Democracy Spraffa

Agenda Document Pack - Renfrewshire Council Joint Negotiating Committee for Teaching Staff - 25/03/2025

Renfrewshire Council · 25 March 2025
Back to Renfrewshire Council Joint Negotiating Committee for Teaching Staff — 25 March 2025 and its agenda

Text extracted from the council's PDF. Layout and reading order may differ from the original.

Original council PDF · Download plain text

Page 1

19/03/2025 
Notice of Meeting and Agenda
Renfrewshire Council Joint Negotiating Committee for
Teaching Staff 
Date Time Venue
Tuesday, 25 March 2025 14:00 Corporate Meeting Room 2, Renfrewshire
House, 
Membership
Representing Renfrewshire Council Management 
Councillor E Rodden; Councillor J Paterson; G McLaughlin, Head of Education; E Henry, Head
of Education; S Bell, Education Manager (Whole Family Wellbeing); K Henry, Head Teacher, St
Andrews Academy; D Rigmand, Head Teacher, Wallace Primary School; A Hall, Education
Manager (Development); Y Ward, Education Manager, (all Education and Childrens' Services);
and K Clark, Strategic Lead Partner (People), S Fanning, Strategic Lead Partner (Health &
Safety) (both Finance and Resources).   
Representing Renfrewshire Council Teaching Staff 
K Fella/M Russell (Joint Secretary), JP Tonner, T Millar, Y Murray, D Tollan, B Kelly and C Niven
(all EIS); R Kane(SSTA); L Gibson (NASUWT) and D Campbell (EIS - Adviser to Teachers'
Side). 
Further Information
A copy of the agenda and reports for this meeting will be available for inspection prior to the
meeting at the Customer Service Centre, Renfrewshire House, Cotton Street, Paisley and online
at http://renfrewshire.cmis.uk.com/renfrewshire/CouncilandBoards.aspx
For further information, please email
democratic-services@renfrewshire.gov.uk. 
MARK CONAGHAN
Head of Corporate Governance
Page 1 of 42

Page 2

19/03/2025
Items of business      
Chairperson
Consider the appointment of a Chairperson for this meeting. 
Apologies
Apologies from members. 
Declarations of Interest and Transparency Statements
Members are asked to declare an interest or make a transparency
statement in any item(s) on the agenda and to provide a brief
explanation of the nature of the interest or the transparency statement. 
1 Minute of Previous Meeting
Minute of previous meeting held on 11 February 2025. 
4 - 8 
2 Matters Arising
Matters arising from the minute of the previous meeting held on 11
February 2025. 
3 Action Log  9 - 14 
4 Teacher Booker Supply Booking System
Report by Joint Secretary (Management Side). 
15 - 17 
5 Review of Job Sizing Processes
Report by Joint Secretary (Management Side). 
18 - 32 
6 Seesaw Guidance for Establishments
Report by Joint Secretary (Management Side). 
33 - 38 
7 Violence and Aggression Policy
Report by Joint Secretary (Teachers' Side). 
39 - 39 
8 Artificial Intelligence
Report by Joint Secretary (Teachers' Side). 
40 - 40 
9 EAL and Sensory Support Service Staffing
Report by Joint Secretary (Teachers' Side). 
41 - 41 
10  Early Years Welcome Pack
Report by Joint Secretary (Teachers' Side). 
42 - 42
Page 2 of 42

Page 3

19/03/2025 
11  Date of Next Meeting
Members are asked to note that the next meeting of the Renfrewshire
Council Joint Negotiating Committee for Teaching Staff is scheduled to
be held at 2.00pm on 29 April 2025. 
Page 3 of 42

Page 4

Minute of Meeting
Renfrewshire Council Joint Negotiating Committee for
Teaching Staff 
Date Time Venue
Tuesday, 11 February 2025 14:00 Corporate Meeting Room 2, Renfrewshire
House, 
Present
Representing Renfrewshire Council Management 
Councillor Rodden; E Henry, Head of Education (Attainment, Inclusion and Wellbeing), G
McLaughlin, Head of Education (Strategy and Improvement), K Henry, Head Teacher, D
Rigmand, Head Teacher and Y Ward, Education Manager (all Education & Children’s
Services); and S Fanning, Strategic Lead Partner (Health & Safety) and L Stewart,
Operational People Partner (both Finance and Resources). 
Representing Renfrewshire Council Teaching Staff 
K Fella, (Joint Secretary), Y Murray, C Niven, M Russell and D Tollan, (all EIS); and R Kane
(SSTA). 
In Attendance
D Cunningham, Committee Services and Licensing Officer and J Barron, Committee
Services Officer (both Finance & Resources). 
Apologies
Councillor Paterson; A Hall; S Bell; K Clark; J P Tonner (EIS); B Kelly (EIS) and D
Thompson, Adviser to Teachers’ Side. 
Declarations of Interest and Transparency Statements
There were no declarations of interest or transparency statements intimated prior to the
commencement of the meeting.  
Item 1
Page 4 of 42

Page 5

Chairperson
In accordance with the terms of the local recognition and procedure agreement, which
stated that the Chair of the Committee should alternate between the two sides
comprising the Renfrewshire Council Joint Negotiating Committee for Teaching Staff, it
was agreed that Councillor Rodden would chair this meeting of the Renfrewshire
Council Joint Negotiating Committee for Teaching Staff. 
DECIDED: That Councillor Rodden chair this meeting of the Renfrewshire Council Joint
Negotiating Committee for Teaching Staff. 
Appointments to JNC
The Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) advised that Dan Thompson had replaced David
Baxter as Advisor to the Teachers’ Side. 
1 Minute of Previous Meeting
There was submitted the Minute of the meeting of this Committee held on 12 November
2024. 
DECIDED: That the Minute be approved. 
2 Matters Arising
There were no matters raised in connection with the previous Minute. 
DECIDED: That it be noted that there were no matters raised. 
3 Action Log
The action log for the JNC was submitted. The Joint Secretaries proposed that the log
be streamlined for the next meeting. Actioned/noted items would be removed, decisions
relative to policy matters would be uploaded to the SNCT website by the Management
Side and removed from the log and business items discussed during the preceding year
would continue to be reported at the AGM. 
DECIDED:   
(a) That the Violence and Aggression Policy be uploaded to the SNCT website; 
(b) That the proposed amendments to the action log be implemented for the next
meeting of this Committee; and 
(c) That the action log be noted. 
Page 5 of 42

