(c) Representations (Pages 887-1208)
Perth and Kinross Council · 12 August 2024
Back to Local Review Body — 12 August 2024 and its agenda
Text extracted from the council's PDF. Layout and reading order may differ from the original.
Some pages contain no extractable text. They may be blank, graphics or scanned pages. OCR has not been applied.
Page 1
5(ii)(c) LRB-2024-13 LRB-2024-13 22/01959/FLL - Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community café, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works, land 30 metres west of St Columba's Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley REPRESENTATIONS
Page 2
No embedded text on this page.
Page 3
No embedded text on this page.
Page 4
No embedded text on this page.
Page 5
No embedded text on this page.
Page 6
No embedded text on this page.
Page 7
No embedded text on this page.
Page 8
No embedded text on this page.
Page 9
No embedded text on this page.
Page 10
No embedded text on this page.
Page 11
No embedded text on this page.
Page 12
No embedded text on this page.
Page 13
No embedded text on this page.
Page 14
L Valentine
Page 15
No embedded text on this page.
Page 16
Katie Baedie
Page 17
No embedded text on this page.
Page 18
No embedded text on this page.
Page 19
J Allan
Page 20
Linda Jolly
Page 21
Linda Lennon
Page 22
No embedded text on this page.
Page 23
J Marshall
Page 24
No embedded text on this page.
Page 25
No embedded text on this page.
Page 26
No embedded text on this page.
Page 27
No embedded text on this page.
Page 28
No embedded text on this page.
Page 29
No embedded text on this page.
Page 30
No embedded text on this page.
Page 31
No embedded text on this page.
Page 32
No embedded text on this page.
Page 33
No embedded text on this page.
Page 34
No embedded text on this page.
Page 35
No embedded text on this page.
Page 36
Jane Campbell
Page 37
W Campbell
Page 38
No embedded text on this page.
Page 39
S Stephen
Page 40
No embedded text on this page.
Page 41
Comments to the Development Quality Manager on a Planning Application Planning Application ref. 22/01959/FLL Comments provided by Lucy Sumner Service/Section Strategy & Policy Contact Details Development Contributions Officer: Lucy Sumner Description of Proposal Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works Address of site Land 30 Metres West Of St Columba's Episcopal Church 19 Perth Road Stanley Comments on the proposal NB: Should the planning application be successful and such permission not be implemented within the time scale allowed and the applicant subsequently requests to renew the original permission a reassessment may be carried out in relation to the Council’s policies and mitigation rates pertaining at the time. THE FOLLOWING REPORT, SHOULD THE APPLICATION BE SUCCESSFUL IN GAINING PLANNING APPROVAL, MAY FORM THE BASIS OF A SECTION 75 PLANNING AGREEMENT WHICH MUST BE AGREED AND SIGNED PRIOR TO THE COUNCIL ISSUING A PLANNING CONSENT NOTICE. Transport Infrastructure With reference to the above planning application the Council Transport Infrastructure Developer Contributions Supplementary Guidance requires a financial contribution towards the cost of delivering the transport infrastructure improvements which are required for the release of all development sites in and around Perth. The site is located in the ‘Full’ Transport Infrastructure contributions zone (Appendix 3 of the Supplementary Guidance) The proposal is for a Community Hub project by the Stanley Development Trust. The cost of delivering the Community Hub project receives funding via Section 75 Agreement developer contributions from Muir Homes, and possibly other developers in future. It is therefore considered that applying a contributions requirement for this proposal is not necessary. Recommended planning condition(s) Summary of Requirements Transport Infrastructure: £0 Total: £0 Recommended informative(s) for applicant Date comments returned 03 March 2023
Page 42
Comments to the Development Quality Manager on a Planning Application Planning Application ref. 22/01959/FLL Comments provided by Charlie Haggart Service/Section HE/Flooding Contact Details FloodingDevelopmentControl@pkc.gov.uk Description of Proposal Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works Address of site Land 30 Metres West Of St Columba's Episcopal Church 19 Perth Road Stanley Comments on the proposal No objections. Recommended planning condition(s) N/A Recommended informative(s) for applicant The applicant is advised to refer to Perth & Kinross Council’s Supplementary guidance on Flood Risk and Flood Risk Assessments 2021 as it contains advice relevant to your development. Date comments returned 06/03/2023
Page 43
Mr Robert McFarlane (Objects) Comment submitted date: Mon 06 Mar 2023 I wish to make an objection to this proposed planning application (22/01959/FLL.) I have ticked off the above boxes which go towards supporting my objection. I also think that the monument is a sacred structure that should not be moved for the sake of a community centre which is currently being proposed.
Page 44
Comments to the Development Quality Manager on a Planning Application Planning Application ref. 22/01959/FLL Comments provided by Lachlan MacLean Project Officer – Transport Planning Service/Section Transport Planning Contact Details TransportPlanning@pkc.gov.uk Description of Proposal Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works Address of site Land 30 Metres West Of St Columba's Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley Comments on the proposal The applicant is proposing to erect a community centre with café and outdoor sports facilities adjacent to the St Columba’s Episcopal church. A new vehicle access for the site directly onto the B9099 Perth Road will be created by re siting the War Memorial. The applicant had discussed taking access from West Park, but an agreement has not been possible from the residents as this is a private road. At the proposed vehicle access onto he B9099, there is streetlighting infrastructure, in particular the streetlighting cable will need to be lowered to a depth of at least 750 mm. In the footway there is a culvert, which will also need to be strengthened to accommodate vehicle access to the site. The vehicle access shall be formed prior to any construction works commencing to avoid damage to the culvert and streetlighting infrastructure. A condition is recommended. Parking will be provided on site for 11 vehicles. The spaces can accommodate minibuses. There will be three accessible spaces included in the total 11 spaces. The centre is located centrally to the community and most local residents are within an 800m walking radius of the site. Cycling is also catered for with a new shared pedestrian/cycle path into the site from Perth Road. Cycle parking on site will be provided for 14 bicycles. If the applicant is successful in gaining planning consent, they must apply for a Vehicle Access Consent before starting works on its formation. This will allow the applicants contractor to apply for the necessary consents to work within the public road network. More information on the process can be found on the following website: https://www.pkc.gov.uk/vehicleaccess. Please note, that as planning permission has been applied for, currently no fee is required for the Vehicle Access Consent (VA1 form), please include the planning application number on your VA application form. Insofar as the Roads matters are concerned, I have no objections to this proposal on the following conditions.
Page 45
Recommended planning condition(s) No development in connection with the permission hereby granted shall commence unless the vehicle access across the footway onto the B9099 has been provided with the lowered streetlighting cable, the culvert has been strengthened and formed in accordance with Perth & Kinross Council's Road Development Guide Type B Figure 5.6 access detail with dropped kerbs across the full 6 metre width of the vehicle access of Type A Road construction detail. Reason - In the interests of road safety; to ensure an acceptable standard of construction within the public road boundary. Prior to the development hereby approved being completed or brought into use, the cycle parking for a minimum of 14 cycles shall be implemented in accordance with the approved details to the satisfaction of the Council as Planning Authority. Reason - To encourage active travel and meet advice within Scottish Planning Policy on transport. Recommended informative(s) for applicant Street lighting plant present at the site, discussions must be had with the Street Lighting Partnership to obtain the locations of plant and the relocation to facilitate the vehicle access. Contact Mark Gorrie at Perth & Kinross Council Street Lighting Department for further details. The road culvert present at the vehicle access, must be strengthened to the satisfaction of the Roads Authority. Contact Brian Milne at Perth & Kinross Council Road Maintenance Partnership for further details. The applicant is advised that, in terms of Sections 56 of the Roads (Scotland) Act 1984, he/she/they must obtain from the Council, as Roads Authority, consent to open an existing road or footway prior to the commencement of works. Information on junction types, requirements for Vehicular Access consents (VA1) and application forms are available at www.pkc.gov.uk/vehicleaccess. Advice on the disposal of surface water should be sought at the initial stages of design from Scottish Water and the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency. The applicant is advised that, in terms of Sections 109 of the New Roads and Street Works Act 1991, he/she/they must obtain from the Council, to place, maintain or adjust apparatus in, or under a Road or remove apparatus from a road. Application forms are available at https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/14916/Road-and-footway-permits. Date comments returned 06 March 2023
Page 46
Dr Eileen Brown (Supports) Comment submitted date: Tue 07 Mar 2023 I would like to register my full support to the creation of a community hub within Stanley. As someone who has lived in the village for more than 30 years & brought up two children here there is currently a lack of Community accessible space within the village. I previously helped run Stanley Tennis Club which is now sadly derelict. It would be wonderful for a sports court to be available again in the village & the hub will allow various sporting & community groups to be formed again which is badly needed in the village. The abandoned tennis courts are sadly now an eyesore & it can only be a good thing for the village for this project to go ahead, especially with all the new houses being built. Stanley very much needs this & it has been promised for many years now.
Page 47
No embedded text on this page.
Page 48
No embedded text on this page.
Page 49
No embedded text on this page.
Page 50
No embedded text on this page.
Page 51
No embedded text on this page.
Page 52
No embedded text on this page.
Page 53
No embedded text on this page.
Page 54
Comments to the Development Quality Manager on a Planning Application Planning Application ref. 22/01959/FLL Comments provided by Joanna Dick Tree and Biodiversity Offficer Service/Section Strategy and Policy Contact Details Email biodiversity@pkc.gov.uk Description of Proposal Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities Address of site Land 30m west of St Columba’s Episcopal Church 19 Perth Road Stanley Comments on the proposal Policy 40: Forestry, Woodland and Trees The Council will apply the principles of the Scottish Government Policy on Control of Woodland Removal and there will be a presumption in favour of protecting woodland resources. Where the loss of woodland is unavoidable, mitigation measures in the form of compensatory planting will be required. The tree survey and tree survey schedule are in accordance with best practice. However, the site was surveyed in January 2021. Reports must be less than 24 months and an updated tree survey report is required. The author of the report also states that his findings are only valid for 12 months. The report doesn’t appear to show a map of the arboricultural impact and tree protection plans though it does have a table with the RPA and CEZ distances in it. The proposed site plan indicates that the RPAs of several trees overlap with the development footprint and that impermeable surfaces have been proposed in part of some of the RPAs. Where trees to be retained are close to the development footprint more detail on how the root protection areas of these trees will be protected during construction taking into consideration the positioning of infrastructure in line with British Standard BS:5837 2012. Where trees are proposed to be felled compensatory tree planting is required on a ratio of 1:3 for every tree lost as outlined in the PKC Planning for Nature Supplementary Guidance Planning Guidance - Planning & Biodiversity - Perth & Kinross Council (pkc.gov.uk) A detailed landscaping plan and planting schedule is required indicating species, location, tree stock size, type, planting spec, maintenance, vermin and weed control. Species should be native to Scotland and include fruit-bearing trees to maximise biodiversity value. See the preferred species list in Open Space Guidance. Local Development Plan - Supplementary Guidance - Perth & Kinross Council (pkc.gov.uk) Policy 41: Biodiversity The Council will seek to protect and enhance all wildlife and habitats, whether formally designated or not, considering natural processes in the area. Planning permission will not be granted for development likely to have
Page 55
an adverse effect on protected species unless clear evidence can be provided that the ecological impacts can be satisfactorily mitigated. European Protected Species Planning permission will not be granted for development that would be likely to have an adverse effect upon European protected species (listed in Annex IV of the Habitats Directive (Directive 92/43/EEC)). All bat species found in Scotland are classed as European protected species. They receive full protection under the Conservation (Natural Habitats, &c.) Regulations 1994 (as amended) making it an offence to disturb a bat in a roost, obstruct access to a roost and damage or destroy a breeding or resting place of such an animal. Development involves demolition of the church hall and felling of some trees. There are bat records within 1km of the property, as per NBN Atlas. There is favourable habitat including trees and grassland within proximity to the site. The church hall appears to have a traditional slate roof and there is a potential for bat roost potential and a bat survey is required. This is as per our PKC Bat Survey Guidance. A bat survey should be undertaken by a suitably experienced and qualified ecologist to determine the actual or potential presence of bats for the building and trees. During the winter months a preliminary bat roost and hibernation assessment can be undertaken. If a winter survey finds the potential for bats to be present, activity surveys must be carried out before the application can be validated. Winter surveys alone will only be acceptable if they find negligible potential for bats to be present. An Ecological Impact Assessment (EcIA) undertaken in accordance with CIEEM guidance is required as part of a further planning application. Survey needs to be undertaken by suitably qualified and experienced persons using recognised methods in accordance with published best practice. More details are available in the Planning for Nature Supplementary Guidance - Planning Guidance - Planning & Biodiversity - Perth & Kinross Council (pkc.gov.uk) A checklist of information required to inform a planning application regarding biodiversity is provided in Annex 4 of the PKC Planning for Nature Supplementary Guidance.Applicants are encouraged to ensure information is submitted in accordance with the checklist to reduce future information requests and delays Planning Guidance - Planning & Biodiversity - Perth & Kinross Council (pkc.gov.uk) Biodiversity Enhancement Enhancement of biodiversity should be demonstrated in all projects and needs to be site specific based on surveys, location, development size, surrounding habitats and landscape character, and follow ecologist recommendations.
Page 56
An ecologist will advise on this and measures may include: Planting native trees, orchards, hedgerows and wildflowers. Providing nesting boxes, bricks or tubes for swallow, house martin and sparrows. Providing nesting boxes for kestrel and owls in woodland. Creating wildlife corridors for hedgehogs, frogs and newts. Creating ponds, swales or rainwater gardens. Installing a green living roof. Enhancing connectivity between existing habitats Guidance is available in the PKC Planning for Nature Guidance Planning Guidance - Planning & Biodiversity - Perth & Kinross Council (pkc.gov.uk) I object due to a lack of information on the trees, bats, ecology and biodiversity enhancement. Recommended planning condition(s) The application cannot be assessed until more information on trees, bats, ecology and biodiversity enhancement is provided. Recommended informative(s) for applicant Date comments returned 9 March 2023
Page 57
No embedded text on this page.
Page 58
No embedded text on this page.
Page 59
No embedded text on this page.
Page 60
No embedded text on this page.
Page 61
No embedded text on this page.
Page 62
No embedded text on this page.
