Agenda Document Pack - Police and Fire and Rescue Committee - 15/08/2022
North Ayrshire Council · 15 August 2022
Back to Police and Fire and Rescue Committee — 15 August 2022 and its agenda
Text extracted from the council's PDF. Layout and reading order may differ from the original.
Page 1
North Ayrshire Council, Cunninghame House, Irvine KA12 8EE Police and Fire and Rescue Committee A Meeting of the Police and Fire and Rescue Committee of North Ayrshire Council will be held in the Council Chambers, Ground Floor, Cunninghame House, Irvine, KA12 8EE on Monday, 15 August 2022 at 14:00 to consider the undernoted business. 1 Apologies 2 Declarations of Interest Members are requested to give notice of any declarations of interest in respect of items of business on the Agenda. 3 Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Performance and Service Update Submit report by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service on performance in relation to the North Ayrshire Local Fire and Rescue Plan (copy enclosed). 4 Police Scotland Performance Update Submit report by Police Scotland on performance in relation to the North Ayrshire Local Policing Plan (copy enclosed). 5 Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Strategic Plan 2022-2025 Consultation Submit report by the Head of Democratic Services on the response submitted in response to the consultation (copy enclosed). 6 Review of Joint Strategic Police Plan 2020-2023 Submit report by the Head of Democratic Services on the review of the Joint Strategic Police Plan (copy enclosed). 7 Urgent Items Any other items which the Chair considers to be urgent. 1
Page 2
North Ayrshire Council, Cunninghame House, Irvine KA12 8EE Webcasting - All Meetings Please note: this meeting may be recorded/live-streamed to the Council's internet site and available to view at https://north-ayrshire.public- i.tv/core/portal/home, where it will be capable of repeated viewing. At the start of the meeting, the Provost/Chair will confirm if all or part of the meeting is being recorded/live-streamed. You should be aware that the Council is a Data Controller under the Data Protection Act 2018. Data collected during the webcast will be retained in accordance with the Council’s published policy, including, but not limited to, for the purpose of keeping historical records and making those records available via the Council’s internet site. Generally, the press and public seating areas will not be filmed. However, by entering the Council Chambers, using the press or public seating area and participating in this meeting by invitation, you are consenting to being filmed and consenting to the use and storage of those images and sound recordings and any information pertaining to you contained in them for webcasting or training purposes and for the purpose of keeping historical records and making those records available to the public. If you do not wish to participate in a recording, you should leave the physical or virtual meetings at this point. This will constitute your revocation of consent. If you have any queries regarding this and, in particular, if you believe that use and/or storage of any particular information would cause, or be likely to cause, substantial damage or distress to any individual, please contact dataprotectionofficer@north-ayrshire.gov.uk. 2
Page 3
North Ayrshire Council, Cunninghame House, Irvine KA12 8EE Police and Fire and Rescue Committee Sederunt Donald Reid (Chair) Nairn McDonald (Vice-Chair) Scott Davidson (from 12 August 2022) Scott Gallacher John Glover Jean McClung Davina McTiernan Donald L. Reid Angela Stephen John Sweeney Chair: Apologies: Attending: 3
Page 4
4
Page 5
Page | 1 Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Police & Fire and Rescue Committee – 15 August 2022 Subject Performance Report and Service updates Purpose To advise members of the Police and Fire Committee as to progress against North Ayrshire’s Local Fire and Rescue Plan and to provide committee members with other key Fire and Rescue Service updates Recommendation For members to note the information contained within this report 1. Introduction 1.1 On the 1st October 2019, the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) laid before the Scottish Parliament its new Strategic Plan for the period 2019-22. As a result of this publication, the Service is legally obliged to review its existing Local Fire and Rescue Plans for all 32 local authorities across Scotland. 1.2 The priorities contained within the current North Ayrshire Local Fire and Rescue Plan were formally approved at the full Council. The continuation of these priorities has been agreed for the 2021/22 period, via the Police & Fire and Rescue Committee, and will be subject to ongoing monitoring via this forum. 2. Performance Summary 2.1 An analysis of operational responses within North Ayrshire for the period 1st April to 30th June 2022 identified a 10.9% decrease in activity levels across the local authority when compared to the corresponding period in 2021. A further review of the three years average indicated a 3% decrease in overall operational activity during a similar timeframe. 2.2 In reviewing operational activity on a broader level, false alarms accounted for 54.4% of all demand within North Ayrshire, with fire related and special service activity accounting for 32.2% and 13.4% respectively. 2.3 For the period 1st April to 30th June 2022, overall progress is being monitored across six indicators, utilising the three-year rolling average as basis of measuring performance. Year on year and the rolling three-year average figures are also used to review short and long terms changes in demand and trends. 2.4 Further analysis of this performance is provided within the associated performance report (Appendix A). Agenda Item 3 5
Page 6
Page | 2 3. SFRS Updates 3.1 The consultation process for the draft SFRS Strategic Plan 2022-25 closed on the 10th July 2022. This will result in a review of the North Ayrshire Local Fire and Rescue Plan and its priorities on the publication of the new Strategic Plan. 3.2 The Local Senior Officer Area officially opened a Youth Volunteer Scheme at Kilwinning Community Fire Station on Thursday 28th April 2022. This programme contains young people from across the region, who will embark on a three-year programme until its completion or them reaching 18 years of age. 3.3 Managers from across the Local Senior Officer are continuing to participate in Carbon Literacy Training, via the North Ayrshire Community Planning Partnership. This training will further support managers to closer align the principles contained within the SFRS Climate Change Response Plan to the environmental and sustainability objectives that are aligned to the Local Outcome Improvement Plan. 3.4 The Ayrshire Local Senior Officer Area has developed a post non-domestic approach to help reduce the number of fires occurring within non-domestic [relevant] premises. This process is designed to support the general principles of Community Wealth Building and further reduce the impact fire can have on the local economy. 3.5 Local teams from across the Ayrshire Local Senior Officer Area have participated in a series of national organisational Courageous Conversations on Race events. These national development events were designed to enhance local teams understanding of the different needs of our diverse communities and to tailor service provisions more towards local needs; in line with the SFRS’s decision making pathway for mainstreaming equalities. These events were supported by representatives from Police Scotland, Ayrshire Division; who attended and actively enriched the conversations during the two-day event. 4. Proposal It is proposed that members of the Police & Fire and Rescue Committee: a) Note the contents of the performance summary and associated report for the period 1st April to 30 June 2022. b) Note the SFRS updates. 5. Implications 5.1 No implications have been identified at this time in respect of service delivery within North Ayrshire. 6
Page 7
Page | 3 6. Conclusion 6.1 Fire and Rescue Service activity is subject to regular monitoring and review and the local fire and rescue plan priorities identified within the Local Fire and Rescue Plan forms part of this reporting process. 6.2 Members of the Police & Fire and Rescue Committee will be kept up to date as to progress against the Local Fire and Rescue Plan and to any future fire and rescue service updates as they arise. Area Commander Ian McMeekin Local Senior Officer East Ayrshire, North Ayrshire and South Ayrshire Scottish Fire and Rescue Service For further information please contact Area Commander Ian McMeekin 01294 606811 7
Page 8
North Ayrshire Performance Report 1st April 2022 - 30th June 2022 8
Page 9
North Ayrshire Performance Report Table of Contents Local Fire and Rescue Service Plan Priorities 3 North Ayrshire Activity Summary 4 Domestic Safety - Accidental Dwelling Fires 5 Domestic Safety - Accidental Dwelling Fire Casualties 6 Unintentional Injury and Harm 7 Deliberate Fire Setting 8 Non-Domestic Fire Safety 9 Unwanted Fire Alarm Signals 10 Prevention & Protection 11 Retained Duty System 11 Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 2 9
Page 10
4 0 3 19 0 17 5 0 0 7 1 17 1 0 2 14 0 3 0 0 1 22 4 24 0 0 3 23 0 33 3 0 3 25 0 6 2 2 0 27 2 15 5 1 2 5 0 13 4 0 0 3 0 13 1 0 2 29 1 19 25 3 16 174 8 160 -32% 50% 0% -34% -11% 27% -12% 67% -14% -6% -26% -1% -6% 0% -8% -9% 4% 2%5 Year Average Change Stevenston North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Total Incidents Year on Year Change 3 Year Average Change Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning Accidental Dwelling Fires Accidental Dwelling Fire Casualties Unintentional Injury and Harm Deliberate Fire Setting Non-Domestic Fire Safety Unwanted Fire Alarm Signals Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Local Fire and Rescue Service Plan Priorities The Local Fire and Rescue Service Plan has been developed to set out the priorities and objectives withinNorthAyrshire and allows our local authority partners to scrutinise the performance outcomes of these priorities. We will continue to work closely with our partners in North Ayrshire to ensure we are all “Working Together for a Safer Scotland” through targeting risks to our communities at a local level. The plan has been developed to complement key partnership activity embedded across North Ayrshire'sCommunity Planning Partnership. Through effective and co-ordintated partnership working we will seek to deliver continuous improvement in our performance and effective service delivery in our area of operations. The Local Fire and Rescue Plan for North Ayrshire identified six areas for demand reduction and is subject to regular monitoring and reporting through the Police & Fire and Rescue Committee. A summary of the priorities and current activity is detailed below with further detail and analysis contained within this performance report. About the statistics within this report The activity totals and other statistics quoted within this report are published in the interests of transparency and openness. They are provisional in nature and subject to change as a result of ongoing quality assurance and review. Because all statistics quoted are provisional there may be a difference in the period totals quoted in our reports after local publication which result from revisions or additions to the data in our systems. The Scottish Government publishes official statistics each year which allow for comparisons to be made over longer periods of time. Activity levels have reduced by more than 5% Activity levels have reduced by up to 5% Activity levels have increased overall Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 3 10
Page 11
North Ayrshire Delivery Activity Summary Hour (am) Total Hour (pm) Total Midnight 12 Mid-day 38 1am 9 1pm 39 2am 12 2pm 27 3am 8 3pm 49 4am 12 4pm 46 5am 10 5pm 48 6am 10 6pm 70 7am 25 7pm 47 8am 29 8pm 60 9am 40 9pm 41 10am 35 10pm 21 11am 33 11pm 12 37% 13% 50% 32% 13% 54% Fires Special Services False Alarms Incidents by Classification Annual Ratio 3 Year Ratio 21.80% 21.80% 17.71% 8.86% 7.36% 3.68% 3.41% 1.91% 1.63% 1.63% 1.23% 1.23% 1.23% 1.23% 0.95% False Alarm (Dwelling) False Alarm (UFAS) Outdoor Fire False Alarm (Good Intent) Refuse Fire Dwelling Fire Special Service - Effecting… Special Service - No action (not… Other Building Fire Other Primary Fire Special Service - Lift Release False Alarm (Malicious) Special Service - RTC Special Service - Assist other… Special Service - Flooding Top 15 Incident Types by % of Total Incidents 238 fires primary & secondary special services 98 false alarms 398 6% totalnumber of incidents 734 -14% -54% fire casualties 3 50% non-fire casualties 16 -1% 0% 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11121314 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 00 Activityby Time of Day 66.61%RDSHome Fire Safety Visits Carried Out 226 Fire Safety Audits Carried Out 99 Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 4 11
Page 12
-32% -12% -6% Main Source of Ignition Year on Year 3 Year Average 5 Year Average Domestic Safety - Accidental Dwelling Fires Domesti 37 45 38 30 37 25 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 Performance Summary AccidentalDwelling Fires to Date Detection Present 80% 95% Detection Actuated Calls Made via Linked Alarms 16% Automatic Detection & Actuation 4 5 1 0 0 3 2 5 4 1 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston 3.5 3.9 0.8 0.0 0.0 2.3 1.2 3.1 3.0 0.8 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston Incidents Per 10,000 Population - North Ayrshire Human Factors Accidental DwellingFires by Ward Area Alcohol/DrugImpairment Distraction Incidents Per 10,000 Population - Ayrshire 1.6 1.8 1.5 1.7 East Ayrshire North Ayrshire South Ayrshire Ayrshire Severity of Accidental Dwelling Fires No FirefightingAction Direct Firefighting 44% 12% 84% 4% 4% 4% 4% 0% 0% 0% Not applicable Item 1st ignited Room of origin Floor of origin Limited to 2 floors More than 2 floors Whole building Whole Roof Extent of Fire Damage 24% 12% Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 5 12
Page 13
50% 67% 0% Year on Year 3 Year Average 5 Year Average Domestic Safety - Accidental Dwelling Fire Casualties 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 - 9 10 - 19 20 - 49 50 - 79 80+ 3 10 1 0 2 3 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 Unintentional Injury or First Aidat Scene Hospital Serious HospitalSlight Injuries Fatal Injuries 0 Performance Summary Accidental Dwelling Fire Casualties Year to Date Extent of Harm Age / Gender Profile Casualties Per 10,000 Population - North Ayrshire Fire Casualties by Ward Area 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 0 0 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.05 0.02 0.00 0.00 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston Casualties Per 10,000 Population - Ayrshire 0.08 0.22 0.09 0.13 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 East Ayrshire North Ayrshire South Ayrshire Ayrshire 0% 100 2 2 Breathing difficulties Asphyxiation Burns – slight Other medical condition Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 6 13
Page 14
0% -14% -8% Year on Year 3 Year Average 5 Year Average Unintentional Injury or Harm 0 0 1 4 2 0 0 4 3 2 0 - 9 10 - 19 20 - 49 50 - 79 80+ Slight Injuries 26 47 24 19 16 16 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 Deliberate Performance Summary Special Service Casualties Year to Date Age / Gender Profile 2.6 0.0 1.6 0.9 2.0 2.3 0.0 1.2 0.0 1.6 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston Extent of Harm Non-Fire Casualties by Ward Area 3 0 2 1 3 3 0 2 0 2 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston Casualties Per 10,000 Population - North Ayrshire Non-Casualties Per 10,000 Population - Ayrshire 1.1 1.2 2.1 1.5 East Ayrshire North Ayrshire South Ayrshire Ayrshire 44% 56% First Aidat Scene Hospital Serious 4 6 Fatal Injuries 1 Hospital Slight Injuries Road Traffic Collision Water Rescue Assisting Other Agencies 31% 6% 50% All Other Incidents 13% Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 7 14
Page 15
-34% -13% -9% Year on Year 3 Year Average 5 Year Average Deliberate Fire Setting 282 248 264 163 264 174 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 282 248 264 163 264 174 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 1,200 1,400 All Deliberate Fires Non Performance Summary Deliberate Fires Year to Date Deliberate Fires by Classification Deliberate Fires Compared to OperationalActivity Incidents Per 10,000 Population - North Ayrshire 16.4 5.5 11.1 19.7 15.2 18.8 15.5 3.1 2.3 22.8 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston Deliberate Fires by Ward Area 19 7 14 22 23 25 27 5 3 29 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston Slight Injuries Incidents Per 10,000 Population - Ayrshire 12.6 12.8 7.5 11.1 East Ayrshire North Ayrshire South Ayrshire Ayrshire All Other Incidents 6% 14% 6% 10% 3% 7% 94% 86% 94% 90% 97% 93% 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 Primary Secondary Secondary Fire Ratio by Activity Type 30% 70% Refuse Other Secondary Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 8 15