Page 6

4  Mobile Phone Guidance for Schools
There was submitted a report by the Head of Education (Attainment, Inclusion and
Wellbeing) relative to Mobile Phone Guidance for Schools. The report advised that a
short-term working group had been established to review the Scottish Government’s
Guidance on Mobile Phones in Scotland’s Schools which had been published August
2024. 
The short-term working group, which consisted of 10 members, met three times and
developed a draft guidance document on the use of mobile phones for schools (Version
4), which was appended to the report for approval. 
Concerns were expressed by the Teacher’s Side that the draft guidance was more
relevant to secondary schools and it was requested that the policy be amended to
ensure its applicability to both secondary and primary schools. The Head of Education
(Attainment, Inclusion and Wellbeing) confirmed that amendments would continue to
be discussed, that this document would be regularly revised, including version controls,
to include lessons learned and to ensure it remained viable for application by schools. 
DECIDED:  That the Guidance on the use of mobile phones for schools (Version 4) be
agreed, subject to the discussed amendments, and that this be soft-launched in Term
4 of this session and fully implemented across all schools from August 2025. 
5 Seesaw
There was submitted a report by the Head of Education (Attainment, Inclusion and
Wellbeing) relative to an update regarding the use of Seesaw and Just2Easy
information sharing applications used in schools. 
The Head of Education (Attainment, Inclusion and Wellbeing) advised that he and the
Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) had discussed this matter and would discuss again
further outwith this meeting and report back, if required, to a future meeting of the JNC. 
DECIDED: 
(a) That the Joint Secretaries would discuss this matter further and report back, if
required, to a future meeting of the JNC; and 
(b) That otherwise, the content of the report be noted. 
6 Printing Procedures/Facilities
There was submitted a report by the Head of Education (Attainment, Inclusion and
Wellbeing) relative to an update regarding printer procedures and facilities. 
Concerns were raised regarding various issues around printing, printer facilities and the
potential impact of these on pupils and the examination process. The Education
Manager advised that testing of printing procedures for exams was being carried out at
various schools, and that St Andrew’s Academy would be the next high school to be
tested to check that the printing procedure to be applied during exams would work for
pupils, staff and invigilators. 
DECIDED: 
Page 6 of 42

Page 7

(a) That it be noted that testing of printing procedures for exams was being carried out
at various schools; and 
(b) That otherwise the content of the report be noted. 
7 Flexible Working
There was submitted a report by the Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) relative to the
Council’s Flexible Working Policy. The report outlined that the updated Policy had been
passed without consultation with the JNC and highlighted issues teaching staff faced
around the practical application of this Policy. 
The Strategic Lead Partner (Health & Safety) suggested that he and HR colleagues
discuss this matter further outwith this meeting with the Joint Secretaries and Children’s
Services Management and that an update be provided to a future meeting of the JNC.
This was agreed. 
DECIDED: 
(a) That it be noted that HR would discuss the flexible working policy with the Joint
Secretaries and Children’s Services Management; and 
(b) That an update be provided to a future meeting of the JNC. 
8 Education for Peace
There was submitted a report by the Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) relative to the
policy document “Education for Peace” recently launched by the EIS. 
The Head of Education (Attainment, Inclusion and Wellbeing) advised that the Council
already carried out many of the areas outlined in the Education for Peace document. 
DECIDED: That the document be noted. 
9 ASN Class Sizes
There was submitted a report by the Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) relative to class
size legal requirements. 
The Head of Education (Attainment, Inclusion and Wellbeing) advised that the SNCT
Handbook was being reviewed nationally and that the Council was currently reviewing
and supporting a particular case. It was agreed that this matter be discussed further
outwith the meeting and that the Teachers’ Side would raise any specific concerns with
the appropriate Education Managers. 
DECIDED: 
(a) That it be agreed that the matter be discussed further outwith the meeting; and 
(b) That it be noted that the Teachers’ Side would raise any specific concerns with the
appropriate Education Managers. 
Page 7 of 42

Page 8

10  Date of Next Meeting
It was noted that the date of the next meeting of the Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating
Committee was scheduled to be held at 2.00pm on 25 March 2025. 
Page 8 of 42

Page 9

Joint Negotiating Committee For Teachers – Action Log                                                                         
Date of JNC
Meeting
Report Action to be taken Officer
responsible
Due date 
(default date is the
date of the next
meeting unless
either the report or
the Joint
Secretaries
suggests an
alternative date)
Status 
(this section requires to be
completed by the two Joint
Secretaries to be included as
an update at the next meeting)
6 February 2024 Item 3
Matters Arising 
(a) Set up working group
to discuss JNC/15
Grievance Procedures 
(c) Standard Circular
access work 
(a) E Henry -
Interim Head of
Education 
(c) J Colquhoun
-Education
Manager
(Development) 
26 March 2024 
26 March 2024 
Groups to be allocated
November 2024 
Emma to find out how
Kenny can access Standard
Circulars as changes to
admin on website – remove
when this happens
Item 3
Page 9 of 42

Page 10

6 February 2024 Item 6
Mobile Phone Use
(a) Staff advised that
policy would be reviewed  
(b) Working group to be
set up to facilitate review
of policy 
(c) Mobile phone policy
reissued to schools with
caveat that phones can
only be used as directed
by staff
G Lyons -
Interim Head
of Education
Ongoing GM HoE to overtake this –
actioned and to be uploaded
to SNCT website – can be
removed when on SNCT
26 March 2024 Item 3
Matters Arising
(c) Review of Mobile
Phone Use in Schools
Policy 
GL – Interim
Manager of
Education and
Teachers’ Side 
14 May 2024  Ongoing – can be removed
when on SNCT
14 May 2024 Item 11
In Service Days/Public
Hoildays and P/T
Contracts
Meeting to be held
between both sides to
discuss
Both Sides 11 June 2024 Ongoing 
14 May 2024 Item 12 
Payroll and Salary
Overpayments
(b) that payroll directional
videos be provided to
teachers; 
(C) Ipads provided to
schools to enable access
to BW to be located and
put back into use within
the Council estate.
Management
Side 
Both Sides
11 June 2024 
11 June 2024
GM to provide update 
GM to provide update 
Page 10 of 42

Page 11

11 June 2024 Item 4 
Annual Report
(a) Investigate how
Standard Circulars could
be made available to staff 
EH  3 September
2024 
GM to provide update
Lauren Johnstone
11 June 2024 Item 9
NQT Induction Days 
The provision of a
separate TU information
session outwith the NQT
induction day would be
discussed
J Colquhoun
and Joint
Secretary
(Teachers’ Side)
As soon as
possible.
Ongoing – GM 
Date to be provided for
additional session 
11 June 2024 Item 11
Seesaw and Digital
Platforms
Review digital platform
use across the school
estate, particularly
Seesaw
GL with
Teachers Side
Ongoing GM HoE to overtake this
Pam McDowall 
3 September
2024
Item 4
Action Log
That the Action Log be
updated by the Head of
Education and Joint
Secretary (Teacher’s side)
at their pre-meeting and
passed timeously to the
Clerk for inclusion on the
agenda 
EH/KF Ongoing GM/KF Ongoing 
3 September
2024
Item 6
Absence Management
/ Supporting
Attendance
(Teachers) Policy 
That it be agreed that
the Joint Secretary
(Teacher’s Side) would
consult with the Head of
Education regarding the
updating of the policy on
Absence Management/
Supporting Attendance 
EH/KF Ongoing GM/KF Ongoing
Page 11 of 42