Page 63
M e m o r To Development Management & Building Standards Service Manager Your ref 22/01959/FLL Date 10 March 2023 Communities a n d u m From Regulatory Services Manager Our ref DAT Tel No Pullar House, 35 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Consultation on an Application for Planning Permission 22/01959/FLL RE: Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works Land 30 Metres West Of St Columba's Episcopal Church 19 Perth Road Stanley I refer to your letter dated 17 February 2023 in connection with the above application and have the following comments to make. Environmental Health Recommendation I have no objection in principle to the application but recommend the under noted conditions be included on any given consent. Comments The applicant is proposing the erection of a community centre with sports/education facilities, community café, offices and the formation of a replacement external all-weather sports pitch (MUGA). The community centre building will be located behind the church on land where the derelict tennis courts were positioned. The replacement MUGA is adjacent and lies to the South of the existing play park, West of the existing bowling club and East of the school playing field. The MUGA will be utilised by the community and Stanley primary school. Odour As the proposed community centre will include café faciliities, it will be necessary to install and maintain an effective ventilation system commensurate with the type of cooking to be undertaken to ensure odours do not adversely affect neighbouring residential properties. Plant Equipment Supporting information refers to the installation of an Air Source Heat Pump (ASHP) system although the exact details and make and models are not known at this time. There will also be the requirement for air conditioning and extract systems and as such there is the potential for noise from plant equipment to impact on residential amenity of neighbouring properties. I note that Section 2.1 of Appendix D10 of the Design Statement, states that a noise impact
Page 64
assessment will be carried out when the full design is known and prior to installation and as such I would recommend the standard plant noise condition being applied to any given consent to ensure noise from plant equipment does not impact on neighbouring residential properties. Whilst Appendix D10 shows calculations for breakout noise from the internal plant room, this only notes dB levels and not the relative noise level at octave frequency bands. Fixed plant of this type can create noise which has characteristics that are not adequately quantified by means of a Leq limit and therefore Noise Rating Curves should be applied. Opening Times At this stage the applicant is unsure as to what the exact operational hours will be, as this will be based on customer demand but does acknowledge that operational hours of the MUGA will be shorter than internal sports facilities, so as to avoid potential noise nuisance to neighbouring properties. Deliveries Section C4 of the Design Statement makes reference to deliveries taking place out with opening hours so that car parking spaces are not impacted, however it should be noted that the standard delivery hours condition is recommended for this development to protect residential amenity of neighbouring properties. Light Appendix D10 includes information on the lighting design and layout, including floodlighting of the MUGA. Appendix B of D10 includes a lighting contour map showing 1, 2 and 5 lux contours. The maps show no residential properties within the 1 lux contour and as such would meet the guidance values for light intrusion for all environmental zones both pre and post curfew. It is also assumed that no light fixtures will be on post curfew hours (2300). It is therefore unlikely that lighting will affect residential amenity of neighbouring properties, however the applicant should ensure that fittings are correctly positioned and directed and as such, I would recommend the standard lighting condition be applied to any given consent. MUGA The application includes the provision of an all-weather sports pitch (MUGA) and given the proximity to residential properties there is the potential of this development to impact on residential amenity. Whilst it is acknowledged that the area has previously been used as a sport ground (tennis club) and the uses of adjacent land, the introduction of an all-weather sports pitch with floodlighting may intensify the use of the area. There is no information on times of operation so I am assuming that the pitch will be available for community use throughout the year, at weekends and into the evening period like other developments of this nature. This Service has dealt with a number of noise complaints from the use of similar all-weather pitches throughout the Perth & Kinross area and as such it will be necessary for the applicant to ensure that noise is adequately controlled.
Page 65
Noise can arise from users of the area as well as impact noise from balls against fencing/kickboards etc. The World Health Organisation (WHO) guidance for community noise recommends that the following sound levels should be maintained: Leq50-55dB(A) in outdoor living areas, Leq35dB(A) in internal living areas and Leq30dB(A) in bedrooms. This guidance is consistent with BS8233:2014 which recommends the following sound level ranges: Leq30- 40dB(A) in living areas and Leq30-35dB(A) in bedrooms. In addition, an increase in ambient noise levels of 5-10 dB would constitute a substantial adverse impact, increases in noise levels by 3-5 dB would constitute a moderate adverse impact, and increases in noise level of less than 3 dB would be unlikely to be perceptible. It may therefore ne necessary for the applicant to include mitigation measures such as lining of goal boxes, noise barriers etc and noise reduction measures such as the installation of rubber inserts, rubber/turf applied to kickboards, noise reduction plastic clips etc on any proposed fencing, as well as good management of the site. Therefore, whilst I have no objections to the application, I would recommend the following conditions be attached to any given consent. Conditions 1. EH01 The hours of operation of the all-weather pitch (MUGA) shall be restricted to 0800 hours to 2200 hours daily. 2. EH02 Servicing of and deliveries to the premises shall be carried out between 0700 and 1900 Monday to Saturday only, with no servicing or deliveries permitted on Sundays. 3. EH10 All plant or equipment shall be so enclosed, attenuated and/or maintained such that any noise therefrom shall not exceed Noise Rating 35 between 0700 and 2300 hours daily, or Noise Rating 25 between 2300 and 0700 hours daily, within any neighbouring residential property, with all windows slightly open, when measured and/ or calculated and plotted on a rating curve chart. 4. EH12 The sound insulation and sound transmission properties of the structure and finishes shall be such that any airborne noise from the operations within the premises does not constitute a statutory noise nuisance as determined by the Local Planning Authority. 5. EH13 No music amplified or otherwise shall be permitted outside the premises and efforts must be made to minimise the impact of noise from inside the premises so no sound is audible in any nearby residential property. 6. EH20 Prior to the development hereby approved being completed or brought into use, an effective ventilation system commensurate with the nature and scale of cooking to be undertaken shall be installed and operated such that cooking odours are not exhausted into or escape into any neighbouring buildings. Thereafter the system shall be maintained.
Page 66
7. EH31 All external lighting shall be sufficiently screened and aligned so as to ensure that there is no direct illumination of neighbouring land and that light spillage beyond the boundaries of the site is minimised to a degree that it does not adversely affect the amenity of the neighbouring land. 8. EH32 The hours of operation of any external floodlighting shall be restricted to between 0800 and 2200 hours. 9. Noise from the site shall not exceed 50dB(A) Leq,15 min, including any relevant penalties for tonality, impulsivity, intermittency or other sound characteristics, or L A90,15 min background noise level plus 5dB (A), whichever is greater when measured within external amenity areas at any residential property in accordance with BS4142:2014. 10. Prior to the commencement of the development a Noise Management Plan shall be submitted for the written approval of the planning authority. The plan shall include all sources of noise associated with the use of the all-weather pitch and community centre, including user noise, activity noise and plant equipment and the measures that will be put in place to minimise and/or control noise. The plan shall be reviewed on a regular basis or, following receipt of a justified complaint or at the request of the planning authority. Once the Noise Management Plan has been approved, it shall be fully implemented for the lifetime of the development. 11. In the event of a justified noise complaint being received by the Council the operator shall, at its own expense, employ a consultant approved by the Planning Authority to carry out a noise assessment to verify compliance with conditions 3, 4, 5 and 9 above. The assessment will be carried out to an appropriate methodology agreed in writing with the Planning Authority. If the noise assessment shows that the noise levels do not comply with conditions 3, 4, 5 and 9 a scheme of noise mitigation shall be included with the noise assessment, specifying timescales for the implementation of the scheme and shall be submitted to the Planning Authority with 28 days of the assessment. The mitigation scheme shall thereafter be implemented in accordance with the approved scheme and timescales.
Page 67
No embedded text on this page.
Page 68
Mrs Joanne Hardy (Supports) Comment submitted date: Fri 10 Mar 2023 The village is in much need of a new modern facilty especially now due to the number of houses that are being built here. The new facilty would allow a number of new groups to be established including youth clubs, breakfast and holiday clubs to name a few.
Page 69
Mr David Trevallion (Supports) Comment submitted date: Sat 11 Mar 2023 I would like to register my support for the creation of a community hub within Stanley. As a former director of the Stanley Development Trust, the hub project was a primary focus and had a significant amount of community support. To be able to submit plans for the community hub is a significant step towards providing a modern, considered facility for a now expanding village. The hub will give a focal point for community activities and provide opportunities for employment and hopefully inspire others to make use for the facilities the hub will provide. I hope the council sees fit to give the go ahead for the community hub and give the chance for the community of Stanley to have a facility to enjoy, make use of and be proud of.
Page 70
No embedded text on this page.
Page 71
A Baker
Page 72
Mr Bruce Meikle (Supports) Comment submitted date: Mon 13 Mar 2023 I support this application as this would be a much needed addition to the facilities in the village especially considering the ongoing expansion of housing in the village.
Page 73
No embedded text on this page.
Page 74
No embedded text on this page.
Page 75
No embedded text on this page.
Page 76
Mr Neil Hardy (Supports) Comment submitted date: Tue 14 Mar 2023 I fully support the proposal to build this facility in Stanley. Currently the village has very few facilities and clubs operating within it for the Community. What facilities do exist are inflexible or beyond use or have already closed altogether. A facility such as the proposed Hub would provide the village with the opportunity to form clubs and groups for the whole Community of every age and ability. There is regularly discussion on social media about the lack of provision for young people, for the older generation and for sports clubs and interest groups. A flexible, modern facility would be able to fill this gap in provision. Health and wellbeing should be in everyone's thoughts - being able to come together when using a facility such as this would enhance the feeling of Community within the village dramatically. We are very lucky that Stanley still retains this sense of Community as a village - I can only see this being enhanced (despite the massive expansion taking place) by everyone having access to the Hub. There will always be objectors however pretty much everything can be overcome through sensible adult negotiation. I would rather the War Memorial not have to be relocated however I am more interested in it's preservation in memory of those that fought. If moving it means it gets preserved and kept within the centre of the village while at the same time allowing the provision of such a facility then surely this is a good thing. Having the ability to better ourselves and come together as a Community is exactly the sort of freedoms it is there to commemorate being fought for. Where it is is not important - the fact 'it is there' is. I fully support this project and cannot wait to see its completion.
Page 77
2?» m 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 3 . 3 Planning and Development, 0 LO % Pullar House, g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD , Elizabeth Mackintosh 3/5/2023 8:09:14 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22101959/FLL. Stanley is continuing grow year on year and would benefit hugely from having these facilities on the doorstep Kind regards, Elizabeth Mackintosh Digitally signed , 3/5/2023 8:16:40 PM com
Page 78
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House. E? g Kinnoull Street. Penh PH1 SGD Elizabeth Scott 3/5/2023 7:34:23 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Would be good to have a focal point for the community - meeting space, contact, info sharing and events Kind regards, Elizabeth Scott Digitally signed 3/5/2023 7:37:52 PM
Page 79
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, E? 5 KInnoull Street. Penh PH1 56D Emma Cameron 3/5/2023 6:05:19 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full suppo}402for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Would be great for the village Kind regards, Emma Cameron Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:06:24 PM
Page 80
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n HU , 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development. L0 ;_'. Pullar House, E? 5 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GB ' Emma Mitchell 3/5/2023 4:54:05 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. Having two young children in the village would be amazing to have space forthem . to enjoy! Kind regards, Emma Mitchell Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:55:35 PM
Page 81
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § § Plannmg and Development, L'- Pullar House, E? E Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD 030 Eric Jamieson 3/8/2023 6:28:30 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, 030 planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Eric Jamieson Digitally signed 3/8/2023 6:30:13 PM
Page 82
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 1x; . H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 5031 Pullar House, S L] Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD 030 Fiona Hepburn 3/5/2023 4:19:18 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. I believe that after 2 years of Covid a hub / cafe is excellent for bringing our cOmmunity together.The hub will be good for all ages with the opportunity for outdoor activities and interests to be passed on from the older generation to the younger. Kind regards, Fiona Hepburn Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:27:08 PM ;
Page 83
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ g 030 E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, L0 E Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Fiona Patton 3/5/2023 6:04:27 PM RE 024Planning Application 22IO1959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22(01959/FLL. The community really needs something to bring everyone together and have pride in their community: Kind regards, Fiona Patton Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:06:27 PM s
Page 84
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development. 0 S Pullar House, L0 3024"- Kinnoull Street,A Perth PH1 5GD Fiona Reec ' . 3/5/2023 5:55:27 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. The hub will be of huge benefit to our village. Somewhere for community groups to meet and our children to gather and play sports. Kind regards, Fiona Reec Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:58:29 PM
Page 85
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 030 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 5031 Pullar House, S ;_'. Kinnoull Street, Perth 031 PH1 SGD GaiIRorie 3/5/2023 3:55:47 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l019591FLL, I Kind regards, Gail Rorie Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:02:06 PM
Page 86
'0 2° 9031 . 3 'U . .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 5031 Pullar House, S L'- Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Gareth Ruddock 3/5/2023 3:26:38 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Kind regards, Gareth Ruddock Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:27:17 PM
Page 87
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 3 Planning and Development, . O S Pullar House, L0 35-; Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD 030 Gavin Ritchie 3/5/2023 4:20:28 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, lwlsh to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. We are a young family and this would be a great facility for the village. I also would be keen to use the space to work remotely occasionally Kind regards, Gavin Ritchie Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:25:21 PM
Page 88
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, E? a Kinnoull Street, 030 Perth PH1 5GD Gemma Stewart 3/7/2023 4:52:30 PM RE 024-Planning Application 22l01959lFLL 030 Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. Kind regards, ' Gemma Stewart Digitally signed 3/7/2023 4:53:20 PM
Page 89
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development. S Pullar House, E? a Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Geoff williamson 3/5/2023 4:20:24 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. A great addition to the village Kind regards, Geoff Williamson Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:23:41 PM
Page 90
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 . 030 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, E? ; Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD George Robertson ' ' 3/6/2023 8:04:48 AM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, . | wish to express my full suppon for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22(01959/FLL. . Essential, and long overdue Kind regards, _ George Robertson Digitallysigned 3/6/2023 8:07:54 AM
Page 91
'0 2° 9: . 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 LO % Pullar House, E Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Geraldine Hardy 3/6/2023 9:59:23 AM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam. 030|wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22101959IFLL. Kind regards, Geraldine Hardy Digitally signed 3/6/2023 10:19:36 AM
Page 92
'0 2° 9: l 3 'U .5; H 031 030 2,_.A \ }402 § § Planning and Development, % Pullar House, S Kinnoull Street, Perth . PH1 56D Gerry Burke 030 3/5/2023 4:11:29 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, ' |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, I planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. With new housing development already approved, the village is expanding and is set to expand dramatically overthe next few years. The Hub will be an excellent focal point for the community and will be warmly welcomed by alle which t Kind regards, Gerry Burke Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:16:53 PM
Page 93
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 E? Pullar House, S K, Kinnoull Street, 0 Penh PH1 5GD 030 ' Gillian Davie 3/6/2023 7:15:56AM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Gillian Davie Digitallysigned . 3/6/2023 7:17:22 AM 1
Page 94
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 V ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, E? :3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Gillian Mairi Whiteford 3/6/2023 7:56:55 AM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Gillian Mairi Whiteford Digitally signed 3/6/2023 7:57:46AM
Page 95
'0 2° m , 3 'U .x. n 3 Planning and Development, 3 K Pullar House, E E Kinnoull Street, 8 3 Perth E? g PH1 SGD 3 Gillian Pown'e 3/5/2023 3:36:32 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. Would be a valued/appreciated addition to recreational facilities in our village, improving mental health by offering spaces to congregate and socialise. Places like this could be used to book visiting speakers and host clubs. Kind regards, Gillian Powrie - Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:43:29 PM
Page 96
23 m 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }401 3 . 3 Planning and Development, , 0 LO % Pullar House, E Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Greg Morgan 3/5/2023 7:31:57 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l019591FLL. Kind regards, Greg Morgan Digitally signed 3/5/2023 7:32:50 PM
Page 97
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 5031 Pullar House, S K, Kinnoull Street.A Perth PH1 SGD Gregor Nimmo 3/5/2023 5:08:42 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Gregor Nimmo Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:11:20 PM
Page 98
'0 2° m 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 5) Pullar House, S a Kinnoull Street, 'Perth PH1 5GD Hannah Sissons 3/5/2023 8:18:57 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Hannah Sissons Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:19:51 PM
Page 99
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._. 'h \ }401 E Planning and Development. 0 S Pullar House, L0 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD HarveyAlexander 3/5/2023 3:36:01 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. Kind regards, Harvey Alexander Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:37:07 PM
