Democracy Spraffa

Policy Leads Report

Argyll and Bute Council · 26 November 2025
Back to Argyll and Bute Council — 26 November 2025 and its agenda

Text extracted from the council's PDF. Layout and reading order may differ from the original.

Original council PDF · Download plain text

Page 1

ARGYLL AND BUTE COUNCIL  COUNCIL   
26th November 2025 
POLICY LEADS REPORT   
1. INTRODUCTION 
1.1 This report provides members with an update on key areas of activity for
each Policy Lead Councillor. This aims to provide updates from all Policy
Leads as regularly as possible, so that all members are informed, up-to-date
and able to engage with current issues. This report covers the period since
the last update provided to Council on 24th September up to 7th November
2025. 
2. RECOMMENDATIONS 
2.1 Members are asked to consider the report.   
3. POLICY LEAD FOR BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT – Cllr Math Campbell-
Sturgess     
3.1 Introduction: This report provides an update on key activity in the
Business Development portfolio, including economic development,
employability, digital infrastructure, rural investment programmes and
film/media promotion.
3.2 Regeneration and Capital Projects: 
Lochgilphead CARS: All funding is now committed. Four priority buildings
have been completed with the final two due to conclude by 31st October.
Shopfront improvements are finished and a celebratory community event
was held on 27 September with strong attendance and positive feedback.
Helensburgh CARS: All shopfronts are complete and priority buildings are
on site. Two small-repair grants were issued for the Grade A Macintosh
Club and a roof refurbishment covering four properties.

Page 2

Tarbert Heritage and Place Programme: Funding applications were
submitted to the National Lottery Heritage Fund and Historic Environment
Scotland; outcomes are expected December/January.
Regeneration Capital Grant Funding (RCGF) 2026/27: Four projects have
successfully passed Stage 1 Expressions Of Interest — Kintyre Sea
Sports (£800k), Nonhebel Park (£595k), Tarbert Harbour Water Sports
Hub (£85k), and Tighnabruaich Refuelling Hub (£120k). Stage 2 bids are
in preparation.
3.3 Business and Employability:
Economic Growth: UK Shared Prosperity Fund: The 2025/26 transition
year funding (£200 k) is now fully committed. Uncertainty remains over the
replacement funding model from 2026–27.Early data shows strong
business impact: turnover among supported firms rose 45–47% and
employment by around 45%.
Employability and Tackling Child Poverty: Delivery continues through the
Council and third-sector partners (InspirAlba, Street League, Clyde
Fishermen’s Trust). By 30 September 2025, 187 participants had started
programmes, including 73 parents. Work placements and training via the
UKSPF scheme continue to perform well with 26 participants gaining
qualifications.
Parental Welfare Fund: Uptake is steady; funds of up to £1 000 help
parents transition to work.
3.4 Campbeltown and MACC Visit: On 17th October 2025, I visited Kintyre
with officers to tour major sites including:
● The new distillery and bonded warehouse nearing completion at
Machrihanish.
● The MACC (Machrihanish Airbase Community Company) site, where
discussions covered future investment potential, redevelopment of the
former CS Wind buildings, and progress with the MachLab rocket
testing facility.
● Several town centre regeneration projects focused on shop
redevelopment and small-business growth.
The visit underlined the importance of sustained infrastructure and skills
investment to support the area’s growing high-tech and energy-linked
industries. Engagements also included discussions on the long-term future
of the MACC site and its integration with the wider Rural Growth Deal
ambitions.

Page 3

At Campbeltown Bond

Page 4

3.4 Economic Growth and New Sectors:
Machrihanish and Space Activity: Following the visit, interest in using the
site for space-related research and testing remains high.
Clipper Round the World Race: Oban confirmed as a 2026 host port.
“Team Scotland” yacht, funded from public funds, SAMS and Diageo, and
came first in the first leg.
International Winter Swimming Championship: Officers are supporting
event delivery in Oban, December 2025.
3.5 Islands and Infrastructure: We have received confirmation of multiple
successful bids to the Scottish Government’s Islands Programme 2025/26.
Argyll and Bute has secured an exceptionally strong outcome, attracting
well over £1.5 million of new external investment across our island
communities.
The successful projects demonstrate the breadth of the Council’s
partnership working and the ambition within our island communities to
deliver tangible, long-term benefits:
• Former Royal Hotel, Rothesay – £400 000 for detailed design
works that will bring a long-vacant landmark building in the town
centre back into productive use.
• Community Digital Hubs Phase 2 – £125 000, supporting Colonsay,
Jura, Lismore and Luing to establish or expand digital coworking
and community connectivity spaces, ensuring full-fibre
infrastructure translates into real local benefit.
• Unlocking Ulva (Landing Craft Project) – £40 020, creating an
essential marine transport link for residents, visitors and the island
economy.
• Skerryvore Lighthouse Cottages – £306 050, enabling restoration
and repurposing of the historic accommodation to support tourism
and heritage activity.
• Multi-Use Games Area, Isle of Gigha – £20 000, providing
accessible sport and recreation space for island children and
families.
• Bowmore Hall, Islay – £100 000, funding critical refurbishment and
energy-efficiency improvements to preserve this important
community venue.
• Isle of Luing Slate Quarry and Shore Works – £20 000, supporting
local enterprise and the cultural heritage of the former quarry.
• Tobermory Worker Accommodation Infrastructure – approx. £100
000, to help deliver enabling works for much-needed local housing
capacity.

Page 5

• Islay Energy Trust – £401 843 through the Carbon Neutral Islands
programme to install energy-efficiency measures in community
buildings across Islay.
Collectively, these awards represent a major vote of confidence in Argyll
and Bute’s island regeneration strategy. They showcase how strong
community partnerships, robust business cases, and a clear vision for low-
carbon, resilient infrastructure can draw significant national investment
even in a tight funding climate.
3.6 Community Led Local Development (CLDD): Twelve projects were
funded under the 2025/26 round, supporting community hubs, energy
efficiency and resilience projects. 
A further eight projects were awarded funding (c. £70 k total) through the
CLLD Development and Improvement Challenge Fund to help
organisations innovate or improve financial resilience.
3.7 Digital Infrastructure and Connectivity: Digital Connectivity: 96.6 % of
premises now have access to fibre broadband; 89.8 % can achieve > 30
Mbps. 
Full-fibre (> 100 Mbps) availability stands at ~26 %. 
Phase 2 of Island Digital Hubs (£125k) will support Colonsay, Jura,
Lismore and Luing. 
Discussions continue with Openreach and BDUK on Project Gigabit
delivery and rural resilience. 
Following Storm Amy outages, resilience reviews are underway including
the use of Starlink backhaul on Tiree. 
4 POLICY LEAD FOR CARE SERVICES – Cllr Dougie McFadzean 
4.1 Primary Care: Investment has been secured to ensure the sustainability
of board-managed practices in Kilcreggan and Garelochead. The
investment will ensure a sustainable workforce model following community
engagement and a formal practice merger between the two sites. The
additional investment will reduce the long-standing locum spend across
these practices, mitigating some of the forecasted HSCP overspend
before the end of the financial year. Communities will benefit from