Page 16
-11% -26% 4% Year on Year 3 Year Average 5 Year Average Non-Domestic Fire Safety 62% 25% 13% Accidental Deliberate Not Known 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Public Utilities Retail Education Non-Residential Residential Unwanted PerformanceSummary Non-Domestic Fires Year to Date Non-Domestic Fires by Nature of Origin Incidents Per 10,000 Population - Ayrshire Non-Domestic Fires by Premises Type Incidents Per 10,000 Population - North Ayrshire 0.0 0.8 0.0 3.6 0.0 0.0 1.2 0.0 0.0 0.8 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston Non-Domestic Fires by Ward Area 0 1 0 4 0 0 2 0 0 1 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston 0.5 0.6 0.6 0.6 East Ayrshire North Ayrshire South Ayrshire Ayrshire 6 13 16 6 9 8 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 3 1 2 1 1 Not applicable Limited to item 1st ignited Limited to room of origin Limited to floor of origin Roof space and other floors Limited to 2 floors (not… Extent of Fire Damage Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 9 16
Page 17
27% -1% 2% Year on Year 3 Year Average 5 Year Average Unwanted Fire Alarm Signals 149 154 163 119 126 160 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 UFAS Percentage Against all False Alarms Performance Summary Unwanted Fire Alarm Signals Year to Date Incidents Per 10,000 Population - North Ayrshire 14.7 13.4 2.4 21.5 21.9 4.5 8.6 8.1 9.9 14.9 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston 747 664 635 628 678 59218% 22% 24% 18% 17% 26% 0%0 300 600 900 1,200 1,500 1,800 2,100 2,400 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 All Incidents UFAS Activty UFAS Percentage Against all Incidents 346 348 389 363 375 398 44% 44% 47% 38% 40% 49% 0%0 300 600 900 1,200 1,500 All False Alarms UFAS Activty Home Fire Safety Visits Unwanted FireAlarms Signals by Ward Area 17 17 3 24 33 6 15 13 13 19 Ardrossan & Arran Dalry & West Kilbride Irvine East Irvine South Irvine West Kilbirnie & Beith Kilwinning North Coast & Cumbraes Saltcoats Stevenston Incidents Per 10,000 Population - Ayrshire 12.7 11.8 13.2 12.5 East Ayrshire North Ayrshire South Ayrshire Ayrshire 26% 11% 13% 9% 11% Unwanted Fire Alarm Signals - Top 5 Premises Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 10 17
Page 18
38.26% 93.06% 82.95% 73.01% 43 25:07:23 8 600% 17.63% 69.48% 58.37% 49.95% 84 44:15:21 11 900% 15.76% 71.90% 49.46% 46.91% 45 22:31:56 8 625% 56.55% 70.25% 75.88% 68.24% 86 51:58:36 12 1050% 32.74% 21.13% 38.04% 30.81% 65 33:00:01 7 600% 89.77% 91.02% 88.86% 89.85% 78 44:44:42 11 850% 23.26% 41.96% 32.73% 32.99% 17 6:59:40 7 525% 92.84% 96.99% 87.66% 92.32% 55.13% 76.85% 35.53% 55.17% 98.29% 98.52% 97.82% 98.19% 13 8:09:28 8 800% 95.61% 96.17% 94.15% 95.26% 10 7:41:11 10 950% 55.99% 85.33% 67.40% 66.61% 70.18% 96.28% 90.41% 86.36% Mon - Thu (18:00 - 08:00) Weekend (Fri 18:00 - Mon 08:00) Total Lamlash North Ayrshire Ayrshire Total Mobilisations Total Time Deployed Largs Skelmorlie Millport -1 Millport - 2 Brodick Ardrossan Dreghorn Dalry Beith Kilbirnie Appliance Availability Mon - Fri (08:00 - 18:00) No. of Personnel Contracts 4 13 1250%2:16:20 Home Fire Safety Visits Home Fire Safety Visits Carried Out Percentage of HighRisk Home Fire Safety Visits Carried Out Percentage of Visits Carried Out FollowingAttendance at an Incident 226 29% 39% Top 5 Premises Smoke Detectors Fitted During Home Fire Safety Visits 631 Fire Safety Audits Carried Out 99 New Audits 88% Post Fire Audits 10% Complaint Audits 0% Re-Audits 2% 2% 89% 8% 0% 2% Broadly Compliant Areas of Improvement Notice of Deficiencies Enforcement Notice Prohibition Notice Fire Safety Audits Retained Duty System Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 11 18
Page 19
Glossary of Terms Term- What it means ADF Accidental Dwelling Fire CSET Community Safety Engagement Toolkit is a internal IT system used to record home fire safety visits and community safety activities FSET Fire Safety Experiential Training is a bespoke training programme developed by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service in Ayrshire and delivered to community planning partners to raise awareness of fire safety within the domestic environment HFSV Home Fire Safety Visit PDIR Post Domestic Incident Response, a term used by Prevention and Protection Directorate to indicate actions taken following attendance at a fire or other incident in the home. PDIRs include amongst things the offer of a free follow-up home fire safety visit Primary Fires These include all fires in buildings, vehicles and outdoor structures or any fire involving casualties, rescues or fires attended by five or more appliances RDS Retained Duty System. Professional on call firefighters who may have other primary employment responsibilities outside the Fire and Rescue Service but respond to emergency calls within their local area as and when required RTC Road Traffic Collision Secondary Fires These are the majority of outdoor fires including grassland and refuse fires unless they involve casualties or rescues, property loss or fire or more appliances attend. They include fires in single derelict buildings Special Service Calls to incidents which are not fires or false alarms such as RTCs, rescues, flooding, incidents involving hazardous materials or the provision of assistance to other agencies UFAS Unwanted Fire Alarm Signals. When an automatic fire detection and alarm system is activated as a result of anything other than an actual fire the activation is classed as a false alarm. If an attendance is made to such an event by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, then the event is recorded as an UFAS incident Scottish Fire and Rescue Service | North Ayrshire Performance Report 12 19
Page 20
20
Page 21
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 1 North Ayrshire Performance Summary Report - Q1 2022/23 Reporting Period: 01/04/2022 - 30/06/2022 Total Crime 2,848 Crimes -1.3% Incidents Recorded 8,955 -20.8%* -0.3% 397 Violence/Homicide Drug Supply -52.8% 10 Sexual Crime -15.6% 68 2.6%* 32 Hate Crime ASB -29.7%* 1,968 Domestic Abuse -21.7%* 214 Housebreaking -19.6% 27 Robbery -15.3% 10 Fraud 62.7% 82 Speeding -2.4% 141 Drink/Drug Driving 32.7% 56 Note: All percentage figures are based on the 5-year average with all data based on Management Information which may be subject to change. *5-yr Average is locally produced and not MI Agenda Item 4 21
Page 22
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 2 Introduction This document has been compiled to look at the quarterly data available for North Ayrshire. The report will be based on the areas of focus identified within the Local Policing Plan agreed with the Local Authority. The ‘Plan on a Page’ document is available on Page 4, this provides details of the areas Police Scotland have agreed to report on. This document will provide an overview of crime and incidents based on the requirements of the LPP. However there will be areas where reporting will be on a rotational/exceptions basis particularly within the Safer Communities and Community Wellbeing Priori- ties. The following list of contents provides an overview of the items included in this report: TOPIC SECTION PAGE Local Policing Plan Plan on a Page 3 Serious Crime Violence/Homicide Drug Supply Sexual Crimes 5 6 7 Safer Communities Domestic Abuse Hate Crime Antisocial Behaviour 8 9 10 Acquisitive Crime Housebreaking/Fraud Robberies 11 12 Community Wellbeing 13 Road Safety - Drink/Drug Driving Speeding 14 15 Public Confidence User Satisfaction Survey Complaints 16 17 22
Page 23
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 3 23
Page 24
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 4 North Ayrshire Performance Summary Report - Year End 2021/22 Reporting Period: 01/04/2021 - 31/03/2022 Total Crime 10,915 Crimes -9.0% Incidents Recorded 37,102 -13.3%* 5.0% 1,626 Violence/Homicide Drug Supply 0.6% 95 Sexual Crime 17.0% 322 17.0%* 143 Hate Crime ASB -12.2% * 8,377 Domestic Abuse -4.1%* 1,022 Housebreaking -36.4% 197 Robbery -25.4% 30 Fraud 62.3% 295 Speeding -9.5% 427 Drink/Drug Driving 23.1% 207 Note: All percentage figures are based on the 5-year average with all data based on Management Information which may be subject to change. *5-yr Average is locally produced and not MI 24
Page 25
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 5 SERIOUS CRIME—Violence/Homicide Analytical Context: Violent crime is currently down 0.3% on the 5-year average. Serious Assaults have reduced markedly with just 7 crimes recorded in the first quarter compared with 14 last year and a 5-year average of 21.2. Detection rates are currently lower at 57.1% compared to 85.7% last year, however work is ongoing to investigate the outstanding crimes. Four of these crimes have taken place within the home with one being domestic related. 5 of the crimes have noted alcohol consumption as a potential factor. Five of the victims were male and three have taken place in Kilwinning. There have been no Murders in the reporting period, however there have been four Attempted Murders, all of which have been detected. Three involved a bladed weapon and one involved a vehicle driven at the victim. Minor Assaults on members of the public continue to show increased numbers, compared with both last year and the 5-year average (see chart below). Notably 7 assaults on retail workers have been recorded in Q1 and these are included in these figures. April currently shows the greatest volume of crimes reported, however 65 crimes have been reported during the Q1 period which did not take place during these three months. Of these 44 are considered non-recent. The current detection rate is 60.3% which is above the figure last year (53.5%) but lower than the 5-year average (63.9%). Local Action/Context: There continues to be proactivity by staff in terms of identifying any repeat victims, offenders and locations which allow measures to be introduced to prevent any further escalations. The Community Wellbeing Unit have undertaken some successful diversionary work with a previous violent offender who is now engaging with services and pursuing an Army career. Local officers continue to be proactively deployed to any repeat locations and a number of successful action plans have resulted in the recovery of offensive weapons and bladed items. The night time economy continues to expand and there has been a significant increase in visits to licensed premises with 1070 inspections completed during this reporting period, compared to only 139 reported incidents. Common assault reports are subject of daily management review and scrutiny and any evidential opportunities are swiftly and fully exploited and this is evidenced in the rise in detections. This review extends to specialist departments who support local officers in the identification and apprehension of offenders. There continues to be proactive engagement with retailers, a focused poster campaign highlighting that violence against retails workers is unacceptable. A non recent enquiry continues to successfully focus on identification of historic offending and offenders and it is anticipated as the Major enquiry develops a number of these common assault offences will be detected. Source: Taken from Police Scotland Business Intelligence Portal Source: Taken from Police Scotland Business Intelligence Portal 25
Page 26
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 6 SERIOUS CRIME—Drug Supply Source: Taken from Police Scotland Business Intelligence Portal Analytical Context: Drug Supply charges are currently down 52.8% on the 5-year average. In Q1 there has been a marked reduction (n= 10) in the number of charges being brought compared with both last year (n=42) and the 5-year average (n=21.2). Cannabis cultivations have also recorded a decrease this year with 5 being identified compared with 7 last year. Proactivity remains the main focus and means by which these charges are obtained, however identifying any real patterns to where these crimes are taking place is often difficult. As stated previously, identifying potential suppliers is more likely to be the result of combined work with local officers and Divisional staff, building on the Community Intelligence provided by North Ayrshire residents, Community groups, etc. Local Action/Context: Ayrshire Division continues to benefit from a dedicated Proactive Crime Team (PACT) and within North Ayrshire officers continue to be supported by our Priority Policing Team (PPT). The teams continue to proactively target those who are concerned in the supply of controlled drugs, develop local intelligence and progress issues identified by members of the community. During this reporting period, significant results with regards to restraining of criminal assets have been made, targeting those involved in Serious and Organised Crime (SOC), particularly targeting those individuals who continue to engage in serious and organised crime. In the reporting period North Ayrshire have seized £65,915.30 from those engaged in SOC. North Ayrshire continue to focus on the threats and risks associated with county lines crimes and work with partners to raise awareness in community and educational settings of the warning signs. Local Campus officers continue to raise awareness of the issues within the education setting. Preventions and Interventions Officers have been promoting Crimestoppers as a means to report anonymously. The new online Neighbourhood Watch scheme utilised by Preventions officers. 26
Page 27
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 7 SERIOUS CRIME—Sexual Crime Analytical Context: Sexual crime is currently down 15.6% on the 5-year average. Q1 has noted a decrease in Sexual Assaults while crimes of Rape have increased slightly. Non-recent crimes have reduced markedly on those being reported last year. In total there have been 68 Sexual crimes reported in the first quarter this year of which 7 are non-recent, this compares with 85 crimes in the same period last year of which 20 were non-recent. Detection rates currently sit at 86.8%, significantly above last year (43.5%) and the 5-year average (54.1%). This is reflected in Rape detections which is currently 84.6% and Sexual Assault detections at 100%. Police Scotland has made a concerted effort to raise awareness and encourage survivors of sexual abuse to report incidents regardless of when they occurred. Every report is investigated thoroughly, albeit there can be challenges with tracing witnesses or securing forensic opportunities. Local Action/Context: It remains unacceptable that these violent and abhorrent crimes are still taking place and North Ayrshire Police remains committed to education, working with partners and challenging behaviours. Campus officers are continuing to work proactively with young persons to highlight reporting mechanisms and danger signs from those who wish to cause them sexual harm. Police Scotland continues to promote the multiple award winning “That Guy” campaign and its positive approach in changing and challenging unacceptable male behaviours, not the actions of victims. It is gratifying that evidence continues to show increased confidence in reporting sexual crime to Police Scotland. In addition an increase has been noted in reports from our partner agencies such as Rape Crisis and Women’s Aid as counselling and support services return to normal levels of service. Feedback generated by victims to Rape Crisis describing and evaluating their experience with our trained officers in Ayrshire has been overwhelmingly positive this year and shows our continued commitment to support and provide the best service to victims of sexual crime. North Ayrshire police and partners continue to work together to raise awareness of reporting mechanisms, support measures and to encourage survivors of abuse to come forward and engage with services. Campus officers are continuing to work proactively with young persons to highlight reporting mechanisms and danger signs from those who wish to cause them sexual harm. Source: Taken from Crime Management through ScOMIS 27
Page 28