Page 100
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, L0 5 Kinnoull Street, 03 Penh PH1 SGD HayleyAiken . 3/11/2023 9:38:45 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Hayley Aiken Digitally signed 3/11/2023 9:39:34 PM com
Page 101
2?» m 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, 9 030 g Kmnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Hazel Ieng 3/5/2023 9:16:44 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. , Kind regards, ' Hazel leng Digitally signed I 3/5/2023 9:17:35 PM
Page 102
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 . 3 Planning and Development, 0 LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Heather Cunningham 3/6/2023 3:09:36 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Need more to keep the community thriving, especially for young people or those of working age. Kind regards, , Heather Cunningham Digitallysigned 3/6/2023 3:12:20 PM
Page 103
2030: m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, E? ; Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Heather Dodds 3/5/2023 4:21:21 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. Kind regards, Heather Dodds Digitallysigned 3/5/2023 4:22:07 PM
Page 104
0302030;. 030m . 0303 l 035.3 H U 3H. A \ }401 3 _ 0313 Planning and Development, O LO % Pullar House, g Kinnoull Street, . Perth -030.' PH1 5GD Heather Smith 3/5/2023 3:52:56 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL ' Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. ' Village needs this Kind regards. Heather Smith Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:54:25 PM
Page 105
. 1 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 LO % Pullar House, % Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Helen Brown 3/5/2023 6:50:39 PM , RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. Stanley is desperately needing this type of facility. Something from the young through to the more mature residents It looks great and situated perfectly in the middle of the village. _ Kind regards, Helen Brown Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:54:29 PM
Page 106
23 n) 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, E? g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD HollyDowns 3/6/2023 8:35:54 AM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub. planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Holly Downs Digitally signed 3/6/2023 8:36:29 AM
Page 107
23 n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }4023 . Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, E? g Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Holly Manin Bated 3/6/2023 12:11:19 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I019591FLL. Kind regards, Holly Martin Bated Digitally signed 3/6/2023 12:11:56 PM
Page 108
2?» m 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, 5031 .:3; KInnoulI Street, Penh PH1 5GD Hugh maclean 3/8/2023 7:39:12 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Hugh maclean Digitally signed 3/8/2023 7:40:21 PM
Page 109
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, E? g Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 sen ' Iain Hare 3/5/2023 7:01:51 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. This will benefit the local community and others for years to come. Kind regards, Iain Hare Digitally signed - 3/5/2023 7:05:25 PM
Page 110
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, L0 ;_'. Pullar House, E? g Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Isla sutherland 3/5/2023 5:36:27 PM RE - Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Isla sutherland Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:37:05 PM
Page 111
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 3 Planning and Development. L0 L'- Pullar House, E? 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Isobel Mowat ' 3/7/2023 7:23:45 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. This is very important to the development of communities. Kind regards, Isobel Mowat Digitally signed 3/7/2023 7:27:48 PM
Page 112
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 030,_.A \ }402 § § Planning and Development, L'- Pullar House, E? 030 K i Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Jackie Mcleod 030 030 3/5/2023 8:58:21 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full suppo}402for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Stanley really needs facilities like this and would be a great assett to the community. Kind regards, 030 Jackie Mcleod 031 Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:59:43 PM 03
Page 113
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, L0 L'- Pullar House, E? : Kinnoull Street, ' Perth PH1 5GD Jacqueline Forbes 3/5/2023 4:22:54 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Think it would be great for the kids in the community Kind regards, Jacqueline Forbes Digitallysigned 3/5/2023 4:24:46 PM
Page 114
'0 2° 9) 3 'U n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § § Planning and Development, L'- Pullar House, E? 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Jacquie peebles 030 3/5/2023 6:33:49 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. ' Kind regards, Jacquie peebles Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:35:12 PM 0uk
Page 115
23 m 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 L'- Pullar House, E? 3 030 Kinnoull Street, Perth 030 PH1 5GD Jade law : ; 3/6/2023 7:23:02 AM 030 RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Jade law Digitally signed 3/6/2023 7:24:03 AM
Page 116
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H 030 U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 L'- Pullar House, E? 3 Kinnoult Street, Pe}401h PH1 5GD Jaime Rodger 3/6/2023 4:08:41 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. This to me is a fantastic development for the village. With the village gaining more housing within the next few years, these facility would give the community a place to come together, have a place to hold sporting events, open more opportunities to get Kind regards, Jaime Rodger . Digitally signed 3/6/2023 4:12:34 PM
Page 117
'0 2° 9031 030 3 'U .x. n H , U , Z ._. A r\ . }402 § § Plannlng and Development, L'- Pullar House, E? 5 3 : Kinnoull Street, : Perth - PH1 56D James Christie 1 : 3/5/2023 5:14:35 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL 030Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, James Christie Digitallysigned 3/5/2023 5:16:35 PM
Page 118
2030: n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development. LO % Pullar House, & Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 56D james }402annigan 3/9/2023 2:38:31 PM 031 RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Kind regards, james }402annigan Digitally signed 3/9/2023 2:40:19 PM
Page 119
23 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 3 . Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, & Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Jamie brown 3/5/2023 9:31:34 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Kind regards, 030 Jamie brown . Digitally signed 3/5/2023 9:34:19 PM
Page 120
20301 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, $ Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Jan Jamieson 3/5/2023 11:50:22 PM . RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, . planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Kind regards, Jan Jamieson 031Digitally signed 3/5/2023 11:52:08 PM
Page 121
E 3 'U .x. n 030 H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 030 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, $ Kinnoull Street, Penh 030 PH1 SGD Janet McBrearty 3/5/2023 5:02:32 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full suppor031tfor the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Janet McBrearty Digitally signed 030 3/5/2023 5:04:50 PM 0uk
Page 122
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development. LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD , Janice Cargill 3/5/2023 6:14:18 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Jahice Cargill Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:15:32 PM
Page 123
u 030
2° 030
m 4
3 030
'U 1
n 1
H
U
3
,_.A
\
g {
§ 1
8 Planning and Development,
LO
Q 030 Pullar House,
3 Kinnoull Street,
Penh
3 PH1 5GB
1 Jason Stewart
030
3/12/2023 3:53:19 PM
030 RE 024Planning Application 22I01959lFLL
Dear sir or madam,
030 |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub,
: planning application reference 22l01959IFLL.
Kind regards,
030 Jason Stewart
Digitally signed
0303/12/2023 3:55:56 PMPage 124
23 : g 5 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, .5 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Jean Mcdougall 3/5/2023 3:52:15 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam. | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Jean Mcdougall Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:53:08 PM
Page 125
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U . Z ,_.A \ }402 § § Planning and Development, . % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Jean McIntyre 3/5/2023 3:39:44 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. The village has a great community spirit with lots of volunteers providing different activities, opportunities and services. They deserve a meeting place to develop and expand this, Kind regards. Jean McIntyre Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:42:40 PM 030com
Page 126
2030; 030 m 3 'U .x. n H . U 3 ,_.A \ }402 g 030 3 030Planningand Development, LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth 'PH1 5GD Jen Penhale 3/5/2023 4:09:42 PM 030 RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL 030Dearsir or madam, 030Iwishto express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, 030Jen Penhale Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:11:07 PM com
Page 127
1: 2° 9: 3 '0 .x. n HU . Z 030 030 ._.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, LO % \Putlar House, 3 \Kinnoull Street. Perth \PH1 5GD Jim Valentine 3/7/2023 12:44:03 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. The community desperately needs this, both for existing residents, and those who will be welcomed in the future. Kind regards, Jim Valentine Digitally signed 3/7/2023 12:46:28 PM
Page 128
1: 2° 9: 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 030Planningand Development, LO % Pullar House, 3: Kinnoull Street, Perth ;PH1 5GD Jo Wiseman 3/5/2023 3:22:32 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. The village is in desperate need of facilities in order to provide recreational space for both children and adults: We are already shouting out for this kind of thing and will only become even more crucial with all the development plans for new housing. 030Kindregards, Jo Wiseman Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:24:46 PM
Page 129
2?» 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % PuHar House, 3: Kinnoull Street, Pe}401h \PH1 SGD Joanne Smith 3/5/2023 4:26:10 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. There is a huge need for a facility in Stanley, where people of different ages (mother and baby, toddlers, children. teenagers, adults and older generation) can access different activities, clubs, sporting facilities There is very little for families to Kind regards, J oanne Smith Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:36:45 PM 30uk
Page 130
1: 2° 9031 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 g , 8 Planning and Development. LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Pedh PH1 56D Johan MacCaskill 3/5/2023 3:46:36 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. 030 To provide leisure activities and fitness activities for the young people in a safe environment To provide social activities for all ages. To allow people to get together and meet up. a very natural instinct. Kind regards, Johan MacCaskiIl Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:50:34 PM
Page 131
'0 2° 9) 3 , 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD John Gunn 3/6/2023 7:36:08 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. A much needed local facility Kind regards, John Gunn Digitally signed 3/6/2023 7:38:39 PM
Page 132
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .x. n H 2 E \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD John Leggat 3/10/2023 3:50:27 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. A much needed facility which will benefit the community Kind regards, John Leggat Digitally signed 31/10/2023 3:52:18 PM
Page 133
2030; I 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, 5: Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD John Livingstone 3/7/2023 6:25:53 AM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, John Livingstone Digitally signed 3/7/2023 6:27:18 AM
Page 134
1: 2° 90313 t '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, V 10 t % Pullar House, 031 $ Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD John O'Donnell 3/5/2023 4:59:34 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, 030Iwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, 030planningapplication reference 22I01959/FLL. 1| support the building of this as it is a Community Asset that will be available to all generations for years to come .The Local community severely lacks a Space like this and with growing community within Stanley will be used to the full Kind regards, John O'Donnell Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:05:28 PM -
Page 135
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, $ Kinnoull Street. Perth PH1 56D Jonathan Barker 3/5/2023 3:23:26 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959/FLL. The village has been going downhilI with closures and there is a huge shottage of amenities especially with the increase of housing but no increase in shops, roads, or amenities Kind regards, Jonathan Barker Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:25:19 PM
Page 136
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, $ Kinnoull Street, , Penh PH1 5GD Jonathan Sinclair 3/5/2023 3:24:38 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub. planning application reference 22101959IFLL. Kind regards. Jonathan Sinclair Digitallysigned 3/5/2023 3:26:07 PM
Page 137
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Jonny Cross 3/5/2023 6:49:15 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l019591FLL. Kind regards, Jonny Cross Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:50:18 PM
Page 138
23 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Josh Caste] 3/5/2023 4:39:46 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, [wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Kind regards, Josh Castel Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:40:28 PM
Page 139
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street. Penh PH1 5GD Joshua Erlemann 3/8/2023 9:43:35 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Joshua Erlemann Digitally signed 3/8/2023 9:44:22 PM
Page 140
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, S Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Joshua hunter 3/8/202312:45:32 AM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, 030 | wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Kind regards, Joshua hunter Digitally signed 3/8/2023 12:46:27 AM
Page 141
2?» 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, S Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Joyce Jamieson 3/5/2023 4:07:47 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959/FLL. Desperately needed resource within the village, Hopefully it will give a focus to all and help reduce vandalism by youths with no focus. Cafe needed for locals and visitors as no facilities at The Mill. Kind regards, Joyce Jamieson Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:11:38 PM
Page 142
1: 2° 9: 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House. 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Julie Higgins 3/9/2023 2:44:10 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, [wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Julie Higgins Digitally signed 3/9/2023 2:46:19 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 143
1: 2° 9: 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 g . § Planning and Development, % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, » Perth PH1 56D ' Julie Hutton 3/9/2023 8:00:18 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. I know this is a long held want for Stanley because it would increase accessibility for all ages and encourage community spirit/connection. It would also facilitate further sporting opportunities and encourage inter024generationalparticipation in multiple Kind regards, Julie Hutton Digitally signed 3/9/2023 8:04:35 PM
Page 144
1: 2° 9: 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 8 Planning and Development. LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Pe}402h PH1 5GD Julie-Anne Lee 3/5/2023 8:18:49 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Kind regards, Julie-Anne Lee Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:24:03 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 145
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, 030 Penh PH1 SGD June Lyon 3/5/2023 3:55:21 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, June Lyon Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:04:35 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 146
23 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, . LO % Pullar House. 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Kasia Brown 3/5/2023 9:36:03 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. Kind regards, Kasia Brown Digitally signed 3/5/2023 9:37:07 PM
Page 147
23g 030 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO Q Pullar House, g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Kate 3/6/2023 9:22:34 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, [wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Kate Digitally signed 3/6/2023 9:24:01 PM
Page 148
2?» 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, g Kinnoul! Street, Pedh PH1 SGD Kate Wyllie 3/6/2023 10:56:55 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Kate Wyllie Digitally signed 3/6/2023 10:58:45 PM
Page 149
21; . 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO % Pullar House, $ Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GB ' Katherine Rix ~ 3/5/2023 3:47:49 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Kind regards, Katherine Rix Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:49:07 PM
Page 150
23 3 'U .x. n H E,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 8 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 56D Kathleen Aitchison 3/5/2023 8:35:46 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Stanley and surrounding areas need a sports facility and a Community centre. Will be wonderful for mental and physical health for young , old and in between Kind regards, Kathleen Aitchison Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:38:45 PM 030 Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 151
'0 2° 030 m 3 'U .5; H E E \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 8 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Katie Patton 030 3/5/2023 7:29:46 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Katie Patton Digitally signed 3/5/2023 7:30:27 PM om
Page 152
1: 2° 9: 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO Q Pullar House, S Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Katrina Marshall 3/7/2023 7:51:39 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. | support the hub in principle, I would like to see a building that will be made of materials which have low environmental impact, good insulation , solar panels for generating energy, etc. It would be good to have a hub for people to book a place to work Kind regards, Katrina Marshall Digitally signed 3/7/2023 8:01:53 PM
Page 153
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, 8 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 56D Kelly Stewart 3/5/2023 3:29:11 PM RE - Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. A|| communities should grow and be great support networks for their locals. The hub will help with that. Kind regards, Kelly Stewart Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:32:06 PM
Page 154
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H 2 E \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, 8 Kinnoull Street, Pedh PH1 58D Kevin Kelly 3/5/2023 7:25:25 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, i wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub. planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Kevin Kelly Digitally signed 3/5/2023 7:27:51 PM
Page 155
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Kirsteen Tares 3/5/2023 10:48:12 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. A sports & community hub in Stanley should amazing for getting people moving, meeting up & brining a sense of community. Kind regards, Kirsteen Tares Digitally signed 3/5/2023 10:51:03 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 156
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § § Planning and Development, '3 Pullar House. ' 8 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Kirsty Harris 3/7/20231:14:53 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959lFLL Dear sir or madam. I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Kirsty Harris Digitally signed 3/7/2023 1:16:29 PM I
Page 157
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House. 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Laura Connacher 3/5/2023 3:27:19 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my ful! support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Kind regards, Laura Connacher Digitally signed ' - V 3/5/2023 3:28:10 PM
Page 158
23 3 'U .5; H 2._.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Laurajeffery . 3/5/2023 3:31:16 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Much needed resource for the village Kind regards, Laura jeffery Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:32:19 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 159
23 m 3 '0 .5; H U 3 E \ }401 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Laura Ritchie 3/5/2023 4:03:39 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22101959IFLL. It would be a brilliant facility for the town! Kind regards, Laura Ritchie Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:04:30 PM .
