premises at the level of an intermediate data zone and
in order to promote the licensing objective of Protecting and Improving Public
Health considers there to be overprovision of the foregoing types of licensed
premises within West Dunbartonshire in the following 15 localities:- 
 IZ01 Clydebank East inc. Whitecrook (part); 
 IZ02 Clydebank Central inc. Dalmuir (part) & Whitecrook (part); 
1 https://www.west-dunbarton.gov.uk/business/licences-permits-and-permissions/west-
dunbartonshire-licensing-board/

Page 3

 IZ03 Drumry & Linnvale; 
 IZ04 Parkhall South, Radnor Park and North Kilbowie; 
 IZ06 Faifley & Hardgate East; 
 IZ08 Mountblow, Parkhall West and Dalmuir Central;
 IZ10 Barnhill, High Overtoun, Milton & Bowling; 
 IZ11 Dumbarton North East – Bellsmyre & Silverton East; 
 IZ12 Dumbarton Central, Dumbarton East & Townend; 
 IZ13 Dumbarton West;
 IZ14 (Renton, Old Bonhill & Loch Lomond;
 IZ15 Bonhill, Lomondgate & Renton North; 
 IZ16 Alexandria Central, Rosshead & Dalmonach;
 IZ17 Balloch & Alexandria North; and  
 IZ18 Jamestown, Balloch North East, Haldane & Gartocharn. 
Of particular relevancy to the Licensing Board is that when looking at Alcohol
Related Hospital Admissions, Alcohol Related Death Rate, and Alcohol Related
Mental Health, the above noted intermediate data zones have two or more
indicators worse than the Scottish average. 
For the avoidance of doubt, the Licensing Board considers, subject to the terms
of paragraph 30, that there is currently no overprovision in the following
localities:- 
 IZ05 Goldenhill, Parkhall North, East Kilbowie & Hardgate Central;
 IZ07 Duntocher & Concho; and
 IZ09 Old Kilpatrick. 
Maps of all 18 localities which make up the West Dunbartonshire area can be
found in the appendices section of this policy. 
29.12 The effect of this policy is to create a rebuttable presumption against the grant
of an application within these localities for types of licensed premises noted at
paragraph 23.9.  Each application still requires to be determined on its merits
and there may be exceptional cases in which an applicant is able to
demonstrate that the grant of the application would not undermine the licensing
objectives, or the objectives would not be undermined if the applicants
operating plan were to be modified.  The Licensing Board will expect applicants
who are seeking the grant of a new premises licence within the foregoing
categories of premises and locality to provide robust and reliable evidence to
the Board demonstrating why the benefit to the licensing objectives through the
grant of their application outweighs the detriment to the licensing objectives and
this policy.  In particular, the Licensing Board recognises the positive health

Page 4

benefits associated with increased employment opportunities as a factor that
applicants may use in support of their application and a factor that may in
appropriate circumstances rebut such a presumption. In particular, the Board
will expect to be addressed on the benefits of granting the application in terms
of each licensing objective.   
29.13 As part of the Licensing Board’s Assessment of Overprovision it has considered
the number, capacity, and licensed hours of licensed premises of the types
specified within each locality. The Licensing Board is aware that the capacity
and hours of a premises can increase by the grant of a variation application in
terms of section 29(5) of the Act.  The Licensing Board considers that an
application seeking an increase in capacity and/or hours will activate a
rebuttable presumption against the grant of the application. 
29.14 If an existing licence ceases to be in force this does not necessarily mean that
there is capacity for a new licence of a similar capacity.  The material
considered by the Licensing Board evidences that there is presently an
overprovision of licensed premises in particular localities within West
Dunbartonshire but does not quantify the extent of that overprovision in
numerical terms. In these circumstances any application seeking to replace
capacity relinquished by other premises will be subject this policy.  This will
have particular regard to the data relating to the intermediate data zone to which
the new application or application for increased capacity relates.  It will also
have regard to the type of premises capacity relinquished compared to the type
of premises applied for. 
29.15 The Licensing Board is aware that most of the 18 sub localities are in close
proximity to areas with significant alcohol related health, crime and disorder
problems.  The Licensing Board is also aware that there is local evidence to
suggest that persons in West Dunbartonshire, wishing to obtain alcohol from
off-licences will travel up to two miles across sub-localities to purchase alcohol.
Similarly persons will travel across the whole of West Dunbartonshire to attend
nightclubs.  Accordingly any application outwith the overprovision locality for
new premises or increased capacity of existing premises of the type specified
at paragraph 29.9 may be subject to an overprovision assessment.  This
assessment will have regard to the alcohol related crime, disorder and health
data relating to both the sub locality in which the application premises are
located and the sub localities from where the customers are likely to be drawn.   
30. Reactive overprovision assessment 
30.1 Sections 23(5)(e) and 30(5)(d) of the Act respectively allows the Licensing
Board to refuse an application for the grant or variation of a premises licence
where the Licensing Board considers that, if the application were to be
granted, there would, as a result, be overprovision of licensed premises, or
licensed premises of the same or similar description as the subject premises,
in the locality. 
30.2 It is, in the view of the Licensing Board, important to make sure that the grant
of a premises licence or variation to increase the capacity or hours of a

Page 5

premises licence does not result in there being an overprovision of licensed
premises in a particular locality. The Licensing Board will therefore carefully
consider overprovision on a reactive basis by having regard to the ground of
refusal for overprovision on a case by case basis. 
30.3 The Licensing Board recognises the value in giving potential applicants an
indication of how it will approach the foregoing ground of refusal. Where a
relevant application is considered by the Board it will consider the locality to
be the intermediate data zone in which the premises is located. Accordingly,
the Board will have regard to the number, capacities and hours of licensed
premises within the relevant intermediate zone as well as any other material
submitted to it as part of the application process, including but not limited to,
objections, representations, anti-social behaviour reports from Police
Scotland, and the Board’s own local knowledge. 
30.4 Applicants will be provided with details of premises including their type,
capacity, and hours in advance of any hearing. The Licensing Board will
expect to be addressed on whether the grant of the premises licence or
variation will not result in an overprovision of licensed premises in that locality.