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 8 SAFER COMMUNITIES—Domestic Abuse Source: Data taken from iVPD through ScOMIS Analytical Context: Domestic Abuse crimes are currently down 21.7% on the 5-year average. Crimes in Q1 are down slightly compared to last year (214 this year compared with 220 last year) however the trend across the quarter is noticeably different as shown in the chart opposite. In 2021/22 crimes increased month on month while this year crimes showed a peak in April but the figures for May and June have decreased below those noted last year. Examination of the types of domestic abuse committed during these first three months indicates that the majority of crimes continue to be minor assaults however there has been one Serious Assault, 8 Rapes and 7 Domestic Abuse Act crimes (examples include Stalking and/or Coercive behaviour). Local Action/Context: 2022 will see the start of a major new collaboration project between Police Scotland and its partners in Ayrshire in the setting up of the MARAC (Multi Agency Risk Assessment Conference). MARAC is set to provide additional safeguarding to the highest risk victims of domestic violence across the region. Monthly conferences will be chaired by Police Scotland and with representation from Social Work and all involved agencies, local authority and third sector. The outcome will be a swift, pro-active and joined up approach to ensure the best possible outcome for victims within realistic timescales and with minimal delay. Ayrshire Division has committed to the continued investigation of domestic crime and the provision of the best services to victims, with the introduction of a new team who will work alongside the existing Domestic Abuse Investigation Unit. From July 2022 the Domestic Abuse Safeguarding Team (DAST) will provide a victim centred approach to creating better outcomes for those affected by domestic violence as well as focussing on prevention through the DSDAS process. North Ayrshire continues to benefit from the now well established Womans Aid premises in Saltcoats, I have reached out to them regarding some additional police funding available which will hopefully secure additional alarms for victims. The highly successful Ask for Angela campaign continues to be supported by Police Scotland in licensed premises across North Ayrshire. The 16 days Violence against Woman Campaign continues to be successful and promoted by North Ayrshire Police. 28
Page 29
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 9 SAFER COMMUNITIES—Hate Crime Source: Taken from the iVPD database through ScOMIS Analytical Context: Hate crimes is currently 2.6% above the 5-year average. However in Q1 there has been a decrease noted when compared to last year (30 this year down from 36). Note that a single crime can have more than one hate crime type, for example one incident could feature homophobic and sectarian language. The chart opposite provides a breakdown of the different types of hate related crimes and highlights an increase in both Racial and Transphobic crimes but decreases in Homophobic and Religious crimes. At this stage in the year there are no repeat victims. Local Action/Context: Each hate crime victim receives a letter containing details of the enquiry officer and the investigations that are taking place to apprehend offenders. There continues to be proactivity by staff in terms of identifying any repeat victims, offenders and locations which allow measures to be introduced to prevent any further escalations. All evidential opportunities are taken to identify offenders and Community Wellbeing Unit colleagues routinely engage with offenders to divert them from further criminality. North Ayrshire Police continues to work closely with Community Wellbeing Unit and partners to engage with vulnerable victims and provide any additional partnership support. Campus officers continue to work closely with schools to raise awareness around the impact and effect of hate crimes. Staff at Barony House have been trained on the “Keep Safe Scotland” course. Refresher and new training has been provided to staff at Irvine Library and visited every Keep Safe Premises in North Ayrshire to confirm their compliance and continued interest in remaining on the I Am Me website. In June 2022 a #DontTolerateHate campaign was conducted across North Ayrshire via Facebook and Twitter mediums. Officers attended at Irvine Beat FM and a further inputs were provided on the campaign at community centres and local surgeries. 29
Page 30
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 10 SAFER COMMUNITIES—Antisocial Behaviour Analytical Context: ASB Incidents are currently down 29.7% on the 5-year average. All three months of this year so far are recording much lower figures compared with last year and the 5-year average as detailed in the second chart below. Around 21.8% of incidents this quarter have resulted in a crime report being raised. It is assessed that approximately 14% of ASB incidents are youth related. There has also been a decrease in the number of ASB fixed penalty tickets issued during Q1 this year (n=23) compared with last year (n=35). However the reason for tickets being issued remains the same with the majority being issued for Breach of the Peace. Local Action/Context: Joint working has continued between British Transport Police (BTP), Police, Scotrail and local officers at train stations throughout Ayrshire (Operation Simplifier). This is a BTP operation designed to curb anti social behaviour in and around railway platforms. A number of Safer Shores initiatives have been held at Irvine Beach where officers from local and specialist departments as well as partners from a range of agencies have worked together to promote public safety on North Ayrshire beaches. Working closely with Scotrail and BTP significant seizures of alcohol were made, reducing the risk of anti social behaviour for all residents and visitors to have fun and enjoy their visit to the coast. North Ayrshire have been working closely with partners regarding the regeneration of Bourtreehill Park, Irvine, where the community have highlighted anti social behaviour as a barrier for visiting this area. An action plan was implemented to target peak days and times of youths using this park for drinking and to enhance public confidence. High visibility patrols and the use of social media received positive community feedback. There was an immediate reduction in anti social behaviour and youths attending to consume alcohol. Largs officers have undertaken extensive consultations with children via youth groups and local schools and feedback was that local children wanted access to sporting facilities. Through community engagements and partners area haves been made available for use throughout the summer period. Early indications are that the scheme is effective with no issues or incidents being reported. Local Irvine and Kilwinning officers continue to work closely with Eglington Park and engage in proactive patrols in response to concerns of antic social behaviour. Officers continue to work closely with North Ayrshire Council and Scottish Fire and Rescue Service in relation to concerns around disused buildings, including Arran Brewery in Dreghorn and North Ayrshire Central Hospital in Irvine. Work is ongoing with Historic Environment Scotland and North Ayrshire Council to identify and ASB issues at known historical buildings and monuments. Source: Taken from STORM data extracted through ScOMIS 30
Page 31
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 11 ACQUISITIVE CRIME—Housebreaking / Fraud Analytical Context: Housebreakings are currently down 19.6% on the 5-year average. The picture in Q1 this year shows very similar numbers to those recorded last year with domestic properties recording the same number of crimes and non-dwelling property recording one more whilst commercial premises recording one less. The detection rate is currently 17.1% which is below both last year (19.5%) and the 5-year average (25.9%). Examination of the commercial housebreakings shows no repeat locations so far, however two schools have been targeted and one pharmacy. Frauds are currently up 62.7% on the 5-year average. Q1 indicates that the upward trend of Frauds is continuing with crimes showing an increase of 67.3% on the figure from last year. However as can be seen from the chart below, Q1 in 2021 was significantly lower compared to 2020. The current detection rate is 14.6% which is below both last year (20.4%) and the 5-year average (27.8%). Local Action/Context: The majority of recorded crimes appear to both spontaneous and opportunistic with the majority occurring during the day. Analytical work is ongoing to support a renewed focus and governance around the issue to improve the detections rates which are increasing during quarter 1. All housebreaking crime reports are subject to rigorous review and scrutiny to identify all evidential opportunities. It is anticipated that when forensic updates are received a number of other opportunities to apprehend offenders will be available. All victims in North Ayrshire are contacted by the Preventions and Interventions Officer to provide safety advice and support to protect their properties All victims of fraud in North Ayrshire receive safety and support advice from the dedicated Crime Prevention Officer. This officer also proactively engages with banks and building societies in terms of modus operandi of offenders and any vulnerable victims, often resulting in victims being reimbursed. Bespoke Police Scotland anti fraud leaflets have been secured and distributed around banks, building societies, retail premises and medical establishments. In addition regular social media updates are provided around frauds and preventative measures can be taken. Source: Taken from Police Scotland Business Intelligence Portal Source: Taken from Police Scotland Business Intelligence Portal 31
Page 32
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 12 ACQUISITIVE CRIME—Robberies Source: Taken from Police Scotland Business Intelligence Portal Local Action/Context: Robberies remain a key priority and daily focus for North Ayrshire, enhanced governance and scrutiny demonstrate that all crimes are thoroughly investigated and any offenders are identified and apprehended at the earliest opportunity. In the vast majority of reported crimes YTD the perpetrator and victim/witnesses are assessed to know each other however in most instances those involved are largely uncooperative or actively hostile with Police investigations. Of those currently undetected one is now marked for “No Crime” whilst another 3 are actively getting investigated. Only one has occurred at a commercial premise (again still currently under investigation) and there are no repeat or vulnerable victims or loci. Dedicated town centre officers proactively engage with retailers regarding preventative measure and raising awareness around repeat offenders. CCTV liaison is ongoing regarding upgrading of CCTV cameras and locations and our Local Authority Liaison Officer is proactively engaging with the Local Authority. Preventative measures continue, including those known offenders subject to bail conditions are subject to routine checks to ensure they are complying with their conditions, any issues identified during these checks can be escalated to the relevant agency. We remain committed to tackling the factors that could lead to offenders committing such crimes, and continue to work closely with partners to ensure appropriate support is in place reducing the likelihood of offending. Analytical Context: Robberies are currently down 15.3% on the 5-year average. Notably Q1 has recorded a slight increase in robberies compared to last year (10 compared with 8 last year) however this was primarily due to a spike in April. The current detection rate is 80% which is above the 5-year average (74.6%). At this stage it is noted that half of the crimes have taken place within the home, two in a shop and the remainder in an outdoor public location. Five have involved the use/ threat of a knife or bladed weapon. There are no repeat victims or offenders at this stage. The items most commonly being taken are mobile phones and cash. 32
Page 33
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 13 COMMUNITY WELLBEING Local Action/Context: Substance Misuse CWU officers engaged with a vulnerable female from, Irvine after various concern for calls regarding mental health and long term addiction issues. Female supported and signposted to services and into local 12 step fellowship CA programme. Officers maintaining contact/support. In response to a concern for person call from social work services where a 19 year old female residing in, Irvine was suicidal and suffering from ongoing addiction issues, CWU officers have engaged. This female is now a regular recipient of all partner services and steps are now being taken to support her ongoing wellbeing issues. Youth Engagement There is ongoing engagement with looked after and accommodated children in Irvine and Kilwinning which has seen a reduction in them being reported as missing per- son. CWU officers engaging with the Street League Team who are delivering 10 week youth engagement programme in North Ayrshire, officers will now link in with this ongo- ing programme and support efforts to divert participants and encourage/link into employment opportunities. Welfare Concerns CWU officers engagement with a repeat high risk missing person twice who attempted suicide. Male and family engaged, support provided to address marital issues and employment matters. Male subject who had suicidal ideation now seeking additional support from health partners. CWU officers identified a repeat concern for a vulnerable male in Dalry. Following multiple joint support visits with Adult Support and Protection, an emergency place of safety was found and subject is now housed within a full time local authority care home. Partners Positive engagement with KA Leisure and local partners who are collectively seeking to set up a Hub Approach involving multi-service involvement to address emerging community issues which cut across all services. Funding is being applied for via Scottish Government’s Cashback For Communities Fund to set up a community wellbeing programme to address ASB within the 10-25 year old age group in North Ayrshire. This will be linked into supporting those age appropriate individuals involved, to gain access to identified employment vacancies within local partner agencies. Development of Information Sharing Agreement between, NHS, Local Authority and Police Scotland to allow details of those in the community who have suffered a Near Fatal Drugs Overdose to be passed to CWU officers. Ongoing work between, National Health Service, Local Authority to develop an Information Sharing Protocol to allow those in our communities who have suffered a near fatal drugs overdose to be passed to CWU officers to allow early engagement and intervention. 33
Page 34
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 14 ROAD SAFETY—Drink/Drug Driving Source: Taken from Police Scotland Business Intelligence Portal Analytical Context: Drink/Drug driving offences are currently up 32.7% on the 5-year average. It should be noted that new legislation around drug driving came into effect in October 2019. So far this year there have been a total of 56 offences recorded which is a decrease on last year (n=63). Solely Drink Driving remains the most perpetrated offence followed by solely Drug Driving, however both are currently recording lower numbers than those reported last year. Local Action/Context: Road Safety remains a key priority in North Ayrshire with activity of both Road Policing and Divisional resources targeted towards the outcomes set in the Scottish Government Road Safety Framework – 2020 – 2030. Within the parameters of this is the ongoing determination to reduce casualties on the road and impact and disrupt those who use the road illegally in respect of criminal activities, and whilst disqualified and under the influence of drink and drugs. Underpinning the efforts of police in North Ayrshire is the PSOS Road Policing Division, National Calendar of Activity which allocates specific periods to target areas such as Speeding, Insurance and Drink and Drug offending. In addition, officers have been encouraged to engage with vulnerable groups such as cyclists, pedestrian and older drivers to educate against the dangers of using roads whilst not always equipped to do so. Campaigns such as these are supported by Safer Scotland Media Campaigns, literature and other forms of messaging. In terms of the 1st quarter of 2022, the number of persons caught either impaired through the consumption of controlled substances, or intake of alcohol is slightly below the previous year but remains at a level that is unacceptable for those using the roads. Driving whilst impaired causes an unnecessary danger to road users. The impact of the Section 5A drug driving legislation has seen a number of cases delayed by Laboratory back-logs and therefore those using the roads can continue to do so when disqualifications would be the most likely disposal. Officers from Ayrshire Road Policing will continue to target drivers who use the roads under the influence of drink or drugs and utilise the Medacx drug wipes that detect cannabis and cocaine users. 34
Page 35