Page 12

3 September
2024
Item 9
Changes to Digital
Infrastructure
That the Interim Head of
Education investigate the
process for logging calls
with the ICT 
Helpdesk.
GL 12 November
2024
GM HoE to overtake this 
12 November
2024
Item 3 
Matters Arising
(b) That updates of
progress with regard to
Seesaw and
implications of digital
platforms be submitted
to the next meeting of
the JNC scheduled to
be held on 11
February 2025
GM  11 February 2025 Ongoing 
12 November
2024
Item 7
Budget
Underspends In
Primary And
Children & Families
And Early Learning
& Childcare Service
(a) That efforts would be
made to recruit any
current shortfall in
school and Early
Learning and Childcare
staff. 
GM  11 February 2025 Ongoing 
12 November
2024
Item 8 
Managing And
Reporting Violence
And Aggression
Launch
(a) That it be noted that
the Violence and
Aggression Policy be
part of the programme
for the in-service day in
August 2025. 
EH August 2025 Ongoing
Page 12 of 42

Page 13

11 February 2025 Item 3
Action Log
(a) That the Violence
and Aggression Policy
be uploaded to the
SNCT website; 
(b) That the proposed
amendments to
streamline the action log
be implemented for the
next meeting of the
Committee.
Management
Side 
Clerk with Joint
Secretaries
25 March 2025 
25 March 2025  Actioned 
11 February 2025 Item 4
Mobile Phone
Guidance for
Schools
That the guidance on
the use of mobile
phones for schools be
agreed, subject to
discussed amendments,
for soft-launch in Term 4
of this session and fully
implemented across all
schools from August
2025.
Both sides Ongoing 
11 February 2025 Item 5
Seesaw
That the Joint
Secretaries would
discuss further and
report back, if required,
to a future meeting of
the JNC.
Both sides Ongoing 
11 February 2025 Item 6
Printing
Procedures/Facilities
That testing of printing
procedures for the exam
process was being
carried out at various
schools.
Both sides Ongoing 
Page 13 of 42

Page 14

11 February 2025 Item 7
Flexible Working
(a) That the flexible
working policy be
discussed by HR with
the Joint Secretaries
and Children’s Services
Management; and 
(b) That an update be
provided to a future
meeting of the JNC.
Both sides Ongoing 
11 February 2025 Item 9
ASN Class Sizes
(a) That the matter be
discussed further
outwith the meeting; and 
(b) That the Teachers’
Side would raise any
specific concerns with
the appropriate
Education Managers. 
Both Sides Ongoing 
Page 14 of 42

Page 15

Agenda Item .......... 
Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
To: Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
On: 25 March 2025 
Report by
Joint Secretary (Management Side) 
Teacher Booker Supply Booking System
1. Background
1.1. On 22nd April 2025, we will be introducing a new electronic supply booking system
within Renfrewshire Schools, called Teacher Booker (TB). We will manage all
supply cover bookings for Teachers, Early Learning & Childcare Officers, and Early
Learning Support Workers via the new system.  
What’s Changing?
1.2. We are modernising and improving our current ways of working, by moving away
from manual driven processing (examples - email requests from schools to HQ,
maintaining contact details and availability via excel files, time consuming
texts/phone calls to and from supply staff, time delays for schools filling cover
requests, and delays to paying supply staff) to using a digital solution, that is quick
and easy to use, provides greater flexibility to manage cover requests at school
level, and, provides instant communication to supply staff.
The Key Changes 
1) Supply staff will have the responsibility to update their own availability within
their electronic calendar in Teacher Booker.  
2) Once a cover request has been processed and submitted to ‘live’, the system
will instantaneously identify any supply matches based on the criteria used e.g.
dates, cover reason, subjects etc.  The school can then ‘auto’ invite matched
supply Teachers to express an interest in covering the position. 
3) Once the supply Teacher has been selected, they will receive electronic
confirmation of the offer which includes school details, dates of cover, rate of
pay, who to report to etc.  Please note, that should the absence duration extend
past the initial requirement, the school will update the cover request by
changing the end date to a later date.  The supply Teacher will receive instant
electronic notification of any changes.  
4) The supply Teacher will be able to see the details of every job they have been
assigned to and covered.  The system will provide them will their supply teacher
record of employment history.
Item 4
Page 15 of 42

Page 16

5) Supply staff will no longer need to complete a timesheet via Business World,
as a timesheet will automatically be created within TB to reflect the cover
request.  
6) This will still require approval from Budget Manager i.e. Head Teacher (or
delegated officer *). At this stage, the timesheet can be amended for example if
cover reason has changed, or wrong cost code has been selected. 
7) Based on agreed national rules, the system will be set up to pay supply
teachers 5.5 hrs for up to 2 days, related to non-class contact time, and 7 hrs
thereafter.  The Head Teacher (or delegated officer) will have the ability to
override the hours paid, should  operational circumstances merit the uplift to 7
hrs, e.g. related to planning tasks.
* Note: The Senior Service Delivery Officers (SSDOs) supporting
ASN/ELCC/PS will be able to approve on behalf of their Heads, which is
currently not an option due to hierarchy set up within BW. There will be greater
flexibility to respond to budget manager’s absences around payroll deadlines,
thus ensuring supply staff get paid on time without delay or the need for
manual payment requests being sent to payroll. Once approved, these will be
uploaded to Business World for payment. 
1.3. There are 4 main role types that we will be used within Renfrewshire, and users
may be assigned more than one dependant on their job:-
1) Administrator – initial recruitment of and manages supply pool employee data
in line with the starter, leaver, and change processes (Employee Services staff)
2) Poster – can create and manage cover requests (School staff)
3) Approver – can approve and amend supply worker’s timesheets (Heads or
approved Delegated Officers) 
4) Viewers – run reports only (HR, Finance Partners etc.) 
1.4. Any user of the system (operators and supply staff) will require to have a licence. 
Due to licence costs, schools have been assigned 3 licences each (2 for
Standalone ELCCs).  During the school holiday periods, in the absence of the HT in
the 52 nursery classes, the office staff and business support school’s management
team will support with processing cover requests and approving timesheets. We
have compared with other councils using the system and Glasgow CC assign 3
licences to each school.  They are over 3 times larger than RC and have provided
positive feedback.
The Planned Timeline
Oct 2024 – Feb 2025 – ‘As Is’, ‘To Be’ and Information Gathering & System Build 
w/c 3rd & 10th Mar – Access to Test System, User Acceptance Testing, and
Preparing RC specific Training Guide 
Page 16 of 42