Page 6

continuity of care and, with time, access to enhanced services in their
local communities. 
The Scottish Government have also announced financial investment into
Primary Care with a £4million uplift into existing enhanced service
provision. The HSCP will work with key stakeholders including the LMC
(Local Medical Committee) to allocate Argyll and Bute’s share of the
allocation in a way that delivers the highest benefit for our communities
while ensuring financial viability for our General Medical Services partners. 
Further investment has been secured following a successful funding bid to
the Scottish Government to establish Early Career Fellows across NHS
Highland. Eight NHS Highland fellowships have been partially funded by
the Government with three being allocated to Argyll and Bute. Plans are
ongoing to develop meaningful job plans with opportunities in sexual
health, mental health and frailty being prioritised to ensure longer term
benefit for our communities. 
Approval has also been given to progress a proposal for a short to
medium term dental investment in Cowal with the Scottish Government,
following several unsuccessful attempts to secure an independent
contractor model in the area. A short – medium term model has been
proposed as a viable alternative allowing the Public Dental Service to
deploy a Dental Access Service for the area while longer term planning to
transition to an independent practice are progressed. Committed
investment from the Scottish Government will be required to progress with
service delivery. 
In the last month we have published the Chief Social Work Officer and the
Child Poverty Reports. Both have been scrutinised through the Council
and IJB processes. Both point to significant work being carried out across
Social Work and multi-agency partners. 
4.2 Children, Families and Justice services: Child and Adolescent Mental
Health Services (CAMHS) services in Argyll and Bute are currently
meeting the waiting time targets set by Scottish Government. This is partly
due to success in filling posts and the targeted deployment of ring fenced
financial reserves. As with much of the progress we make in services it is
fragile and reliant on relatively small numbers of staff. It requires to be
recognised that staff are reporting an increase in demand and complexity. 
Services for those with neurodiversity are developing through a single
multi-agency point of contact and the development of a partnership with
an organisation offering virtual support.

Page 7

Work on phase two of the physical development of the Bairns Hoose is
moving towards completion. The focus is now turning to the recovery
programme for children and their families. We are developing conceptual
plans for a further Bairns Hoose in the west of the county, if capital money
were to become available. 
Overall, in Argyll and Bute the numbers of late Social Work reports for the
Scottish Children’s Reporters Administration is reducing. The numbers of
children on the Child Protection Register are reducing. We recognise that
waits for some children with disability assessments continue to be lengthy.
There is a statutory requirement to complete such assessments, however
there is no statutory timescale. There is a commitment to complete
assessments as quickly as we possibly can within the resources available. 
There is significant work being carried out on repatriating young people
currently placed in external placements. This also includes tightening the
planning for those in our internal residential and fostering resources.
Recruitment of foster carers is exceptionally challenging nationally and
Argyll and Bute is experiencing a similar pattern. The number of foster
carers is reducing. 
Within the field of Justice services we note the recent decisions by
Scottish Government to initiate a further round of early releases of short
term prisoners. Such releases are risk assessed and the numbers of
people impacted in Argyll and Bute is likely to be low. 
Recruitment across Social Work and Health services remains challenging.
There are vacancies and absences across our services. Work is
continuing to address this. For example: we have a number of ‘grow your
own’ trainee Social Workers at various points in their developmental
journey. We have also been successful recruiting oversees Social
Workers who have qualified in Scotland. It requires to be acknowledged
that meeting the envisaged savings targets for the next financial year may
need to be a reduction in head count in some professions. 
4.3 Finance: The financial position remains critical.  The HSCP is
overspending in the current year, largely on external children’s
placements.  Additionally, the budget outlook for the next three years
highlights a significant funding gap, if no action is taken; this is
approximately £6m (6%) for Social Wolk / Social Care services, and £12m
for NHS services.   
To help address this financial challenge, the IJB approved a new policy to
introduce a threshold of care for care at home, to 28 hours per week, with
any packages recommended for weekly hours more than 28 to be

Page 8

reviewed by senior management within the organisation. The impact of
this is now being monitored, on a weekly basis, both in terms of the impact
on unmet need in the community and delayed discharges from hospital,
and the favourable financial impact. Whilst this is an important step in
contributing towards a return to a more sustainable financial position, it is
not enough.   The HSCP will continue to work on further proposals /
recovery plan for service changes and reductions being developed in
advance of the budget cycle for 2026/27. 
4.4 Property: Tigh-a-Rudha Care Home (Tiree) hosted a successful opening
event to celebrate the completion of its refurbishment and remodelling.
The works have made a significant difference to the aesthetics of the
facility and to the services that can be offered. It also means that all the
residential care rooms now have en-suite facilities and meet current
standards for residential care.   
A further project to renew the radiography equipment in the Campbeltown
Community Hospital also completed in October 2025.  In addition to
investment in new digital imaging equipment by NHS Highland, the project
also remodelled the hospital to locate the new unit to a better location,
which is a huge benefit to both the staff and patients, who will no longer
have to be wheeled from one end of the hospital to the other for an X-
ray.  The remodelling and change in location will also help us manage
down the carbon footprint of the building. 
Good progress continues to be made in respect of key worker
accommodation, and awards and nominations continue for the project
between Argyll and Bute Council, Shelter, and the HSCP.  We now have
nine key workers in accommodation made possible by the project, with
more opportunities to increase this nearing completion. Investment from
the Strategic Housing Fund has been instrumental in making this happen.
Additionally, there are many permanent members of staff who have been
assisted to find housing, as part of their relocation process. 
4.5 Health and Social Care Winter Planning: A comprehensive winter
preparedness assessment aligned with the Scottish Government’s
resilience checklist has been completed. The review covers acute, primary
care, social care, mental health, workforce capacity and seasonal
outbreak planning.