Page 160
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 9. Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 56D Lesley Dunbar 3/5/2023 4:07:48 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full suppott for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Lesley Dunbar Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:09:05 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 161
20301 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, 9. Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Lesley Young 3/7/2023 12:32:42 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub. planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Kids in the village DESPERATELY need this Kind regards, Lesley Young Digitally signed 3/7/2023 12:34:31 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 162
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Letitia McKirdy-Deadman 3/10/2023 5:31:07 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Fantastic forthe local community, children and adults to encourage all year round fitness. Kind regards, Letitia McKirdy-Deadman Digitally signed 3/10/2023 5:32:58 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 163
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H E E \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Liam Ure 3/5/2023 8:12:54 PM RE - Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Liam Ure Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:14:01 PM
Page 164
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 8 Kinnoull Street, Pedh PH1 5GD Lindsay Cook 3/11/2023 6:48:19 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Would be a fabulous addition to the village providing much needed facilities, bring folks together Kind regards, Lindsay Cook ' Digitally signed 3/11/2023 6:49:41 PM _ Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 165
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § § Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House. S Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Liz Dundas 3/5/2023 6:08:41 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. ' It would be a great benefit to the wider local community as well as Stanley to have such a facility for sports & meeting up Kind regards, Liz Dundas Digitallysigned 3/5/2023 6:11:15 PM
Page 166
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, S Kinnoull Sheet. Penh PH1 SGD Lois Lelland 3/6/2023 9:36:40 PM RE - Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Lois Lelland Digitally signed 3/6/2023 9:38:38 PM com
Page 167
23 m 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 3 Planning and Development. L0 g Pullar House, S Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Lorraine Flannigan . 3/6/202312:03:02 AM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish m express my fuII support for the creation 0fthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. The village is sadly lacking and way behind in facilities and with population expanding rapidly.034 Kind regards, Lorraine Flannigan Digitally signed 3/6/2023 12:08:01 AM _
Page 168
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .x. n H E E\ , }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 5 030 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Louise Cameron-Elston . 3/5/2023 4:23:53 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. My sons football team would use the facilities a lot & be a great addition to Stanley Kind regards, Louise Cameron-Elston Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:25:04 PM
Page 169
23 9031 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, 5 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Louise Hendry 3/5/2023 4:11:04 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. ' Kind regards, Louise Hendry Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:12:21 PM om
Page 170
23 m 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 PuHar House, 5 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Lynn Haddow 3/5/2023 7:13:00 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. Would give Stanley Community a place to go and things to do for the teens as well as provide a place for families Kind regards, Lynn Haddow Digitally signed ' 3/5/2023 7:15:07 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 171
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, : Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD MacKenzie Murphy 3/5/2023 7:25:12 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, MacKenzie Murphy Digitally signed I 3/5/2023 7:26:19 PM
Page 172
1, . 2° 9: 3 'U .x. n H E E \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, LO Q Pullar House, 5 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 560 Malcolm Devenny 3/5/2023 5:06:08 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Kind regards, Malcolm Devenny Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:07:53 PM
Page 173
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 5 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Mandy Mackay 3/5/2023 3:54:00 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, V | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Kind regards, Mandy Mackay Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:54:45 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 174
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .5; H U 3 E \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, 5 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Margaret Carruthers 3/6/202311:56:49 AM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. This would be a great asset for the village. I personally would appreciate the gym, it would be great to have this on my doorstep rather than driving into Perth. Kind regards. v Margaret Carruthers Digitally signed 3/6/2023 12:04:21 PM ,
Page 175
E 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }401. § § Planning and Development, 8 PuIlar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 56D Margaret fisher 3/5/2023 10:58:25 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. I have 3 children growing up in the village and they would greatly benefit from what the Hub can offer Kind regards, Margaret }401sher Digitally signed 3/5/2023 11:00:11 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 176
23 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § § Planning and Development, 8 Pullar House. :3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Marion Adams 3/5/2023 5:14:13 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. I believe it would bene}401teveryone in the local community030 Kind regards, Marion Adams Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:16:39 PM
Page 177
«a 2° 9: 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § § Planning and Development, Q Pullar House, 1'3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Marion Crawford 3/7/2023 1:11:30 AM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, , ' I wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. The kids and adults desperately need a focus point for the village - especially the kids who are causing problems like vandalism. Having this Hub would help both adults and teenagers: Kind regards, - Marion Crawford Digitally signed 3/7/2023 1:15:09 AM
Page 178
1: 2° 9: 3 '0 .x. n H U3 . ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, » 5 Kinnoull Street, 031 Perth PH1 5GD Mark Fertacz 3/5/2023 5:53:15 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my fuil support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Mark Fertacz Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:54:20 PM
Page 179
23 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Mark MacDonald 3/5/2023 4:36:52 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Kind regards, Mark MacDonald Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:38:41 PM 0uk
Page 180
1: 2° 9: 3 'U H E,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 8 Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Mark Mitchell 3/5/2023 6:07:24 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959/FLL. As my grandchildren live in Stanley I think this would be something good for them and the community. Kind regards, Mark Mitchell Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:09:47 PM
Page 181
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, E Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Marylinton 3/8/2023 7:43:46 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, [wish to express my fuII support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. We need to bring some new support to the village Kind regards, Mary linton Digitally signed 3/8/2023 7:46:09 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 182
23 3 'U .x. n H U 3 E \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, E Kinnoull Street, ' Pe}401h PH1 56D Mathew Rae 3/7/2023 2:27:53 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam. I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Mathew Rae Digitally signed 3/7/2023 2:28:44 PM
Page 183
1: 2° 9: 3 'U .5; H E E \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 g Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Maureen Brown 3/5/2023 5:51:44 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Think we need another something for the growing community with all the new houses Kind regards, Maureen Brown Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:54:43 PM . com
Page 184
1: 2° 9031 3 'U .x. n H E E \ }402 § § Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Maxine Rae 3/7/2023 2:18:35 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Maxine Rae Digitally signed 3/7/2023 2:19:17 PM
Page 185
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, L0 L3 Pullar House, 5? g Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD ' Megan Hempseed 3/5/2023 7:43:43 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Kind regards, Megan Hempseed Digitally signed 3/5/2023 7:44:57 PM o.uk Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 186
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H . U 3 ._.A \ }401 § § Plannxng and Development, K, Pullar House, 5? 3 Kinnoull Street, Pe}402h PH1 5GD Melissa Scott 3/5/2023 4:45:25 PM ' RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. Ithink it will be a brilliant addition to the village, and give all the children much needed things to do here. Kind regards, Melissa Scott Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:46:22 PM
Page 187
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 L3 Pullar House, 5? ; Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Michael George Baillie 3/5/2023 5:54:32 PM RE - Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22101 959IFLL. I believe Stanley has pressing need for such a facility, to enhance non digital 030 communication, sports for youngsters. meeting place for seniors - just a great idea all round Kind regards, Michael George Baillie Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:58:51 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 188
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 5? 030 g Klnnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Michelle Ruddock 3/5/2023 3:24:45 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full suppo}401for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22(01959/FLL. Kind regards, . Michelle Ruddock Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:25:37 PM 0uk
Page 189
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development, L0 L3 Pullar House. 5? g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Miguel De Gouveia 3/5/2023 6:38:26 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Kind regards, Miguel De Gouveia Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:39:28 PM
Page 190
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 PuHar House, 5? g Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 560 Mike hendry 3/5/2023 5:01:03 PM RE 024Plahning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, iwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. ' Kind regards, Mike hendry Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:02:37 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 191
23 n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 5? :2: Klnnoull Street, Pedh PH1 5GD Mike Massie 3/7/2023 6:18:20 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Stanley needs a community facility for all ages to utilise Kind regards, Mike Massie Digitally signed 3/7/2023 6:19:35 PM
Page 192
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, L0 L3 PuHar House, S? :2: Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Moira Henderson 3/8/2023 9:44:29 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL 7 Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Kind regards, Moira Henderson Digitally signed 3/8/2023 9:45:20 PM 030 Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 193
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, 0 g Kinnoull Street, Perth F031H15GB Moira Macdonald 3/6/2023 9:54:01 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Would be a great asset to the local area Kind regards, Moira Macdonald Digitally signed 3/6/2023 9:56:44 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 194
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § _ § Planning and Development, K, Pullar House, 5? 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Morag ness 3/5/2023 3:29:44 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub. planning application reference 221019591FLL. Kind regards, Morag ness Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:30:42 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 195
g 2 n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_. A 030 \ }402 § § Plannlng and Development, K, Pullar House, S? K Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 56D Morag Roberts 3/10/2023 6:12:37 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam. lwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Morag Roberts Digitallysigned 030 3/10/2023 6:15:12 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 196
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § § Planning and Development, g Pullar House, K Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Mrs Leanne Sinclair ' 3/5/2023 5:03:08 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Ifeel the village needs the hub it will bring a lot to the village and community supponing everyone of all ages Kind regards, Mrs Leanne Sinclair Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:05:49 PM
Page 197
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3,_. 4 A \ }401 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 L3 Pullar House, 5? 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Murray Gauld 3/5/2023 9:21:15 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Murray Gauld Digitally signed 3/5/2023 9:28:28 PM
Page 198
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, 5? g Klnnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Neil McKirdy-Deadman 3/10/2023 5:33:03 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam. I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. , Fantastic for local community Kind regards, Neil McKirdy-Deadman Digitally signed 3/10/2023 5:33:58 PM _ Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 199
2030;. m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 5? g Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 SGD Nick Summersgill 3/11/2023 7:29:00 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Kind regards, Nick Summersgill Digitally signed 3/11/2023 7:30:53 PM
Page 200
23 n) 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 5? g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Nicki Moncur ' 3/5/2023 4:29:24 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub. planning application reference 22101959lFLL. 030 Kind regards, Nicki Moncur Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:30:31 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 201
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 . Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 5? % Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Nicola Carrie 3/5/2023 6:08:41 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22lo1959/FLL. lthink this should be built as it is a place that everyone in Stanley can use, The land it will be built on is empty at the moment so it will make the village look better as well as being a good resource for the people in the village. Kind regards. Nicola Carrie Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:12:50 PM Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 202
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 5? g Klnnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Nicola holmes 3/5/2023 5:55:52 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, Iwish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. My daughter Son in law and grandaughters live in stanley, Would be a fantastic resource for them and visitors Kind regards. Nicola holmes Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:58:21 PM
Page 203
2030: n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, S? g Klnnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Nicole Gallagher 3/5/2023 7:09:32 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Nicole Gallagher Digitally signed 3/5/2023 7:10:12 PM com Invalid Comment - Incomplete Address
Page 204
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development. . L0 K, Pullar House, S? : $ Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 56D Norma Bryce 3/5/2023 4:03:44 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Community needs a focal point for all local organisations Kind regards, Norma Bryce Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:05:29 PM
Page 205
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, L0 L3 Pullar House, 5? 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Patricia Mann . 3/5/2023 3:53:13 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959/FLL. Kind regards, Patricia Mann Digitallysigned 3/5/2023 3:54:26 PM
Page 206
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, 5? .43 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Paul 3/7/2023 6:19:50 AM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, 030 | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub. planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Stanley needs something like this! Kind regards, Paul Digitally signed 3/7/2023 6:20:46 AM
Page 207
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 . Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House. S? 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Paula Cunningham 3/5/2023 3:52:10 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959/FLL. Hopefully the teenagers in the village will have the opportunity to use this space as ~ there is not really anywhere for them to go/anything for them to do. Kind regards, Paula Cunningham Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:56:51 PM
Page 208
23 m 3 '0 .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House. v f? 3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Phillip Clark 3/6/2023 3:42:20 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22lO1959IFLL. As a past director of SDT, I was involved in the evolving ofthe plans for the hub in the village and fully suppon it's creation, Kind regards, Phillip Clark Digitally signed 3/6/2023 3:45:56 PM
Page 209
23 n) 3 , 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, . f? 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Rachel Calam 3/5/2023 6:13:43 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam. V I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Rachel Calam Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:14:46 PM
Page 210
23 n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, 030? '3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Rachel Shilliday 3/5/2023 8:00:57 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Rachel Shilliday Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:07:36 PM '
Page 211
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, Lo 030 K, Pullar House, S? 4:. Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Rebecca Anderson 3/5/2023 4:19:54 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959/FLL. Kind regards, Rebecca Anderson Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:21:16 PM
Page 212
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 2 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, 0 % Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD ' Richard Cross 3/7/2023 7:05:25 AM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full suppon for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Stanley desperately needs a hub to help to draw togetherthe different strands ofthe community. Without one it will be a fractured commuter town with no heart. Kind regards, Richard Cross Digitally signed 3/7/2023 7:08:00 AM 030 '
Page 213
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 3 . 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, 030? Lo" Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Richard Plasting 3/5/2023 4:36:41 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Would be a well needed addition to the village Kind regards, Richard Plasting Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:39:42 PM
Page 214
23n, , 3 'U .5; H U 3 ,_.A \ }401 E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, a Kinnoull Street, 0 Perth PH1 5GD Robert Edgar 3/6/2023 12:51:50 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Robert Edgar Digitallysigned 3/6/2023 12:53:44 PM com
Page 215
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development_, 3 Pullar House, 5? }402 Kinnoull Street. Perth PH1 5GD _ Robert Findlay 3/5/2023 8:02:04 PM RE 024-Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. No Kind regards, ' Robert F indlay Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:02:45 PM
Page 216
2?» m 3 '0 .x. n H . U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development, S Pullar House, 5? g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Ros McCuIIagh 3/5/2023 8:38:52 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Kind regards, Ros McCullagh Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:40:14 PM INVALID COMMENT - INCOMPLETE ADDRESS
Page 217
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 L3 Pullar House, S? 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Ross Mitchell 3/5/2023 8:11:19 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam. |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, . planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Fantastic for the villagers Kind regards, Ross Mitchell Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:12:19 PM
Page 218
2?» m 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, 0 L}. Kinnoull Street,A Penh PH1 5GD Sandra Bendall 3/5/2023 4:10:10 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Sandra Bendall Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:11:44 PM
Page 219
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House. 0 L}. Kinnoull Street.A Penh PH1 SGD Sandra robenson 3/7/2023 9:30:37 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam. I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. It would be amazing forthe local community Kind regards, Sandra robertson Digitallysigned 3/7/2023 9:32:10 PM
Page 220
23 m 3 'U .x. n . H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 3 030 3 Plannlng and Development, 0 S Pullar House, S? : Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Sandy Mclead 3/5/2023 8:36:14 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub. planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Kind regards, I Sandy Mcleod Digitally signed 3/5/2023 8:37:45 PM
Page 221
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, 0 L}. Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Sarah Laing 3/8/202310:11:06AM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Kind regards, Sarah Laing Digitally signed 3/8/2023 10:11:43 AM
Page 222
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development. 3 Pullar House, 5? g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Sarah Mitchell 3/5/2023 6:03:33 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam. | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. My grandchildren live in Stanley and this would be a brilliant resource for them and the community Kind regards, ' Sarah Mitchell Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:06:04 PM
Page 223
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 E? Pullar House, 3 Kinnoull Street, 00 Penh PH1 5GD Sarah Pettigrew 3/7/2023 8:49:38 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL , Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full suppon for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Kind regards. Sarah Pettigrew Digitally signed 3/7/2023 8:51:09 PM
Page 224
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, E030.030 g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Sarah Smith 3/5/2023 5:29:35 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam. | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Very much needed In Stanley Kind regards, Sarah Smith Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:31:11 PM
Page 225
'0 2° 9031 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._. A . \ }401 § 3 Planning and Development, L0 P PuHar House, S Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Scott Dunbar 3/5/2023 3:25:29 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. Kind regards, Scott Dunbar Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:28:08 PM
Page 226
23 n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, E030.030 5 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Scott Hendry 3/5/2023 4:07:38 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full suppon for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. The creation of the hun would be fantastic for the localCommunity Kind regards, Scott Hendry Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:09:08 PM
Page 227
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, L0 L3 Pullar House, E030.030 5 Kinnoull Street. Penh PH1 5GD 031 Scott Mackintosh 3/5/2023 4:02:21 PM RE -024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Scott Mackintosh Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:03:47 PM
Page 228
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, ._. B Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Scott McDonald 3/10/2023 11:08:29 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, [wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Scott McDonald Digitally signed 3/10/2023 11:09:36 PM
Page 229
20301 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, E030.030 5 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Scott Rix 3/5/2023 3:51:40 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959IFLL. Kind regards, Scott Rix Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:52:13 PM
Page 230
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 3 3 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, '1030 i; Kinnoull Street. Perth PH1 56D Shaun cole 3/5/2023 4:22:53 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or méadam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959lFLL. Kind regards, Shaun cole 030 Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:24:23 PM
Page 231
23 n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development. 3 Pullar House, 2'.030 5 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Sheena howden 3/5/2023 6:50:32 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or m'adam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. With a growing village we are desperately in need of a centre which will serve all age groups. Kind regards, Sheena howden Digitally signed 3/5/2023 6:52:51 PM .