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 15 ROAD SAFETY—Speeding Source: Taken from Crime Management through ScOMIS Analytical Context: Speeding offences are currently down 2.4% on the 5-year average. The start of this year has also noted a slight decrease on the figures recorded last year (see chart opposite). The Road Policing Unit continue to carry out initiatives in specific areas based on information from local communities and Elected Members, which may influence where offences occur. Local Action/Context: Road Safety remains a key priority in North Ayrshire with activity of both Road Policing and Divisional resources targeted towards the outcomes set in the Scottish Government Road Safety Framework – 2020 – 2030. Speeding remains a key community concern with complaints of excessive speed present within areas of most communities. In North Ayrshire, Road Policing Units and Locality Policing Officers with specialist training in the operation of speed detection devices routinely deploy in those areas, roads and routes that generate the most concern. Locally, officers have listened to the community and spent time in areas such as Greenock Road, Largs, Fairlie Village, the A737 passing through Kilwinning and targeted speeding drivers and HGV’s using these routes without due care and attention. North Ayrshire Towns such as Ardrossan, Saltcoats and Burnhouse, all with historical speeding issues, remain very much on the radar for Road Policing Officers and attention has been given to the town centre of Irvine to enforce restrictions to protect pedestrians. In the first Quarter of 2022, a slight reduction in speeding detections has been recorded and Road Policing Officers remain vigilant at many locations to ensure those who do continue to speed are stopped and dealt with accordingly through direct measures. In the Summer months of 2022, a Islands Road Safety Action Plan remains ongoing with Road Policing Officers deploying to Millport and Arran to support local officers with a view to promoting safe driving on the islands to preserve the safety of vulnerable groups such as cyclists, walkers and tourists. 35
Page 36
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 16 PUBLIC CONFIDENCE—Survey Information User Experience - Current Position The information on the table below is from data gathered in the April to June 2022 period for the whole of Ayrshire and is not specific to North Ayrshire. It should also be noted that the ‘Feeling adequately informed’ question has changed this year and only applies to those who stated they expected to be kept informed. Your Survey The following information is based on data from April and May—June data currently unavailable. Local Action/Context: The Your Police Survey remains open for all police and members of the public to provide their views on Policing in the Local Community. The data currently available covers April – June 2022 and members may not that the number of responders is currently low however feedback is relatively positive. Local officers continue to promote engagement with Your Police Survey at all events and community engagements. Questions YTD Force YTD Female Male Blank/ Other Number of Respondents 251 3752 103 68 80 Ease of Contact? (% Easy and Very Easy) 67% 72% 74% 76% 50% Being provided with the appropriate response? (% Yes) 55% 63% 63% 61% 40% Feeling adequately informed about progress made with your report 48% 49% 49% 54% 43% Overall Satisfaction? (% Satisfied or Very Satisfied) 63% 67% 71% 72% 46% How Safe do you feel in your local area? Male Female Total Respondents Very Safe Safe Total Very Safe Safe Very Safe Safe North 11.54% 65.38% 76.92% 15.38% 53.85% 7.69% 76.92% 26 Concern About Crime Male Female Total Respondents Inc. a Little Inc. a Lot Total Inc. a Little Inc. a Lot Inc. a Little Inc. a Lot North 34.62% 30.77% 65.39% 30.77% 46.15% 38.46% 15.38% 26 36
Page 37
OFFICIAL—POLICE & PARTNERS 17 PUBLIC CONFIDENCE—Complaints Against the Police Complaints Breakdown of complaint allegations Breakdown of complaint allegations DIVISION TOTAL YTD LYTD % CHANGE TOTAL 48 68 -29.4% North Ayrshire 13 24 -45.8% Criminal Complaint Non Criminal Complaint FLR Combined Abandoned / Withdrawn Ongoing NCARU U DIVISION 5 8 22 2 11 North Ayrshire Council 1 3 8 0 1 Assault Excess Force Incivility Irreg in Proc Discrim Behav Opp Conduct / Harass Other Non-Crim Unlawful Arrest U DIVISION 4 2 8 14 0 2 0 0 North Ayrshire Council 1 1 3 3 0 0 0 0 37
Page 38
38
Page 39
NORTH AYRSHIRE COUNCIL 15 August 2022 Police and Fire and Rescue Committee Meeting Title: Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Strategic Plan 2022- 2025 Consultation Purpose: To advise the Committee of the response submitted in response to the consultation. Recommendation: That the Committee notes the response submitted. 1. Executive Summary 1.1 The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (“SFRS”) issued a request for responses to a consultation on the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service’s strategic plan over the next three years. 1.2 The response required to be lodged by 10th July 2022 prior to the next meeting of the Committee. The purpose of this report is to advise the Committee of the response that was submitted. 2. Background 2.1 The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service were undertaking a consultation on the draft Strategic Plan 2022-2025 and looking for responses from the public and strategic partners on shaping the plan for the SFRS for the next three years. The plan wishes to deliver on the following broad outcomes that complement the strategic priorities of the Fire and Rescue Framework for Scotland, and are as narrated in the draft plan as:- 1. Community safety and wellbeing improves as the SFRS deploy targeted initiatives to prevent emergencies and harm. 2. Communities are safer and more resilient as the SFRS respond effectively to changing risks. 3. That the SFRS value and demonstrate innovation across all areas of their work. 4. That the SFRS respond to the impacts of climate change in Scotland and reduce their carbon emissions. Agenda Item 5 39
Page 40
5. That the SFRS are a thriving organisation, that use their resources responsibly and provide value for money to the public. 6. That the experience of those who work for SFRS improves as they aim to be the best employer that they can be. 7. Community safety and wellbeing improves as the SFRS work effectively with their partners. 2.2 As the response required to be submitted prior to the next meeting of the Committee, a high level and general response was submitted by officers. A copy of the response is included at Appendix 1. 2.3 In summary, the priorities highlighted by the SFRS reflect the direction of travel required to provide a modern, comprehensive, proactive and responsive Fire and Rescue Service . The Council welcomed the priorities suggested by the SFRS and confirmed that the Council looks forward to working in partnership with the SFRS to improve outcomes for our communities. 3. Proposals 3.1 That the Committee notes the response submitted to the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service. 40
Page 41
4. Implications/Socio-economic Duty Financial 4.1 There are no Financial Implications arising from this report. Human Resources 4.2 There are no Human Resources Implications arising from this report. Legal 4.3 There are no Legal Implications arising from this report. Equality/Socio-economic 4.4 The SFRS will assess the outcomes of the survey and consultation exercise for equality, diversity and socio-economic outcomes. Children and Young People: The consultation exercise and its outcome will benefit children and young people by leading to safer environments and communities for children and young people. Climate Change and Carbon 4.5 There is a specific strategic action plan in the draft plan that the SFRS is committed to responding to the impacts of climate change in Scotland and reducing their carbon emissions. Key Priorities 4.6 The response to the consultation contributes to the Council priorities of working together to develop stronger communities and supporting all of our people to stay, safe healthy and active. Community Wealth Building 4.7 N/A 5. Consultation 5.1 The SFRS will take into account the response to the consultation responses received on their draft plan from members of the public and strategic partners. The finalised version of the plan will be brought back to this Committee for information. Aileen Craig Head of Democratic Services For further information please contact Raymond Lynch, Senior Legal Manager, on Email: raymondlynch@north-ayrshire.gov.uk. Background Papers 41
Page 42
0 42
Page 43
Appendix 1 Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Consultation Draft Strategic Plan 2022-2025 Response from North Ayrshire Council Background The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) is undertaking a Consultation on the draft Strategic Plan for 2022 - 2025 that outlines proposals for the forthcoming years to deliver a fire and rescue service that work towards the overall purpose, as outlined in the Fire and Rescue Framework for Scotland 2022: ‘To work in partnership with communities and with others in the public, private and third sectors on prevention, protection and response to improve the safety and wellbeing of people throughout Scotland.’ The Fire and Rescue Framework for Scotland 2022 sets out seven strategic priorities which the SFRS have a statutory duty to have regard to these when developing their Strategic Plan: • Prevention and Protection • Response • Innovation and Modernisation • Climate Change • Effective Governance and Performance • Partnership • People Consultation Request SFRS have asked for our views on the proposed strategic plan. Due to the summer recess and the Committee timetabling, this response has not yet been put to Elected Members on the Police and Fire and Rescue Committee. Accordingly, there may be additional matters that are submitted in this regard. This draft Strategic Plan 2022-2025 sets out what our broad ambitions will be over the next three years. The plan wishes to deliver the following broad outcomes that complement the strategic priorities of the referred to Fire and Rescue Framework for Scotland and are as narrated in the draft plan as:- 1. Community safety and wellbeing improves as we deploy targeted initiatives to prevent emergencies and harm. 43
Page 44
2. Communities are safer and more resilient as we respond effectively to changing risks. 3. We value and demonstrate innovation across all areas of our work. 4. We respond to the impacts of climate change in Scotland and reduce our carbon emissions. 5. We are a thriving organisation, use our resources responsibly and provide value for money to the public. 6. The experience of those who work for SFRS improves as we are the best employer we can be. 7. Community safety and wellbeing improves as we work effectively with our partners. Response The Council recognises that all public services need to ensure that they are fit to serve and meet the needs of local communities in accordance with the principles of the Christie Commission. The Council therefore welcomes the general proposals contained in the consultation document and would make the further following comments:- • The contribution of SFRS to Community Planning should continue and resources should be made available to deliver local outcomes and improvement plans. The Council welcomes the renewed commitment and focus on partnership working. • The preventative strategy is welcomed to improve outcomes for communities and protect people from harm. It is recognised that this is an increased area of demand with our aging population and the work being done by SFRS in assisting to keep people safe and prevent them from coming to harm is a valuable contributor to public service delivery. The Council fully supports the commitment to working with communities, partners and stakeholders to produce and disseminate safety advice and information effectively. Working in collaboration in this regard makes good sense. • Recognising the diversity of local areas and the specific needs of communities is vital. The Council welcomes that SFRS is building upon our knowledge of and responding to the changing risks and inequalities faced by our communities. This is further to the learning experiences from the COIVD-19 pandemic. • SFRS should continue to engage with local communities to build confidence in the service and establish and foster relationships with a view to the prevention agenda and supporting communities. The SFRS is a well-respected emergency service. • The objective of early intervention is welcomed as this will not only lead to reduction in demand but will build community capacity and responsibility for individual safety and property • It is noted that there is an objective of responding more efficiently responding to false fire alarm calls and improving road safety by reducing the number of 44
Page 45
blue light journeys that are required to be made. This is welcomed given that this diverts the availability of services from other areas of potential need. The Council welcomes actions to tackle this issue on an ongoing basis. • The people strategy is welcomed. The contribution of SFRS as an employer in the local area makes a difference in the local economy and community as a whole and the continued availability and retention of quality local jobs should be a priority as a contributor to the area. The Council notes the commitment to paying the living wage for employees and developing and deploying new and more agile ways of working to protect the safety, wellbeing, physical and mental health of staff. • Governance and accountability should form a key part of monitoring the implementation of the strategic plan to ensure that outcomes are met. • Investment in IT and digital solutions is recognised as key in developing a modern fire and rescue service which is fit for purpose. The innovative use of technology, data and information to change how the organisation works is welcomed and is crucial in service delivery post Covid pandemic and beyond. • It is noted that the draft plan refers to strategically placing specialist resources in areas where there is a greater risk of flooding. This is something that was raised and considered in the previous response by this Council to the 2019- 2022 plan, and it is beneficial to see its inclusion again within the plan for the benefit of local communities that are affected by such. • The Council notes OUTCOME FOUR: Respond to the impacts of climate change in Scotland and reduce our carbon emissions. This is an important outcome in the context of the national and worldwide position. Accordingly, the commitment to investing further in the greening of fleet by acquiring zero emission vehicles where appropriate and supporting staff to adopt changes and behaviour to support more environmentally friendly working practices is welcomed. This is something that will be of interest to Elected Members on the Committee on an ongoing basis as to the progress thereon at a local and national level. Comments on current service provision We have an excellent working relationship with the Local Area Commander and his officers both at strategic and operational level. The positive level of engagement of SFRS at the Police Fire and Rescue Committee has been most welcome. The approach of localism is vital with local commanders being empowered to deliver services according to local needs and demands. In North Ayrshire we have excellent working relationships with SFRS which delivers well for our communities. Raymond Lynch Senior Manager Legal Services North Ayrshire Council 45
Page 46
Page 47
Page 48
Page 49
46
Page 50
Page 51
Page 52
Page 53
!"#$!
%&'(&)&*+,-.&)./+0.(/)12&.-&32/..+4-5+(&'0)
&421&3&(6+2&735
383.('.&,+29*'0:;::<:;:=
>4?&'@@(/'2-/1(;.-'00+6&(4'(A+0:;:BC.-+4
+4/1(D/1(.-3.('.&,+29*'0'0).-&E(4./0&.-'.
'*+,04.//1(FGHIJKLMNOPQPGHD/(.-&3&(6+2&?-+2-
?&@1R*+4-&)+0:;:0/1(S+4+/0?&4&./1./1(
'TR+.+/04./R&'@(/,(&44+6&/(,'0+4'.+/0C2&0.(&)
'(/10)@&/@*&U40&&)4C+02*14+6&/D'**'0)R&..&(
2/00&2.&).//1(2/TT10+.+&4-+49*'0T'(V4.-&0&W.
4.&@4./?'()4(&'*+4+0,.-'.S+4+/0.'*4/R1+*)4/0/1(
/(,'0+4'.+/0'*OXYZLQC)&T/04.('.&4/1(2/TT+.T&0.
./D1(.-&(T/)&(0+4+0,.-&3&(6+2&RA)/+0,T/(&
D/(/1(2/TT10+.+&4'0)2-'0,+0,-/??&?/(V.
D1(.-&(4.(&0,.-&04/1('@@(/'2-./@(&6&0.+/0?-+*&
T'+0.'+0+0,'0&W2&**&0.&T&(,&02A(&4@/04&'0)
'))(&44+0,.-&(&@'+('0)(&@*'2&T&0.2-'**&0,&4
?+.-+0/1(&4.'.&
-+49*'0?+**)&*+6&(','+04..-&4.('.&,+2@(+/(+.+&4
4&./1.D/(.-&3&(6+2&RA.-&32/..+4-[/6&(0T&0.+0
.-&\PMLXH]^LQ_ZL\MXNL`GMabGMc_GdYXH]efee.
2/T&4'.'0+T@/(.'0..+T&D/(32/.*'0)'4?&(&2/6&(
'0)*&'(0*&44/04D(/T$!S"<g0(&4@/04&./
.-&@'0)&T+2'0)./-&*@32/.*'0)(&2/6&(D(/T+.4
+T@'2.4C.-&32/..+4-[/6&(0T&0.-'42/TT+..&)./h
i
"&6&*/@+0,'@(/,(&44+6&C?&**R&+0,
&2/0/TAD/(32/.*'0)
i
j1+*)+0,@1R*+24&(6+2&4/0
'@&(4/0<2&0.(&)R'4+4
i
>))(&44+0,+441&4/D4A4.&T+2
4/2+'*'0)&2/0/T+2+0&k1'*+.A
i
3.(&0,.-&0+0,@'(.0&(4-+@?/(V+0,
'2(/44@1R*+24&(6+2&4
>4'3&(6+2&2/TT+..&)./.-&$-(+4.+&(&D/(T
@(+02+@*&4C?&?+**@*'A/1(@'(.+0'2-+&6+0,.-&4&
?+)&('TR+.+/04D/(32/.*'0)0@(/)12+0,.-+4@*'0C
?&-'6&&041(&).-'./1('2.+/04?+**41@@/(..-&4&
@(+/(+.+&4D/(32/.*'0)'4?&?/(V./+T@(/6&.-&4'D&.A
'0)?&**R&+0,/D/1(2/TT10+.+&4
>*.-/1,-?&@(+)&/1(4&*6&4/0/1('R+*+.A./@*'0
/1(4&(6+2&4D/('D1.1(&32/.*'0)C.-&@'0)&T+2-'4
4-/?0+.+4+T@/44+R*&./D1**A@(&)+2..-&D1.1(&>4
412-C?&-'6&4&./1.?-'.?&0&&)./'2-+&6&/6&(
.-&0&W..-(&&A&'(4?+.-+0.-+49*'0%&'*4/-+,-*+,-.