Page 9

The assessment confirms that contingency arrangements are in place
across most domains, with strengthened escalation protocols, enhanced
vaccination uptake campaigns and cross-sectoral coordination
mechanisms embedded through the Health and Social Care Partnership. 
Key risks remain around sustained workforce pressures, variable
resilience in remote and rural services, and capacity constraints within
community and social care provision that impact timely hospital discharge.
Winter vaccination uptake will require continued focus, and resilience
planning for concurrent outbreaks (COVID-19, influenza, norovirus)
remains critical. 
Overall, we enter winter 2025/26 with a resilience framework, but
sustained monitoring, rapid escalation pathways, and targeted support in
identified pressure areas will be essential to maintain system stability and
ensure safe, effective care delivery. 
4.6 Strategic Planning , Performance and Technology: Argyll and Bute
Health and Social Care Partnership (HSCP) is developing a new Joint
Strategic Plan for 2026 – 2031. We will be consulting with communities,
partners, and stakeholders between 10th October and 10th January 2026.
Through this engagement, we will build on the Draft Joint Strategic Plan to
jointly produce the final proposed version. 
Integration Joint Boards (IJBs) are required to create a Joint Strategic
Plan (JSP). This is a high level plan of how the IJB will manage and
deliver health and social care services using the resources and budgets
they control. They must review and update this plan at least once every
three years. 
We will communicate in person, online and through press during this
period but you can register or subscribe on this hub to keep up to date
with how this consultation is progressing. 
Our proposed priorities:
• Priority 1: Preventative and Community Based Care
• Priority 2: Integrated and Person Centred Care
• Priority 3: Financial and System Sustainability
• Priority 4: Healthy and Engaged Workforce
• Priority 5: Access and Tackling Health Inequality
• Priority 6: Digital Transformation

Page 10

We would ask elected members to encourage constituents to participate in
this consultation. More information can be found at the engagement hub 
5 POLICY LEAD FOR CLIMATE CHANGE, RENEWABLES AND NET ZERO –
Cllr Luna Martin 
5.1 KIMO AGM: Last month I attended the KIMO (Kommunernes International
Miljøorganisation or Local Authorities International Environmental
Organisation) Annual General Meeting in Inverness where KIMO adopted
the new KIMO Strategy for 2026-2030. The new strategy focuses on four
key priorities:
1. Marine Litter: Continuing KIMO’s long-standing mission to combat
plastic and other waste in our oceans and rivers.
2. Chemical Pollution: Addressing the impact of hazardous
substances such as PFAS on marine ecosystems and human
health.
3. Maritime Safety and Pollution: Enhancing measures to prevent
pollution from shipping and maritime activities.
4. Organisational Sustainability: Ensuring KIMO’s own long-term
effectiveness and resilience.
“This new strategy is a testament to our shared commitment and provides
a powerful framework for our work ahead,” said Lisa Bugge Nør Larsen,
Executive Secretary of KIMO. “It ensures we remain at the forefront of the
fight against marine pollution for the next five years”

Page 11

5.2 Argyll and the Isles Coast and Countryside Trust (ACT) AGM: I
attended the ACT AGM last month; it was brilliant to catch up with
members face to face and discuss new ideas and concepts. 
We heard from Karen McCurry at the Snowdrop Centre, Lochgilphead,
who shared such a thoughtful perspective on the challenges faced by the
people they support due to our changing climate, and on their work with
ACT over the past four years, from the early days of the food share
scheme right through to their current, inspiring ABCAN (Argyll and Bute
Climate Action Network) Seed Funded projects. 
Our ABCAN Team also led an engaging Climate Adaptation Pathways
activity, sparking brilliant conversations around climate risks and
opportunities across all of ACT’s projects. 
5.3 Public Bodies Climate Change Duties (PBCCD) Report – Compilation
Underway: The Council is currently compiling its statutory PBCCD report
for the 2024/25 period. This year’s submission reflects strengthened
governance, strategic planning, and operational delivery across mitigation,
adaptation, and engagement. Key developments include implementation
of the Local Heat and Energy Efficiency Strategy (LHEES), and internal

Page 12

drafting of a refreshed Net Zero Route Map. The Council continues to
embed climate considerations across decision-making, procurement, and
capital planning, with climate change holding strategic risk status and
undergoing regular audit and scrutiny. Regional partnership working
remains central, with the Council leading the Community Planning
Partnership Climate Change Sub Group and contributing to national
adaptation outcomes through infrastructure investment, nature-based
solutions, and community resilience planning. 
5.4 Strategic Leadership Engagement: In October, a climate change
presentation was delivered to both the Chief Officers Group and the
Senior Leadership Forum. The presentation reviewed the past 25 years of
climate change impacts and projected trends for the next 25 years. It
reaffirmed the Council’s strong track record in climate action and
emphasised the increasing importance of resilience and adaptation in
future planning. The session provided strategic context for continued
development of the Council’s climate response. 
5.5 Renewable Energy and Infrastructure: The Council has secured
£35,000+ in grant funding for a new solar PV system at Taynuilt Primary
School. Procurement is underway, with installation targeted for Easter
2026. 
5.6 Carbon Literacy: Argyll and Bute Climate Action Network (ABCAN)
continues to deliver climate literacy training and facilitate climate
conversations. 
5.7 Climate Ready Regions – Community Planning Partnership Activity:
The CPP continues to progress its designation as a Climate Ready
Region, supported by the Scottish Government. A business case for a
regional climate adaptation partnership is being developed, with
consultant support commissioned in October. The project officer role has
been extended to July 2026 to support legacy planning and community
resilience development. Initial engagement with community councils has
begun to assess existing emergency plans and identify best practices. Full
rollout of community resilience planning is scheduled to begin in
November. 
5.8 Climate Strategy and Governance – Community Planning Partnership
Activity: The CPP’s Climate Change Strategy has been published [Argyll
and Bute Climate Action: A climate change strategy for Argyll & Bute v3].
The accompanying Action Plan, originally scheduled for submission in
October, is now expected in November due to expanded workstreams and
the addition of new deliverables. The strategy identifies key risks (hotter
summers, wetter winters, sea level rise) and outlines actions across
infrastructure, policy, skills, and procurement.

Page 13

POLICY LEAD FOR COMMUNITY PLANNING AND CORPORATE SERVICES
– Cllr Mark Irvine   
6.1 Community Councils: Strengthened Framework and Broad Support:
The Council has completed a comprehensive review of the Scheme for
the Establishment of Community Councils (2026–2030). The updated
Scheme modernises governance arrangements, incorporates national
best practice, and ensures compliance with the Local Government
(Scotland) Act 1973 and the Community Empowerment Act 2015. It
introduces clearer guidance on transparency, accessibility, and inclusion,
with formal provision for hybrid and online meetings, and stronger
engagement standards. 
Two full consultation phases have now concluded. Feedback was
overwhelmingly supportive, with only two community councils raising
funding considerations and one specifically confirming satisfaction with the
proposals — a clear indication that the review was well-received and
stable across all areas. A minor boundary alignment between
Lochgilphead and Dunadd ensures effective local representation while
avoiding disruption to neighbouring areas. The final Scheme, Best
Practice Agreement, boundary map, and associated documents will take
effect from 20th August 2026, coinciding with the next scheduled
community council elections. 
Improved Governance, Accountability, and Partnership Working - the Best
Practice Agreement 2026–2030 reinforces collaborative working between
the Council and community councils. It formalises the Council’s
commitment to annual engagement meetings with community
representatives, maintains council funding for administration grants and
public liability insurance, and introduces updated Codes of Conduct and
Financial Guidelines. The Integrated Impact Assessment identified no
adverse impacts and recorded positive effects in relation to access,
representation, and redress. 
The Scheme now includes specific expectations around equal
opportunities, accessibility, and inclusion, ensuring meeting venues —
physical or digital — are suitable for all participants.