Page 232
'0 2° 9) 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ,_.A \ S E Planning and Development, ' O S Pullar House, ,_. 3024"- Kinnoull Street, 0030 Perth PH1 5GD Sheila O'Donnell 3/6/2023 4:24:41 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Nothing here for children today would be great for the children to go somewhere for activities very amazing for them Kind regards, Sheila O'Donnell Digitally signed 3/6/2023 4:26:23 PM
Page 233
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, ._. 3024"- Kinnoull Street, 0030 Perth . PH1 SGD Skye Rix 3/5/2023 4:18:04 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Skye Rix Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:18:43 PM 2nd from same household
Page 234
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 2'.030 a Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Stephen Duncan - 3/5/2023 4:57:21 PM RE - Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam. I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. I think it031sgood to have extra weII-being facilities as the village continues to grow over the next 5 years, Kind regards, Stephen Duncan Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:00:11 PM
Page 235
'0 2° 9) 3 . 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 3 1 3 Plannlng and Development, 0 S Pullar House, E030.030 g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Stephen Livingston 3/10/2023 11:25:10 AM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. As the village continues to grow a modern facility like this is needed to enable us to create a sense of community, as well as offering space for sports and leisure pursuits Kind regards, 031 Stephen Livingston Digitally signed 3/10/2023 11:28:54 AM o.uK
Page 236
§ 3 'U .x. n , S 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House. E030.030 ; Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD STEVE AND LESLEY FORBES 3/8/20231:54:57 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to éxpress my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, STEVE AND LESLEY FORBES Digitally signed 3/8/2023 1:56:38 PM
Page 237
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ }401 E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, S Kinnoull Street, L0 Perth PH1 5GD Steve Lennon 3/5/2023 4:13:03 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Steve Lennon Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:14:35 PM
Page 238
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, l'.030 g Klnnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Sue Burke , 3/6/2023 9:12:09 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, [wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959/FLL. I think it would be great to have a sports hall/classes/coffee facility in the centre of Stanley and something I would use a lot! Would also help to build a stronger sense of community within Stanley, especially as so many new houses being built here ove Kind regards, Sue Burke Digitally signed 3/6/2023 9:23:34 PM
Page 239
23 m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, ET . g KInnouH Street, Penh PH1 5GD Susan kyle 3/10/2023 6:23:38 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, [wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Susan kyle Digitally signed 3/10/2023 6:26:30 PM
Page 240
E m 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }402 . 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, 2'.030 g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Tara Walster I 3/5/2023 4:25:00 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wi5h to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. The village has nothing. This would be a fantastic opportunity for future generations. Kind regards, Tara Walster Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:26:42 PM
Page 241
g . n, , 3 'U .x. n H . U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 . 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, '1030 '3 Kinnoull Street, Penh PH1 5GD Thomas Brown 3/9/2023 3:55:12 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. Kind regards. Thomas Brown Digitally signed 3/9/2023 3:57:02 PM 2nd from same household
Page 242
'0 2° 9: , 3 '0 .5; H U 3 ,_.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, H . K, Kinnoull Street,A Perth PH1 5GD Toby Jeffery 3/5/2023 6:13:51 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. It seems like a positive move for the village. Kind regards, Toby Jeffery Digitallysigned 3/5/2023 6:16:23 PM 030 com
Page 243
E m 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, S Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 56D V Tom Howden ' 3/5/2023 7:00:41 PM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959/FLL Dear sir or madam. I wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. The village badly needs a community hub where there willBe a variety of activities for all age groups and especially something for the young people Which is desperately needed Kind regards, ' Tom Howden Digitally signed 3/5/2023 7:03:33 PM 2nd from same household
Page 244
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ,_.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, S Kinnoull Street, 0030 Perth PH1 58D Tracey Lawson 3/12/2023 8:37:29 AM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959lFLL. To provide a place for The Community to go that is a modern and space that isn030ta pub and that younger people have somewhere to go as well as the rest of the community. Kind regards, Tracey Lawson Digitally signed 3/12/2023 8:42:08 AM
Page 245
1: 2° 9: 3 '0 .5; H 2 E \ }402 § 8 Planning and Development, L0 P Pullar House. 3 Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Tracy Kelly 3/6/2023 7:20:39 AM RE 024Planning Application 22/01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full suppor031tfor the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. [ am local to the villags and feel the hub would be a great asset. Kind regards, Tracy Kelly Digitally signed 3/6/2023 7:22:57 AM 2nd from same household
Page 246
'0 2° 9) 3 'U H U 3 ._.A \ }401 E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, ._. K, Kinnoull Street, 00 Perth PH1 5GD Vida Chapman 3/5/2023 7:33:08 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959/FLL. Be good to have local facilities and activities par}401cularlyfor children and teenagers. Kind regards, Vida Chapman Digitally signed 3/5/2023 7:37:29 PM
Page 247
2?» m 3 '0 . .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 S PuHar House, E030.030 N Kinnoull Street, L0 Penh PH1 5GD William little 3/5/2023 6:20:06 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, lwish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. The village is expanding and needs facilities like this Kind regards, William little Digitallysigned 3/5/2023 6:22:39 PM com
Page 248
23 n) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A\ . }402 8 3 Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, 2'.030 . g Kmnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD William Robert Campbell 3/10/2023 1:50:39 PM RE 024Planning Application 22I01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22I01959IFLL. Something and place for the youngsters to go and do. Kind regards, William Robert Campbell Digitally signed 3/10/2023 1:54:46 PM
Page 249
'0 2° 9) 3 'U H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, ._. 2.; Kinnoull Street. 0 Perth PH1 560 William Todd 3/10/2023 7:26:39 AM RE 024Planning Application 22IO1959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22/01959/FLL. Kind regards, William Todd Digitally signed 3/10/2023 7:32:25 AM 2nd from same household
Page 250
'0 2° 9) 3 'U H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, ._. L; Kinnoull Street,._. Perth PH1 5GD Yasmin Elder 1 3/6/20231:46:42 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959IFLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation ofthe Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959lFLL. Kind regards, Yasmin Elder Digitally signed 3/6/2023 1:47:50 PM
Page 251
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ,_.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, ,_. g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Yolanda Gill . 3/5/2023 5:24:00 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, |wish to express my full suppon for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. Kind regards, Yolanda Gill Digitally signed 3/5/2023 5:25:15 PM
Page 252
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ,_.A \ }402 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, E030.030 g Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Yvonne Baillie 3/5/2023 4:38:12 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, I wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22l01959IFLL. A central multi purpose building is desperately needed in the village. Kind regards, Yvonne Baillie Digitally signed 3/5/2023 4:41:02 PM
Page 253
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .x. n H U 3 ._.A \ }401 8 Q Planning and Development, 3 Pullar House, E030.030 3 ' Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 5GD Yvonne Robertson 3/5/2023 4:52:52 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959/FLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22(01959IFLL. Kind regards, Yvonne Robertson Digitally signed 030 3/5/2023 4:53:53 PM
Page 254
'0 2° 9) 3 'U .5; H U 3 ._.A \ S E Planning and Development, 0 S Pullar House, ._. 2.; Kinnoull Street, Perth PH1 SGD Zara Duncan 3/5/2023 3:33:15 PM RE 024Planning Application 22l01959lFLL Dear sir or madam, | wish to express my full support for the creation of the Stanley Community Hub, planning application reference 22IO19591FLL. Kind regards, Zara Duncan Digitally signed 3/5/2023 3:34:23 PM
Page 255
No embedded text on this page.
Page 256
Mrs Catherine Dyce (Supports) Comment submitted date: Wed 15 Mar 2023 I am in Stanley a few times a week assisting with my Grandaughters childcare, I feel there is a need for somewhere to take her where she interact with other children, particularly in the colder months or to have a snack after playing in the park.
Page 257
No embedded text on this page.
Page 258
Mr William Twaddle (Supports) Comment submitted date: Wed 15 Mar 2023 I think this will be a huge asset to the community
Page 259
Mr James Brown (Supports) Comment submitted date: Thu 16 Mar 2023 I personally think the proposed new Hub would be a fantastic addition for the village and surrounding area and provide a much-needed facility for the entire community. The village for many years has lacked such a facility and this Hub could provide a modern sustainable building with flexible space which could accommodate everybody from toddler groups to pensioners groups within the community. The proposed site of the new hub is also more central than the existing village hall and could not be better placed for the Local Bowling club, Football pitches, Primary School, and playpark. As a member of Stanley development Trust and the local Badminton club I would certainly use any new facility and have for many years driven my children to surrounding halls in neighbouring villages many times as there wasn't a suitable hall within Stanley. I don't think anyone locally would argue that any new children's clubs/activities in the village are long overdue. Whilst moving the War memorial was not part of the original plans - I believe a move to the more central village square could ultimately be beneficial and provide a more prominent position for such an important monument. It is also worth remembering that Stanley is rapidly expanding by approximately a third over the coming years with hundreds of new houses planned and many already built. I feel a community hub like this one could be vital for an ever-growing Stanley Community and certainly provide a much-needed focal point.
Page 260
No embedded text on this page.
Page 261
No embedded text on this page.
Page 262
Dr Michael Taylor (Objects) Comment submitted date: Thu 16 Mar 2023 - This planning application contains a proposal to relocate the Stanley war memorial - The application gives no details of why, how or where - The memorial is listed and of intrinsic historic and artistic importance - The memorial's highland soldier figure is the only stone war memorial figure in Perth and Kinross and one of only three figurative memorial sculptures in the area - The memorial represents community remembrance and commemoration and should be treated with respect - The memorial is to be relocated to provide car parking - The memorial lists the name of Captain Alexander McKenzie, 2nd Battalion Manchester Regiment, among many others. Captain McKenzie was killed alongside his comrade, the poet Captain Wilfred Owen on 4 November 1918 - a point of national interest - "War memorials were often carefully located in places chosen by the local community and they should not normally be moved or relocated unless there is a very good reason to do so. Damage can be caused by dismantling or if they are moved to an inappropriate location" (The Repair and Maintenance of War Memorials, Historic Scotland / War Memorials Trust, p.38) - This proposal has clearly not been thought through. There is no context for the memorial and no analysis of the historical context of the creation of the memorial or its siting (for a detailed account of the dedication of the memorial see the Perthshire Advertiser 11 June 1924) - The application assumes that it is acceptable to give no details of the necessity for the proposed relocation - The application assumes that it is acceptable to give no details of the site of the proposed relocation - I urge refusal of the application
Page 263
No embedded text on this page.
Page 264
No embedded text on this page.
Page 265
No embedded text on this page.
Page 266
No embedded text on this page.
Page 267
No embedded text on this page.
Page 268
1: 2° 9031 3 'U .5; H U 3 8 \ }401 § 8 E? "' Planning & Development Of}401cer . Perth & Kinross Planning Department 030 Pullar House Klnnoull Street Perth 24 Ref 22/01959/FLL Dear Sir I would like it to register my full support to the creation of a community hub within Stanley as there 034' 030'is a lack of Community accessible space within the Village. The hub will allow groups and activities to be formed for all ages within the community. . . Yours Faithfully 030 NM / Mus H mm .