Page 17

w/c 17th Mar – Supply and School staff will receive a warm-up letter providing
details of what’s changing and what happens next.  Load data files will be
transferred for ‘live’ system set up 
w/c 24th Mar – Validate ‘live’ system and carry out Webinar Training for Supply and
School staff 
w/c 31st Mar– Supply and School staff will receive invitation to create their TB
account 
w/c 7th Apr - Chaser emails for staff who have not activated their account. Noting:
it is spring break / easter holiday period 
w/c 14th Apr – School staff will begin to post jobs to start from Tuesday 22nd April
2025 
w/c 21st Apr (Tues 22nd Apr)– ‘Go Live’ for all schools 
2. Recommendation
2.1 The JNC is asked to note this report. 
Page 17 of 42

Page 18

Agenda Item .......... 
Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
To: Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers
On: 25 March 2025
Report by
Joint Secretary (Management Side) 
Review of Job Sizing Processes 
1. Background 
1.1 Custom and practice in Renfrewshire Council has been to job size teaching promoted
posts at points of vacancy, where a new school is being built, or in response to a
personal job sizing review request in line with SNCT terms and conditions. 
1.2 Given the predicted changes to school roll figures going forward, to ensure fairness
and equity as well as effective stewardship of financial resource, it is vital that we have
in place a mechanism to allow for a whole scale review of pay grades for promoted
teaching staff in all sectors.   
1.3 Accordingly, in collaboration with HR colleagues a draft has been produced
encompassing and outlining proposed changes that would allow such a review to take
place on a biennial basis.   
1.4 The intention to review the job sizing process has been shared with DMT and with the
Joint Secretary (Teachers’ side) with whom we will collaborate to seek agreement on
the proposed proportionate approach with a view to bringing the finalised revised
document to the next JNC meeting.   
2. Recommendation 
2.1 Note the intention to revise practice within Renfrewshire in respect of job sizing of
promoted teaching posts.  
Item 5
Page 18 of 42

Page 19

Issue Number: 
Issue Date: 
Review Date:  
Job Sizing Process
For all posts on SNCT terms and conditions
This document is
available in alternative
formats on request.
Page 19 of 42

Page 20

Job-Sizing: Policy & Procedure – January 2025 
CONTENTS Page
1.0 INTRODUCTION Pg 2
2.0 PRINCIPLES Pg 2
3.0 FRAMEWORK Pg 3
4.0 EQUALITY STATEMENT Pg 4
5.0 BACKGROUND INFORMATION Pg 3-4
6.0 JOB-SIZING CO-ORDINATORS Pg 4-5
7.0 JOB-SIZING A VACANT  POST Pg 5-6
8.0 POSTHOLDER REQUEST FOR REVIEW Pg 6-7
9.0 COUNCIL INITIATED REVIEW Pg 7
10.0 PROCEDURE FOR RE-SIZING Pg 7-9
11.0 JOB-SIZING A NEW POST Pg 9
12.0 TEMPORARY FUNDING AND JOB-SIZING Pg 9-10
13.0 JOB-SIZING FOR A NEW SCHOOL Pg 10-11
14.0 EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGIST Pg 11
15.0 JOB-SIZING TIMESCALES Pg 11
16.0 JOB-SIZING APPEAL Pg 12
SNCT DOCUMENTS REFERENCED Pg 13   
Page 20 of 42

Page 21

2 
1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Job-sizing is the agreed means by which promoted posts are evaluated for
salary purposes in accordance with Teachers’ conditions of service.
Renfrewshire Council is committed to ensuring that the application of this policy
is consistent, transparent, fair and equitable with respect to pay. Job- sizing is
not intended to address issues related to workload or individual performance,
but rather assess the role to which an individual is appointed. 
1.2 This policy and procedure document defines the principles and process to follow
where the size of a post is to be evaluated for the first time, or, in the case of re-
sizing, the size is deemed to be no longer appropriate due to permanent
measurable qualitative or quantitative changes to the duties and responsibilities
to a post or group of posts in a school. Such changes relate to the duties and
responsibilities of a post and not to individual work demand or performance. 
1.3 This policy and procedure document details the process to be followed when
posts are to be evaluated and sets out the circumstances when a re-sizing will
be initiated. Re-sizing will be undertaken when the requirements detailed in the
SNCT handbook have been met (Part 2: Appendix 2.3, Annex A, Review
Criteria). 
2.0 PRINCIPLES 
2.1 In addition to the process of ‘sizing’ a post being fair and transparent, there are
five main principles which are applied when job-sizing: 
 Definition: Duties and responsibilities must be clearly defined such that
they are identifiable and easily distinguishable. These jobs must then be part
of the job description.
 Sizing: Job-sizing must be completed for all promoted posts with consistent
application across each sector.
 Job Understanding: Job-sizers must understand the job design process.
They must understand the various tasks involved.
 Concern: Job-sizing must be concerned with the job and not with the
person. i.e. it is the job that must be job-sized and not the postholder.
 Evaluate: Job-sizing must be carried out in accordance with (SNCT) /
(JNC) procedures. All persons who are involved in job-sizing are required to
act with integrity in the process particularly in those parts of the process
which require judgement.
Page 21 of 42

Page 22

3 
3.0 FRAMEWORK 
3.1 Job-sizing forms part of the teachers’ conditions of service as agreed by the
Scottish Negotiating Committee for Teachers (SNCT). Full account has been
taken of SNCT guidance in developing the policy and procedure document. 
3.2 The SNCT Handbook of Conditions of Service, Part 2, Appendix 2.2 outlines
the process of job-sizing. Annex A contains the job-sizing questionnaire and
notes for guidance. Annex B contains the job-size score allocation to grades and
spinal point. This information is available from the SNCT website 
www.snct.org.uk 
3.3 The provisions set out in this policy and procedure document are not intended
to replace those of the SNCT handbook. 
4.0 EQUALITY STATEMENT
4.1 Renfrewshire Council aims to have in place policy documents that meet the
diverse needs of our service, population and workforce, ensuring that none are
placed at a disadvantage over others. It considers the provisions of the Equality
Act 2010 and has been impact assessed in line with the Council’s obligation to
comply with the Equality Act 2010 and the Public Sector Equality Duty. 
5.0 BACKGROUND INFORMATION 
5.1 The job-sizing process starts with the completion of a questionnaire designed to
record the main responsibilities of a post under four headings (sections): 
2. Leadership, Good Management and Strategic Direction
of Colleagues;
3. Responsibility For Curriculum Development and Quality
Assurance;
4. Responsibility For Whole School Policy And
Implementation;
5. Responsibility For Working with Partners 
In addition, whole school information, provided by the Council (section 1, of the
questionnaire) is used to provide a base score for each post and when taken
together through the evaluation process and an output grade is the result. 
5.2 Whole school data consists of the school roll, numbers of staff, percentage of
pupils registered for free school meals, size of the school budget and the
Page 22 of 42