4/T&/D.-&2-'**&0,&4?&'(&D'2&)?+.-'0).-&
R'((+&(4?&?+**0&&).//6&(2/T&./'2-+&6&T/(&D/(
32/.*'0)%&T14.'))(&44.-&@(/R*&T4/D'0',&+0,
&4.'.&'0)/@&('.+0,4A4.&T4.-'.0&&)1@,(')&)
%&'*4/0&&)./T'+0.'+0'0&W.&04+6&l&&./D6&-+2*&4
'0)&k1+@T&0..-'.41@@/(.4?-'.?&)/C?-+*4.
.'V+0,4.&@4./(&)12&/1(2'(R/02/041T@.+/0%&
?+**-'6&./'2-+&6&.-+4RA?/(V+0,T/(&l&W+R*A
'2(/44.-&?-/*&2/10.(Aj1../)/4/C?&?+**(&k1+(&
4+,0+E2'0.+06&4.T&0.'0)414.'+0&)2/TT+.T&0./6&(
.-&0&W..-(&&A&'(4'0)R&A/0)
5+0'**AC.-&2/TT+.T&0.4?+.-+0.-+49*'0'(&/0*A
@/44+R*&R&2'14&/D.-&&W2&**&0.?/(V/D'**/1(
@&/@*&-&A'(&.(1*A+04@+('.+/0'*'0)?&?/1*)*+V&./
.-'0V.-&T'**D/(&6&(A.-+0,.-&A)/D/(&'2-/.-&('0)
.-&@&/@*&/D32/.*'0)%&?/1*)'*4/*+V&./.-'0V/1(
@'(.0&(4'0)2/TT10+.+&4?-/?&@(/1)*A4&(6&'0)
?-/41@@/(.14+0?-'.?&)/
:%
m>3mn3
>n[$
9o>:;::<:=p
-&35
3?'4&4.'R*+4-&)+0>@(+*:;B3+02&.-&0?&-'6&@(/)12&)4.('.&,+2@*'04&6&(A.-(&&A&'(4./)&.'+*
.-&'2.+6+.+&4?&10)&(.'V&./2/0.(+R1.&./.-&4'D&.A'0)?&**R&+0,/D32/.*'0)U42/TT10+.+&4C?-+*4.V&&@+0,/1(
E(&E,-.&(44'D&
-+43.('.&,+29*'0/1.*+0&4.-&-+,-<*&6&*/1.2/T&4.-(/1,-?-+2-?&?+**2/0.+01'**A?/(V./?'()4/1(/6&('**
@1(@/4&C'4/1.*+0&)+0.-&5+(&'0) &421&5('T&?/(VD/(32/.*'0):;::hqrstsuvwxyzu{x|u}~wytw{~
sxw{w|}zxtw{~s{~|u}wx{~|yw
yuwz{|zx{~wu}|{su}sxyu||x{wsx
yus{|{wsxzx
u|}ysx}|{swyus|{~|}z|{zxt||wxsy|sy|{~us~s{s{zx
KL\PMLXH]^LQ_ZL\MXNL`GMabGMc_GdYXH]efee'*4/4&.4D/(144&6&04.('.&,+2@(+/(+.+&4'0)?&-'6&'4.'.1./(A
)1.A./-'6&(&,'()./.-&4&?-&0)&6&*/@+0,/1(3.('.&,+29*'0h
sxr|uw}wsx
>4?&**'42/04+)&(+0,.-&5+(&5('T&?/(VC.-+43.('.&,+29*'041@@/(.4.-&'2-+&6&T&0./D/1(c\^cFGHIJKLMNOPQPGH
!1(S+4+/0+4'0'4@+('.+/0'*)/21T&0.?-+2-?'44-'@&)RA/1(4.''0)4.'V&-/*)&(4.4&.4/1./1(D1.1(&)+(&2.+/0
'0)/1.*+0&4?-&(&?&?'0../R&+0.&0A&'(4U.+T&-+49*'0/1.*+0&4.-&0&W.4.',&+0.-'./1(0&A
!1(9*'0-'4R&&0)&6&*/@&)?+.-.-&4&+T@/(.'0.)/21T&0.4+0T+0)C?+.-/1(4&6&0!1.2/T&42/T@*&T&0.+0,.-&
4.('.&,+2@(+/(+.+&4/D.-&5+(&'0) &421&5('T&?/(VD/(32/.*'0)%&-'6&)&6&*/@&).-+49*'0+02/041*.'.+/0?+.-/1(
@&/@*&C'('0,&/D/1(@'(.0&(4'2(/44.-&2/10.(A'0).-&@&/@*&/D32/.*'0)
i
9(&6&0.+/0'0)9(/.&2.+/0
i
&4@/04&
i
00/6'.+/0'0)/)&(0+4'.+/0
i
$*+T'.&$-'0,&
i
n&2.+6&[/6&(0'02&'0)9&(D/(T'02&
i
9'(.0&(4-+@
i
9&/@*&
47Page 54
Page 55
Page 56
Page 57
!"
#$%
"&'$!()#
&(*
#+,-)./0/01/2
3453674898:8398359
;<=<>;<>?=@A>BA@>BA<;CDCDECF
GH>I=HJKLMNO
PQRST
;U?VWX=HJKLMNO
SYQSZ[
\+,&
,]-'
^+,(_`-$-)&*,
&'$!()#a&'__+)-$- &
bcdbefbghidefjcdkblemdbcnodblpiblbdqrpbrnefbshdjoidtbudhjbsrjjcjsculvbehdblwhnoehmdblcnohefbd
bxbdkbnpurnprobnelviesbohxipfxhdbefcnefce-nphxxinrerblcpdhll&phejcno^uhiajjmnoily
bmdxjuvbjrbqbefceefbvblescuehobcjsrefcnu
euwbhgbxbdkbnpurleheducnolehwregdhxfcwwbnrnk
rnefbmdlewjcpb
refctbughpilhnwdbqbnerhn^
wcderpijcdjurnliwwhdehgefbxhleqijnbdcvjbxbxvbdl
hglhprbeu^sbshdtsrefhidwcdenbdlcpdhllefbphinedu
ehobjrqbdypdiprcjmdblcgbeupcxwcrknlzwdbqbnerhn
rnebdqbnerhnlzcnoshdthncsrobdcnkbhgwivjrp
lcgbeurnrercerqblefcetbbwwbhwjbcnovilrnbllbl
lcgb`bpcilbhgefrlcnovbpcilbhidmdbmkfebdl^
vhefsfhjberxbcnohnpcjj^cdblhqcjibosrefrnefbrd
phxxinrerbl^sbfcqbcncxvrerhnehobqbjhwhidh{bd
eh&phejcno(lsbobqbjhwefrlh{bdsbxilebnlidb
efceefbgcprjrerblcnob|irwxbnesbilbcdbhgefb
frkfblelecnocdo$fbunbboehvbxhobdn^widwhlb
oblrknboghdefb/2lepbneiducnolcgbghdhidwbhwjb
$frlsrjjfbjwildbecrnefhlbsfhpiddbnejushdtghdil
sfrjbceedcpernknbswbhwjbehfbjwilvbphxbcxhdb
orqbdlbhdkcnrlcerhnefcedb}bpelefbphxxinrerblhg
xhobdn&phejcno
bsrjjtbbwrxwdhqrnkwbhwjbaljrqblcnoefb
lcgbeucnosbjjvbrnkhgefbphxxinrerblsblbdqbz
vudboiprnkefbdrltgdhxfcdxcnoshdtrnkrn
phjjcvhdcerhnsrefhidwcdenbdlcnophxxinrerbl
~
~
48Page 58
Page 59
Page 60
Page 61
!"#$%& '()*+
, *-.*/,#&
%$$+
*0/)*0'+%)/+
& *$."$1")& *0
*! "$*2*&)*$+++
+$"3&$"'$!&24
567896:;<=><?@6>:<;<=A:8BCDEFGHIJ
"$.0$.&&1)*2
/K+))1&'+
L#)$*0'
$."1)"&*"'&$1"$! %M')! *0)*
**$!)& !'"! /'
%$"$."/$22.* & '4
21)/&'$%&1)*2
/)"
*$&$!")*+
)!))'& *0N/&$*.'K/$22.* & '
)*,.' *'''$!"&#)"'))4O& ' 21")& !&)&
+1.&3#''$*'+)!)"*%"$2&1)*2
/
*&$1)/&$1.'K)*P/$&)*K%.#"/$!"4
Q@6R;S;@;TU
V *0)2$"-W ,$"0)* ')& $*+)'3#&$$+
+
"'1$*&$&XYZO[M\]1)*2
/4^+
2) *&) *
$.")0 )*-W ,)11"$)/&$ !"+)& '
"_. "$%.',#$."/$22.* & '4 '2)*')!$ *0
)`$*' ab&')c2*&) &#)*)11"$)/'$&)&+/)*
"'1$*&$ N" *0/$22.* &#*')11"$1" )
d6:9;76e8?6:<;f>T;8<
^+
!$1$."$N"&$/$22.* & ')')*
2"0*/#'"! /,)'$*),&&".*"'&)* *0
$%/)*0 *0" '3)*"')1&.'$%$.""'$."/'
)*'"! /)/& ! & '4g$+!"K)/ ! *02$"&$
'.11$"&)*')%0.)"$."/$22.* & '+
& *W '& *0
"'$."/'+
,$.", 00'&/)*04
hi?=6T;<=56fj8<f;S@U
Y!"&*W&&"#)"'++
%)/' 0* b/)*&
,.0&)"#1"''."' *,$&$.""'$."/)*/)1 &)
,.0&'4^+
,%)/+
& 0!'$% *-)& $*
*
&0$$')*'"! /'+*&$1."/)'&$ !"
$."'"! /'4^)" 3#&$'/)*0'2"0 *0
%$"$."1$1)"$.*&
*/")'/$'&$% ! *0)*
&1"''."'& '1)/'$*&2)*& "$.'$'4
^)'$%)/)' 0* b/)*&)*0"$+
*0
*!'&2*&*
*$."'&)&+ /"_. "'$*0$ *0/)",$* ')& $*4
Y.",. *0')")0 *0)*2)*#"_. "'.,'&)*& )
.10") *0$""1)/2*&4k) ."&$
*!'& *$."'&)&
+
)%."&"1"''."&$$.""'$."/,.0&)'+
*/")' *0#'1*2$"2$*#&$$!"/$2&"1) "
/$'&'&)&/$2%"$2)*)0 *0'&$%,. *0'4^+
)+)#',))*/$.",.0&l+)""_. "&$$'$
,#)+4g$+!"K0 !*&'1"''."'++
*
&$2)3)"/$ /'$*& 2
*0)*b*)*/ )/)1)/ &#
)'+2$"* '&P"! /+ '&2) *&) * *0/.""*&
b*)*/ )'.'&) *), &#)*,.0&)"#/$*&"$4
C@;B>T6mB6:=6<7U
21)/&'$%/ 2)&/)*0+
*/")'$!"& 24
^+
)!&$"'1$*&$2$"+)&"M")&
*/ *&'+ /+
*/")'
*
*&*' &#K 21)/&)*
%"_.*/#)*/$*& *.&$*'."$."b"b0&"')"
1"$1"#&") *K_. 11)*'.11$"&
*& '4
G6B8=:>jn;7Cn><=6
($1)" ! *0$*0")*/)"+
*/")' *0#' L
%"$2 *'& &.& $*)'&& *0'&$+)"'$2M,)'/)"4 '
/)*0+
0*")&*+
2)*')'P/$&)*'3'&$
'.11$"&$."1$1.)& $*&$)0+ *')%)*"' *&
/$22.* & 'K+ ++$"3&$"./&" '3$%b"
)*$&"%$"2'$%.* *&*& $*))"2+
& *$2'4
^+
/$*& *.$."/"./ )+$"3+
&/$22.* & ')*
$."1)"&*"'&$1"!*&'./)"2%"$2)11* *0)*
!$1$."'"! /$N" *'.11$"& *0&!.*"),
22,"'$%P/$&)*o'/$22.* & '4
p@>76
^)")*)& $*)'"! /K !"$/)#4^)"
/$22
&&&$.*"'&)* *0&/)*0 *0" '3')/"$''
&/$.*&"#)*2& *0/$22.* &#*' *+)#'&)&
+$"3,'&%$"&24^+
'.11$"&&+
"1., /
'"! /"%$"2)0*)$%)$1& *0)1)/M,)'
)11"$)/&$$+
1., /'"! /')"' 0*)*
!"4 '+
')1$+
++$"3&$*'."&)&
$."/$22.* & ')"')%"K'&"$*0")*2$""' *&4
56f;@;6<76
^1)#)*
21$"&)*&"$1 *0/$22.* & ',/$2
2$""' *&4^
&" *')%0.)" *01$1)*
/$22.* & ')0) *'&&
21)/&'$%)1)*2
/K&
N/&'$%)!"'+)&"!*&'K) *0+
&&&")&
$%&""$" '2)*2./2$"4""2) *')! &)*
)*)'&)&.&$"#.&#%$".'&$+$"3+
&$."/$22.* & '
)*2"0*/#'"! /1)"&*"'&$1"1)",&&"&$
2&&'&")&')'&#!$!$!"& 24
q4YrsY(tsuOvw
tvZOsYvxtv
kYsgtvtyz{tusP
p68j@6
t*'." *0&')%&#$%$."b"b0&"')**'." *0&
+, *0$%/$22.* & ')')+)#',*)&&)"&
$%$+
+$1")&4 ')11"$)/$%1.&& *01$1
b"'&"2) *')&$."/$"4^+
/$*& *.&$1)/)
'&"$*0%$/.'$*2& *01$1o'*')'+/)*0
$+
++$"34
m<=>=6B6<T><?mBj8|6:B6<T
$2)30$$/ ' $*'#$.*&$*0)01$1
*&/ ' $*M2)3 *01"$/'')*21$+"&2
&$2)3)11"$1" )&/$ /'%$"&2'!'4^)"
/$22
&&&$+$"3 *0& '+)#K,$&+
&$."$+*
1$1)*+
&$."/$22.* & '4 '+
1.'