Page 14

6.2 Community Development and Empowerment: Through the Supporting
Communities Fund, 74 local groups have received awards of up to £1,500
each to deliver projects that enhance wellbeing, social connection, and
local opportunity. The Community Development Team has provided direct
support to over 30 groups on constitutions, governance, funding
applications, and community asset management — strengthening local
capacity and confidence. 
The Community Planning Partnership (CPP) has launched a Short Life
Working Group to develop a five-year business case for the Argyll and
Bute Climate Ready Region, funded by the Scottish Government via
ABCAN (Argyll and Bute Climate Action Network). 
Preparations are also under way for the 2026 Gaelic Gathering,
celebrating culture, language, and identity while promoting local
participation. 
6.3 Corporate and Digital Service Improvements: The ICT Service
continues to be recognised (via Socitm benchmarking) as one of the most
cost-efficient and highest performing local authority ICT operations in the
UK, supporting more than 2,000 users and 200 systems. Enhanced cyber
security protocols have been implemented, and the Customer Services
Team completed a successful Commercial Waste GAP project, identifying
and onboarding 314 new customers, billing £92,000, and collecting
£59,000 to date. 
Our progress on getting Bots to answer queries for both internal and
external customers has taken another step forward with our AI enabled
HR Bot. This new AI Bot now answers queries from employees on all
aspects of their employment. It searches in all of our policy and procedure
documents as its source material and so it can handle more complex
questions than our old Bot. We are getting great feedback. The AI Bot will
continue to learn the more we use it. You can find it on MyCouncilWorks.
We now have our workforce data available on the new Data Hub. This
means that managers can see at a glance all of the important information
about their teams when they want to, they no longer have to wait for a
monthly spreadsheet or a quarterly report. This is another great example
of the Data Project making a positive difference to the organisation as well
as continuing to improve everyone’s digital skills.

Page 15

Cyber security remains high profile and the ICT team continue to keep up
to speed with new developments, having recently attended the National
Information Security Conference in Edinburgh. Cyber attacks like those on
JLR and the Co-Op highlight just how costly it can be if the hackers get
through the security defences. Everyone matters in our approach to
managing this risk. It is usually human error that results in an attack. We
have made our cyber security training mandatory, as all of us are on the
front line of this area of risk.
The ICT team have been busy upgrading 4700 devices to make sure they
are up to date and secure. They have also migrated 2272 education
colleagues from Skype to Teams Telephony. 
The recent storm damaged BT’s subsea cable to Tiree, affected phone
and internet services on the island. The ICT team worked as fast as they
could to restore temporary services to the High School and Tigh a Rudha
Care Home. 
The team continue to maintain a fast turnaround in ‘time to fix’ for ICT
incidents averaging 2.31 hours this month. This is one of our core service
standards to keep the council operating effectively. 
6.4 Communication, Engagement and Reputation Management: The
Communications Team have launched two new services this year. Our
email subscription service, for employees without ICT access (because of
the nature of their roles) to the council network and communication
channels, is growing in use by employees: we now have 320+ subscribers
who have opted-in out of a totally of nearly 800 non-networked
employees. We concluded the first year of activity for the council-wide
sounding board. Three sessions took place with great turn-out and
planning is underway for 2026. 
The team is leading on the Budget Communications Budget planning 2026
| Argyll and Bute Council having launched a poll asking the public if they
support fair funding for services. We are currently getting good
engagement on this from our communities and will report back on this.
Research into AI-generated content is being undertaken to understand
and manage public perception proactively. 
A revised Social Media Policy will be introduced in early 2026, aligning
with the Councillors’ Code of Conduct and corporate strategy.

Page 16

The Council continues to promote positive campaigns across recycling,
the Rural Growth Deal, and education achievements. 
6.5 People, Workforce and Organisational Development: Workforce
analysis shows an overall improvement in workforce-planning risk
compared with the previous year. The new Health of the Organisation
Data Hub provides live workforce metrics to support management
decisions. An attendance management workshop was delivered at the
Senior Leadership Forum, focusing on wellbeing and support. 
The Employee Experience Pulse Survey is running this quarter,
encouraging broad participation to guide wellbeing and culture initiatives. 
6.6 Customer Services and Registration: Our Customer Service and
Engagement team continue to be in the top 1% nationally for website
accessibility according to the Silktide assessment index. Our new AI
Chatbot is live and we anticipate that this will lead to improved satisfaction
scores. The team has worked with colleagues in other services to develop
more automated online applications – a single point of access digital front
door for Education Psychology, a new smart application for Strategic
events and festivals and a new automated form for the comms team to
manage social media requests from staff. A comprehensive review of all
downloadable and online forms has been completed by the web team and
identified numerous opportunities for improvement. This feeds into the
Delivering Services Differently budget theme work. 
Our Registrars saw an increase in both births and death registrations over
the same period last year. Our numbers of marriages/civil ceremonies is
up on last year and we have recruited new home-based Registrars for Coll
and Colonsay following retirements.
6.7 Summary and Outlook: Across all directorates within my policy portfolio,
the Council continues to deliver effectively within existing resources,
strengthen community and partnership working, and demonstrate
resilience and innovation. 
Stable governance frameworks are in place for the 2026–2030 term, with
growing community empowerment and continued progress in digital
transformation and workforce modernisation. 
Overall, the directorates I work with are well positioned for the future.

Page 17

7 POLICY LEAD FOR EDUCATION – Cllr Audrey Forrest 
7.1 Ulva Primary School Inspection: I would like to congratulate all the staff
and pupils at Ulva Primary School for a very positive Inspection outcome,
following a visit from Education Scotland in September.  The school
achieved an “excellent” evaluation with regard to learning, teaching and
assessment, and a “very good” evaluation for raising attainment and
achievement indicator. 
The inspection team found a number of strengths in the school’s work
including:- 
• The outstanding leadership of the headteacher, very well supported by
the principal teacher, in improving learning experiences for all children. 
• The school’s exemplary approaches to learning for sustainability and
outdoor learning. Children are passionate, engaged campaigners who
relish the opportunity to learn about their natural environment. They
appreciate and celebrate the uniqueness of their island. 
• Curious, engaged and highly motivated children. They are polite and
welcoming, and demonstrate fully the school’s values of being kind,
respectful and hard-working 
• The warm, supportive and nurturing relationships across the school
and local community 
• Highly effective partnership working with local and national partners. 
7.2 MCR Pathways Progress: Following on from my update at the last
Council meeting that MCR Pathways will be developed in another five of
our schools (Lochgilphead, Tarbert, Campbeltown, Tobermory and Islay), I
am pleased to report that the new MCR Pathway Coordinators
commenced in their new posts on 3rd November.  They will now undertake
a series of training sessions delivered on a central basis by MCR and
locally by the Education Service, prior to beginning the matching mentors
phase.