Page 269
23 3 'U .5; E 8 \ }401 § 8 E? " Planning & Development Of}401cer Perth & Kinross Planning Department Pullar House Kinnoull Street M Ref 22/01959/FLL Dear Sir I would like it to register my full support to the creation of a community hub within Stanley as there is a lack of Community accessible space within the viliage. The hub will allow groups and activities to . be formed for all ages within the community. ., .. Yours Faithfully ( [saga HACQKCC030CSR
Page 270
1 Development Management From: Ben Tattersall < Sent: 25 March 2023 19:43 To: Development Management Subject: Re: Planning Application Reference 22/01959/FLL- Objection With regard to the proposed community hub in Stanley, I wish to raise some concerns. The word 'objection' doesn't seem to fit, as I don't object in principle, but feel some aspects could do with a little more looking at. However, I'll go with your chosen turn of phrase for the purposes of this email. Whilst I am fully in support of a community hub in Stanley, I am concerned that with the current plan: Not enough parking is proposed. I worry this will create congestion on the main road, possibly creating conditions for a serious accident. Apart from anything else we would surely want this facility to be well used; if there is not enough parking it might not be which would be a great shame. The look of the building as per current plan is somewhat out of keeping with the aesthetics of the area. There are a number of building types in Stanley but nothing like this. As such I'm not sure how it will fit in, especially behind a bonny church. The height of the structure does not personally affect me, but I wonder if those who live close by might be adversely affected and would hope their concerns are taken into consideration in this regard. Could the C listed church hall be saved and incorporated into an updated design? This would surely be more in line with modern building ideas of efficiency and carbon emissions, and the idea of 'embodied carbon' of an already existing building. Again, I am very much in favour of a community hub on this site; I think the village could stand to really benefit from a facility such as this. I feel however some more thought could perhaps be given to the practicalities and overall design. Yours,
Page 271
Comments to the Development Quality Manager on a Planning Application Planning Application ref. 22/01959/FLL Comments provided by Lachlan MacLean Project Officer – Transport Planning Service/Section Transport Planning Contact Details TransportPlanning@pkc.gov.uk Description of Proposal Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works Address of site Land 30 Metres West Of St Columba's Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley Comments on the proposal The applicant has submitted redesigned plans to erect a community centre with café and outdoor sports facilities adjacent to the St Columba’s Episcopal church. Previously the vehicle access to the B9099 Perth Road was to be through the existing War Memorial, which would have been relocated. The revised plans are for a shared cycle/pedestrian/vehicle route created between the church and the war memorial, approximately 10 meters south of the previous proposed entrance. The proposed access will be 4.2metres in width. The applicant had discussed taking access from West Park, but an agreement has not been possible from the residents as this is a private road. At the proposed vehicle access onto he B9099, there is streetlighting infrastructure, in particular the streetlighting cable will need to be lowered to a depth of at least 750 mm. In the footway there is a culvert, which will also need to be strengthened to accommodate vehicle access to the site. The vehicle access shall be formed prior to any construction works commencing to avoid damage to the culvert and streetlighting infrastructure. A condition is recommended. Parking will be provided on site for 4 vehicles. There will be three accessible spaces and one minibus space for drop offs and pickups. The centre is located centrally to the community and most local residents are within an 800m walking radius of the site. Cycle parking will be provided for 8 spaces located beneath the canopy at the entrance to the hub, a further 10 on the main terrace overlooking the bowling rink and 4 for staff outside the enclosure for ancillary facilities. All of these spaces will be either overlooked from within the building or covered by CCTV. If the applicant is successful in gaining planning consent, they must apply for a Vehicle Access Consent before starting works on its formation. This will allow the applicants contractor to apply for the necessary consents to work within the public road network. More information on the process can be found on the following website: https://www.pkc.gov.uk/vehicleaccess. Please note, that as planning permission has been applied for, currently no fee is required for the Vehicle Access Consent (VA1 form), please include the planning application number on your VA application form.
Page 272
Insofar as the Roads matters are concerned, I have no objections to this proposal on the following conditions. Recommended planning condition(s) No development in connection with the permission hereby granted shall commence unless the vehicle access across the footway onto the B9099 has been provided with the lowered streetlighting cable, the culvert has been strengthened and formed in accordance with Perth & Kinross Council's Road Development Guide Type B Figure 5.6 access detail with dropped kerbs across the full 6 metre width of the vehicle access of Type A Road construction detail. Reason - In the interests of road safety; to ensure an acceptable standard of construction within the public road boundary. Prior to the development hereby approved being completed or brought into use, the cycle parking for a minimum of 22 cycles shall be implemented in accordance with the approved details to the satisfaction of the Council as Planning Authority. Reason - To encourage active travel and meet advice within Scottish Planning Policy on transport. Recommended informative(s) for applicant Street lighting plant present at the site, discussions must be had with the Street Lighting Partnership to obtain the locations of plant and the relocation to facilitate the vehicle access. Contact Mark Gorrie at Perth & Kinross Council Street Lighting Department for further details. The road culvert present at the vehicle access, must be strengthened to the satisfaction of the Roads Authority. Contact Brian Milne at Perth & Kinross Council Road Maintenance Partnership for further details. The applicant is advised that, in terms of Sections 56 of the Roads (Scotland) Act 1984, he/she/they must obtain from the Council, as Roads Authority, consent to open an existing road or footway prior to the commencement of works. Information on junction types, requirements for Vehicular Access consents (VA1) and application forms are available at www.pkc.gov.uk/vehicleaccess. Advice on the disposal of surface water should be sought at the initial stages of design from Scottish Water and the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency. The applicant is advised that, in terms of Sections 109 of the New Roads and Street Works Act 1991, he/she/they must obtain from the Council, to place, maintain or adjust apparatus in, or under a Road or remove apparatus from a road. Application forms are available at https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/14916/Road-and-footway-permits. Date comments returned 20 November 2023
Page 273
No embedded text on this page.
Page 274
No embedded text on this page.
Page 275
No embedded text on this page.
Page 276
No embedded text on this page.
Page 277
No embedded text on this page.
Page 278
No embedded text on this page.
Page 279
No embedded text on this page.
Page 280
No embedded text on this page.
Page 281
No embedded text on this page.
Page 282
No embedded text on this page.
Page 283
No embedded text on this page.
Page 284
No embedded text on this page.
Page 285
No embedded text on this page.
Page 286
Comments to the Development Quality Manager on a Planning Application Planning Application ref. 22/01959/FLL Comments provided by Diane Barbary Service/Section Conservation Contact Details Description of Proposal Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works Address of site Land 30m West of St Columba’s Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley Comments on the proposal The proposed development is to the west of the category B listed St Columba’s Episcopal Church, requiring its partial demolition, and requiring alteration to the adjacent category C listed war memorial. These comments are further to my previous response of 22nd March, following revisions and submission of additional supporting information. The proposed retention of the war memorial is welcomed, although the proposed alterations to the boundary walls raise concerns, as set out in my consultation response to the accompanying application for listed building consent (23/01473/LBC). NPF4 states that development proposals affecting the setting of a listed building should preserve its character and its special architectural or historic interest. The revised Design Statement and Heritage Assessment specify that the proposed new development would not harm the special interest of the church and war memorial, and in fact the removal of the church hall would enhance the church. The proposed sports hall is in very close proximity to the church and war memorial, and would form a prominent backdrop to key views of the listed buildings from the east. Given its relative scale, it would become the dominant feature in this view. The adverse visual impact resulting from the loss of the hall, unsympathetic alterations to the war memorial garden and the scale of the new development, would be significant. While retention of the war memorial is welcomed, the amendments and additional information submitted do not adequately address the concerns raised by the proposals in relation to the adverse impact on listed buildings. Recommended planning condition(s) Recommended informative(s) for applicant Date comments returned 05/12/2023
Page 287
Comments to the Development Quality Manager on a Planning Application Planning Application ref. 22/01959/FLL Comments provided by Joanna Dick Tree and Biodiversity Officer Service/Section Strategy and Policy Contact Details Email biodiversity@pkc.gov.uk Description of Proposal Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works. Address of site Land 30m West of St Columba’s Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley Comments on the proposal Policy 40: Forestry, Woodland and Trees The Council will apply the principles of the Scottish Government Policy on Control of Woodland Removal and there will be a presumption in favour of protecting woodland resources. Where the loss of woodland is unavoidable, mitigation measures in the form of compensatory planting will be required. The submitted Arboricultural Impact Assessment details that two birch trees (ref 81, 82) and one alder tree (ref 89) will be felled to allow this development to proceed. I am unclear if the mixed mature hedge will be removed. Trees and hedgerows should be retained and incorporated into the design in line with the mitigation hierarchy. The submitted report states that two semi-heavy standard native trees will be planted to compensate for the loss of the two birch trees. Oak is a good choice as they are very long lived and great for local biodiversity in urban areas. This should be increased to three to compensate for the three trees. In this instance, one heavy standard for each tree removed would be accepted as compensation. A detailed landscaping plan and planting schedule is required indicating species, location, tree stock size, type, planting spec, maintenance, vermin and weed control. Policy 41: Biodiversity The Council will seek to protect and enhance all wildlife and habitats, whether formally designated or not, considering natural processes in the area. Planning permission will not be granted for development likely to have an adverse effect on protected species unless clear evidence can be provided that the ecological impacts can be satisfactorily mitigated. The submitted Ecological Impact Assessment (Tay Ecology, May 2023) is in accordance with best practice and surveys were undertaken at the correct time of year. The Report provides comprehensive impact assessments of the proposed development on protected habitats, species, and wider biodiversity.
Page 288
European Protected Species All bat species found in Scotland are classed as European protected species. They receive full protection under the Conservation (Natural Habitats, &c.) Regulations 1994 (as amended) making it an offence to disturb a bat in a roost, obstruct access to a roost and damage or destroy a breeding or resting place of such an animal. The impact of development on protected species must be understood before planning permission can be granted. All methods in the submittedBat, Bird and Protected Species Survey Report are in accordance with best practice. Dusk and dawn surveys carried out in 2023 confirmed the presence of bats. Due to the presence of bat roosts, no works can be undertaken before a derogation licence from NatureScot (formerly Scottish Natural Heritage) has been issued. The submitted Bat, Bird and Protected Species Survey Report contains sufficient information for the planning authority to be satisfied that all three tests are likely to be met. The same tests need to be passed in order for NatureScot to issue a licence. Breeding Birds For all wild bird species in Great Britain, it is an offence to intentionally or recklessly kill, injure or take a bird; take, damage, destroy or interfere with a nest of any bird while it is in use or being built; or obstruct or prevent any bird from using its nest. Biodiversity Enhancement NPF4 requires local planning applications to include appropriate measures for biodiversity enhancement that are proportionate to the nature and scale of the development. The submitted Ecological Impact Assessment details biodiversity enhancement suggestions in section 6 that are in line with the PKC Planning for Nature Supplementary Guidance. These should be provided to ensure biodiversity enhancement is delivered as part of the proposed development. A suitable condition to ensure these measures are provided should be added to any consent. In addition, 10.7 of the submitted Arboricultural Impact Assessment recommends that approximately 400 whips of native trees should also be planted as mixed species hedging where appropriate after all other works are complete. The Report states the recommendation is not to reinstate the Leylandii hedging and instead invest in local biodiversity enrichment. This is welcomed as a very positive measures for biodiversity and should be secured via a condition. Recommended planning condition(s) If you are minded to approve this application then I recommend the following conditions be included in any approval:
Page 289
TR04 Prior to the commencement of any works on site, all trees on site (other than those marked for felling on the approved plans) and those which have Root Protection Areas which fall within the site shall be retained and protected. Protection methods shall be strictly in accordance with BS 5837 2012: Trees in Relation to Design, Demolition and Construction. Protection measures, once in place, shall remain in place for the duration of construction. TR10 All trees on site, other than those marked for felling on the approved plans, shall be retained. Prior to the commencement of the development hereby approved, a detailed landscaping and planting scheme for the site shall be submitted for the further written agreement of the Council as Planning Authority. The scheme shall include details of the species, height, size, location, density and maintenance regime of trees and shrubs to be planted. The scheme must illustrate that adequate compensatory tree planting for lost trees will be achieved with at least 3 trees planted for every tree lost. The scheme as subsequently approved shall be carried out and completed within the first available planting season (October to March) after the completion or bringing into use of the development, whichever is the earlier. NE00 The conclusions and recommended action points within the supporting biodiversity survey submitted and hereby approved (document(s) INSERT relates) shall be fully adhered to, respected and undertaken as part of the construction phase of development, to the satisfaction of the Council as Planning Authority. NE03 Prior to the completion or occupation of the building(s) hereby approved, whichever is the earlier, ten bird nesting boxes and ten bat boxes shall be provided on the completed building or nearby trees in line with the recommendations in the submitted Preliminary Ecological Appraisal and Ecological Impact Assessment (Tay Ecology, May 2023). Thereafter, the agreed scheme shall be maintained in a reasonable condition for the life of the development, to the satisfaction of the Council as Planning Authority. Recommended informative(s) for applicant Date comments returned 7 December 2023
Page 290
CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Mike Taylor Sent: 25 March 2024 10:17 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Re: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Please delete my last email. It seems to have been sent while incomplete. Application Ref: 22/01959/FLL Thank you for your email of 22 March 2024 bringing to my notice the forthcoming Review of Application Ref: 22/01959/FLL. I do indeed wish my original comments to stand and be placed in front of the Local Review Body. I also wish to take this opportunity to highlight once more the potential threat to this significant war memorial which was the focus of my original comments. Its current site, in proximity to the church in a landscaped setting is its original context and a move would potentially place it in an unsympathetic context while placing it at risk during dismantling and transport - a specialist task which would require detailed proposals to be developed. The fact that the proposed relocation is to clear the site for car parking shows little regard for the sacrifices made by the community and the effort it made to place its memorial to its fallen in that spot. Michael Taylor (Chair, Tayside Branch, Western Front Association)
Page 291
CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Harvey Alexander Sent: 27 March 2024 12:51 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Re: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson I support this proposal to build a much-needed community sports facility in the village. The Hall that is to be demolished, to make way for this community facility, has sat in a state of terrible disrepair for decades. It is of little architectural interest/value, and its loss, inconsequential. Conversely, the War Memorial is of great local value. It is pleasing to see that only minor adjustment to the boundary wall is necessary to provide access to the community facility. Councillors should grant planning permission andoverturn the Officer's decision: a decision not taken in the interests of our growing community. Sincerely, Harvey Alexander
Page 292
CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Morag Roberts Sent: 27 March 2024 08:44 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Re: LRB-2024-13 Attachments: decision notice.pdf CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson I support this proposal to build a much-needed community sports facility in the village. The Hall that is to be demolished, to make way for this community facility, has sat in a state of terrible disrepair for decades. I am also aware that the diocese is in complete agreement with this as it is unusable for them in its present state. It is of little architectural interest/value, and its loss, inconsequential. Conversely, the War Memorial is of great local value. It is pleasing to see that only minor adjustment to the boundary wall is necessary to provide access to the community facility. It seem very important that the facility is at the centre of the community to allow those without transport to easily access it. Councillors should grant planning permission andoverturn the Officer's decision: a decision not taken in the interests of our growing community. Sincerely Morag Roberts