Page 23

4 
number of pupils for whom dedicated school transport is provided. This
information is updated annually following the September census and in June
when the School Meals survey is published by the Scottish Government. 
5.3 All responsibilities must be permanent and contained within the relevant job
description, as agreed through JNC. Any responsibility which is part of a remit
for less than 2 years will be excluded for job-sizing purposes. 
5.4 Over time there may be significant changes to whole school data and/or
responsibilities which may necessitate a job-sizing review to ensure that a post
is still sized appropriately with the commensurate salary. The SNCT have agreed
the review criteria (Part 2: Appendix 2.3, Annex A, Review Criteria). 
5.5 Changes to either whole school information, responsibilities or both will trigger
a review of a post being assessed against the SNCT review criteria. If the criteria
are met, the post will be subject to re-job-sizing. 
5.6 The job-size of a promoted post will be reviewed in the following circumstances. 
1. When an existing post becomes vacant and prior to the post being
advertised;
2. When a postholder requests a review of their post in the belief that
aspects of the whole school information and/or the responsibilities of a
post have changed;
3. When the Head of Education believes that aspects of the whole school
data and/or the responsibilities of a post/posts merit a review 
If the criteria are not met then the review is complete and there will be no change
to the recorded job-sizing outcome for a post. A review of a post may lead to a
full re-sizing of the post. With the exception of when a post is being reviewed
due to a vacancy the SNCT have agreed set times when re-sizing should be
undertaken. 
6.0 JOB-SIZING CO-ORDINATORS 
6.1 Job-sizing co-ordinators must have received training directly by the SNCT
trainers identified for that purpose. 
6.2 Children’s Services will maintain a register of trained job-sizing co-ordinators on
both the management and teachers' side. This register will be shared with the
SNCT 
6.3 Two job-sizing co-ordinators (one management and one teachers' side) will be
Page 23 of 42

Page 24

5 
involved in any one job-sizing/review exercise. 
6.4 The role of the job-sizing co-ordinators is to work together to ensure that the
job-sizing process is efficient, fair and transparent. They are tasked to: 
(a) Consider applications for review and using the SNCT review criteria
decide whether a re-sizing is necessary;
(b) Provide advice and guidance on the completion of the relevant
documents;
(c) Validate and sign off the questionnaire when satisfied that the details
provided are an accurate reflection of the role;
(d) Process all data through the Toolkit;
(e) Provide written confirmation of the outcome to the postholder/head
teacher, copied to Employee Services to be recorded in the employee’s
file. 
6.5 In the event that the assigned job-sizing co-ordinators are unable to reach
agreement on the content of any claim advice will be sought informally from the
SNCT Joint Secretaries If there is no agreement the matter will be referred to
the SNCT formally for determination. 
7.0 JOB-SIZING A VACANT  POST 
7.1 When it is known that an existing promoted post is to become vacant, the Head
Teacher must inform the EM with responsibility for staffing to enable the job-sizing
of the post to take place. Job-sizing will be undertaken prior to a post being
advertised. A post cannot be advertised until job-sizing has been concluded. 
7.2 Only after a post has been job-sized should an online advert request via completion
of a Vacant Position Form on Business World be submitted. 
Page 24 of 42

Page 25

6 
the exigencies of the service. 
8.0 POSTHOLDER REQUEST FOR REVIEW 
8.1 Under normal circumstances a post will be reviewed only once in a twelve-
month period. 
8.2 The SNCT has determined that applications may be submitted for review in June
and December of each year. Applications for post reviews must be submitted
no later than 31st May for June review or 30th November for December review.
If an application is received out with these times, it will be held until the next
scheduled diet of reviews. Any request must be based on significant and
permanent qualitative change(s) to the level of duties and responsibilities of an
individual post or group of posts when assessed against the review criteria. 
8.3 Where a substantive postholder believes that there have been significant
changes to the whole school data and/or the responsibilities of the post (as
permitted by the JNC agreed job description for the post) since the last job-
sizing of the post, he/she should in the first instance refer to the SNCT review
criteria. 
8.4 All changes in whole school data and/or post responsibilities must be accounted
for when considering the review criteria. 
8.5 Changes are graded - Type A, Type B and Type C - depending on the likely
effect they will have on the overall score for a post; One type A change
automatically initiates a re-sizing of the post; Two type B or one type B and two
type C changes are required to initiate a re-sizing. Four type C changes are
required to initiate a re-sizing. 
8.6 Some changes only apply to certain posts. This is based on whether or not the
particular section of the questionnaire impacts on the size of that type of post. 
8.7 If, when assessing the changes against the review criteria, it is thought that the
criteria have been met the postholder should discuss this with their Head
Teacher. Advice and guidance will be available from the job-sizing co-
ordinators. 
8.8 The Head Teacher along with the postholder, should sign and submit a
completed post review application form (Appendix 2) to enable a review of the
post to take place. All information must be provided with supporting documents
as required before a review can be initiated. A job-sizing questionnaire should
not be submitted until the request to review the post has been accepted by the
assigned job-sizing co-ordinators.
Page 25 of 42

Page 26

7 
8.9 The job-sizing co-ordinators will consider the post review application and if they
agree that the review criteria have been met, they will inform the postholder and
Head Teacher that a re-sizing of the post will be undertaken. It is at this time that
a completed job-sizing questionnaire must be completed. 
8.10 Consideration will be given, by the job-sizing co-ordinators, to whether changes
to the whole school data and/or responsibilities of the post could have a possible
impact on the job-size of any other promoted post(s) in the school, which may
thus require to be reviewed at the same time. 
8.11 If the job-sizing co-ordinators agree that the review criteria have not been met,
the postholder will be informed, and they will record their decision on the review
paperwork stating clearly their rationale before signing the document. 
8.12 All paperwork associated with the review will be held in a digital format and
linked to the post and the postholder’s employment record. This should be done
via Employee Services. 
9.0 COUNCIL INITIATED REVIEW 
9.1 The Council may initiate a review of one or more promoted post if there is an
indication of a change to the whole school data and/or the responsibilities of a
post where there is a likelihood of the review resulting in a change to the job-
size score. A Head Teacher can request the Council initiate a review if there is
a reallocation of areas of responsibility. 
9.2 An biennial desktop exercise will be undertaken by Children’s Service staff and
HR to determine whether there has been a category “A” change in the whole
school data of any school. School roll data will be taken from the previous year’s
September census and free meals entitlement from the Scottish Government’s
survey published in June. In circumstances where a category “A” change has
occurred a review will be undertaken. 
9.3 Any review will be undertaken in partnership with the trade unions and a re-
sizing exercise will follow the process detailed in section 10 of this document.
Each promoted postholder is required to complete a questionnaire. 
9.4 Any resulting change to salary will be implemented on the 1st February the
following year. Cash conservation of salary will be applied in accordance with
the prevailing SNCT conditions of service. 
10.0 PROCEDURE FOR RE-SIZING 
10.1 Where it has been agreed by the job-sizing co-ordinators that the review 
criteria have been met the postholder will be asked to complete and
Page 26 of 42