Page 18

This service, which is based on building
relationships, relies on volunteers. If you have
any spare time, would you consider giving one
hour a week during school hours to take part?
For further information or to enquire about this
role please visit the MCR website. I would
recommend reading the latest Scotland Impact
Report to fully understand the profound positive
impact MCR has on young people engaged with 
the programme. 
7.3 STEM Hub: The STEM Hub South will be situated within Dunoon
Grammar School.   The STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering and
Maths) team will coordinate visits from local primary schools and the wider
community, while also providing crucial outreach to rural and remote
schools. The facility's core mission is to deliver exciting STEM learning
opportunities directly linked to future areas of economic growth in Argyll
and Bute and across Scotland. 
Phase 1 of the project is scheduled for completion this year, which
includes the establishment of an immersive classroom. This advanced
learning environment incorporates cutting-edge projection and interactive
technologies to provide a seamless, 360-degree fully immersive
experience. This innovative technology is designed to virtually transport
pupils to diverse and stimulating learning environments. 
Phase 2 is scheduled for completion by October 2026 and will significantly
expand the project's capacity with five key, high-tech learning areas:
• Exhibition Space: Developed in partnership with the Glasgow Science
Centre, this dedicated facility will host dynamic, high-impact STEM
exhibitions. The content will directly correlate with future employment
sectors in the Argyll and Bute region.

Page 19

• Auditorium: A compact, purpose-built theatre space designed to
accommodate a full class of learners.
• Collaborative MakerSpace: A highly adaptable and multi-configuration
flexible space cantered around a makerspace theme.
• Green Screen Studio: A full-scale green screen backdrop and
professional lighting and audio. This studio will enable learners to
engage in digital content creation, virtual environment development,
and advanced media projects.
• Virtual Reality (VR) Suite: A specialised room featuring a three-bay
layout dedicated to harnessing the power of VR technology. 
7.4 Rothesay Joint Campus – Outdoor Learning: A once-overgrown
garden at Rothesay Joint Campus has blossomed into a vibrant outdoor
learning hub, thanks to a generous donation from Saputo, an international
cheese company. 
The transformation has created a dynamic space where over three
hundred children and young people now enjoy hands-on horticulture
lessons, grow their own food, and connect with nature — all while learning
valuable life skills. 
The school community has
worked tirelessly to bring the
vision to life. The project
included: 
• Revamping the old garden with
raised beds
• Redeveloping the secondary
playground with formal planting
• Constructing large-scale
polytunnels and a greenhouse
• Creating an outdoor larder and
learning classroom

Page 20

Children now grow everything from courgettes and pumpkins to grapes,
cucamelons, potatoes — and even stevia, a natural sugar alternative. The
Early Learning Centre has already won awards for its impressive
produce. 
The school has recently secured additional funding and hopes to expand
the outdoor space even further, with ideas including: 
• A sensory garden
• Community growing days
• Opportunities for residents to visit and get involved. 
7.5 Planet Youth: A Growing Up in Oban community event took place at the
Corran Halls on 21st September, which brought together 25 local groups
for a showcase of the youth and leisure opportunities available within the
local area. The event aimed to connect families with local clubs,
organisations, and services and valuable networking opportunities for
group leaders and volunteers. With nearly 200 visitors attending, the day
featured activities from Oban Youth Café and Oban Toy Library, and a
fantastic live performance by young people involved in the Fèis. The event
was praised for its warm, welcoming atmosphere, with a variety of
information and activities on offer. Based on the success of this event, it is
hoped that it can be replicated within other areas.   
7.6 Education Review: All elected members were invited to attend an initial
seminar on 27th October, advising on the background/scope of the
Review.  A further seminar has been arranged for 21st November to
discuss the findings of the Review, including the recommendations that
have been made.  A copy of the full report is contained within today’s
agenda.

Page 21

7.7 Clyde Cottage Nursery: I was really pleased to be invited to Clyde
Cottage Nursery to see the fantastic upgrades that have been made to the
Early Learning Centre, including the Tiny Treasures Room. It was lovely to
meet with staff and hear about the impact of the works. 
7.8 Aspiring to Headship / Into Headship Event: I was delighted to be
invited to attend the Aspiring to Headship celebration in Helensburgh.
Argyll and Bute Council run a programme called ‘Aspiring to Headship’ for
any of our teachers who would like to explore moving into Headship. This

Page 22

can be followed by the Education Scotland course, ‘Into Headship’. It is
encouraging to see people progress through the former to continue into
the latter. It is a huge commitment our staff make to take up these studies
as they juggle work and home life. Every year, a celebration takes place
and it is a really joyful event and I have been privileged to attend. ‘Growing
our own’ is a well established principle in Argyll & Bute and it enables us
to inspire, nurture and grow the talent which we are fortunate to have. 
7.9 Meetings: Since my last report, I continue to attend a wide range of
meetings associated with my Education remit, including COSLA Children
and Young People Board, chairing the Local Negotiation Committee for
Teachers, and Policy Lead meetings with the Executive Director and 2
Heads of Education. 
8 POLICY LEAD FOR FINANCE AND COMMERCIAL SERVICES – Cllr Ross
Moreland 
8.1 Financial Services:
Annual Accounts for the year ended 31st March 2025: The 2024-25 pre-
audit annual accounts were considered by the Audit and Scrutiny
Committee on 26 June and thereafter, approved for submission to the
auditor, Mazars by the statutory deadline of 30th June 2025. 
Information has now been received from the Council’s treasury advisors,
MUFG in respect of accounting for leases and lease type arrangements
under IFRS16.  Officers are in the process of preparing the required audit
changes to the financial statements and associated disclosure notes in
respect of IFRS16 compliance.