)"" !)&,&&"/ ' $*'+ /+
2)3.')'&"$*0"
)*2$"'.//''%.$"0)* ')& $*4
e><>=;<=Cn><=6
^)!)*+
/$*& *.&$".*)"0/)*0
1"$}/&')/"$''&P"! /4("$}/&'/)*")*0%"$2
*&"$./ *0*+
&/*$$0#'#'&2'K.*"&)3 *0
)"0'/),. *01"$}/&'K+$"3 *0+
&'.11 "'
&$!$1*+
'$%2"0*/#"'1$*'
! /'K&$/)*0 *0&+)#'++$"34"$.0$.&
&.")& $*$%& '()*++
%."&" 21"$!$+
+2)*)01"$}/&'&$*'."& "N/& !)*
~/ *& !"#4
u'+1"$/$!"&*W&&"#)"'++
/$*& *.)#"! ' &$.")''.21& $*'),$.&$."$1")& *0*! "$*2*&
)*$+
)*#/)*0'2)# 21)/&$*$+
++
+$"34&) *&%$$+
*0'/& $*'$.& *'+)&++
)/ !$!"& %& 2$%& '()*4g$+
++
$'$+
,'&$.&K'/".& * ')*2$* &$"&"$.0,$&$."
u**.)Y1")& *0()*)*X)*0()*,#$."V$)")*&+
"1., /)'+ !"$*& '()*o')2, & $*'4
49Page 62
Page 63
Page 64
Page 65
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`>7?7021-091::;7522A7A75>2-6-/>47>?1@787:1?7>3.-87:54127?-:?742-.772$@-2:508N4@A50<10<07784 _ H791::;7100-?521?710-/>/47-627@A0-:-<3J8525508106->.521-02-@A50<7A-9979->K _ `5>207>4A1=9->K10<91::;7522A7@->7-6A-9979->K _ H791::;78>1?70;35877=7>/087>4250810<-62A707784-6-/>@-../012174 _ H791::;75.->770?1>-0.7025::34/425105;:7-><5014521-0 *aER'E+\RbTRR'TD'*\E*Rc[FD+R'CD'B EFFC*F[&RD(CE*^*%&TR'TD'*\E(%&'(%)*R _ d1>7$56723#06->@7.702e`>-27@21-0fd>5.79->K6->$@-2:508WXWg _ !-../0123$56723#0<5<7.702`:50010<508#?5:/521-0`-:1@3508`>-@78/>7 _ !-../01@521-04508#0<5<7.702$2>527<3 R&[[%T'E+\%&TF%+\]'*T)^ERE%+[TE%TE'E*R _ `>7?7021-091::;7522A7A75>2-6-/>47>?1@787:1?7>3.-87:54127?-:?742-.772$@-2:508N4@A50<10<07784 _ H791::;7100-?521?710-/>/47-627@A0-:-<3J8525508106->.521-02-@A50<7A-9979->K _ `5>207>4A1=9->K10<91::;7522A7@->7-6A-9979->K _ H791::;78>1?70;35877=7>/087>4250810<-62A707784-6-/>@-../012174 *aER'E+\RbTRR'TD'*\E*Rc[FD+R'CD'B EFFC*F[&RD(CE*^*%&TR'TD'*\E(%&'(%)*R _ !hijkgl7@-?7>3`:50 _ =7>521-05:$2>527<3WXWWkWXmW _ M4472"505<7.702$2>527<3WXglkWXWl _ !-../0123M44727<1427> %&'(%)*'B %, !-../0121745>74567>508.->7>741:170254 97>74=-087n7@21?7:32-@A50<10<>14K4 B CD'B *B EFFG% H791::5==:32A7:744-04:75>0786>-.2A7!hijkgl=5087.1@2-A-997-=7>527H791::@-0210/7-/>9->K2- /087>425082A7@A50<10<>14K4912A10-/>@-../01217450842>527<1@5::387@187A-9;7422-:-@527-/>-=7>521-05: >74-/>@74;5478-09A7>72A7<>752742>14K4:17H791::87:1?7>-02A7@-..12.7024.58710-/>=7>521-05: $2>527<3J704/>10<97A5?72A7>1<A2>74-/>@74102A7>1<A2=:5@74522A7>1<A221.745086/>2A7>1.=>-?7-/>-0@5:: 47>?1@7H791::A5?72A7;74243427.42-81>7@2-/>I>7I<A210<5@21?121747n7@21?7:3508@-0210/72-704/>75::-/> =7-=:7A5?72A7>1<A24K1::4J2>51010<5087L/1=.702H791::@-0210/72-=:50508>74=-08912A-2A7>7.7><70@3 47>?1@742-1.=>-?7I>7I<A27>508=/;:1@456723 B CD'R&((*RRB EFFF%%SFES*E+'CT**U*DTR V3WXWY-/>7n7@21?77.7><70@3>74=-04791::704/>7@-../012174>7.5104567H791::5@A17?72A14;3Z _ 76-@/410<-/>=>7?702521?75@21?121742-588>744 144/74-64-@15:J7@-0-.1@508A75:2A107L/5:12174 _ o75810<10121521?74912A-/>=5>207>42-5==>-=>1527:3 4A5>78525508106->.521-0 _ o75810<10121521?742->78/@7/01027021-05:A5>.10 -/>@-../012174 _ H ->K10<912A@-../012174J=5>207>4508 425K7A-:87>42-=>-8/@750881447.10527456723 58?1@7508106->.521-07n7@21?7:3 _ i.=>-?10<@-../012345672350897::;710<;3 9->K10<2-70@-/>5<74/4251078;7A5?1-/>5: @A50<7912A10A-/47A-:84 _ $/==->210<;/410744-907>42-=>-27@2$@-2:508N4 0-0k8-.7421@;/1:810<4508=>7.1474 _ V/1:810</=-0-/>K0-9:78<7-6508>74=-0810< 2-2A7@A50<10<>14K4508107L/5:1217465@78;3-/> @-../012174 _ M==:310<2A7:744-0497A5?7:75>0786>-.!hijkgl 2-8>1?74/425105;:71.=>-?7.70210A-9979->K _ >51010<7n7@21?7:35087O@1702:3545$7>?1@7508 912A-/>=5>207>42-1.=>-?7@-../0123456723 _ `>-?1810<2A7>1<A227@A0-:-<35087L/1=.7022- K77=I>7I<A27>44567 _ i.=>-?10<A-997.505<7@5::46>-.2A7=/;:1@ 50887=:-3-/>>74-/>@742-7.7><70@310@187024 _ "->77O@1702:3>74=-0810<2-65:47I>75:5>.@5::4 5081.=>-?10<>-58456723;3>78/@10<2A70/.;7> -6;:/7:1<A2p-/>073497.5K72-2A7. 50
Page 66
Page 67
Page 68
Page 69
!"#!!$
%&'()*&(+,,&-.+/01(0&2++.'(02.+
(31.//())(1&(/.4.*15.167
8
"98
!8
:;;<
%&52))3.+02+*&0.&-=&,2++.'(02.+2+0.>.55&5.16(+,.?&1(0&7@/5&,2,0>1.*A>.*00>&?(+,&-235&52))
5.16520>.0>&1/0./&&62++.'(02'&.??.10*+202&/0.,12'&3>(+A&(+,2-?1.'&-&+07%&52))4*10>&1*/&.*10()&+0B
?(10+&1/>2?/(+,1&/.*13&/0.,&'&).?(+,2-?1.'&.*1/C/0&-/B?1.3&//&/(+,?&14.1-(+3&7%&52)),&'&).?.*1
D1/0E++.'(02.+(+,E-?1.'&-&+0F01(0&AC5>23>52))/&0.*0>.5B(/.+&.40>&)(1A&/0D1&(+,1&/3*&/&1'23&/2+
0>&5.1),B5&52))&+3.*1(A&(+,,12'&2++.'(02.+(31.//())(1&(/.4.*15.16(+,>&)?*/-(6&0>&=&/0*/&.4.*1
1&/.*13&/B(,(?00.3>(+A2+A12/6/(+,,12'&A..,?1(3023&7
8
"9G!GG8
:;;;H;:H!:I"#!!J!9#G
KCLMLN5&52))&-=1(3&2++.'(02'&(??1.(3>&/0.>.55&.?&1(0&7%&52))(3>2&'&0>2/=CO
!P#$
%&1&/?.+,0.0>&2-?(30/.43)2-(0&3>(+A&2+
F3.0)(+,(+,1&,*3&.*13(1=.+&-2//2.+/7
8
"98
!8
:;;<
%&52))4*10>&1,&'&).?0>&1&/.*13&/+&&,&,0.0(36)&0>&2-?(30/.43)2-(0&3>(+A&(+,5&52))&+/*1&0>(0
0>&/&(1&/01(0&A23())C).3(0&,(31.//0>&3.*+01C7Q*1D1&DA>0&1/52))1&-(2+4*))C01(2+&,(+,&R*2??&,0./*??.10
3.--*+202&/2+-&&02+A&S01&-&5&(0>&1&'&+0/7%&52))()/.-(6&*/&.4.0>&1).3()1&/.*13&/0>(0(1&('(2)(=)&
0.=.)/0&1.*11&/?.+/&,*12+A?1.).+A&,.152,&/?1&(,2+32,&+0/7%&52))3.+02+*&0.5.160.1&,*3&.*1.5+
.1A(+2/(02.+()2-?(30.+0>&&+'21.+-&+0=C3>(+A2+A>.55&5.16B>.55&3.+/*-&(+,-(+(A&&+&1AC(+,
>.55&=&>('&(/5&(,(?00.3)2-(0&3>(+A&7T&,*32+A.*13(1=.+&-2//2.+/2/0>&D1/0/0&?2+0>2/U.*1+&C7KC
LMVN5&52))=&3.-&(3(1=.++&*01().1A(+2/(02.+7
8
"9G!GG8
:;;;H;:H!:I"#!!J!9#G
KCLMLN5&52))1&,*3&.*13(1=.+&-2//2.+/(+,3.+02+*&0./*??.10.*13.--*+202&/0.0(36)&3)2-(0&3>(+A&7
%&52))(3>2&'&0>2/=CO
W
X1.-.02+A(+,&-=&,,2+A(3*)0*1&.42++.'(02.+
2+0>&F&1'23&0.,&'&).?+&55(C/.40>2+62+A(+,
5.162+A7
W
Y&)2'&12+A+&5.??.10*+202&/B?(10+&1/>2?/(+,
3.))(=.1(02.+/0.2-?1.'&=.0>?*=)23(+,.*1
?&.?)&/Z/(4&0C(+,5&))=&2+A7
W
Y&'&).?2+A(+,,&?).C2+A+&5,2A20()(+,.0>&1
0&3>+.).A2&/0.3>(+A&>.55&5.16(+,0.6&&?
D1&DA>0&1//(4&7
W
E-?1.'2+A2+0&1[,&?(10-&+0()5.162+A(+,
6+.5)&,A&/>(12+A(31.//0>&F&1'23&7
W
E-?)&-&+02+A(+&5(??1.(3>0.*+,&10(62+A
1&/&(13>(+,,&'&).?-&+07
W
Y&'&).?2+A4*10>&12++.'(02'&(??1.(3>&/0.