Page 27

8 
sign a job-sizing questionnaire supplied by the co-ordinators. 
10.2 Section 1 of the questionnaire will be populated with the whole school
information which will be taken from the review supporting documentation. The
whole school information will include: school roll, staffing numbers, free meal
registrations, budget and school transport numbers. 
10.3 Sections 2-5 of the questionnaire will be completed by the postholder in
agreement with their Head Teacher, or in the case of a Head Teacher, the Head
of Education or nominee. These sections capture information specific to the
remit of the post within the context of the JNC agreed job descriptions relating
to: Management and Strategic Direction of Staff; Curriculum Development and
Quality Assurance; Implementation of Whole School Policy; Working with
Partners. 
10.4 The completed questionnaire, should be scanned and emailed to XXX A receipt
will be provided for each application received. Only questionnaires received in
this way will be validated. 
10.5 The co-ordinators will validate entries in the questionnaire and ensure that there
has been no double counting of responsibilities. 
10.6 Consideration will be given to whether changes to the whole school data and/or
responsibilities of the post could have a possible impact on the job-size of any
other post in the school, which may thus require to be reviewed at the same time. 
10.7 If a questionnaire cannot be validated, the co-ordinators will provide a rationale
to the postholder in writing. The co-ordinators may ask for the questionnaire to
be resubmitted with additional supporting documents. 
10.8 Once validated, the co-ordinators will sign the questionnaire. Only at this point
will the entries in the questionnaire be processed using Job-Sizing Toolkit.
There are five possible outcomes of a re-sizing exercise: 
(a) There may be no change to the job-size score, and no change to the
salary;
(b) There may be an increase in the job-size score, but no change to the
salary;
(c) There may be an increase in the job-size score, and an increase in salary;
(d) There may be a decrease in the job-size score, but no change to the
salary;
(e) There may be a decrease in the job-size score, and a decrease in salary. 
10.9 All paperwork associated with a review will be held in a digital format and
Page 27 of 42

Page 28

9 
linked to the post holder’s employment record by Employee Services 
10.10 Any change to salary resulting from a December review and subsequent re-
sizing will be effective from 1st February of the following year. Any change to
salary resulting from a June review and subsequent re-sizing will be effective
from 1st August of the same year. Retrospective payments will not be made.
Cash conservation of salary will be applied in accordance with the prevailing
SNCT conditions of service. 
11.0  JOB-SIZING A NEW POST 
11.1 When, following consultation with staff, a new promoted post is to be
established the Head Teacher should have an initial discussion with one of the
co-ordinators to discuss the role and potential impact on other posts. It will be
the responsibility of the Head Teacher, in consultation with their People Adviser
to draft a job description if there is no approved description for the post. 
11.2 The Head Teacher should complete a questionnaire along with supporting
documents. Reference should be made to Appendix 3 and emailed to XXXX
and will be acknowledged. Only a questionnaire received in this way will be
validated. 
12.0 TEMPORARY FUNDING AND JOB-SIZING 
12.1 There may be occasions when authority might be given for the creation of
additional promoted posts using external funding streams. For example, Pupil
Equity Funds. 
12.2 When additional promoted posts are being considered there are a number of
factors that have to be taken into account: 
(a) The remits assigned to substantive post holders;
(b) No management responsibility can be claimed for staff not funded from
core budget;
(c) Due to the temporary nature of the funding no responsibility for
management of a budget can be delegated to a post;
(d) There can be no double counting of remit/responsibilities;
(e) Unlikely to be a job-sizing claim in sections 2.1-2.4; 3.2-3.4; 4.1-4.3 of
the job-sizing questionnaire.
Page 28 of 42

Page 29

10 
12.3 Due to the temporary nature of such posts, no substantive post holder should
be disadvantaged. 
12.4 A remit must be provided by the Head Teacher at the time of submission of the
job-sizing questionnaire. 
12.5 Promoted posts funding using a temporary funding stream will be for a
maximum duration of twenty months. It is the responsibility of the Head Teacher
to put in place an appropriate plan to manage the transition leading to the
discontinuation of the role. This may include the review of the role undertaken
by substantive postholders should it be planned to distribute in part or in whole
remit of the temporary post to others. Reference should be made section 10. 
12.6 Any change to the school’s core management structure brought about by an
increase in promoted posts will require an initial review to be undertaken to
establish whether there is an impact on other posts. This might arise in a
situation where a decision is taken to subsume the remit of a temporary role and
create another permanent position. Reference should be made section 11. 
13.0 JOB-SIZING FOR A NEW  SCHOOL 
13.1 When appointments are to be made for a new school the whole school
information, for an initial desktop exercise, will be determined using known data
for existing schools. Care must be taken to ensure that the data used can be
evidenced. 
13.2 All promoted posts will be sized initially using the estimated whole school data
to determine an indicative salary level for each role. Such an approach will be
referred to as a desktop exercise with the final salary level for each post being
determined when the new school has been established and the first recorded
census information is known. 
13.3 The biennial desktop exercise to size each post will be undertaken in
partnership with trade union job-sizers and led by the Head of Education or
representative, and follow a similar process to that set out in section 10. 
13.4 The exercise will be carried out based on comprehensive and up-to-date job
descriptions for each role, in consultation with the Head Teacher with guidance
from the HR (People Adviser) in which the school will be located, and trade
union co-ordinator. The job description will be used to inform the completion of
a job-sizing questionnaire for the desktop exercise. 
13.5 When the questionnaire has been finalised and the co-ordinators have agreed
the content, the information will be entered into the Toolkit to determine the
Page 29 of 42