Page 23

The council’s external auditor, Mazars completed their audit planning in
July, with fieldwork underway from August.  Weekly progress meetings
between the Mazars Audit Manager and senior council finance officers
commenced in July.  The audit continues to progress, with no significant
matters arising, at this stage.  There are two significant audit areas still to
be completed – IFRS16 and Payroll (migration to the new iTrent system).
These are extensive and extraordinary pieces of work, however, officers
continue to work closely with Mazars to conclude the audit in a timely
manner. The audit completion timescale is likely to be late November/early
December. 
Budget Outlook 2026-27 to 2030-31: An updated Budget Outlook,
reported to the Policy and Resources Committee on 9th October 2025,
outlines a projected budget gap of £10.6m (previously £10.5m) for 2026-
27, rising to £33.9m (unchanged from previously reported position) by
2030-31, based on the mid-range scenario.     
There has been a net increase in cost and demand pressures of £0.1m
from the previous reported Budget Outlook as at 30th June, reported to
Policy and Resources Committee in August. However, there are no other
changes to the previously reported planning assumptions underpinning
our Budget Outlook. 
There are a number of financial risks, which may impact the financial
position of the council in 2025-26 and future years.  The HSCP financial
position in respect of delivery of Social Work services will be subject to
ongoing monitoring and review, including in respect of delivery of the IJB’s
financial recovery plan.   
It is also worth noting that the timescale for the Scottish Budget
announcement has now been confirmed as 13th January 2026. This
delays confirmation of our government grant funding (a key planning
assumption) and makes our budget process timescale more challenging,
reducing the time available for consideration of measures to meet the
confirmed budget gap.     
The Budget Outlook and Financial Risks will continue to be monitored and
reported on an ongoing basis to Policy and Resources Committee. 
Revenue Budget Monitoring: The 2025-26 Revenue Budget Monitoring as
at 31st August, reported to Policy and Resources Committee on 9th
October, outlines a forecast net underspend of £0.301m. This comprises a
forecast underspend of £0.5m in respect of Council Tax income, offset by
a forecast net overspend across services of £0.199m.

Page 24

As at 31st August 2025, the HSCP was forecasting an overspend of
£0.668m for the year in respect of Social Work services, due to demand
for residential placements within Children and Families and Older People
Services, with an expectation that this would be managed from within
available HSCP reserves.  This forecast overspend has increased to
£0.738m as at 30th September.  There is very little headroom for this to be
managed within available HSCP reserves, representing a significant
financial risk to the council in 2025-26 and future years. This position will
continue to be closely monitored throughout the year. 
Capital Plan Monitoring: The Capital Plan monitoring will now be reported
on a quarterly basis to align with Treasury Management governance
reporting requirements.  The next update, as at Quarter 2, 30 September
2025, will be reported to the Policy and Resources Committee in
December. 
As at Quarter 1 2025-26, there was a forecast overspend of £0.180m on
the overall approved gross expenditure budget of £210.3m for 2025-26
and future years.  This comprises £125k in respect of Lochgilphead Depot
Rationalisation and other relatively small individual project budget
variances of less than £50k. 
The forecast spend had been profiled across 2025-26, 2026-27 and future
years, with £75.4m forecast to be incurred in 2025-26.  As at Quarter 1,
actual spend totalled £6.7m, representing 9% of the total forecast for the
year.  The profile of forecast spend across 2025-26 and future years will
be subject to ongoing monitoring and review, with updates reported to
committee. 
Benefits: Housing Benefit performance has been strong in 2025/26.
Between 1 April and 30 September 2025, new claims were processed in
an average of 11 days and changes in circumstances were processed in
an average of 3.79 days. Both results are well within target, supporting
timely access to benefit, helping prevent rent arrears, and promoting
housing stability.
Council Tax: As of 30th September 2025, the in-year Council Tax
collection rate stands at 55.78%, which is 0.63% lower than the same
period in 2024/25. The current position is being heavily influenced by the
ongoing review of Self-Catering Units by the Assessor. 
Around £1.5 million of Council Tax charges are on hold pending
completion of their review of the 2023/24 canvass, which impacts the most
recent three years of collections. Work on the new canvass will begin in
November, with revised assessments expected to flow through the
interfaces and impact the taxbase from January 2026. The Assessor has

Page 25

not yet confirmed plans for the 2024/25 canvass work which was originally
planned for May 2025.  
Second Homes: By 30th September 2025, Council Tax income from
second homes was £5.25m, representing 61.0% of the total billed. This
compares favourably to £5.088m (60.8%) at the same point in 2024.
A report assessing the impact of the policy applying double Council Tax
on second homes in Argyll and Bute is due to be considered at the
November meeting of the council. 
Non-Domestic Rates (NDR): In 2025/26, 73.07% of NDR billed has been
collected by the end of September, more than 3% higher than the same
period last year. The reason for the improvement was a late and
significant Assessor change in March 2024 which reduced percentage
collection in the 24/25 year and increased it in the current year.  
Scottish Welfare Fund (SWF): By 30th September 2025, the Council had
awarded £282,000 in Community Care Grants and Crisis Grants – up
£24,000 compared with September 2024.If this rate of spend continues,
there is a projected overspend of around £180,000 against Scottish
Government programme funding by year end. The position is being
closely monitored, with options under consideration to manage spend
across the remainder of the year.
Discretionary Housing Payments (DHP): As at 30th September 2025, the
Council has spent or committed £960,000 of its £1.3m allocation. These
payments remain critical in supporting households to sustain tenancies
and avoid homelessness.
A draft new DHP policy has been developed and will be presented to the
Council in November 2025, and, if approved, will increase accessibility to
the fund providing greater flexibility in supporting households in need and
helping to prevent homelessness.
Taking Action on Rural Poverty (TARP): The Taking Action on Rural
Poverty (TARP) programme has funded a Test of Change project in Argyll
and Bute, delivered in partnership with ALIenergy. The project supports
vulnerable tenants in social housing to reduce heating costs by helping
them make full use of energy efficiency and renewable technologies,
including insulation improvements and low-carbon heating systems often
fitted as standard in the social rented sector. 
Working closely with Registered Social Landlords, the initiative provides
tailored advice and hands-on support to ensure tenants can operate new
systems effectively. Early results show energy bill savings of several

Page 26

thousand pounds for many households, alongside improved comfort and
reduced fuel poverty. 
The project also gathers lived experience feedback to understand barriers
and behaviours, helping to shape future retrofit and housing policies. It
aligns strongly with the Council’s priorities around reducing fuel poverty,
supporting vulnerable residents, and promoting a fair transition to net zero
across rural and island communities.
8.2 Commercial Services:
Helensburgh Waterfront Development (Commercial Area): Following my
update at the last Council meeting, the position remains the same with
regard to the Judicial Review. A procedural hearing was called for 12th
June, with a substantive hearing held on 4th July 2025.  The Council
continue to await the outcome of this process. 
Helensburgh Leisure Centre
(HLC): As per the latest monthly
update, good progress continues
to be made with the varying steps
and actions needed to repair
HLC. 
The substantial amount of
scaffolding needed is now fully in
place around all four sides of the
leisure centre, with a total length
of approximately 220 metres —
about the same as two full-size
football pitches laid end to end. This has been a complex operation,
requiring scaffolding to be specially designed to fit the requirements of the
building such as the need to extend over the flood defence rock armour. 
With scaffolding in place, our contractor can now safely access the roof,
carry out detailed assessments and work with bulky materials. 
Work has started on removing damaged parts of the roof and installing the
temporary roof. As this progresses, we will begin removing the water
capture system that was initially installed. Once wind and watertight, we
will then carry out extensive internal surveys of the mechanical and
electric systems throughout the building as well as the internal fabric, for
example the plasterboard, wiring, heating systems, insultation, flooring
etc. 
To satisfy health and safety requirements and so make it possible for this
internal and external work to be done, we have also installed a temporary,