-.,&1+2/2+A.*1&/0(0&7
W
\+/*12+A.*1?&.?)&3.+02+*&0.?)(+B(1&01(2+&,
4.1(+,&R*2??&,0.1&/?.+,0.3)2-(0&3>(+A&
2+32,&+0/7
W
%
.162+A520>?(10+&1/0.?1&'&+0D1&/B0>&1&=C
1&,*32+A3(1=.+1&)&(/&,2+0.0>&(0-./?>&1&7
W
F01(0&A23())C?)(32+A/?&32()2/01&/.*13&/2+(1&(/
5>&1&0>&1&2/(A1&(0&112/6.4]..,2+A7
W
T&,*32+A.*13(1=.+3.+/*-?02.+=C2+'&/02+A2+
1&+&5(=)&0&3>+.).A2&/(+,1&,*32+A&+&1AC5(/0&
(31.//0>&F&1'23&7
W
E+'&/02+A4*10>&12+0>&A1&&+2+A.4.*1]&&0=C
(3R*212+A^&1.&-2//2.+'&>23)&/5>&1&(??1.?12(0&7
W
F*??.102+A/0(_0.(,.?03>(+A&/(+,=&>('2.*1
0./*??.10-.1&&+'21.+-&+0())C412&+,)C5.162+A
?1(3023&/7
G``#:Ia#;Iab!#
c:G:I`#:#::!G
W
%&52))=&2++.'(02'&2+.*1*/&.40&3>+.).ACB,(0((+,2+4.1-(02.+0.3>(+A&>.55&5.167
W
X(10+&1/>2?5.162+A52))=&(00>&3.1&.4>.55&5.167
W
%&52))=&,12'&+=C(,&&?&1*+,&1/0(+,2+A.40>&+&&,/.4.*13.--*+202&/7
!d:G:IaGP#GG#9!a:!Ge`;9IG"98
:;;"!;`G9":!c!#G#9!a:
!G
W
E++.'(02.+(+,E-?1.'&-&+0F01(0&AC
W
K*/2+&//E+0&))2A&+3&F01(0&ACLMLf[LMLV
W
Y2A20()F01(0&AC
W
Q?&1(02.+()F01(0&ACLMLL[LMLg
G``#:Ia#;Iab!#
c:G:I`#:#::!G
W
%&52))=&2++.'(02'&2+.*1*/&.40&3>+.).ACB,(0((+,2+4.1-(02.+0.3>(+A&>.55&5.167
W
X(10+&1/>2?5.162+A52))=&(00>&3.1&.4>.55&5.167
W
%&52))=&(-.1&&+'21.+-&+0())C/*/0(2+(=)&.1A(+2/(02.+7
!d:G:IaGP#GG#9!a:!Ge`;9IG"98
:;;"!;`G9":!c!#G#9!a:
!G
W
h(1=.+i(+(A&-&+0X)(+LMLM[LMLN
W
h)2-(0&h>(+A&T&/?.+/&X)(+LMVN
W
\+&1AC(+,h(1=.+F01(0&ACLMLM[LMgM
W
%
2),D1&F01(0&AC
W
Q?&1(02.+()F01(0&ACLMLL[LMgL
51Page 70
Page 71
Page 72
Page 73
!"#
$
%&'(&')*(+,+-./(.'-+0')+/-120&/2((&0/2(3&0(&04/-0+567
'-84(/,+8&,'62&9/(:/-&7)/)*&4256+3;
<
=><
<
"??@
A0'4(/.(&00+,&/(.'-+0')+/-/2(B/'(8C+663/-)+-2&)/4(/,+8&(/520)03(2)+-7C*+60)./,&(-+-.(&04/-0+567'-8
)('-04'(&-)67;%&C+663/-)+-2&)/3/66&3)'-84256+0*)*&(+.*)8')')/0*/C*/CC&66C&'(&4&(9/(:+-.1:'D+-.)*+0
+-9/(:')+/-','+6'56&)/)*&4256+3+-C'70)*')'(&'33&00+56&'-8&'07)/2-8&(0)'-8;%&C+663/-)+-2&)/:'-'.&
/2(E-'-3&014*70+3'6'-88+.+)'6+-9('0)(23)2(&1,&*+36&01&F2+4:&-)'-80244/()+-.+-9('0)(23)2(&(&04/-0+567'-8
:'+-)'+-)*&:)/)*&,&(75&0)/9/2('5+6+)7;G-'88+)+/-1'0'-&:&(.&-370&(,+3&'-8'-/(.'-+0')+/-)*')+0'6C'70
6&'(-+-.'-86//D+-.)/+:4(/,&1C&C+663/-)+-2&)/9/320/-)*&&H&3)+,&:'-'.&:&-)/9(+0D1'-8)*&*&'6)*10'9&)7
'-8C&665&+-./9/2(0)'H'-8:&:5&(0/9)*&4256+3;
<
=>I
II<
"???J?"J
"K=L
M
>LI
B7NONPC&C+663/-)+-2&)/8&:/-0)(')&*/C
&H&3)+,&C&'(&'):'-'.+-.'-80*'(+-./2((&0/2(3&01'-8
4&(9/(:+-.'.'+-0)/2(/5Q&3)+,&0'-8/56+.')+/-0;%&C+66'3*+&,&)*+057R
I"S$
T*&&U4&(+&-3&/9)*/0&C*/C/(D9/(VWXV+:4(/,&0
'0C&'(&)*&5&0)&:46/7&(C&3'-5&;
<
=><
<
"??@
%&C+665&)*&5&0)&:46/7&(C&3'-5&;A0'-'04+(')+/-'6&:46/7&(1C&C+66+-,&0))/'))('3)'-8(&)'+-)*&5&0)
4&/46&)/8&6+,&(/2(0&(,+3&0)/)*&4256+3;T*(/2.*/2))*&YZ[G\]^_4'-8&:+3C&*'8)/C/(D+-:/(&`&U+56&
'-8'.+6&C'70;Z,&()*&-&U))*(&&7&'(0C&C+66&:5&8)*/0&3*'-.&0+-*/C
C&C/(D'-820&)&3*-/6/.7)/:'D&
8'7)/8'7)'0D0&'0+&(9/(/2(4&/46&;%&C+663/-)+-2&)/+:4(/,&/2()('+-+-.)/&-'56&/2(4&/46&)/8&,&6/4'-8
:'+-)'+-)*&+(3/:4&)&-3+&0'-80D+660;%&C+66+:4(/,&/2((&3(2+):&-)4(/3&00&0'-8:'D&/2((/6&0:/(&'))('3)+,&
)/'66:&:5&(0/9/2(3/::2-+)+&0'-88&,&6/4/2('44(/'3*)/7/2)*&-.'.&:&-)'-8&:46/7:&-)92()*&(;%&
C+663/-)+-2&)/-2()2(&'-+-3620+,&326)2(&)*'),'62&0'-8C&63/:&0&,&(75/87)/5&)*&:0&6,&0')C/(D;%&C+66
4(/,+8&/2(4&/46&C+)*)*&8+.-+E&8C/(D9'3+6+)+&0)*'))*&78&0&(,&'-8C&C+66C/(DC+)*/2((&4(&0&-)')+,&
5/8+&0)/3*':4+/-9'+(-&001&F2'6+)714'()-&(0*+41&-.'.&:&-)'-8(&04&3)9/('66;%&C+663/-)+-2&)/5&'W'+(
%
/(Da:46/7&(14'7+-.)*&b+,+-.%'.&9/('66/9/2(0)'H;
<
=>I
II<
"???J?"J
"K=L
M
>LI
B7NONPC&C+665&'-&:46/7&()*')8&:/-0)(')&0/2(3/::+):&-))//2(4&/46&;%&C+66'3*+&,&)*+057R
c
X&:'+-+-./4&-'-8)('-04'(&-)
+-*/C
C&:'D&8&3+0+/-0;
c
G:4(/,+-.6&,&60/9V&(,+3&4&(9/(:'-3&C*+60)
4(/,+8+-.,'62&9/(:/-&7)/)*&4256+3;
c
G:4(/,+-.)*&20&/98')''-8520+-&00+-)&66+.&-3&
)/0244/()8&3+0+/-:'D+-.;
c
d(/'3)+,&67&-.'.+-.C+)*'-84(/,+8+-.:/(&
'33&00+56&+-9/(:')+/-/-C*')C&8/9/()*&4256+3
'-8/2(0)'D&*/68&(0;
c
e'-'.+-.'-8:'+-)'+-+-./2(52+68+-.01,&*+36&0
'-8C+8&(+-9('0)(23)2(&'0C&66'0C&3'-;
c
e'-'.+-.92()*&(:'Q/(3*'-.&4(/Q&3)0'-8
/(.'-+0')+/-'6(+0D0&H&3)+,&67'-8&f3+&-)67;
c
Y/-)+-2+-.)/C/(D+-4'()-&(0*+4C+)*/2(
(&4(&0&-)')+,&5/8+&0)/&-02(&)*&0'9&)7'-8
C&665&+-./9)*&4256+3'-8/2(4&/46&;
c
\&,&6/4+-.'-88&46/7+-.-&C
'-8:/(&'.+6&
C'70/9C/(D+-.)/4(/)&3))*&0'9&)71C&665&+-.1
4*70+3'6'-8:&-)'6*&'6)*/9/2(4&/46&;
c
d(/,+8+-.)*&5&0))('+-+-.'-88&,&6/4:&-)
/44/()2-+)+&09/('66/2(4&/46&)/&-02(&)*&7*',&
)*&(+.*):+U/9D-/C6&8.&'-80D+660;
c
W2()*&(4(/:/)+-.8+,&(0+)7'-8&U4'-8+-./2(
7/2)*&-.'.&:&-)'-8&:46/7:&-)4(/.('::&0;
c
Y/-)+-2+-.)/:'D&C/(D+-.9/(VWXV:/(&926E66+-.
'-8&-02(+-.'66/2(4&/46&3'-*',&)*&+(0'7
(&.'(8+-.*/C
C&C/(D;
c
d(/:/)+-.'326)2(&)*'),'62&0+-3620+/-14(/:/)&0
9'+(-&001&F2'6+)7'-8(&04&3)9/('66C*+6&4(/,+8+-.
8+.-+E&8C/(D9'3+6+)+&09/(/2(4&/46&;
IggL"Kh
L?Khi
L#"I"K
gL"L"" I
c
%&C+665&+--/,')+,&+-/2(20&/9)&3*-/6/.718')''-8+-9/(:')+/-)/3*'-.&*/C
C&C/(D;
c
%&C+665&8(+,&-57'8&&4&(2-8&(0)'-8+-./9)*&-&&80/9/2(3/::2-+)+&0;
c
%&C+665&':/(&&-,+(/-:&-)'667020)'+-'56&/(.'-+0')+/-;
S"I"Kh
I!LIIL>
h" Ijg?>KI=><
"??=
?gI>=" #
LIL>
h"
I
IggL"Kh
L?Khi
L#"I"K
gL"L"" I
c
%&C+665&'-/(.'-+0')+/-)*')C/(D0+-'.+6&'-80:'()C'70)/0244/()/2(0)'H)/'3*+&,&'4/0+)+,&C/(Dk6+9&5'6'-3&;
c
%&C+66+-,&0)+-8&,&6/4+-./2(6&'8&(0'-8)('+-/2(0)'H)/)*&*+.*&0)0)'-8'(80;
c
%&C+66,'62&8+H&(&-3&/9,+&C01&U4&(+&-3&0'-85'3D.(/2-80C+)*+-'-8/2)C+)*/2(/(.'-+0')+/-;
S"I"Kh
I!LIIL>
h" Ijg?>KI=><
"??=
?gI>=" #
LIL>
h"
I
c
A00&)e'-'.&:&-)V)(')&.7NO^_]NON_
c
b/-.T&(:W+-'-3+'6V)(')&.7NO^_]NON_
l(&,+0&8NONNkNONmn
c
e&8+2:T&(:W+-'-3&e/8&6NONm]NONo
c
d(/32(&:&-)V)(')&.7NON^]NONp
c
q/,&(-'-3&'-8A33/2-)'5+6+)7W(':&C/(D
c
Y'(5/-e'-'.&:&-)d6'-NONO]NONP
c
Y6+:')&Y*'-.&X&04/-0&d6'-NOpP
c
a-&(.7'-8Y'(5/-V)(')&.7NONO]NOmO
c
Y/::2-+3')+/-0'-8a-.'.&:&-)V)(')&.7
c
e&-)'6r&'6)*V)(')&.7NONO]NOmO
c
A.+6&%
/(D+-.W(':&C/(D
c
Y/::2-+3')+/-0'-8a-.'.&:&-)V)(')&.7
c
d/0+)+,&A3)+/-V)(')&.7
c
Y/(4/(')&d'(&-)+-.d6'-NONO]NONm
c
T('+-+-.V)(')&.7NONO]NONP
c
X&0/2(3+-.d6'-NON^]NONo
52Page 74
Page 75
Page 76
Page 77
!"!#!$%
&'(()*+,-./01,-/*2314451+*6+(78'91.
/.313'8:1;1<,+914-3+,=')87/8,*18.>
?
@A?
!?
BCCD
E/8,*18.=+73'8:+*6+./,')8<'81>F=12+;181*<1+,(/21,'')8'718/,+'*.,=8')6='),,=17/*21(+<3/.:1-,'
=147+*6<'(()*+,+1.,=8')6=,=+.<=/441*6+*6,+(1>G13+44<'*,+*)1,'3'8:<4'.14-3+,=')87/8,*18.H+*<4)2+*6
3+,=',=18I81/*281.<)1.189+<1.,=8')6='),,=1JK/*2+*,18*/,+'*/44-H,'+(78'91I81I6=,18./01,-/*2,=1
314451+*6'0+*2+9+2)/4./*2<'(()*+,+1.>G13+4481(/+*0)44-<'((+,,12,'&'(()*+,-E4/**+*6H/*23'8:3+,=
7/8,*18.+*<4)2+*6E'4+<1L<',4/*2H,=1L<',,+.=M(5)4/*<1L189+<1HN'</4M),='8+,+1.HO1/4,=P'/82.H,=1F=+82
L1<,'8/*2&'(()*+,-Q8')7.,=8')6='),L<',4/*2>E/8,*18.=+73'8:+*6+.9+,/4,'1*.)81317180'8(/,')851.,+*
/44,=/,312'>G13+443'8:('81<4'.14-3+,=')8<'(()*+,+1.,')*218.,/*2,=1+8<=/*6+*6*112./*2+*<4)21,=1(
+*,=121.+6*H21914'7(1*,/*278+'8+,+./,+'*'0')8.189+<1.>
?
@A"!""?
BCCCRCBR!B$@S!!T!AS"
P-UVUW313+445181<'6*+.12/./814+/541/*29/4)127/8,*18H214+918+*6/*1;1<,+911(1861*<-.189+<1/*2/3+21
8/*61'074/<15/.12+*+,+/,+91.3+,=7/8,*18./<8'..L<',4/*2/*20)8,=18/I142>G13+44/<=+191,=+.5-X
F=+.28/YL,8/,16+<E4/*UVUUZUVUW.1,.'),3=/,')858'/2/(5+,+'*.3+4451'918,=1*1[,,=811-1/8.>\')89+13.
/81+(7'8,/*,,')./*2-')/81+*9+,12,',144).3=/,-'),=+*:'0')8/778'/<=>
F=10'8(/4<'*.)4,/,+'*0'8,=+.28/YL,8/,16+<E4/*'71*12'*
]^_`ab
`acdcc`^_efgghi^i^jfg"i^_`a
kdligacdcc>F'1*.)8131819+13/*2(/*/61/4481.7'*.1.<'*.+.,1*,4-741/.101125/<:,').).+*6')8'*4+*1
.)891->F=+.</*51/<<1..12/,mnopqrstuvwxqysyzovp{uqoxqr|>MY18,=1<'*.)4,/,+'*+.<4'.12313+447)54+.=,=1
81.)4,.>
}0-')</**',/<<1..')8'*4+*1.)891-H'8+0-')3')424+:1('81+*0'8(/,+'*/5'),,=1L<',,+.=~+81/*21.<)1
L189+<1-')</*X
G8+,1,'X
L<',,+.=~+81/*21.<)1L189+<1O1/2)/8,18.
G1.,5)8*8+91
&/(5).4/*6
QUM
E='*1X
V
WV
+.+,')8315.+,1X
xmnopqrstuvwxrx
&'*,+*)+*6')8<'((+,(1*,,'&'(()*+,-
E4/**+*6/*27/8,*18.=+73'8:+*6/<8'../44
4'</4+,+1.+*L<',4/*2>
G
'8:+*63+,=')87/8,*18.,'0)8,=18./016)/82,=1
-')*6/*2')89)4*18/541/2)4,.>
G
'8:+*63+,=')87/8,*18.,'/2281..<'(('*
.189+<121(/*2<=/441*61.>
L=/8+*6('81'0')8781(+.1.3+,=7/8,*18.
/*2.11:+*61<+1*<+1.3=18131</*,=8')6=
<'44/5'8/,+913'8:+*6>
*6/6+*6('813+,=<'(()*+,+1./*27/8,*18.3=1*
21.+6*+*6H21914'7+*6/*2214+918+*6.189+<1.>
P1+*67'.+,+914-9/4)125-')87/8,*18./*2
<'(()*+,+1.+*/44,=/,312'>
>FNNJLG
OMF\JFO}K
"SB$SC$!S
#B"B$SBSBB!"
E/8,*18.=+73'8:+*63+4451/,,=1<'81'0='3313'8:>
G13+4451+**'9/,+91+*')8).1'0,1<=*'4'6-H2/,//*2+*0'8(/,+'*,'<=/*61='3313'8:>
G13+445128+91*5-/211718)*218.,/*2+*6'0,=1*112.'0')8<'(()*+,+1.>
G13+4451/('811*9+8'*(1*,/44-.).,/+*/541'86/*+./,+'*>
!B"B$"S""SA!B!"CA$"@A?
BCC@!C"A@B!#!S"SA!B
!"