Page 30

11 
anticipated salary level for the post – desktop exercise outcome. It is this
salary that will be used when recruiting for each role. Postholders will be
advised that the posts will be formally job-sized after the first recorded
Census data – job- size exercise outcome. 
13.6 Each role will be job-sized when nationally published data is available for the
new school. If  job-sizing leads to a change in salary level, from that anticipated
because of the desktop exercise, the following action will be taken: 
1. If the role has been found to be job-sized with a higher salary than
had been anticipated following the desktop exercise, the postholder
will receive the higher salary from the date of their appointment; or,
2. If the role has been found to be job-sized with a lower salary than
had been anticipated following the desktop exercise, the postholder
will be informed that their salary is to be cash conserved from the
date of notification of the job-size outcome. Conservation will be in
accordance with the prevailing SNCT conditions applicable at the
time. 
14.0 EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGIST 
14.1 The SNCT have made provision for job-sizing Principal and Depute Principal
Educational Psychology positions. 
14.2  (SNCT Part 2: Appendix 2.4, Annex A). 
14.3 Posts will be subject to re-sizing if any change in responsibilities results in a
change in the banding in any section of the questionnaire. 
15.0 JOB-SIZING TIMESCALES 
15.1 When a vacancy is to be job-sized it is anticipated that the outcome will be made
known no later than four working weeks after the decision has been taken to
size the post. Similarly, this time period will apply when a new post is being
sized. 
15.2 Requests for a post to be re-sized in accordance with section 8. The postholder
will be notified in writing of the outcome of their application with a copy to their
Head Teacher no later than eight working weeks following receipt of their
request. Where there is a change to the grade level of the post, any change of
salary will be effective in accordance with paragraph 10.10
Page 30 of 42

Page 31

12 
16.0 JOB-SIZING APPEAL 
16.1 There is no mechanism to appeal the outcome of the job-sizing of a post unless
the postholder is of the view that the process set out in this policy and procedures
document has not been followed correctly. 
16.2 A postholder wishing to appeal must do so within ten working days of receipt of
their outcome letter. The appeal must be in writing to the Head of Education
setting out clearly where the perceived omission in the process has been. 
16.3 A postholder can choose to be accompanied by a member of a trade union or
professional association. The Head of Human Resources or nominee, along with
a nominated trade union official, will hear the appeal. The trade union official
will not be from the same union/professional association accompanying the
postholder. The postholder will be invited to present the appeal. The job-sizing
co-ordinators will not attend the appeal hearing. 
16.4 The Head of Human Resources or nominee, and a trade union official from the
teachers’ side will hear the appeal no later than two months from the date of the
submission of the appeal. There are two possible outcomes from an appeal: 
1. The appeal is upheld and remitted back to the co-ordinators to
re-size;
2. The appeal is not upheld 
The decision of the appeal hearing will be final and communicated in writing
within ten working days. 
16.5 A teacher who remains dissatisfied with the outcome can request, via the JNC
Joint Secretaries, to have their case submitted to the SNCT Joint Secretaries
for their consideration. 
16.6 No provision in this policy will prejudice an employee’s rights under the
approved Grievance Procedure. 
Page 31 of 42

Page 32

13 
SNCT DOCUMENTS REFERENCED IN THIS POLICY &
PROCEDURE 
 Handbook of Conditions of Service
 Part 2: Appendix 2.2 Annex A & Annex B
 Part 2: Appendix 2.3, Annex A, (Review Criteria)
 Part 2: Appendix 2.4, Annex A 
Page 32 of 42

Page 33

Agenda Item .......... 
Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
To: Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
On: 25 March 2025 
Report by
Joint Secretary (Management Side) 
Seesaw Guidance for Establishments
1. Background
1.1. A request report was submitted by the Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) regarding the
use of Seesaw and other digital platforms.
1.2. The focus was on the implications for teacher accessibility outside of working hours
due to the instant messaging function. Some points raised were:
1.2.1. There is an expectation that learning continues to be shared with
parents/carers, impacting teaching and lesson preparation time.
1.2.2. This has led to additional workload and stress for teachers, which is deemed
unsustainable.
1.2.3. Despite reminders, parents/carers regularly use Seesaw as a communication
method.
1.2.4. There is now an expectation that learning continues to be shared with
parents/carers which is impacting teaching and preparation time.
1.2.5. This has led to additional workload and stress for teachers, which is deemed
unsuitable.
1.3. A draft guidance for establishments was created by Pam McDowall, Digital Learning
Manager. This guidance provides:
1.3.1. A consistent approach across establishments, including the need to agree
the procedures for sharing information
1.3.2. Clear guidance on use during working hours
1.3.3. Protocols for parents
1.4. The final draft (attached) was produced for DMT approval prior to being shared with
JNCT. 
Item 6
Page 33 of 42

Page 34

2. Recommendation
2.1 The JNCT approve this guidance with a view to it being shared with schools from
Term 4 to allow this to be incorporated into their Working Time Agreement for the
new session.
Page 34 of 42

Page 35

Seesaw Guidance for Establishments
Overview
Seesaw is a learning journal that shares pupil learning and achievements through a safe digital
learning platform. Learners can document their learning creatively by periodically adding entries
such as photos, videos, drawings and notes to profile the learning they have engaged with in
class. 
Seesaw creates a triangle of communication between families and the establishment, whilst
encouraging digital citizenship and showing how to use technology in a safe and creative way. 
The aim of this guidance is to ensure that all staff, parents and members of our community
understand how Seesaw should be used in establishments. 
Aim and Purpose
Seesaw may be used by establishment in Renfrewshire for the following purposes:
• To give parents, carers and families’ regular updates about what their child is learning and
doing in their establishment, therefore bringing them further into the life of the
establishment. 
• To support and encourage parents, carers and families to discuss their child’s learning with
them at home, therefore extending learning opportunities for children. 
• To compile a record of progress in learning that Early Years practitioners, teachers and
learners can use to reflect on what has been achieved and what next steps might be
appropriate. 
Privacy and Access
To use Seesaw the following must be in place: 
• Parental consent must be obtained (see Appendix 1) and a copy of this letter stored
appropriately.
• If a parent/carer does not consent to the use of Seesaw, this must be recorded and
managed by the establishment, ensuring all staff are made aware.
• Appropriate photograph consent must be in place and staff should be mindful of this when
sharing information on Seesaw and ensure no group photographs are used for these
learners.
• Personal information or medical information must not be shared through Seesaw. 
• Staff, parents and carers have a secure log in for Seesaw using the app. Children’s
information is not accessible by anyone without a log-in code.
• Seesaw’s privacy policy can be found here: https://seesaw.com/privacy-security/ 
Ways of Working
• All staff must ensure that they keep their Seesaw log in codes secure.
• Staff must log out of Seesaw when finished. This should be done each time.
Page 35 of 42