Page 293
re: Town & Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 The Town & Country Planning (Schemes of Delegation & Local Review Procedure) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 Application Ref: 22/01959/FLL – Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works, land 30 metres west of St Columba’s Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley – Stanley Development Trust Dear Sirs, I am writing in further support of the above planning application having been informed that it will be reviewed by the Perth and Kinross Local Review Body. The Planners basis for refusing the application is based purely on the aesthetics of the proposed Community Hub structure and I wish to point out how this is based on poor advice & research with a failure to adopt a holistic approach to reviewing the application and shows major inconsistencies in the planning processes. Had the Planner carried out due diligence they would have discovered that the Hall that is referred to in the refusal notice has been unused for in excess of 20 years. It is in such a state that even if it were to be returned to any degree of use the sums required to implement this would be significant. I would hazard a guess that it currently remains upright only as it takes support from the main structure of the Church building itself. It is unsafe and of no benefit to anyone and is an eyesore. Even the Church and its current representatives are supportive of the proposal. With regards to the War Memorial: I am an active supporter of all things connected with Remembrance, coming from a military family. However in this instance the Planner has again failed to carry out due diligence and follow any precedence set by PKC and his department in previous applications. I refer to the relocation of the War Memorial in Luncarty village (less than 5 miles away) some years ago. This was not done for any benefit to Luncarty village but for commercial gain - the relocation of the Memorial allowed the building and selling of 4 houses. The original proposed relocation of the Memorial in Stanley would have been purely for the benefit of the Community and Village of Stanley. In point of fact any such relocation would have allowed there to be more space around the Memorial for Remembrance gatherings – the current location is considerably limiting in this. I am aware however that the request to relocate the Memorial no longer forms part of the application (having been pushed into removal of this aspect of the proposal by PKC Planners). I can only hope then that this part of the application will be granted as the minor changes requested to the boundary of the Memorial will allow greater access for pedestrians and disabled persons to the proposed Hub and Memorial. The Planner refuses overall permission based on the ‘setting’ around St. Columbas and the War Memorial. With Stanley currently going through major changes to its structure and population numbers there is urgent need for the Community to have access to a facility such as is being proposed by the Stanley Development Trust. The failure of the Planner to take a holistic approach to this application has led us to where we are now. It needs to be asked whether such concerns about ‘setting’ considered when PKC Planners recently approved the planning application for the Murrayshall Estate. The architects drawings for that application show a huge ‘block’ of a structure completely out of keeping with anything near it and which will eat up huge areas of the local countryside (something Perthshire is renowned for). Compared to that application the proposal for the Community Sports Hub in Stanley will only put to excellent Community use ground that is currently beyond use and sits derelict. I ask that the Local Review Body adopt a holistic approach to the application from Stanley Development Trust and take into account the significant population growth that the village will experience over the coming years coupled with the lack of facilities in or around us. I would also like to ask the LRB to take into account the recent decision to ‘downgrade’ the facilities on offer in Perth City with the proposals for the replacement of the Bells and Dewars Centres and Perth Leisure Pools. Looking at other developments of similar nature I can only hope that the members of the LRB come to the only sensible conclusion and reverse the Planners decision. To stand with the Planner and leave the decision unchanged will have a huge detrimental affect on Stanley and the facilities available to a growing Community. Yours faithfully Neil Hardy
Page 294
CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Sent: 28 March 2024 15:07 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: RE: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisaon. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open aachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson I support this proposal to build a much-needed community sports facility in the village. The Hall that is to be demolished, to make way for this community facility, has sat in a state of terrible disrepair for decades. It is of little architectural interest/value, and its loss, inconsequential. Conversely, the War Memorial is of great local value. It is pleasing to see that only minor adjustment to the boundary wall is necessary to provide access to the community facility. Councillors should grant planning permission and overturn the Oicer's decision: a decision not taken in the interests of our growing community. Sincerely Joanne Hardy
Page 295
CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Lois Lelland Sent: 28 March 2024 15:32 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Re: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson, I support this proposal to build a much-needed community sports facility in the village. The Hall that is to be demolished, to make way for this community facility, has sat in a state of terrible disrepair for decades. It is of little architectural interest/value, and its loss, inconsequential. Conversely, the War Memorial is of great local value. It is pleasing to see that only minor adjustment to the boundary wall is necessary to provide access to the community facility. Councillors should grant planning permission and overturn the Officer's decision: a decision not taken in the interests of our growing community. Sincerely, Lois Lelland
Page 296
29 March 2024 CDS Planning Local Review Body Application Ref: 22/01959/FLL I am responding in respect of the review of the above application regarding mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, oices, community café, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works, land 30 metres west of St Columba’s Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley – Stanley Development Trust. I very much do wish to make further representation and comment in support of this proposal. The reason given for the refusal of application i.e. in the opinion of the planner the proposed community centre would be detrimental to the existing character of existing structures namely the church and war memorial. In reality this assumption is incorrect and I question whether or not the planner actually visited our village to view the proposed site. Had he/she done so they would have learned that the church hall at the rear of the building is derelict, unsafe and as a result has not been in use for more than two decades. Additionally, the associated proposed land for the community hub has also not been in use for years and is currently an eyesore to anyone passing by. As I understand it the church representatives themselves are in favour and supportive of this project. I believe the relocation of the war memorial element of the application has been removed but there was actually a precedent for this to happen as the War Memorial in Luncarty was relocated some years ago. If anyone cares to join us when we remember our dead on 11 November each year they will see just how little room we have to do this. The relocation plan would have solved that problem. As for the proposed Hub not looking ‘nice’ I refer you to the recently agreed plan for the planning application for the Murrayshall complex. The architect drawings show a massive concrete building with no character whatsoever. How on earth did that get approved? Once built this particular complex will be of very little benefit to the local community as it is primarily aimed at visitors to the Murrayshall estate. The proposed Stanley Hub on the other hand will definitely be an asset to the local community including the adjacent villages of Murthly, Bankfoot and Luncarty.
Page 297
With the new housing estates springing up within and around our village it is only a matter of time before Stanley falls into the category of a small town and the proposed Stanley Hub is a facility that is very much needed. Please take another look at this proposal and make the right decision for it to go ahead. Thank you. Mrs Geraldine Hardy
Page 298
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Sheena Howden Sent: 30 March 2024 15:46 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Cc: Subject: Planning appeal - Stanley Community Hub CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisaon. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open aachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson I support this proposal to build a much-needed community sports facility in the village. The Hall that is to be demolished, to make way for this community facility, has sat in a state of terrible disrepair for decades. It is of lile architectural interest/value, and its loss, inconsequenal. Conversely, the War Memorial is of great local value. It is pleasing to see that only minor adjustment to the boundary wall is necessary to provide access to the community facility. Councillors should grant planning permission and overturn the Officer's decision: a decision not taken in the interests of our growing community. Sincerely Sheena Howden Sent from my iPhone
Page 299
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: S Howden Sent: 30 March 2024 15:54 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Cc: Subject: Planning appeal - Stanley Community Hub CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson I support this proposal to build a much-needed community sports facility in the village. The Hall that is to be demolished, to make way for this community facility, has sat in a state of terrible disrepair for decades. It is of little architectural interest/value, and its loss, inconsequential. Conversely, the War Memorial is of great local value. It is pleasing to see that only minor adjustment to the boundary wall is necessary to provide access to the community facility. Councillors should grant planning permission and overturn the Officer's decision: a decision not taken in the interests of our growing community. Sincerely Tom Howden
Page 300
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Ben Tattersall Sent: 30 March 2024 19:53 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Stanley Community Hub CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. With the 2 new developments under way now within the village, there is a great need for this resource to be built within our Community. I support this proposal to build a much-needed community facility in the village. As an individual who originally raised concerns, on reflection and on balance, I would much rather this went ahead than not. I simply hope that concerns that some raised, such as surrounding road safety, traffic management, and wildlife management, can be taken forward satisfactorily during development, in conjunction with the Stanley Development Trust. Councillors should grant planning permission and overturn the Officer's decision. If this is not granted, urgent efforts should be made to develop a Stanley Community Hub that is acceptable in another way, shape or form, and delivered as quickly as possible, rather than through a drawn- out process lasting years. An expanding and dynamic community needs, and deserves, this resource. Yours sincerely, Benedict Tattersall
Page 301
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Gerry Burke Sent: 31 March 2024 18:02 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Cc: Subject: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Town & Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 The Town & Country Planning (Schemes of Delegation & Local Review Procedure) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 Application Ref: 22/01959/FLL – Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works, land 30 metres west of St Columba’s Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley – Stanley Development Trust Thank you for your letter of 22 March 2024 in reference to the above application. I support this proposal for the reasons outlined below. Stanley village is currently undergoing a level of housing expansion, comparable only to when it was laid out as the mill workers village. In the last few years Phase 1 of a Muir Homes development has been completed, 187 houses of Phase 2 are currently underway, future phases of the Muir Homes estates are planned around the village and ground has been broken in the last few weeks by Ogilvie Homes for 81 houses. Planning has also passed the application for six homes on a small piece of land at the south entrance to the village. There appears to be a scramble to build housing in the village for residents flowing out of Perth. We are witnessing a rapid expansion. Yet, nothing has changed in the village to accommodate them. The school, GP surgery, roads infrastructure all remain untouched. There is not a cafe in the village, no indoor sports facility, no modern community meeting space for young or old. There is a Victorian church hall which is used for summer teas and yoga classes but it is neither inviting or comfortable and has long passed its best days. Stanley's most successful community event of each year, the Christmas Lights switch on, has no base to work from, so the main road has to be closed for a short period to allow the event to be rushed through. Then, villagers go back to their homes. Whilst the National Planning Framework protects our listed property settings from harmful development, I feel the common sense argument is plain to see in this case - especially when the two listed properties (Church and War Memorial) are both currently surrounded by modern buildings in their immediate setting. The argument that this setting will be negatively impacted was lost when adjacent modern development started surrounding both the church and memorial. This is a working village and not a site of architectural importance. I applaud that the framework is there in protection of our heritage but it should not be at the expense of community
Page 302
2 furtherment at this small scale but huge importance. The hall has been in disrepair for decades and the memorial needs only a minor adjustment. This is a small consideration compared to a huge benefit for Stanley. The location is the last and only central plot available for a community hub, ideally placed in the centre of the village. At a time when councils encourage their residents to engage with their communities, care about where they live and improve lives for all, there is a will to be a community here and so a community centre is needed now more than ever, if this village is to be more than just another large cluster of houses. We have the plot, we have the Section 75 agreement in place for the community hub - we're about to have a lot of new residents - but sadly, nowhere to meet with them. Our sincere request is that Councillors should grant planning permission, overturn the Officer's decision and please let our village thrive as it grows. Gerry Burke
Page 303
CDS Planning Local Review Body From: janicecargill Sent: 31 March 2024 22:06 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Re:LRB-2024-13 I fully support the application . The new facility would enhance Community spirit . Stanley sorely needs to bring the community , both young and old together , "local" and "incomer" together . An obvious village hub would be a significant improvement . It's what the war memorial represents that's important, not it's exact location . Janice Cargill
Page 304
Town & Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 The Town & Country Planning (Schemes of Delegation & Local Review Procedure) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 Application Ref: 22/01959/FLL – Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works, land 30 metres west of St Columba’s Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley – Stanley Development Trust Dear Ms Simpson I am writing to express my support for the much-needed sports/community Hub in Stanley village. It is quite unbelievable that the whole project could be jeopardised by an extremely old church hall due to be demolished which as far as I can remember (nearly 30 years) has never been used or wanted (including the church) in the village and has recently been structurally condemned by a local engineer. I fully understand that we must endeavour to keep listed buildings of interest but the hall in question is of little architectural value and its loss inconsequential. Conversely the war memorial is something we should be trying to improve by opening out the surrounding area giving the memorial a prominent position within the community which it rightly deserves. Councillors should without question overturn the planning officer’s decision. This decision was obviously not taken in the interests of the ever-growing community in Stanley a fact which was emphasised by the 200+ letters of support for the project received prior to refusal. This proposed Hub is a massive opportunity for Stanley to finally get the community focal point it deserves and needs. Regards James Brown
Page 305
CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Sent: 03 April 2024 12:41 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Re: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Good Afternoon I am writing to express my deep disappointment in the councils decision to decline planning of the much needed Community hub in Stanley. The reasons behind their refusal I find bewildering. See points below. Church Hall - this is a derelict Hall which proves no value architecturally or to the community. This Hall has remained empty and has recently been condemned I understsnd and is also in a grave state of disrepair. The church have previously advised they are happy to hand this over to the development Trust. War memorial - given that the trust are now agreeable for this to be left in situ this cannot be used within the decision. Surely elevating the position of the war memorial beside the hub can only be a positive result. Stanley is an ever growing village and will see over 300 approx new houses being built in the next few years we are desperately looking for a community hub which will support our needs. After receiving over 200 plus letters of support and only a few objections I hope this decision will be overturned and Stanley can grow alongside other villages. Kind regards Helen Brown
Page 306
CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Katherine Rix Sent: 04 April 2024 19:04 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Re: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. To whom it may concern I am very much in favour of Stanley having a much-needed sports facility built. There are so many opportunities this can open up to locals. The village is growing, current There are two housing developments being build which will add over 250 houses in the village - a lot of these are family size homes. We need to have a dedicated space to allow the village to host different events that everyone can benefit from. Being able to offer our children somewhere local to attend rather than having to drive to Perth or elsewhere would cut down a lot of families car running costs, and perhaps allow families to send their children to participate in activities. I have lived in the village for over 6 years. In that time the hall that is to demolished has sat unused falling further and further into disrepair and becoming an eyesore. Along with the disused tennis court. The War Memorial, which I understand needs to be repositioned, is part of the village history. This should be in a more central spot where more people can repay their respects and so future generations can be reminded of our history. Councillors should grant planning permission and overturn the Officers decision. Their decision seems to have failed to recognise the need of our growing community. Many thanks Katherine Rix