Page 27

wireless intruder and fire alarm system specifically for construction sites
throughout the building 
In terms of a timescale for re-opening, the position remains as per my last
update - a reasonable estimate for reopening could be no later than the first
quarter of the calendar year 2026.  I was able to visit the Leisure Centre on
Wednesday 19th November with the Head of Commercial Services, Ross
McLaughlin and see first hand the work that is being undertaken. 
As the work progresses updates will delivered on a more frequent basis, all
updates can be accessed on the Council website via the following link:-
Helensburgh Leisure Centre updates | Argyll and Bute Council. 
Tobermory Campus Project: With regard to the Judicial Review, I can
confirm that the procedural and substantive hearings scheduled for 2nd and
13th October, respectively, went ahead as planned.  The Council await the
outcome of this process. All updates and information in respect of the
project can be found on the dedicated webpages here. 
Capital Works: The Property Design Team have been busy in October
undertaking works across the area, including:-

Page 28

Park Primary School
– Storm Damage:
Roof Replacement 
Work has
commenced during
the October
Holidays on the
replacement Roof at
Park Primary
School. Four
classrooms will have
newly installed roof
panels and new
clerestory windows
fitted as part of the first phase of work. The new roof and windows will
result in energy efficiency savings. 
Tigh-a-Rudha Care Home Refurbishment: Property Services staff
attended the official re-opening of the Care Home facility on Tiree
following the £2.4M refurbishment.

Page 29

Existing Flat                Refurbished Flat 
9 POLICY LEAD FOR PLANNING AND REGULATORY SERVICES – Cllr Kieron
Green 
9.1 Introduction: In the last two months I have chaired meetings of the
Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (PPSL) on 16th
September and 22nd October, and the Licensing Board on 23rd September.
In addition, there were several Short Term Let and Civic Government
hearings during this time. 
9.2 Development Management: Applications received remain in line with
those seen in previous years. Average determination times for
householder applications are under eight weeks, with other local
applications averaging 24.5 weeks. The number of applications waiting
over a year to determine is now under a third of that in January 2024. 
Further reductions may be more difficult to achieve as numbers of new
cases taking over a year from validation to determine is matching those
determined. This reflects the complexity of certain applications, and
developers lacking the momentum to either actively progress or abandon
some proposals. 
Increased staff turnover in several area teams over the last few months is
reducing capacity to process applications. Whilst some planning posts
have already been filled, and additional temporary resource is being

Page 30

secured, it will be challenging to maintain levels of performance in
determinations over the upcoming period. 
9.3 Development Policy: Work on LDP3 topic papers continues which will
form the Evidence Report which is due by Easter 2026. The first of these
has now been sent to consultees, 12 are in the process of being drafted,
and work on five is still to commence. 
As previously reported, the Development Scheme for LDP3 will not meet
timescales set out by the Scottish Government. As such details of actions
being undertaken to complete the LDP3 quicker are being requested,
however current resources will not permit any further acceleration. 
The first phase of community engagement with Strategic Development
Frameworks has taken place in Oban with the second phase now being
planned in Helensburgh. 
The Scottish Government is seeking views on ways to deliver additional
housing more quickly. Currently it appears that consideration is being
given to expanding permitted development rights to support this. It is felt
that such an approach could have disadvantages in Argyll and Bute, and
that encouraging policies in Local Development Plans that are more
supportive of developments may be more appropriate locally. 
9.4 Building Standards: The service continues to exceed all performance
measures, and income remains above projections. This is due to
increases in fees offsetting a 30% decrease in warrant numbers compared
to the same period last year. As anticipated in the current investment plan,
the commercial market for Argyll and Bute to carry out work on behalf of
other authorities has not returned.
Staffing capacity is instead being directed to enable more site inspections.
This is part of the strengthening of regulation required by government in
return for ongoing increases in fees. Audit arrangements to demonstrate
this have been discussed with the Scottish Government. 
A national Competency Assessment is also due to commence with 20% of
staff to be peer reviewed each year, with all staff to have undergone the
process after five years. 
There has been further work arising from dangerous buildings, in
particular on East Clyde Street in Helensburgh and at Dunselma, in Strone
near to Dunoon. 
9.5 Regulatory Services: A number of vacancies remain impacting on
service capability, and which reflects the national shortage of
Environmental Health Officers. In response increased flexibility is being

Page 31

given where necessary to support newly appointed officers achieve
recognised professional qualifications though different career pathways. 
9.6 Short Term Lets: The team currently consists of a licensing officer and
eight assistants, with a further licensing officer post vacant. The backlog of
applications from existing operators submitted in September 2023 prior to
the deadline has now been largely eliminated. Only four such applications
remain which are currently being consulted on. 82 new applications are
currently awaiting determination, along with 33 renewals. In total 3,252 
licenses have been granted to date. 
The government has given recognition and thanks to the team for clearing
outstanding applications, demonstrating fairness to applicants and
supporting the launch and embedding of short term let licensing locally.
These successes are even more impressive given that Argyll and Bute
received the third highest number of applications across Scotland, and I
equally commend the team for their efforts over the last three years. 
10 POLICY LEAD FOR ROADS, TRANSPORT AND AMENITY SERVICES – Cllr
John Armour 
10.1 Introduction: Since my last report to Council in September 2025, there
has been a significant amount of work going on within my policy lead
remit, I have tried to capture as much of it as I can, but with such a broad
scope, it’s not possible to include everything that’s ongoing.  As always, if
anyone has any queries or questions they would like me to pick up, I will
be happy to try to assist.   
Here are some of the works that have been taking place since my last
report.   
10.2 Storm Amy: I would like to praise officers for their hard work in keeping
our communities safe during Storm Amy.  We experienced some road
closures as trees were blown over and roads were flooded, but thanks to
the hard work of our roads teams disruption to the network was kept to a
minimum.  Sadly, some of our staff who were managing a road closure to
protect the safety of the travelling public were verbally abused while
carrying out their duties, which is extremely disappointing. 
10.3 Campbeltown – Ardrossan Ferry:

Page 32

Following the announcement that
Calmac will not restore the
Campbeltown to Ardrossan ferry
service next year I wrote to the
Cabinet Secretary for Transport,
Fiona Hyslop MSP, to express my
regret and shock at the decision.  I
have now received a response
confirming that the Minister
recognises the importance of this
service to the Kintyre community and advising that Ministers are currently
in active discussions with Transport Scotland officials and CalMac to
consider the issue further, including potential options to provide a service
for Kintyre during the summer months next year.  I will keep Members
updated when I receive further information. 
10.4 Craignure Marine Infrastructure Liaison Group: I recently travelled to
Mull with the Marine Team to host a meeting of the Craignure Marine
Infrastructure Liaison Group (CMILG). This hybrid meeting brought
together members from Transport Scotland, CMAL, Calmac, both Mull and
Iona Community Councils, Mull and Iona Ferry Group, members of the
public and local ward councillors. 
The purpose of CMILG is to provide a forum for open consultation and
communication with both Iona and Mull Community Council
representatives, local ferry groups and community residents. The group
discusses the infrastructure needs of Mull and explores options for
delivering a new pier that will be affordable, deliverable and fit for purpose
for the next 60+ years. 
Council Officers, CMAL and Transport Scotland provided updates on a
number of live projects: 
• Argyll and Bute Council are progressing toward the appointment of
consultants who will carry out the Final Business Case and detailed
design for the new pier infrastructure works. 
• Transport Scotland announced plans for the Community Needs
Assessment for Mull, with consultancy support expected to be
appointed soon.
• CMAL are advancing with two major projects, the New Mull Vessells
(NMV) and Oban 1. Public engagement meetings for both projects are
expected before the end of the calendar year.
10.5 Electric Vehicle (EV) Chargers: The Council have now successfully
secured £260,000 to replace nine older EV chargers with new units that
support contactless payment.  This investment will enhance the resilience

Page 33

and accessibility of the network, complementing the larger £1 million
programme being delivered through the Electric Vehicle Infrastructure
Fund (EVIF). 
10.6 Highlands and Islands Airports: I attend monthly meetings between
Highlands and Islands Airports Ltd (HIAL) and the Council.  HIAL are
currently rotating the meetings
around their airport locations to
facilitate engagement the local
communities.  A meeting at
Campbeltown Airport for local
stakeholders was held in early
October and was very
interesting and gave me an
insight into the airports operated
by HIAL (Campbeltown, Islay
and Tiree).  Islay and Tiree have shown a really positive increase in
numbers of flights and passengers and Campbeltown and Islay have
experienced an increase in flights over the last year.  It is great to see
more people making use of the air services our area has to offer. 
10.7 Oban Airport: Oban Airport
has been selected as one of
two new seasonal helicopter
bases for HM Coastguard. 
The airport is ideally placed
to support this vital service,
offering quick and easy
access to the west coast and
surrounding islands. The
base will enhance HM
Coastguard’s search and
rescue provision during the
busy summer months, supporting safety in one of Scotland’s most popular
coastal regions. 
The council has worked closely with the Maritime and Coastguard Agency
(MCA) to get the project off the ground and is delighted that construction
work has now started on site. 
The base will operate one aircraft from April to September. The second
seasonal base will be located in Carlisle. 
10.8 Balliemore Bridge, Glen Lean: The newly constructed Balliemore Bridge
in Glen Lean, Cowal, has opened to traffic marking a major milestone in
Argyll and Bute Council’s infrastructure recovery efforts following severe

Page 34

weather in 2023.  The original bridge was irreparably damaged during the
extreme weather event on 7th October 2023, prompting its immediate
closure and plan for demolition.
The new bridge has an increased span
length over the original bridge, and the
foundations are protected by steel sheet
piles to reduce the risk of further scour
and undermining events from future
storms.  Installing the new bridge was a
complex engineering project which
required a 130-tonne crane to lift and
position six precast, 15-metre-long, pre-
stressed concrete deck beams—an
impressive feat of logistics and
precision.
This project was unplanned, triggered by extreme weather, and the
response has been nothing short of remarkable.  The reopening is
fantastic news for the local community. 
10.9 Grubin Rockfall: You will be aware that the B8035 Kinloch to Gruline
road on Mull is closed following three recent rockfalls. Specialist
Geotechnical consultant, AtkinsRéalis, has provided the Interim Appraisal
as part of Stage 2 of the Geotechnical Risk Management Assessment. 
Given the nature of the findings in the Interim Appraisal / Assessment
Stage (Stage 2), the road must remain closed for the following reasons: 
• Further potential failures of a similar size have been identified.
• The risk to road users is calculated as unacceptable according to
Health and Safety Executive (HSE) standards, with estimated fatality
rates exceeding the tolerable threshold.
• Intervention is required before the road can be safely reopened. 
Stage 3 of this Geotechnical Risk Management will run from 13/10/2025 to
17/11/2025 and will include: 
• Development of mitigation options. Options will range from low-cost
interventions (e.g. signage only, stopping-up of road) to engineered
solutions (e.g. rock netting, catchment areas, attenuator fencing).
• Final report submitted to the council by the consultant.
• Council appraisal of final report.
• Decision on any further actions able to be taken at final report stage.
• Final report update and details of any further actions able to be taken
following a review by Roads and Infrastructure Services.

Page 35

The road remains closed as we have a duty of care and must keep the
travelling public safe. 
10.10 Rest and Be Thankful: As reported in my last Policy Lead update, I
attended a roundtable meeting in September along with Jenni Minto MSP,
Jackie Baillie MSP, Brendan O’Hara MP, Highlands and Islands
Enterprise, Argyll and Bute Council and the Rest and Be Thankful
Campaign Group.  Following the meeting I received a letter from the
Transport Minister confirming that they will explore the option of having a
two-way diversion in place while the work is carried out on the main trunk
road.  This is welcome news and would reduce disruption to road users
while the works take place. 
10.11 Campbeltown Old Quay: I attended the re-opening of Campbeltown’s
historic Old Quay following an 18-month construction project to
replace Wall A (see below). 
With origins in the 18th
century, the Old Quay
continues to be a key asset
for Argyll and Bute Council. It
supports both commercial
and private fishing vessels,
accommodates a wide
variety of leisure craft, and
plays a significant role in
boosting local tourism. The
RNLI also operates from this important site. 
One section of the quay, known as Wall A and originally built in 1941, had
shown signs of accelerated corrosion at low tide. Detailed inspections
uncovered extensive deterioration, including holes in the sheet piles and a
reduction in material thickness, up to 50% in both the inner and outer
layers, with some areas measuring less than 3mm. 
This section has now been fully
upgraded, with resurfacing and repainting
completed to ensure it meets the needs
of its many users. As part of the contract,
the contractor also delivered a range of
community benefits, including support for
Christmas lighting, local football facilities,
and school engagement activities.

Page 36

The Old Quay has been central to life in Campbeltown for over two
centuries. Knowing that its lifespan has now been extended by at least
another 100 years is a remarkable achievement. 
11. CONCLUSION 
11.1 This report provides members with an update on each of the Policy Lead
portfolios. Policy Lead Councillors will be happy to discuss any particular
issues with colleagues as required. 
Argyll and Bute Council – Policy Lead Councillors Report – 13th November 2025 
For further information please contact Aileen McNicol, Leadership Support and
Member Services Manager, telephone 01546 604014 or email
aileen.mcnicol@argyll-bute.gov.uk