Page 36

• If using a desktop or laptop to access Seesaw, the screen should be locked as soon as
they move away from the device.
• Staff should only approve posts or comments from parents or pupils in their own class.
• All staff should post under their own name to ensure parents can see which member of
staff is making the comment.
• Only the minimum necessary personal information should be uploaded to Seesaw.
Our Expectations
Establishments should agree the procedures for sharing information with parents. This should
include the number of posts required each week. 
Staff
• Post regularly (as per agreement) a selection of photographs that showcase learning
• Approve all comments and posts before they are visible on the learning journal
• Ensure your working hours are set up on Seesaw so families are aware of these
• Only respond to private messages during agreed working hours 
Families
• Check Seesaw regularly for updates and announcements
• Comment positively on any learning experiences which have been shared
• Celebrate your child’s successes and encourage the skills that we are building
• All pick-up and drop-off, medical information and absences must be reported via the office
• Any urgent messages during the day must by made by calling the office
• Parents and carers are not permitted to share images shared on Seesaw via any form of
social media
• Complaints should not be made via Seesaw; please contact the establishment directly by:
o Telephoning for a meeting
o Writing a letter to request a meeting
o Speaking to staff to request a meeting
• Please be mindful about when you message and avoid weekends, holidays and late in the
evening. 
The establishment website is the main platform for sharing information and this will always be
posted there in the first instance. 
Page 36 of 42

Page 37

Appendix One
Seesaw – Our Communication App 
Parent Consent 
Seesaw is a learning journal that shares pupil learning and achievements through a safe digital
learning platform. Learners can document their learning creatively by periodically adding entries
such as photos, videos, drawings and notes to profile the learning they have engaged with in
class. 
Seesaw creates a triangle of communication between families and the establishment, whilst
encouraging digital citizenship and showing how to use technology in a safe and creative way. 
The establishment will also send important messages and reminders using Seesaw. When there
are new posts or messages, you'll be notified and can see what's new. 
You can read more about their privacy promises here: https://web.seesaw.me/privacy. 
Under an EU law called the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), in order for your child to
use Seesaw, the school must get your consent. For more information on GDPR, please visit
https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/law-topic/dataprotection/reform/rights-citizens. 
————————————————————————————————————
When signing up to Seesaw we ask Parents/ Carers to agree to the following guidelines: 
• Agreed guidelines for accessing and using Seesaw ‘Online Learning Journeys’
• As a parent/carer I agree to:
o Check Seesaw regularly for updates and announcements
o Comment positively on any learning experiences which have been shared
o Celebrate my child’s successes and encourage the skills that we are building
o Report all pick-up and drop-off, medical information and absences via the office
o Call the office for any urgent messages during the day
o Not publish any of my child’s observations, photographs or videos on any social
media site.
o Understand that my child’s image may be used in another child’s profile if they are
engaged in the same activity.
o This image will not be shared by the other parent (please see above point)
o Keep the login details within my trusted family Speak to a member of staff if I
experience any difficulties accessing my child’s learning journey
o Complaints should not be made via Seesaw; please contact the establishment
directly by:
▪ Telephoning for a meeting
▪ Writing a letter to request a meeting
▪ Speaking to staff to request a meeting
o Please be mindful about when you message and avoid weekends, holidays and late
in the evening.
Page 37 of 42

Page 38

I give consent for my child, listed below, to use Seesaw. 
Student Name: ____________________________ Class:________________________________ 
Parent Printed Name: _______________________ Parent Signature:_______________________ 
Establishment Name: 
Tel:      E-mail: 
Page 38 of 42

Page 39

Agenda Item .......... 
Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
To: Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers
On: 25 March 2025
Report by
Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) 
Violence and Aggression Policy 
1. Background 
The role of Headteachers in facilitating the recording process relating to violence
against teachers is central to the successful implementation of the policy. It has come
to the attention of the Teachers’ Side that there is an issue with the recording process
when a Headteacher is absent, leading to a delay in the application of the protocols
designed to protect teachers from further violence and aggression. 
2. Recommendation 
Headteachers to be advised of the protocols to be adopted with regard to the recording
of incidents of violence and aggression against teachers whenever a Headteacher is
absent. Teachers to be given some form of written acknowledgement that the violent
incident form has been submitted to Renfrewshire Council HQ. 
Item 7
Page 39 of 42

Page 40

Agenda Item .......... 
Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
To: Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers
On: 25 March 2025
Report by
Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) 
Artificial Intelligence 
1. Background 
As the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) grows in commerce and society, its emerging
benefits and costs are regularly being reported.  The Scottish Government published
“Scotland’s Artificial Intelligence Strategy – Trustworthy, Ethical and Inclusive” in
March 2021, which set out the vision for positive use of AI in Scotland. 
Some secondary schools in Renfrewshire have provided CLPL sessions for teachers
with the aim of upskilling staff to harness the power of AI in creating learning &
teaching resources.  This has been well-received, and many teachers are putting this
new learning to good use. 
However, as learners become more familiar with using AI and uncover its potential,
this may lead them to use the technology in potentially questionable ways. One major
concern is the use of AI to complete tasks such as homework and, more significantly,
certificated assignments. 
Indeed, the Scottish Qualifications Authority published guidance for teachers in
identifying malpractice (see “Authenticating learners’ work – good practice advice for
centre staff”).  This is helpful, but there is some concern that failure to identify
plagiarism, whereby AI has been used in whole or part by a learner, will result in
unnecessary blame being placed on the teacher.  AI is so advanced that it may be
very difficult to detect nuanced plagiarism. 
2. Recommendation 
• Management to acknowledge the above concerns. 
• Management to promote SQA guidance “Authenticating learners’ work – good
practice advice for centre staff” to Renfrewshire secondary schools, and consider
investing in further training for teachers to help in the identification and prevention of
inappropriate AI use. 
• The teachers’ side seeks assurances that incidents of plagiarism and/or other
inappropriate pupil use of AI in relation to schoolwork will be viewed as the fault of
the perpetrator and not the teacher. 
Item 8
Page 40 of 42

Page 41

Agenda Item .......... 
Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
To: Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers
On: 25 March 2025
Report by
Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) 
EAL and Sensory Support Service Staffing 
1. Background 
Concerns have been expressed to the EIS Secretaries around the staffing quotas in
the EAL Service and the Sensory Support Service with a reduction in staffing being
intimated in both service areas. There are concerns that the teams will be unable to
provide adequate support to children, staff and parents. 
2. Recommendation 
Discussion to take place between the Management and Teachers’ Side around the
staffing complements for the EAL and Sensory Support Service and how these
adequately meet the needs of the children requiring to use these services. 
Item 9
Page 41 of 42

Page 42

Agenda Item .......... 
Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers 
To: Renfrewshire Joint Negotiating Committee for Teachers
On: 25 March 2025
Report by
Joint Secretary (Teachers’ Side) 
Early Years Welcome Pack 
1. Background 
The EIS has launched a new book, ‘Mochara Goes to Nursery’ to help welcome young
children who are new to Scotland. The story follows Mochara as she arrives in
Scotland and gets ready for her first day in nursery. The story focuses on the warm
welcome and support she receives from nursery staff and her new friends as she
navigates the different surroundings. 
2. Recommendation 
The Teachers’ Side seeks to engage with Management to promote the book as a
resource for Renfrewshire nursery and early years staff. 
Item 10
Page 42 of 42