P).+*1..}*,144+61*<1L,8/,16-UVUZUVU
&'(()*+</,+'*./*2*6/61(1*,L,8/,16-
53Page 78
Page 79
!"#!$!%& '( ( )*+ ,* ) - (-(.// 0 ))*,1 ..2,( 2*)( .3-, ) ) 4/ ( /*)+ /( )*.5 6789!&% :"6#;6< 54
Page 80
NORTH AYRSHIRE COUNCIL 15 August 2022 Police Fire and Rescue Committee Title: Review of Joint Strategic Police Plan 2020/23 Purpose: To advise the Committee of the consultation request and to provide comment for preparation and submission of the response. Recommendation: That the Committee notes the terms of the consultation request and provides comment to enable a response to be submitted. 1. Executive Summary 1.1 The Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland developed the Joint Strategy for Policing 2020 -2023, which was approved in March 2020. As 2022-23 is the final year of delivery for the current plan, an initial desktop review was commissioned to assess progress, relevance to future delivery of policing and whether there are gaps in provision of service. 1.2 The views of Local Authorities and other strategic partners are being sought on the conclusions reached. The responses provided will be considered for incorporation into the emerging draft Strategic Police Plan for 2023-26 which will be shared with the Committee for consultative response in later in the financial year. The findings of the initial review are detailed in Appendix 1 for consideration by the Committee. 2. Background 2.1 The Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland developed the Joint Strategy for Policing 2020-2023. The Strategy contains strategic priorities, priorities for policing and five strategic outcomes. 2.2 An initial desktop review has been completed and considered the National Strategic Assessment, undertaken horizon scanning to consider future needs and requirements and has also considered progress on delivering the strategic outcomes of the Strategic Police Plan. The five strategic outcomes are as follows: • Keeping people safe through proactive and responsive policing • The needs of local communities are addressed through effective service delivery Agenda Item 6 55
Page 81
• The public, communities and partners are engaged and have confidence in policing • Supporting our people through a positive working environment • Sustainable policing for the future 2.3 The conclusions of the review are detailed in Appendix 1 and are narrated as follows: Conclusions on the five strategic outcomes • There is evidence of good progress made in 2020-2022 to deliver on the ambitions set by strategic outcomes; • The outcomes remain relevant to current and future context for delivery and reflect the key focus areas identified; • The outcomes are set at a broad strategic level which enables the capture of known and emerging focus areas during the period of delivery and are reflective of the newly published Scottish Government Justice Vision; • The outcomes are currently shaping aligned plans for delivery in 2022/23 and the development of a 5 year Police Scotland delivery plan covering the period 2023-2028. Conclusions on the underpinning Strategic Objectives and Plan narrative • The objectives remain broadly reflective and relevant to current and future delivery context with some amendments or enhancements to language required to reflect increased importance of key areas. 2.4 The Committee is asked to consider the review and provide comment on whether it agrees with the conclusions reached by the joint review along with any further feedback for incorporation into a consultation response. 3. Proposals 3.1 That the Committee (i) notes the consultation request, (ii) provides feedback on the conclusions reached by the initial review outlined in greater detail at Appendix 1 to enable a consultation response to be formulated and (iii) instructs and authorises the Head of Service (Democratic) to submit a response on behalf of the Committee in consultation with the Chair. 4. Implications/Socio-economic Duty Financial 4.1 There are no financial implications arising from this report. Human Resources 4.2 There are no Human Resources implications arising from this report. Legal 4.3 There are no Legal implications arising from this report. 56
Page 82
Equality/Socio-economic 4.4 The Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland will assess the outcomes of the consultation exercise for equality, diversity and socio-economic outcomes. Environmental and Sustainability 4.5 There are no Environmental implications arising from this report. Key Priorities 4.6 The response to the consultation contributes to the Council’s priorities of developing and promoting Aspiring Communities in North Ayrshire with active and strong communities where residents and communities are safe. Community Wealth Building 4.7 There are no Community Wealth Building benefits arising from this report. 5. Consultation 5.1 The Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland will consult on any actions they propose to take in response to the consultation responses received from members of the public and strategic partners. Aileen Craig Head of Service (Democratic) For further information please contact Raymond Lynch, Senior Manager, Legal Services), on 01294 324322. Background Papers Appendix 1 57
Page 83
OFFICIAL 1 OFFICIAL REVIEW OF STRATEGIC POLICE PLAN Phase One Summary INTRODUCTION The Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland jointly developed the Joint Strategy for Policing 2020 -2023, which was approved in March 2020. As 2022- 23 is the final year of delivery for the current plan, the Authority Chair and Chief Constable commissioned an initial review of the current Strategic Police Plan (SPP). To date the Review has been undertaken collaboratively by the Authority and Police Scotland on a desktop research basis, drawing on a range of evidence and intelligence that builds an informed position on progress made to deliver against the SPP, as well as changes in the current/future strategic landscape in which policing services will be delivered. This initial review of the SPP took place between January and June 2022. The next phase of the Review (Summer 2022) involves seeking the views of Local Authorities, COSLA, HMICS, Audit Scotland and Scottish Government on the findings and conclusions reached so far, and the proposed next steps of the Review. LEGISLATIVE CONTEXT The Authority is responsible for preparing (and keeping under review) a Strategic Police Plan, which sets out the main objectives for the provision of policing services in Scotland. Section 34 of the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 sets out the legislative basis upon which the SPP is developed and kept under review. The current Strategic Police Plan, published in March 2020, consists of five overarching strategic outcomes, each of which is underpinned by three strategic objectives. Further narrative detail under each objective articulates the expected implementation approach and accompanying activities. 58
Page 84
OFFICIAL 2 OFFICIAL 59
Page 85
OFFICIAL 3 OFFICIAL FORMAT OF THIS REVIEW This initial phase of the review commenced in November 2021 through a joint working group of from the Authority and Police Scotland. This working group has overseen desktop research and analysis activity aligned to two main workstreams: (1) An assessment of current and future strategic risks, opportunities and challenges affecting, or likely to affect, policing in Scotland, based on a strategic horizon scanning exercise and a strategic landscape review; and (2) An evidence-based review of progress made to date to deliver the fifteen objectives set out in the current Plan. The findings from these two workstreams have informed an analysis of the current Plan, assessing its continued relevance and identifying any gaps or other areas that may require enhancement or re-emphasis. The working group reported its initial findings and conclusions to the Authority and Police Scotland Executive in June 2022 where there was agreement as follows: a) The review’s findings and conclusions to date were accepted; b) Prior to preparing a revised Strategic Police Plan, views from key stakeholders will be sought as part of an engagement exercise undertaken during the summer of 2022 to inform a draft revised Strategic Police Plan; c) The Authority, in consultation with the Chief Constable, will be asked to approve a draft revised Strategic Police Plan in the early autumn of 2022, followed up by broader public and stakeholder consultation on the draft document. It is the intention of the Authority and Police Scotland Executive to have in place an approved final Strategic Police Plan ahead of the financial year 2023/24 to enable Local Police Plans and Police Scotland’s Annual Police Plan 2023/24 to be reflective of the Strategic Police Plan. SUMMARY OF THE REVIEW’S FINDINGS 1. HORIZON SCANNING AND STRATEGIC LANDSCAPE REVIEW This part of the review considered i) the current Police Scotland National Strategic Assessment, ii) a horizon scanning and futures exercise and iii) the strategic, policy and legislative landscape in which a future, revised Strategic Police Plan would be delivered. 60
Page 86
OFFICIAL 4 OFFICIAL i) National Strategic Assessment Review The current National Strategic Assessment (NSA) was reviewed and the content approved by the Police Scotland Executive in November 2021 at its Strategic Operational Performance Board. An evidence based exercise reviewed current areas of focus in the NSA and determined if these are effectively covered within the current Strategic Police Plan, identifying any potential gaps or areas where additional emphasis was needed to inform the future strategic direction of policing in Scotland. The joint working group determined that the underpinning evidence base reflects the priorities for policing and organisational priorities; and that these are captured in their entirety within the Joint Strategy. The review of the NSA identified the following key areas which will likely be described in greater depth and have an elevated status in future assessments: Police Scotland has work underway to address each of these areas and takes a human rights based approach to policing across all key areas. A rights based policing framework is being developed and new strategies for Violence Against Women and Girls and Equality, Diversity and Inclusion are also under development. The Cyber Strategy is currently being implemented via the Policing in a Digital World Programme and there is a range of work ongoing to continue to focus on hate crime. The current Plan covers these themes in broad terms. ii) Horizon Scanning and Futures Approach Ongoing horizon scanning outputs from both organisations were brought together and used to form a view on current and future issues affecting, or likely to affect, the policing of Scotland in the coming years. These can be grouped under four key themes: Policing and Society; Equality, Diversity and Inclusion; Technology; and Environment and Sustainability. After analysis of projected trends had taken place a series of key recommendations were identified, as shown in the table below. These areas of change will influence policing in the period 2022-27. - Focus on continuing to provide meaningful insights and analysis to enable the service to adapt to trends such as evolving crime types and levels, demand due to mental health and vulnerability, demographics, relationships with seldom heard voices, children and young people and those who are digitally excluded, both internally and externally. - Continued focus on public health approaches, early intervention and preventative approaches. Cyber crime Hate crime Human rights based approaches to policing Violence against women and girls Equality, diversity and inclusion 61
Page 87
OFFICIAL 5 OFFICIAL - Emphasis on collaboration with blue light and local authority partners to enable shared approaches to key challenges and opportunities. - Adopting person-centred approaches that promote participation, that are trauma informed and respect individuals. - Continued monitoring of the both the national security and political landscapes to understand changing demand and priorities. - Improved understanding of how trust and confidence in policing is influenced by experiences in relation to protected characteristics, for example racism, misogyny and sexism, both internally and externally. - Analysis and response to key areas of changing demand highlighted in the Cost of Living report - Investment in and engagement on new technologies for policing in order to maximise policing capability whilst retaining legitimacy, trust and confidence from the public. - Focus on environmental sustainability, both internally with regards to infrastructure and colocation, and externally with a focus on potential new crime types and an evolving role for policing. - Monitoring of the impacts of the spending review and potential future budget allocations to inform SPA, SG and public discussions on policing demand, capability and capacity. - Working closely with Scottish Government and Local Authority colleagues on the development and implementation of the National Care Service to ensure policing demand challenges are considered and that policing is fully involved in developing the new model; - Colleague wellbeing, safety and protection to continue to be prioritised. iii) Strategic Landscape Review This strand focused on ensuring strategic alignment with important emerging and developing areas of policy and strategy including the spending review narrative, future legislation, programme for government priorities, and the recently published Justice Vision for Scotland 2022, Vision for a ‘Just, Safe and Resilient Scotland’. Overall there is good alignment between the Joint Strategy and the Justice Vision, with an outcomes-focused approach taken, and similar areas of focus/principles in place such as being evidence-led, person-centred, trauma- informed and working in partnership/collaboration. The new Vision articulates how all parts of the justice system must deliver person-centred services and enshrine trauma informed practice, which will be reflected in any revisions to the SPP. 62
Page 88
OFFICIAL 6 OFFICIAL 2. DELIVERING THE CURRENT STRATEGIC POLICE PLAN The current Plan consists of five strategic outcomes, underpinned by fifteen strategic objectives. An evidence review of progress made against each objective, drawing from a range of published information and internal Police Scotland documentation has been undertaken. The majority of evidence to inform this review was drawn from papers in the public domain, supported by recorded discussion at Authority Board and Committee meetings. The review has identified clear evidence of good progress made from 2020 to date to deliver on the ambitions set in the Joint Strategy for Policing (2020) under each of the strategic outcomes. This is despite the significant operational challenges of the Covid-19 pandemic and delivery of a safe and secure COP26 event. Delivery and decisions over the remaining period of the plan, will also be taken into account in this review of the Joint Strategy / Strategic Police Plan for 2023 onwards. CONCLUSIONS Consideration of the main findings from the review has led the Authority and Police Scotland Executive to agree the following conclusions, at this stage, in relation to the five Strategic Outcomes and underpinning Strategic Objectives and Plan narrative. Conclusions on the five Strategic Outcomes There is evidence of good progress made in 2020-2022 to deliver on the ambitions set by strategic outcomes; The outcomes remain relevant to current and future context for delivery and reflect the key focus areas identified; The outcomes are set at a broad strategic level which enables the capture of known and emerging focus areas during the period of delivery and are reflective of the newly published Scottish Government Justice Vision; The outcomes are currently shaping aligned plans for delivery in 2022/23 and the development of a 5 year Police Scotland delivery plan covering the period 2023-2028. Conclusions on the underpinning Strategic Objectives and Plan narrative The objectives remain broadly reflective and relevant to current and future delivery context with some amendments or enhancements to language required to reflect increased importance of key areas. 63
Page 89
OFFICIAL 7 OFFICIAL Strategic outcome Areas of emphasis Threats to public safety and wellbeing are resolved by a proactive and responsive police service. o Cyber crime and delivery of ‘Policing in a Digital World’, reflecting debates around legitimacy of policing in a private / online space and how the service responds to the continued significant escalation of cyber enabled and dependent crimes; o Violence against women and girls. The needs of local communities are addressed through effective service delivery. o Rights based policing approach; o Person centred and trauma informed policing, recognising areas of increased need and vulnerability, such as mental health. The public, communities and partners are engaged, involved and have confidence in policing. o Enhanced strategic approach to engagement and focus on building relationships with seldom heard people and communities. Our people are supported through a positive working environment, enabling them to serve the public. o Equality, diversity and inclusion (also Outcome 1); o Enhancing culture, leadership and wellbeing approaches aligned to the People Strategy refresh and colleague voice. Police Scotland is sustainable, adaptable and prepared for future challenges. o Delivery, with investment in technology and infrastructure to enable operational policing to continue to respond effectively to threat, risk and harm. NEXT STEPS The Authority, in consultation with the Chief Constable, will consider a draft of the Strategic Police Plan in September 2022. This draft document will reflect the review’s findings and conclusions, feedback obtained from policing partners during the summer of 2022, and outcomes from a Scottish Government review of the existing strategic police priorities. If approved by the Authority, the draft Strategic Police Plan will be issued to the public, communities and stakeholders later in 2022 as part of an accessible engagement exercise. This exercise will inform the development of a final Strategic Police Plan 2023-26 for consideration/approval by the Authority in late 2022/23 which, if approved, will be then be laid before Parliament. 64
Page 90
OFFICIAL 8 OFFICIAL FURTHER INFORMATION This report provides a summary of the review’s main findings and the conclusions that have been drawn. Further detail on the underpinning evidence and supporting information for the review is available on request by contacting: SPA Strategy and Performance at SPAStrategyandPerformance@spa.police.uk 65
Page 91
66