Page 307
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Robert Baldie Sent: 05 April 2024 13:10 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Proposed Muga in Stanley CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. The importance of this project to the Community far outweighs the original very limited justification for the refusal of planning consent last month. This new building will replace a former Church which dates back to 1845 and since 1960 has served the community as the village hall. Whilst there has been investment and upgrading in recent years the scope for extending on the current site is very limited with no immediate access to the planned outdoor space at the new site and further space is essential to provider better facilities within our ever growing village. The height of the new building would also allow the continuation of current hall users such as badminton and free runners to make use of this new facility. I also think rather than being detrimental to the backdrop to St Columba's one has to currently view a dated wooden structure with a rear stone extension which is disused and in poor condition will be a positive. The provision of a new modern building close to the War Memorial would bring the community closer to the memory of those who served during the war years and should be looked as a positive. In conclusion I feel that those who have a vision for the future of our Community should be allowed to progress this project without such very limited and narrow objections. The positives for Stanley and the wider community far out way the negatives. Robert Baldie
Page 308
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Sue Burke Sent: 05 April 2024 16:16 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Cc: audrey.brown@pkc.gov.uk Subject: Fwd: LRB-2024-13 Attachments: decision notice.pdf CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Town & Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 The Town & Country Planning (Schemes of Delegation & Local Review Procedure) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 Application Ref: 22/01959/FLL – Mixed use development comprising alterations to church, relocation of memorial, erection of community centre with sport/education facilities, offices, community cafe, formation of replacement MUGA, landscaping, parking and associated works, land 30 metres west of St Columba's Episcopal Church, 19 Perth Road, Stanley – Stanley Development Trust Thank you for your letter of 22 March 2024 in reference to the above application. I support the proposal to build a much needed community hub and sports facility in the village. As the village grows it is vitally important that we have a community hub and sports centre. We have a good community and provide a number of services in the village: for the older community we have the Soup Club, and Winter Warmer lunch club; for teenagers we have just started a Youth Music project, and hold a monthly Family Fun and Food Sunday. We run weekly Healthy Walks and the Christmas Lights switch on each year is well attended. Last year there was a Community Gala with National Lottery Funding with over 300 people attending. There is absolutely no shortage of a sense of community, but these are held in separate locations and no sporting facilities. A hub would only build on that sense of community providing services over and above those above, and its location in the centre of the village means it would be easily accessible to all residents. I am somewhat at a loss to understand the reason given by the Planning Officer to reject the application because of a "significant detrimental impact on the setting of a Category C listed church". When I look at the buildings around it, especially a modern bungalow right alongside the church, the reason given by the Planner is somewhat hard to fathom? Similarly, planning permission has been granted to large house builders to build modern housing schemes - which personally I feel have a "significant detrimental impact" on the village of Stanley. The development at the head of Mill Brae case in point will do little to enhance Stanley Mills below it. It seems the rationale given to reject the planning application is somewhat subjective. The justification given is that "the proposal is not in accordance with the Development plan and therefore no material reasons which justify departing from the development plan". However in the Development Plan it actually states "there are five housing allocations proposed for Stanley. These will be Master planned to reinforce the Hub project, as well as supporting the Luncarty to Stanley cycle route and existing
Page 309
services." Therefore, I do not understand why the Planning Officer feels that the Hub is a departure from the plan? Last but not least, I have been in Stanley for 9 years and have never attended or known of an event taking place in the hall which is to be demolished alongside St Columba’s Church. I understand the hall is in a terrible state and that it is of little architectural interest so should not be a consideration by the Planning Officer. Councillors should grant planning permission and overturn the Officer’s decision: a decision that was not taken with the best interests of our growing community in mind. Kind regards Sue Burke
Page 310
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: pam.e.campbell Sent: 05 April 2024 12:59 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson I make further representation to my objection as follows - The 2010-2015 Community Action Plan states "to explore the potential to designate and promote Stanley as an historic village". The setting of the C Listed Church and Church Hall and the C Listed War Memorial is an important part of this historical village and it is utterly unthinkable to even consider that a 9M high glass sports hub be built on this site. Another site needs to be chosen for the sports hub w here it doesn't have a detrimental impact on these important C Listed buildings. Yours sincerely Pamela Campbell
Page 311
Ef 3 g ' E g Dcorl PCVHKVA Kunrossa, LQQQL RQUKQAD 8663 mm 1L 03 M3 mmd Obs AYE Ccmrd .pome Von Wm; Lagcex 30h 17-23am 30%, \e Raod en jZ u au ox ?\nQMQ3 $0¢QX be palMQWAv \\' woos GKM CB k) - LOVY CQ. 93> Om ' :m E:\rxe, WEDK gcx NOAWEB COM; \JQ W TKMCV E § o\ Doug qdf (D 0?}:
Page 312
' . ' [** --*'~ -*-;-#% , 3 \cc A Ce b weews 1 : IQRSQ aha @0q c clari » .3 cat the, S vcc 05 g Q m (Stam g 30 :- MC, «33 g ._ Q CmdL Q L600) ($94133 13 91,083 SW108>KALLQ5 E Emma Nwmw'g} % e u . isomg, 6m OggbaMgQO f 1 K kkbs riAg Avg Noa 3. . " EQKKW DUE CARE ,) ' ) mm A emmomi AmcS g .- EHNQW SQWQ- E:\MQ'EE ' Qt HA2. CV©%%\J/\S ' < [Even Gama élovw" 1 $\0Uo C W Q Ye}: LE3. z . ' ' para L\g /\\4$. ' i , .l I _ __J
Page 313
- . rff i * 3: _
: 15¢ \nQudaL/xg the, 99404 '
E « ' Erqboh «\2, Qeq Z Z\O\C\Sq E -
E V E/FLP A - l
g 1: \ cs A QEQZB Oxaqox d l, '
_ gbmexg Dom (Dag '
{ r fm m 30, DEW l'
:gma Cw usox ex Wm
.1 WAND M3 LoiraPMum/xg \ '
éRdoénows Savtd gm" g
. . «?<a CQWQWA Armc x QQ\$25 1 V
, LEV»; Uédcxmt m, H/wn \
TVA29F PVQ%\®\X% \\§Q
-' [Amok hows '\o\r\3 mead
" E:\ér be QQ, \FQ SCNQ
?%dc on \\FQ\Q \LMQV W
. - pWe.% g) §c\m®®\
' . y . «3' chwclfaa¥c , EPage 314
w: . " ;'_~" ;- " " _" A E
' r b. i« .
i . i 1 6g, \AQQXWS PpCn
E 1 [$3, 94a 'LQQB. S rcxmb3
E - i 5% Pang CMUVCV \g . i _
° Lmueaed Ewrk QLQ VNQV i ,
. 1 UN 7+s Cgv
' W OVC¥\ \"b do LE, A f
W596 :98 Eabcxvxmg A$ {3
. I che. mac (5s Cube 3 _
» : {ED UW ap wmé 5;
{EM D gc Omb) \nOpeé .
. 1 SC DU um dexqa c amd 3AM?) §
4' Lojcber ;
, : \lOuf >\Y'\QQVQ\3 (1
1 . 1,
. i v
, J
, L;_- _,_ __ \Page 315
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Claire Dalby Sent: 05 April 2024 13:55 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: LRB-2024-13 CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson, Planning Application reference LRB-2024-13 (previously 22/01959/FLL) Land 30 metres West of St Columba’s Episcopal Church 19, Perth Road Stanley Mixed Use Development…. My objections to this proposed development remain the same as in my two communications 2023. These include Traffic/danger/congestion/parking Design/appearance/height/shade Reduced protection for War Memorial and Church from removal of gated enclosures Noise/disturbance in West Park, also effect on wildlife - during construction and in use I strongly agree with the decision by PKC to refuse planning permission for this proposed development based on its overbearing scale and inappropriate building style in relation to St Columba’s Church and the War Memorial. Claire Dalby
Page 316
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Lawrence Valentine Sent: 05 April 2024 13:02 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body; audrey.brown@pkc.gov.uk Subject: Planning Application Reference: 22/01959/FLL. Appeal. CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Good afternoon. I strongly support the proposal to build a much-needed community centre and sports and recreation facility in the growing village of Stanley. The Hall that is to be demolished, to make way for this community facility, has sat in a state of terrible disrepair for decades. It is of little architectural interest/value, and its loss, inconsequential. Conversely, the War Memorial is of great local value. It is pleasing to see that only minor adjustment to the boundary wall is necessary to provide access to the community facility. Councillors should grant planning permission and overturn the Officer's decision: a decision not taken in the interests of our growing community. Best regards. Eileen Valentine
Page 317
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Anne Sweet Sent: 05 April 2024 16:50 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Application Ref: 22/1959/FLL Importance: Low CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Ms Simpson Many thanks for your letter with regards to the above application by Stanley Development Trust. As a local, I am very much in favour of the development to build a much needed community hub, with sports facilities, in the village. The community is growing with housing developments underway and, on the whole, the feeling within the village and surrounding area is that the hub would be a major asset to the village for all residents. The St Columbas Church Hall that would require to be demolished hasn’t been in use for many years and is in a serious state of disrepair. It is unlikely the hall will ever be refurbished due to the cost required to do this and will deteriorate more as time goes on. The War Memorial is of great local value but only minor adjustment to the boundary wall is required to provide access which I don’t see as a great problem. The Stanley Community Action Plan was updated last year and one theme highlighted the lack of community facilities and amenities within the village for residents e.g breakfast club/after school club, community café, lack of facilities/ activities for young people etc which a community hub would be able to cater for. A huge amount of work has taken place to get to the planning application stage for this proposal and I think it would be really detrimental for the village and its residents if the planning application was not given approval. Yours sincerely Anne Sweet Sent from Mail for Windows
Page 318
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Lawrence Valentine Sent: 05 April 2024 12:54 To: CDS Planning Local Review Body; Subject: Planning Application Reference: 22/01959/FLL. Appeal. Attachments: Central Location of Proposed Hub.pdf CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Good afternoon. Further to the applicants application for a review of the Councils Decision to refuse Planning Permission for Stanley Community Centre, Application Reference: 22/01959/FLL, and the Perth & Kinross Local Review Body letter of the 22/03/04 I wish to make further representations as below. 1/ Formal Application by the Clients Agent The submission attached to the Refusal Notice review Application Form dated 06-03-24 is detailed, comprehensive and in my opinion makes a robust case for the Approval of the Planning Application, I would however like to add the following. 2/ Demolition of Church Hall. I would like to suggest that the refusal for the demolition of the Church Hall because of Listed Building status has not been adequately considered. Regardless of the question mark over the Church Halls listing, in my opinion the Hall is of no period architectural significance what so ever, it was obviously built at the lowest cost, it has no architectural features of any note and does not enhance the main church building in any form. Even Historic Environment Scotland note that the hall was closed before 1970 and is in a poor state of repair. It would not be wrong to say that the plain nondescript Hall detracts from the main Church building, which does indeed have some interesting features and architectural merit. I would point out that I am strongly supportive of the Historic Built Environment and indeed I live in a heritage property (1850) which has very distinctive period features and visitors always comment on how handsome and attractive the building is. I think it is probably fair to say that in over 100 years not one person walking down Perth Road has stopped by the Church and said some thing like "goodness, look how beautiful that hall is and how it enhances the Church", it just wouldn't have happened because the Hall is indeed very plain, insignificant and of no architectural merit.
Page 319
2 The Review Application has suggested that the most appropriate procedure for the handling of the Review would be "By means of inspection of the land to which the review relate". If a site inspection is indeed carried out then I am sure the review body will come to the same conclusion raised in my comments above. 3/ Location of the Sports & Community Centre (Hub) As the Council is aware Stanley Village is undergoing significant expansion with in excess of 500 dwellings planned as shown on the attached scan of drawing reference 17_00088_IPM-INDICATIVE_MASTERPLAN which was granted Planning Permission in Principal on the 24-08-18. Upon this drawing I have marked free hand in orange the location of the proposed Hub which you will note places it centrally in the current and expanded village, the location does indeed fulfil the true meaning of a "Hub". More importantly, the Hub with its toilets, showers and changing facilities is directly adjacent to the EXISTING Stanley AFC soccer field which of course is where the welfare facilities should be located. The Hub also directly overlooks the EXISTING bowling green and will allow a pleasant overview from the café of the bowling matches during the summer months, what's not to like with such an opportunity. As a sports facility it is simply in the right location adjacent to the EXISTING village sports facilities and as a Community Hub it could not be more centrally placed and accessible to the Stanley Community. 4/ Scale and Massing. It has been suggested that the scale of the Hub is not appropriate as a back drop to the Episcopal Church Listed in 2002 however I would suggest that when seen from the key view point of Perth Road it will still be the architectural interest of the Church itself and the War Memorial in the forefront that will catch the eye and not the backdrop of the lighter design Hub. In Perth City itself there numerous examples of modern architecture sitting next to churches and other listed buildings, indeed there are too many to mention but I will offer the example of the huge mass and scale of the Perth Concert Hall (constructed in 2003/4 and unlisted) sited between Mill Street and North Port directly and closely surrounded by the following listed buildings all of which are also within the Perth Central Conservation Area. Perth Art Gallery and Museum, George Street. "B" Listed in 1965. Fair Maids House, Curfew Row (North Port). "B" Listed 1965 Building on the site of Lord John Murrays Town House. Curfew Row (North Port). "B" Listed 1977 Buildings, North Port 8-16 (even numbers). "B" Listed 1977. Buildings, George Street 62, 64 (W Side) and 2 Bridge Lane. "C" Listed 1977. The above example clearly demonstrates that you can have very large scale and mass modern architecture sitting very close to listed buildings without detrimental impact to the character, special architectural or historic interest and setting of the adjacent listed buildings, for instance;
Page 320
3 A/ When standing in North Port to look at the historic Listed Fair Maids House your eye and observations are concentrated on the varied architectural features of the Fair Maids House and not the very huge mass of the rear of the modern Concert Hall just a few metres away. B/ When walking around the Listed Art Gallery, the modern roof brise soleil overhang of the Concert Hall is only approx. 2 metres away from the Listed Art Gallery but this does not detract from the architectural detail of the stonework etc on the side and rear facades of the Art Gallery, your eye and observations are concentrated on the detail of the Art Galleries 1930's stone extension and not the very modern Concert Hall just a few metres away. Relating this Concert Hall example to the proposed Stanley Hub demonstrates why I say that it will be the architectural interest of the Episcopal Church itself and the War Memorial in the forefront that will stand out and catch the eye and not the backdrop of the modern design Hub regardless of scale and mass which is, of course, exceptionally minor when compared to the example of the very large modern Concert Hall sitting right next to the very small historic Listed Fair Maids House. I would add that, having spent my whole career involved with Architects and architecture, it can be very enlightening to have modern placed next to Historic buildings because the differing period features and form can be compared with each other and actually add significant interest. I have also seen some brutal and inappropriate examples of modern placed next to listed Historic buildings but the proposed Stanley Hub just does not fall into this category. Summary. I have no direct involvement in the Planning Application or Stanley Development Trust, I comment as a member of the local community simply because I do take an interest in the Historic Built Environment and I don't consider that, in this instance, the proposed Application is harmful in that regard. The Hub proposal is for the benefit of the growing Stanley Community as a whole without any detrimental architectural impact due to scale, mass or location and therefore is to be commended and welcomed. If you require any further information or clarification of the above please do not hesitate to contact me. Lawrence Valentine HARD COPY HAND DELIVERED TO PULLAR HOUSE ON THE 05/04/2024.
Page 321
No embedded text on this page.
Page 322
1 CDS Planning Local Review Body From: Euan FS Pearson < > Sent: 18 April 2024 16:51 To: Cc: CDS Planning Local Review Body Subject: Re: LRB-2024-13 | Comments under Regulation 10(6) CAUTION: This email originated from an external organisation. Do not follow guidance, click links, or open attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe. Hello Audrey The Applicant makes the following comments under Regulation 10(6): * the vast majority of respondents support the project, and encourage Councillors to grant planning permission; and * a few respondents have misunderstood that the War Memorial will NOT be moved. Therefore, their objections can be discounted. As this completes the exchanges of written submissions, the Applicant asks that the matter be dealt with at the LRB meeting scheduled for 13 May. Regards Euan Euan FS Pearson MRTPI MRICS Pearson Planning, Chartered Surveyors PO Box 28606 | Edinburgh | United Kingdom EH4 9BQ 0843 886 1974 | RICS Regulated Firm 890096 Pearson Planning Surveyors Limited, 786595